The late 1800s and early 1900s mark a period of turbulence and transformation in the history of capitalism. On a practical level, this period witnessed increasing commercialization, burgeoning financial markets, and escalating political tensions between labor and capital. On a theoretical level, moreover, it witnessed the formation of neoclassical economics, a scholarly tradition—or ideological doctrine, depending on whom you ask—that came to serve, at least in part, as an intellectual justification of the prevailing economic order.
This development was not without cultural implications and manifestations. In art, literature, and—as Alisa Zhulina convincingly demonstrates in her new book—on stage, economic issues were frequently explored and critically engaged with. Theater of Capital is Zhulina’s ingenious interpretation of the interplay between the economics of the fin de siècle, on the one hand, and the evolution of modern drama, on the other. Not only did groundbreaking dramatic works by, e.g., Henrik Ibsen, August Strindberg, Victoria Benedictsson, George Bernard Shaw, Anton Chekhov, and Gerhart Hauptmann coincide with various capitalist convulsions, Zhulina contends, but contemporary economic matters and ideas made it into their plays quite explicitly. More specifically, Zhulina draws on the Marxian conception of immanent critique to show that “[d]rama—which allows multiple and competing voices to be heard in the most concrete way—became the channel through which these playwrights attempted to work through their own and their era’s inherent contradictions” (p. 16).
The understanding of these contradictions is delineated by Zhulina in four chapters, individually focused on one (or occasionally a few) of the primary six European dramatists of her choice, as well as in a lengthy thematic introduction and a brief coda. A wide range of topics are covered, all pertaining to the conditions of capitalism in modernity, and to theatrical representations thereof—from gambling and speculation in Chekhov to courtship and sexual politics in Strindberg. One could have suspected that the strong emphasis on immanent critique would lead to a somewhat rigid and formulaic account, but Zhulina is much too attuned to the diversity of the material for this to happen. The argument is also not entirely driven by Marxist theory; there is rather a broader engagement with economic criticism—that is, the joint study of literature and economics, a field which “is just as much a branch of economics as it is an avenue of literary scholarship” (Paine Reference Paine2019, p. 253)—in the tradition of scholars such as Mary Poovey and Marc Shell.Footnote 1 In this way, Theater of Capital becomes a literary, or rather theatrical, contribution to the history of economic thought at large, instead of a more circumscribed, strictly Marxist piece of criticism.
The introduction is arguably the richest section of the book, as it presents, in detail, the stakes of the argument, whilst also anchoring it in many different research literatures. Zhulina begins by theorizing “the notoriously difficult-to-define term ‘capital’” (p. 4), and in doing so, she makes useful comparisons between that concept and the very idea of theater, since they are both characterized by “the boundary between the visible and the invisible” (p. 7). She goes on to highlight other relevant dramatic-economic adjacencies, such as the idea that theater might just be “the oldest art form to expose how the economy relates to broader collective decisions” (p. 35). These connections, simple as they may seem, inform the hermeneutical justification of Zhulina’s entire project, as she aims to correct for a tendency within economic criticism to focus almost exclusively on novels.
After the introduction, the first chapter unfolds as an examination of several Ibsen plays, among them Pillars of the Community (1877) and An Enemy of the People (1882), against the backdrop of financialization, here defined simply as “the process by which financial institutions and elites gain control over economic policy” (p. 45). The chapter also includes comparative reflections on A Bankruptcy (1875), a play by Ibsen’s countryman and colleague Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson, as well as on a recent Ibsen production by Thomas Ostermeier. What is more, at this point Zhulina provides an insightful analysis of economic metaphors—especially with regard to the well-known trope of the invisible hand in Adam Smith and beyond—and a discussion about A Doll’s House (1879), in relation to, for example, theories of value and money in Marx. The only part of this multifaceted chapter that seems a bit out of place is the invocation of Ayad Akhtar’s play The Invisible Hand (2015) as a present-day example of how theater “puts the free market on trial in the spirit of Ibsen” (p. 66); it is too short to be an explication in its own right, and too long not to be read as an unnecessary digression, given the context of this being a chapter on Ibsen.
It is nevertheless in the second chapter that Zhulina makes the most out of immanent critique, both thematically and methodologically. As she identifies critiques of “the inherent contradiction of courtship and the love marriage in the age of capital” (p. 84) in works by Strindberg, Shaw, and Benedictsson, Zhulina performs a similar critique herself, against a certain economic understanding of sexuality in social thought today. That is, she utilizes the logical form of immanent critique when manifesting the existence of this very form in the plays at hand. Specifically, she criticizes the notion of “erotic capital,” famously and controversially theorized by sociologist Catherine Hakim, for its reductionist economism, whilst also putting it to work in the interpretations of Strindberg’s Miss Julie (1888) and Shaw’s Mrs. Warren’s Profession (1893). “[T]he value of the term ‘erotic capital,’” Zhulina claims, intriguingly and somewhat counterintuitively, “lies in its very contradiction—it presents itself as a capital when it often is not” (p. 89). Contradictions and antinomies abound in Theater of Capital, and this chapter is indeed an incisive attempt to partake, alongside the dramatists themselves, in the resolving of those.
In the third and fourth chapters, Zhulina studies Chekhov and Hauptmann, respectively, the former not least by way of his recurring depictions of gambling, e.g., in Three Sisters (1901) and The Cherry Orchard (1904), and the latter as a writer of “one of the first European plays to bring forth a true collectivity onto the stage” (p. 176), namely The Weavers (1892). These chapters are a bit shorter than the first two, but they nevertheless contain important ideas about, for instance, as in the Hauptmann chapter, “the advantages of the stage over the novel in representing labor” (p. 206), a point that aligns perfectly with the overarching theme of the book, and with its self-positioning vis-à-vis previous work in economic criticism. The focus on production history in the treatment of Hauptmann and The Weavers is especially pertinent in this regard, for it clearly demonstrates the merit of theater and theater studies for economic criticism—and vice versa.
As we have seen, there are many different economic ideas being discussed in this book, and the readings of each chapter vary quite a lot. However, a common thread is Zhulina’s contention that her selected playwrights approach economics more “as an integral part of human existence that involves fundamental questions of social morality and social organization” (p. 10) than as a narrow “science whose scope is limited to the study of mercantile exchanges” (p. 203). In Zhulina’s telling, then, “the late nineteenth-century theater of capital became a repository for economic ideas, models, and dreams that neoclassical economics discarded” (p. 203). The dramatists of her study offer alternative, increasingly anachronistic visions of economics, more in line with the ancient notion of the oikos—that is, of household management, broadly conceived—than with their era’s emerging ideas about the utility maximizing Homo economicus. Theirs is an economics of the social, and a critical rejection of the soon-to-be discipline that has continued to influence our world ever since.
I have but one noteworthy point of contention with this compelling monograph. In light of Zhulina’s laudable comparatist aims, I find it warranted to question her imbalanced preference for English-language publications when discussing non-anglophone writers. For instance, it is quite peculiar, in my view, to largely neglect the vast body of scholarly work on the Scandinavian playwrights of the study (Ibsen, Strindberg, Benedictsson) that is conducted and published in Scandinavian languages, especially if done without much comment. By simply giving more credit to such prior work, Zhulina could have avoided any conceivable, but surely mistaken, accusations of parochialism.
COMPETING INTERESTS
The author declares no competing interests exist.
