In his book, Isaac Williams Martin traces the twentieth-century history of antitax movements. These movements sought to redistribute resources to the wealthy by repealing the Sixteenth Amendment passed in 1913, and legitimizing a federal income tax, or by limiting congressional authority to set tax rates, or by seeking in some way to combine these approaches. Martin’s thesis is straightforward. “Since the early twentieth century,” he writes, “a small but vocal minority of Americans has fomented nonviolent rebellions … to demand that government redistribute resources to the rich” (p. 1). He identifies these “nonviolent rebellions” as coming out of “the grassroots libertarian right” (p. xiv), and describes in meticulous detail how members of the business classes, beginning in the 1920s, used the organizing techniques of the populists and other Progressive protest groups to create movements for the benefit of the more privileged members of American society.
Rich People’s Movements is organized as a set of case studies, beginning in the 1920s. From that point, Martin traces the emergence of a variety of antitax movements across the twentieth century that, he argues, eventually provide the ideological and policy basis for the Tea Party movement. The introductory chapter lays out the author’s framework for understanding the basic character of these movements. He finds that policy threats, including acts of Congress that increased taxes on at least some of the wealthy, “were necessary to trigger mobilization on behalf of the rich” (p. 12). Advocates for the rich turned to grassroots tactics when, in times of crisis, the usual methods of lobbying, pressure-group activity, and other “familiar channels of political representation” (p. 14) failed to overturn the perceived threats to their interests. They drew on grassroots tactics because many of these activists had learned their skills in the heat of the populist and Progressive eras, and were what they knew best.
In its demonstration that conservative social action has always been a normal part of modern American politics, Martin’s close study of twentieth-century antitax movements makes a valuable contribution to the social movement literature. Each of the substantive chapters examines a particular movement. Chapter 2 discusses the tax clubs organized by J. A. Arnold in the early 1920s. Arnold, who grew up and cut his political eye teeth living and working in the prairie regions dominated by agrarian radicalism, went to Washington in 1924 to ask Andrew Mellon’s Treasury Department for support in setting up local antitax clubs across the South. Arnold’s methods, Martin writes, were “in the pure image of the Texas Farmers’ Union and the Farmers’ Alliance before it” (p. 57). The participants in the tax clubs, though middle income, were overwhelmingly bank presidents and other bank officers, along with a scattering of businessmen and merchants, and an occasional cattleman.
Chapter 3 examines the role played by the American Taxpayers’ Association (ATA). In the 1930s, Robert Dresser, an estate management lawyer from Providence, Rhode Island, used his position on the board of the ATA to draft a constitutional amendment and to promote a movement that would restrict the income-taxing powers of Congress. Support for Dresser’s amendment was strongest among businessmen and property owners; those who “went beyond sympathy” to actually join the ATA were mostly corporate executives (p. 78).
Chapter 4 looks at the Committee for Constitutional Government (CCG), which in the 1940s and 1950s, under the direction of Ed Rumely, continued the push for a tax-limitation amendment. Rumely, once active in Progressive causes, turned against the New Deal in 1937 and helped organize the CCG, launching a drive in Texas in 1943 to set up clubs to fight Roosevelt’s war time-tax proposals. Martin describes the CCG organizers as traveling around the state “much like union organizers or old Populist lecturers.” The campaign, however, focused primarily on oilmen and business elites associated with the oil industry (p. 99).
Chapter 5 examines the role of conservative activist women. Vivian Kellems was a well-known figure in national social circles. She brought the tactics of civil disobedience, which she had learned in the suffrage movement, to her opposition to the income tax, refusing in 1943 to pay her taxes, and in 1948, daring the Bureau of Internal Revenue to arrest her for not collecting withholding taxes from the workers in the Connecticut factory she owned with her brother. In 1951, she formed, with other women from her milieu, the anticommunist Liberty Belles, a women’s political association committed to repealing the income tax and fighting what it called creeping socialism. To establish the Liberty Belles, Kellems and her associates used the grassroots organizing techniques of setting up clubs, holding house parties and discussion groups, and relying on other forms of direct outreach. Most chapters arose, Martin writes, in states where wealthy women were comparatively numerous and where Kellems had extensive personal networks (p. 121).
Chapter 6 concerns the legacy of Willis Stone, who in 1959 founded the National Committee for Economic Freedom. The NCEF set up local committees to push state legislatures to approve the Liberty Amendment, written by Stone, which called for both income tax repeal and the radical privatization of all government services. By 1961, the NCEF had affiliated chapters in 30 states, and by 1964, six state legislatures had passed resolutions supporting Stone’s amendment (p. 146).The drive for the Liberty Amendment, I suggest, was the only one of the earlier antitax movements to extend beyond local elites and reach a broader electorate. Its appearance at the beginning of the 1960s might be seen as a transitional moment on the path to contemporary right-wing populism.
Martin’s point is that while none of these movements succeeded in repealing the income tax, they set the groundwork in the United States for the conservative resurgence in the last decades of the twentieth century. These decades saw efforts to pass a balanced-budget amendment, the victory of Howard Jarvis and Proposition 13 in California, and, finally, Grover Norquist’s efforts to abolish the estate tax. In Martin’s view, there is an essential continuity between the antitax movements of the earlier part of the century and the conservative populism of the later. What links them, he argues, are the grassroots organizing techniques that antitax leaders knew firsthand and adapted to their own ends and purposes. In their organizational style, their tactical choices, and even their rhetoric, these leaders, Martin writes, “copied the progressive social movements that had put those taxes on the books” (p. 43).
In Martin’s schema, it is the application of the techniques learned from populism by these conservative activists that defines the antitax movements they promoted as grass roots. Yet other than in terms of organizing methods, the sense in which these may be read as grassroots movements is not clear. These groups were created and called into being by members of elite political and economic associations, or by individuals close to such associations. Membership numbers in these movements remained limited. And while those who participated were often well below the highest income tax brackets, there is little in the author’s data to indicate that active engagement ever extended beyond local business classes—for example, the farm mortgage bankers who supported Arnold’s tax clubs.
Martin’s theme that conservative movements were resilient throughout the twentieth century is unassailable, and is a valuable corrective to much of the social movement literature that followed in the wake of the 1960s. But when he attempts to draw a straight line between the elite-driven rich people’s movements of the earlier part of the century and the right-wing populist activism that begins to appear in the 1960s, Martin is on shakier ground. The right-wing movements that rose in the 1970s drew from a much broader popular constituency than their forerunners, had deeper roots in middle-income and working class communities, and flourished in a political atmosphere that did not come into its own until the years before Ronald Reagan’s election. The federal and state movements for balanced-budget regulations, laws reversing and limiting property taxes, and drives to repeal the estate tax took place in an atmosphere infused by the white backlash against the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Goldwater’s nomination that same year, George Wallace’s presidential run in the North in 1968, and the growing erosion of the New Deal coalition.
To grasp the character of contemporary right-wing populist movements, and how they differ from the elite anti tax movements of a previous era, one must view their emergence within the context of a society that has come to legitimate a broad atmospheric shift to the right. Martin's approach, however, conceives these contemporary movements in terms of an outward resemblance to elitist-led movements of a previous era. His perspective thus weakens the historical frame for understanding how larger shifts in American politics and society have given rise to a full and flourishing conservative grassroots activism.
