Farzin Vejdani's Making History in Iran tells how modern history writing emerged in Iran by focusing on its formative years between 1860 and 1940. There have been significant contributions to the scholarship of Iranian nationalism, many of which have addressed some aspects of the construction of nationalist historiography. Yet, scant attention has been paid to how individual historians were positioned in relation to social networks, institutional contexts, and dominant discourses as well as how these positions informed their framings of historical narratives. By closely looking at the “institutional, material, and public contexts” (p. 15) in which national history came to be written, Vejdani provides a highly nuanced account of how history evolved as a discipline at a time when the nation was being forged.
Vejdani demonstrates that a broad segment of the Iranian population came to engage in history writing. Rather than being the exclusive domain of a small number of Iranian intellectuals and European Orientalists, many groups of literate Iranians, including teachers, statesmen, government officials, clerics, notables, poets, and journalists expressed contending visions of the past as useful lessons to serve their respective visions of the future of the nation. Consequently, rather than being passive consumers of history produced by luminary intellectuals, even when state control over history writing was tight, various segments of society played an important role in shaping Iranian nationalism and defining the Iranian nation through history writing.
The structure of the book is both chronological and thematic. The first three chapters are organized chronologically and trace the development of history as a discipline. Vejdani emphasizes how changes such as innovations in print technologies, the establishment of private modern schools, and the weakness of the central state freed history writing from the restrictions imposed by the patron-client relationship with the Qajar court. At the turn of the 20th century, wealthy patrons, including constitutionalists, funded history writing, resulting in the popularity of a people-centered history. In the interwar period, however, the centralizing Pahlavi state attempted to standardize history through its propaganda institutions and state-run modern schools. Therefore, while the expansion of modern education created employment for history writers (albeit of low socioeconomic status), their autonomy diminished significantly, which in turn narrowed the range of positions they could take.
The next two chapters cover the period from the Constitutional Revolution to the late Reza Shah period and thematically focus on two groups that were largely excluded in the national history of Iran: namely, women and local historians. As case studies, these chapters demonstrate the broad base of participation in history writing, the wax and wane of their autonomy, the increasing prevalence of the nation (and its unity) as the primary category upon which the evaluation of historical figures was based, and the internal diversity of viewpoints that reflected the diverse social backgrounds of history writers.
The final chapter examines the process of literary canonization and demonstrates how Iranian nationalists actively participated in the process rather than uncritically accept Orientalist scholarship, as Mostafa Vaziri's controversial work has argued. The point to which the author returns throughout the book is most clearly demonstrated in this chapter: that is, the significance of transnational imaginations and encounters in the making of nationalized history. This is an important point that historians such as Mohamad Tavakoli-Targhi and Afshin Marashi have made in the context of Indo-Iranian connections. In previous chapters, Vejdani has provided numerous examples of transnational imaginations expressed in history writing, such as exemplary biographies of mainly “Eastern” women printed in Iranian women's periodicals in order to legitimize their agenda, and even a subtle call for female suffrage (pp. 102–12). In the final chapter, Vejdani discusses what he calls “transnational epistolary encounters” (p. 146), referring to the exchange of letters between the Orientalist scholar E. G. Browne and the Iranian and Indian interlocutors who influenced his scholarship. In turn, among the body of Orientalist scholarship, Iranian nationalists strategically chose to celebrate Browne's scholarship due to his anti-imperial stance and praise for contemporary Persian literature. Since his scholarship was widely disseminated in the Reza Shah period as modern education became more centralized and standardized, reciprocal transnational encounters contributed to the making of the Iranian nation.
As Vejdani notes, “any act of periodization carries with it certain assumptions about continuities and ruptures” (p. 83). Viewing history writing as a practice of various segments of society, Vejdani questions the imposition on social and cultural history of the conventional periodization of Iranian history based on political events. The periodization of Vejdani's book is similar to that in the scholarship of historians such as Marashi and Camron Michael Amin. He treats the mid-19th century to the mid-20th century as a crucial period of transition for the formation of the Iranian nation. Vejdani pays attention to continuity before and after major political upheavals. For instance, rather than seeing the Constitutional Revolution as a rupture in the history of education, Vejdani stresses the impact of Muzaffari-era (1896–1907) private educational institutions and networks on the development of education after the revolution that started in 1905. Likewise, neither the 1921 coup nor the change of dynasties in 1925 represents a radical break. To examine the methods in which the love for the nation was inculcated at educational institutions, the author uses teachers’ pedagogical manuals, including one written by ʿIsa Sadiq in 1919, rightly indicating that ideas of history and pedagogy formulated prior to political change were implemented in early Pahlavi Iran.
I wish Making History in Iran contained more images such as cartoons and maps, especially because the author's primary sources include historical writings that were printed in the popular press as serialized articles, some of which abundantly used images, as well as teachers’ pedagogical manuals that advocated the use of maps. How was the Iranian nation represented in such cartoons and maps? How was the nation's perceived “other,” such as the Turks and the Mongols, represented? How were religious minorities, whom the author mentions mostly in passing, represented? Considering that historical texts were sometimes printed in conjunction with cartoons and maps, these discussions could have expanded Vejdani's analysis of history writing.
These minor critiques aside, this is a strong, insightful contribution that sheds light on the agency of a broad segment of Iranian society in the making of modern Iran. Due to the comparative framework Vejdani employs throughout the book, this text would be useful not only to those interested in nationalism and historiography in Iran but also to students of these subjects in other geographic contexts. Vejdani's use of accessible language to discuss complex ideas also makes the book appropriate for advanced undergraduate courses.
