Belarus is a postcommunist state located between the European Union, on the one hand, and Russia, on the other. In the past decade, this country with the population of approximately nine million people has become known as Europe's last dictatorship. President Alyaksandr Lukashenka, who has held the post since 1994 and grooms his seven-year-old son Kolya as his successor, has consolidated power and unleashed violence against the political opposition. Several presidential candidates, for example, were arrested during the 2010 elections, and the police violently dispersed protests against vote rigging and secured Lukashenka's fourth term in office. The survival of a nondemocratic regime in Belarus makes it an interesting case study for examining the causes of authoritarian resilience.
Andrew Wilson's Belarus offers an incisive analysis of the country's history and politics. The author seeks to answer two main questions: 1) “Is Belarus a proper country?” and 2) “Why has Belarus ended up with Lukashenka?” (p. xi). To address these issues, he has divided the book into two parts. Part I traces the origins of the Belarusian nation and scrutinizes its path to statehood. Part II covers Belarusian politics from the late Gorbachev period to the present day. In particular, the second half of the book focuses on Lukashenka's presidency.
The first six chapters, comprising Part I, meticulously investigate the genesis of Belarusian national identity. Chapter 1 discusses a foundation myth centered around the medieval city of Polatsk. Chapter 2 explores the role of the grand duchy in the construction of the national narrative. The next two chapters scrutinize political developments in the region between the thirteenth and eighteenth centuries. Chapter 5 traces the emergence of rival identity options in the nineteenth and the early twentieth centuries. This part concludes with the analysis of the national idea from the 1900s to the 1980s.
Turning to more recent events, Part II delves into the study of Belarusian politics from the late 1980s onward. Before plunging into the discussion of authoritarianism and nationalism in the former Soviet republic, the book draws a profile of contemporary Belarus, supplying detailed information about its current territory and the population. The next two chapters examine the rise of the Belarusian national movement in the 1980s and the emergence of independent Belarus after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Finally, three chapters are devoted to the analysis of the political regime under Lukashenka, with each presidential term discussed in a separate chapter. An additional chapter dispels the myth of the economic miracle in the authoritarian state. The book concludes with a discussion of policy dilemmas faced by the incumbent ruler.
The book's forte lies in the well-documented survey of pre-Soviet Belarusian history. Compared to a few recent publications on the topic (Brian Benett, The Last Dictatorship in Europe: Belarus under Lukashenko, 2011; David Marples, Belarus: A Denationalized Nation, 1999; Stephen White, Elena Korosteleva, and John Lowenhardt, Postcommunist Belarus, 2005), Belarus devotes much more attention to the origins of the nation. The book is rich in historical detail, immersing the reader in the complexities of nation-building processes in Eastern Europe and supporting Wilson's contention about “a series of false starts” in the development of the Belarusian nation (p. 255).
As an expert on Ukrainian history and politics (e.g., see Ukraine's Orange Revolution, 2005; The Ukrainians: Unexpected Nation, 2009), Wilson frequently brings up the case of Ukraine to draw a contrast between the two Slavic nations. The book under review, for example, stresses the fact that Belarusians lacked a prototype of a Belarusian state, comparable to the Cossack Hetmanate in the seventeenth century (pp. 43–45). Another interesting observation is that Belarusians were unable to counterbalance Polish Roman Catholicism with their own version of Orthodox Christianity in the nineteenth century. Wilson states that “Orthodoxy meant belonging to all-Russian culture” in the nineteenth-century Belarus, whereas Ukrainian intellectuals built a national identity based upon a distinct (non-Russian) version of Orthodoxy (p. 63). Moreover, the author notes that the dissident movement was much weaker in Soviet Belarus than in neighboring Ukraine, leading to negative consequences for the political opposition in the 1990s (p. 143). For scholars interested in East European societies, the book provides an enormously valuable resource.
This thoroughly researched analysis of Belarusian history and politics would have reached an even wider audience if it had been better grounded in comparative politics literature. Having adopted the case study approach, Wilson omits a discussion of extant scholarship on nationalism and authoritarianism. For example, he does not explicitly state how his analysis of Lukashenka's Belarus fits in with prior research on the survival of nondemocracies around the globe. By the same token, the presentation of most material in chronological order dilutes the salience of key explanatory variables.
Nonetheless, this work speaks to the debate over the durability of authoritarian regimes. Scholars have identified a wide range of political, socioeconomic, and cultural factors conducive to authoritarianism. This book focuses on the concept of national identity to explain the rise and the persistence of the nondemocratic regime in Belarus. The analysis clearly demonstrates how historical legacies had an impact on nation building and regime consolidation in contemporary Belarus. Wilson states that the incumbent president secured political support among a significant share of voters due to three interrelated strategies: 1) the pursuit of “egalitarian nationalism,” 2) the supply of public goods, and 3) an eclectic version of national identity (pp. 257–58). In addition, the analysis illustrates how external actors can affect the regime's survival. The book suggests that the flow of Russian subsidies for the Belarusian economy and, in particular, the provision of cheap energy resources enabled Lukashenka to appease his electorate, especially the elderly rural population, by virtue of social spending.
Another incumbent strategy discussed in the book is the creation of state-controlled institutions as an alternative to genuinely independent civil society actors. The establishment of a state-controlled public opinion company, for example, was used to fabricate exit poll data in line with the official electoral results, undermining the legitimacy of the opposition's claims about vote rigging (p. 207). It might have been helpful for the reader to see a full list of incumbent strategies and tactics summarized in the concluding chapter so that it could be applied to the analysis of other nondemocratic regimes.
Taken as a whole, the book makes an important contribution to our understanding of nation building and authoritarianism in contemporary Europe. In particular, this work directs our attention to the linkage between the development of national identity and the consolidation of a nondemocratic regime. An area for future research is the interplay between economic reform and authoritarian resilience. As Wilson observes in the concluding chapter, Lukashenka faces the challenge of maintaining a high level of social spending in an economy largely unreformed since Soviet times. The shrinkage of the welfare state might expose the extent to which the identity issue alone can sustain the political longevity of the autocratic incumbent.
