I. INTRODUCTION
The history of economics in the post-World War II period is very much an American story. We can quibble about how much and note, say, the shadows of John Maynard Keynes, Leon Walras, Arthur Pigou, etc. looming large over various facets of American economics during this period, but the American ascendancy is indisputable. As one thumbs backward from WWII, however, the picture begins to change dramatically. American Institutionalism figured prominently in American economics in the inter-war period but not much beyond it; Footnote 1 Irving Fisher, John Bates Clark, and, to a lesser extent, Henry George had an international influence in the generation prior to that, though this is not much on which to hang one’s hat. But when we get to, say, the 1870s and look back from there, we find an absence of Americans in canon, textbook, and even, for the most part, the scholarly literature. Footnote 2
There surely was no lack of ‘economics’ going on in the US during the first two-thirds of the nineteenth century, as the articles published in this symposium amply illustrate. And indeed, Joseph Dorfman (Reference Dorfman1946), after all, devoted nearly 500 pages to explicating this history for us—perhaps to such a degree that subsequent scholars have felt no compulsion to attempt to add to his voluminous chronicles. But it seems to me that there is more to the explanation for this substantial lacuna in the subjects to which historians of economics have devoted their attention than Dorfman’s wide-ranging treatment. This ‘more,’ I would argue, lies in the historiographic method that historians of economics tend to employ—one where the focus is on the big, original ideas, ideas that changed the course of how others, contemporary and future, viewed either the totality or some particular aspect of economic analysis (or perhaps offered an alternative that the writer believes was unjustly neglected). When it comes to American economics in the nineteenth century, it is perhaps justifiable to conclude that those transformative analytical insights were largely absent. But does this justify that period’s neglect by historians of economics?
The answer is surely ‘no,’ though this author must admit to some bias, (a) being American and (b) having played a bit part as editor of a fifteen-volume collection of works in the history of American economics, the coverage within which ranges from the colonial period to the founding of the American Economic Association in 1885. Footnote 3 My position here is grounded elsewhere, however—in matters of historiography. Over the last two decades, increasing efforts have been made to expand the ‘economics’ that historians study. I am not speaking here simply of the value of looking beyond the canon, or at issues of contextualization and processes through which professional knowledge is created, but to what constitutes ‘doing economics,’ including efforts such as engagements within the policy realm, the transmission and diffusion of economic ideas into the public sphere, Footnote 4 the role of textbooks in the diffusion and solidification of economic knowledge, and so on. This last set of features loomed large in American economic thought and discourse during the nineteenth century, and the articles published in this symposium shed important light on how and why this matters for understanding the history of American economics.
Historians of other stripes have been well ahead of their history of economics counterparts in recognizing the interesting insights to be gleaned from the study of American economics in the first half of the nineteenth century, as the contributions to this symposium—the majority of which come from scholars who do not travel in the history of economics community—indicate. But historians of all stripes, like historians of economics, bring their own priors and other baggage to the table, including (often) a limited background in and understanding of both the nuances of economic analysis and the larger contours of economic thought within and against which the history of American economics played out. In light of this, the papers in the present symposium serve both as welcome contributions to our understanding of important facets of this history and as a call to further work by historians generally, including historians of economics—work that will allow us to better understand how economics (or, better said, political economy) developed on this continent and the myriad interesting contextual forces that gave this work its particular character.
II. DIFFERENT SOURCES, DIFFERENT QUESTIONS
If the articles included in this symposium demonstrate anything, it is that writing the history of American economics is an historiographic enterprise that differs radically from how we have written the history of British economics during this period. The latter history—essentially, the history of nineteenth-century English classical political economy—is based, for better or for worse, almost exclusively on canonical texts, the analysis of which may or may not (depending on the author) be set against the background of the period. Even those nods to non-canonical works—e.g., the popular writings of Harriet Marineau or Jane Marcet—tend to be fundamentally canonical, as these writings were based largely on the messages found in the works of contemporaries and near-contemporaries such as Adam Smith, Thomas Robert Malthus, James Mill, and David Ricardo.
American economics, though it has its texts/treatises, is decidedly non-canonical in nature, lacking the landmark original reference points that we find in the British literature. The periodical literature played a very significant role in the dissemination of economic ideas in America during this period, both in an absolute sense and relative to the British experience. Moreover, our authors have found important and influential economic insights conveyed through what, from a traditional history of economics perspective, are rather odd sources—as with the travels literature/genre discussed here by Harro Maas. Given the historian of economics’ fondness for canonical touchstones, this provides at least one part of an explanation for why the American economics of this period has been so little studied. But it also suggests that studying the history of American economics during this period requires a different approach—and very different source materials—from those historians of economics have typically used, one in which ‘ideas’ play at least as large a role in the history as does ‘analysis,’ and where the basic questions that guide historical inquiry have a somewhat non-traditional (for these scholars) cast.
The Writers
Who was—or what types of people were—asking the ‘interesting questions’ in America during this period? Treatise authors tended to be college presidents teaching courses in political economy (often to college seniors) and writing textbooks for use in these courses—a very different breed of ‘political economist’ from those we find writing treatises in England during this period. Footnote 5 But these works are at best bit players in most of the studies published in this symposium. A goodly amount of the American literature involves individuals of varying backgrounds pushing particular agendas via expositions that remind one of the style found in the mercantilist literature, and the points being made are very often idiosyncratic to the author or a particular set of interests he or she represents rather than additions to a somewhat cumulative stream of analysis. This complicates the task of the historian as against the author who is, say, responding to a particular point made by Ricardo, which was itself a revision of a point made by Adam Smith.
The Audience(s)
What was the nature of the audience(s) for these various literatures? What are the images—literally and figuratively—employed to reach those audiences? We have seen a variety of different illustrations in the symposium articles. The public role of the economic analyst/commentator (the latter probably being the better term) looms large here, as quite a number of the individuals who appear in the stories told in this symposium were attempting to influence policy directly via access to the political process. We find very little in these articles that reflects economic theorizing proper, but much about the desire to shape public opinion and policy. Was this an artifact of attitudes molded by the American democratic political structure and views on the role/identity of the expert? To whom were policy-makers listening, and how far did these popular works go in the shaping of public attitudes and economic policy?
The Science
The symposium articles make clear that American ‘political economy’ was replete with evidence of the ‘political,’ but where is the ‘science’ of political economy in all of this? What ideas were taken to be ‘received knowledge’ in America and how did this compare with that which was considered received knowledge in Britain? Differently put, what were the standards of knowledge-related belief in the US during this period and in what ways did these standards contribute to particular and perhaps distinctive beliefs about reality, theoretical systems, etc.?
We have seen that at least some strains of American political economy commentary had a significant empirical basis. The symposium discussions of, for example, Frederick Olmsted, James D. B. De Bow, Mathew Carey, and Horace Mann bring this empirical bent to the fore and suggest a measure of contrast with what one might consider a more natural law-oriented, British political economy of the period. This, in turn, points to the need for a more comprehensive examination of the basis (or bases) for ideas underlying American economic thinking and the extent to which empirical work of various sorts was relevant to creating those distinctive aspects of American economics during this period. More generally, it becomes important to discern how evidence was marshaled and/or used to support positions, policy and otherwise, including regarding slavery, but also regarding free trade versus protectionism, monetary matters, and ‘defending’ the southern (northern) economy against the North (South).
The Teaching and the Treatises
The foregoing raises interesting questions regarding the teaching of political economy in America during this period. What was being written about by the textbook/treatise authors and taught in these courses, and how does that relate to what has been discussed in the articles that appear in this symposium? Were the textbook authors largely removed from the debates that have dominated much of this discussion? Did what was written about in these textbooks and taught in the courses focus on ‘principles’ that were unrelated to the concerns evidenced in the symposium articles? Perhaps most importantly, how or to what extent did institutional features, such as slavery (and the related structures which gave rise to it or to which it gave rise), work themselves into treatises on political economy as compared with popular literature?
III. A UNIQUELY 'AMERICAN' ECONOMICS?
The symposium papers suggest, if only indirectly, that there was something unique about American economics during this period. Carey’s zones theory, taken up by Stephen Meardon, is perhaps the most distinctive illustration of an ‘American’ theoretical construct pointed to in these articles, an idea very much founded on the American situation. But these articles reflect a host of other features suggestive of influences distinctive to the American experience. This is an issue that merits a good deal of examination, both in its own right and as a part of the study of the international diffusion of economic ideas. That is, to what extent were Americans creating economic ideas unique to the American experience and to what extent were they importing ideas from elsewhere? For those ideas being imported, to what extent were they reshaped to fit the American situation? Is there evidence of American ideas being exported? And to what effect?
Of particular interest here, of course, is the transatlantic discussion and the degree of influence of English classical political economy on American economic thought. We have seen that issues of money and banking (James Morrison), trade (William Belko), development/growth, taxation, and so forth figured prominently in the economic discussions of US authors, as one might expect. But how did the nature of these discussions—the issues around which they revolved and the positions taken—compare with those in the British literature, and what accounts for the differences? We find a few hints regarding transatlantic influences in the present symposium, as when Marc-William Palen writes about Cobdenite links and Joseph Persky about education. But there is clearly shaping of discussions or use of these ideas that is unique to the American experience, and getting at the ‘how’ and the ‘why’ here is important for understanding why American economics evolved as it did. Likewise for the perspectives on the role of the state to the operation of the market mechanism. While the British economics of the period is not nearly so laissez-faire as some would caricature it, the American literature seems several steps removed from even this, suggesting that, to the extent that there was borrowing from English classical political economy, it was a very selective borrowing indeed.
The history of American economic thinking during the period under consideration here illustrates vividly how social institutions impact the stream of economic discussion and analysis. Policy issues have always been major drivers of economic thought, but these were typically economic in the traditional sense—trade issues, banking issues, education, etc. When it comes to the American experience, however, we have something economic, but much larger that features prominently in the analysis: slavery, and the north-south divergence to which it gave rise. This raises the obvious question of how differing conceptions of, for example, economic growth and development and of the importance of slavery and other social institutions for economic growth influenced the directions taken by various commentators and the conclusions reached. As Phillip Magness nicely illustrates in his article, the slavery context gave rise to colonization discussions, which, in turn, fed back into nationalism, free-trade/tariff debates, and so forth. The colonization proposals discussed by Magness can be seen as remedies for the disharmony in American society caused by the slave system, and allowed for the establishment of American values and an American sphere of influence in Africa. Did changing attitudes toward colonization and slavery translate in any way into the nature of political economy discussions? To what degree, if any, did economic commentary play a role in helping to change these attitudes?
One of the many interesting insights that emerges from this symposium is that there was not, in reality, a neat north-south distinction or any significant sense in which one can think of a monolithic ‘North’ or ‘South’—particularly when it came to economic activity and thus economic interests. Each region saw plenty of within-region variation due to disparate intra-regional interests, as well as a blurring of lines traditionally distinct, such as between commerce and agriculture. Ariel Ron tells us that, against the typical juxtaposition of the industrial North and agrarian South, we need to understand how important agriculture really was in the North to come to grips with the development of American political economy. Given that the emphasis on agriculture in the North—and its impact on the stance of northern interests in the policy realm—is not commonly understood, how weak is our understanding of the roots of American political economy, being grounded in the traditional view?
Brian Schoen’s convincing demonstration that there were many norths and many souths is particularly instructive. Whether we are looking at hot-button issues such as slavery, tariffs, and the banking system, or lesser (but still very important) issues such as migration, education, the appropriate mix of agriculture and manufacturing within and across regions over time, or the appropriate scope for market and State, we find contending ideas both within and across these regions. What is more, the somewhat primitive nature of the ‘science’ of political economy in this age is reflected in the evidence that the effects of policy were imperfectly understood—particularly when it came to monetary, trade, tax, and development issues. Of course, the institutional structure, in a macro sense, and the uncertainty surrounding its future played no small part in these imperfect understandings, as much was viewed as contingent upon the particulars of what would happen to the Union—for example, whether secession would be good for manufacturing or cotton depended on which states chose to go with the Union and which with the Confederacy.
The contending regional and intra-regional interests come through loud and clear in the strong mercantilist flavor (even, at times, stench) that one finds in certain quarters of this literature—including in the propensity of authors to couch their self-interest in terms of national or sectional interests. While those familiar with the mercantilist literature are no strangers to such arguments, this rhetoric raises a significant question. What, exactly, was the national interest in the US context during this time? Or, differently put, what are the conceptions of US national interest to be found in this literature and how do these conceptions compare with what is to be found in the textbook/treatise literature of the period?
IV. CONCLUSION
Much has been made of the pluralism that characterized American economics during the interwar period as compared to the increasing homogenization that followed it. Footnote 6 But the literature examined by the contributors to this symposium suggests that the pluralism of the interwar period may have been a defining characteristic of American economics for many decades prior to this—that perhaps the post-WWII period was the first epoch in the history of American economics that was not incredibly heterogeneous. In the end, the challenge is to ascertain how all of this comes together to form a big-picture view of the history of American economics during this period. How do we move from the cacophony of voices to a history? Indeed, can we?
