No one has offered a comprehensive synthesis on Roman Egypt since Ulrich Wilcken's 1885 dissertation, and his Grundzüge und Chrestomathie der Papyruskunde (1912). This is proof of the difficulty of the topic, due to the peculiar nature of its principal source, the papyri, often oracular when asked historical questions. Erhard Schaub ambitiously aims to fill the gap, presenting us with a history of Egypt from Octavian to Diocletian, centred on the ‘population’ (Bevölkerung). S.’s 2014 dissertation Aufstände im römischen Ägypten generates the main arguments here: Egypt did not rise against the emperors in the first three centuries of Roman domination because the Fellachen were mainly concerned with agriculture, and lived in such poor conditions that they could not be preoccupied with politics (an interesting statement in the age of populism). At Alexandria, distinct and competitive Interessengruppen, namely Alexandrians, Greeks and Jews, kept fighting each other, and never managed or wanted to oppose Rome. Civic strife went on until the second century, when Trajan quelled the Jewish insurrection in favour of the Greeks, and prompted a period of renewed prosperity. Despite further city riots, and endemic anachoresis, the occupying Roman army discouraged any Egyptian rebellion, partly because it was more helpful (helfend, 194) than oppressive. The Jewish revolt of a.d. 116/117 did not affect the Egyptians, who fought on the side of Rome, both because they historically hated the Jews and because they had no great economic problems that could spark a revolt against Trajan. The rebellious Boukoloi were a sect, sharing nothing with the peasants except poverty (197–8), although their revolt went on for over a decade, and required the intervention of troops from Syria (116–18). Prices remained stable, taxes not too high and inflation low: a ‘success story’ (Erfolgsgeschichte) which was ended only around a.d. 270 by the Palmyrene invasion, which prompted an open revolt, quelled with difficulty by Diocletian. Against most recent scholarship, which shows that Egypt was a Roman province, governed by Roman magistrates and garrisoned by Roman troops who were more often threatening than kind, S. concludes that Egypt was indeed a ‘special case’ (Sonderstellung): a remote province with peculiar local traditions, which Octavian left more or less unchanged, modifying the tax system ‘only a little’ (191). For him, many inhabitants of second-century Egypt would have agreed with Gibbon's view that their world was governed with exceptional ‘wisdom and virtue’ (209).
There are too many conspicuous absences in the bibliography to be listed here; it will be enough to note the omission of R. S. Bagnall's Oxford Handbook of Papyrology (2009) and C. Riggs’ Oxford Handbook of Roman Egypt (2012). The positive aspect of this book is its close analysis of third-century topics such as the reforms of Philip the Arab, the usurpations of Mussius Aemilianus and Firmus, the age of Probus and the attack of the Blemmyes, the revolts of Coptos and Busiris. However, there is too strong a contrast between this part and the chapters on the ‘peaceful’ first and second centuries. The idea that Egypt was one of the ‘most tranquil’ (ruhigste, 191) Roman provinces should be revised. At Alexandria there was a lively opposition to Rome. Apart from Timagenes, censored for criticising Augustus, the death of Cornelius Gallus was significant, but his elegiacs on papyrus, recently restudied by M. Capasso, are omitted. On Germanicus’ visit, perhaps more than a tour of Egyptian antiquities, S. reverts to Wilcken. The ‘Jewish question’ at Alexandria is oversimplified, and all Acta are excluded (except, for some reason, the Acta Isidori). The riots are depicted as a clash of civilisations, and the Jews are seen as an isolated group, despite the fact that they had lived with the local population since the Pharaonic period, and were in close touch with other Diaspora communities and Judaea. The Roman army indeed intervened to quell a revolt: Josephus (Jewish War 2.490–8) reports that, in a.d. 66, the prefect Tiberius Julius Alexander launched the Roman legions against the Jews, killing 50,000 people (probably not only in Alexandria). In my view, the prefect Rutilius Lupus evoked this massacre as ‘the battle of the Romans against the Jews’ in his edict of 14 October 115 (PMilVogl 2.47) to discourage further retaliation. The thesis that during the Jewish revolt all Egyptians fought on the side of Rome is unsupported by any positive evidence. On the contrary, a contemporary letter (CPJ 2.438) laments: ‘The one hope and expectation that was left was the push of the massed villagers (ἀθρώων κωμητῶν) from our district against the impious Jews; but now the opposite has happened.’ At least some Egyptians, like the inhabitants of other regions, joined the revolt: when Hadrian came to power, not only the regions just conquered by Trajan defected, but also ‘the Moors began to make attacks, the Sarmatians waged war, the Britons could not be kept under Roman sway, Egypt was thrown into disorder by riots, and finally Libya and Palestine showed the spirit of rebellion’ (HA Hadr. 5.2). Hadrian's foundations of Aelia Capitolina on the site of Jerusalem and of Antinoopolis in Egypt were part of a consistent strategy, not confined to Jews. Under the later Antonines, the insurrections of the Boukoloi share many features of the Jewish revolt (and, for example, of the later Circumcelliones): poverty, social revenge, millenarian hopes, strange liturgical habits, deformed by later accounts into a world of desperadoes, cannibals and transvestites. Another major crisis took place under Commodus: in the Acta Appiani, the gymnasiarch Appian (in my view the son of the famous surgeon Heraclianus) depicted Commodus as a tyrant. Caracalla's massacre of a.d. 215 here seems to come out of the blue (138), a view challenged long ago; Severus’ visit to Egypt, preceded by edicts forbidding oracles and closing the tomb of Alexander, and PGiss 40, especially the third edict, would deserve more discussion. When Tacitus (Hist. 1.11) called Egypt ‘difficult of access, productive of great harvests, but given to civil strife and sudden disturbances because of the fanaticism and superstition of its inhabitants, ignorant as they are of laws and unacquainted with civil magistrates’, he probably mirrored the current Roman attitude, influenced by a history of small-scale, but diehard opposition. His later definition of Tiberius Julius Alexander, an Alexandrian Jew, as eiusdem nationis, shows that, on some occasions, Alexandrians, Graeco-Egyptians and Jews could all be labelled ‘seditious Egyptians’.
