Between 1968 and 1982, filmmakers working within the Palestinian Liberation Organization produced a body of films in support of the Palestinian revolution. Filmmakers working within Arab public-sector cinema industries, as well as solidarity activists around the world, also produced films about the Palestinian cause during this time. The films were mostly modest works, limited in scope by the means available to filmmakers and the precarious contexts in which they worked. Nonetheless, they circulated widely through film festivals in the Arab world and Eastern Europe and activist circles elsewhere. When the PLO left Beirut as a result of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, its filmmaking mostly stopped and the films themselves faded from view.
Palestinian archives in Beirut, including those that held films and footage, disappeared during the invasion, but copies of many of the works survived in the private archives of filmmakers from that period and those of institutions around the world where film copies had been sent for screenings. During the past two decades, a new generation of filmmakers, artists, curators, and scholars has worked to find, restore, and digitize this early Palestinian cinema, and a number of important new films have emerged from these projects. They include Azza El-Hassan's Kings and Extras (2004) about the disappearance of the archive of the Palestinian Cinema Institute during the Israeli invasion, Emily Jacir and Monica Maurer's restoration of the feature-length documentary Tal el-Zaatar (1977) about the siege and fall of the eponymous Palestinian refugee camp during the Lebanese civil war, Annemarie Jacir's feature-length fictional film When I Saw You (2012), which is set in a refugee camp and Palestinian military base in Jordan in the late 1960s, Basma Alsharif's video O, Persecuted (2014), which engages directly with the 1974 film Our Small Houses that Kassem Hawal made for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, and Rona Sela's film Looted and Hidden (2017) about stolen Palestinian archives, including film and photography archives, held in Israel.
One of the most substantive of such works to emerge in recent years is Mohanad Yaqubi's masterful essay film Off Frame AKA Revolution Until Victory (2016). Comprised of photographs and footage from dozens of early material created by and about Palestinians, the film elicits an affective and contemplative engagement with the Palestinian revolution and its visual production. Off Frame presents its material directly, without a narrator, relying on editing and the juxtaposition of image and sound to shape the viewer's experience with this early material. Although it does offer the bare bones of a chronology through sparse intertitles, it offers no historical narrative or contextual explanation of the PLO film movement. Footage is organized thematically rather than chronologically, with clips from different periods of the revolution intermingling so as to emphasize continuity of its political aims across time even as it thematizes different aspects of the struggle (e.g., engagement with violence, the participation of women and children, and, most saliently, the PLO's attention to its own image production).
The film is divided into three segments, each of which is introduced by a series of introductory still images. In the first, a range of pre-1948 images of Palestine, including early Orientalist photographs and shots of life during mandate Palestine, precedes a section focused on Palestinian loss, suggesting a line of continuity with regard to the loss of land, society, and rights stretching from the European colonial period through the 1948 and 1967 wars, as well as the seeds of resistance that were planted during that period and blossomed into an organized national liberation movement in the late 1960s in Jordan. A second set of stills, this time heroic images of Palestinian militancy, accentuates the integral role of armed struggle to the revolution. A series of studio portraits of young men and women posing as fida'iyin introduces the final segment, which focuses on the revolution as a mature movement – one in which the extreme violence of Israeli attacks on Lebanon and Syria and the Palestinian participation in the Lebanese civil war have been folded into a national culture with symbols and ritual practices acclaiming a robust nationalism. The images, from Hashim al-Madani's studio in Sidon, Lebanon, suggest the degree to which the revolutionary goal of creating a Palestinian peoplehood had succeeded while also emphasizing the performative nature of that peoplehood.
Off Frame is bookended by scenes from the present: Yaqubi himself viewing and editing the older material he is turning into a film, and shots in a school in Ramallah where bored children listen to a nationalist lesson and salute the Palestinian flag to the stentorian strains of the national anthem. The contextualization of the 1970s material within these contemporary shots invites an ironic distance through which viewers can contemplate the distance that separates the revolution from the current state of Palestinian politics. The symbols of a Palestinian national movement have survived, but the spirit of engagement and collective purpose that the earlier footage suggests have not, at least not within the official structures (the Palestinian Authority and its education system) that claim descent from the revolution. And yet, Off Frame itself is not cynical, for while it reveals the gulf that separates the period of the revolution from the present, it also suggests the possibility of bridging that gulf, of mounting alternative claims to this chapter of Palestinian history in order to draw different, perhaps more agential lessons.
Off Frame is an excellent addition to courses on modern Middle East history, the Arab-Israeli conflict, and Arab, Middle East, or Third World cinema. The film effectively conveys the dynamism of the Palestinian revolution that attracted activists from around the world. It also offers a rich selection of militant images that were integral to political (as well as a popular strand of commercial) filmmaking from the Arab world in the late 1960s and early 1970s.
