In the building frenzy of present-day Shanghai, housing built and neighborhoods established in the early twentieth century are quickly disappearing save for a few on the Bund or in the former French Concession. Scholars have argued for the preservation of old neighborhoods that are historically valuable, but amidst the beehive of commerce that is Shanghai today, their pleas are often dismissed as misplaced nostalgia. Old Shanghai has been ruthlessly destroyed.
Few, however, know that this is not the first time that modern Shanghai was torn down—not because of war or revolution, but because of commerce. In the late nineteenth century Shanghai experienced its first boom in the modern era, creating a city that was as “modern” as the nation had ever seen. Yet much of the city, at least physically, was razed and replaced throughout the early twentieth century. Samuel Liang's Mapping Modernity in Shanghai reconstructs a world that has largely vanished and, to some extent, has been forgotten. Liang views “nineteenth-century modernity as another form of modernity rather than a premature version of the positivist notion of the modern” (p. 26). In other words, late nineteenth-century Shanghai has its own place in the formation of this great city and, more importantly, in China's search for modernity
Liang's book can be seen first of all as a work of urban and architectural history on a period when virtually all of what were to become old Shanghai's landmark buildings, such as those on the Bund, as well as its trademark buildings—those that came to be recognized as characteristically “of Shanghai”—had not yet been built. In meticulous detail Liang describes how modern Shanghai developed from a configuration of housing compounds known as li, where private rooms and courtyards were virtually extensions of streets and public spaces. Such an urban layout facilitated not only the integration of private quarters and public spaces but also the mingling of a wide breadth of society. Although the source materials Liang has used for this study are hardly new to scholars in the field, he should be credited for piecing together and conjuring up the life of modern Shanghai in its adolescence, so to speak. Readers will readily visualize the foreign concessions, brimming with a multitude of businesses and shops, the core of modern Shanghai where the great majority of residents were recently arrived Chinese sojourners. Liang depicts the life in courtesan houses, restaurants, opium dens, teahouses, theaters, and gardens as well as activities and events in public spaces such as storytelling, parades, and spectatorship.
The centerpiece of the study is the numerous courtesan houses in the then newly established “foreign places” (yichang), namely the British Settlement and French Concession north of the walled old Chinese city. The book therefore is also relevant to women's and gender studies. The courtesan houses and the culture surrounding these commercial establishments offered Shanghai's male sojourners—the clientele consisted mostly of merchants and literati—a place they might call “home,” with the comforts, pleasures, and solace associated with those usually provided by the wife. Liang captures what he calls the “ephemeral splendor of the courtesan culture” (p. 83) and engages with previous scholarship—such as the works of Catherine Yeh, Christian Henriot, and Gail Hershatter—on prostitution in Shanghai. Liang argues that these surrogate “homes” hosted by substitute “wives” were sites that reveal the complex dynamics of Chinese society rather than the simple oppression of women. In that regard, Liang joins the ranks of recent scholars, such as Dorothy Ko and Susan Mann, in rejecting the image of a simple and total victimization of Chinese women. This approach to the issue of gender inequality parallels the book's thesis that late nineteenth-century Shanghai represented “a hybrid and multifaceted modern development that stands in contrast to the positivist conception of the modern marked by progress and totality” (p. 7).
That the author has been able to include in this slim volume (the text runs about 180 pages) a good amount of detail on popular and material culture is impressive. Readers will be struck by the picture Liang paints of the teeming humanity of Shanghai's streets in the three decades after the city recovered from the catastrophe of the Taiping Rebellion (1850–64). At times the author may rely too heavily on literary and artistic sources, such as Han Bangqing's 1894 novel Flowers of Shanghai, and the Shenbao supplement, the Dianshizhai Pictorial, but he nonetheless effectively weaves together disparate pieces of material culture into a coherent fabric: the interiors of courtesan houses and the layout of ordinary homes, changing views of the pleasure quarters, the marvels on the Bund, the façades of Western-style houses, the use of glass, the printing industry, travel and guide books, and so on. Much of the material culture depicted in the book was new and seen as novel (as well as a novelty) at the time, but it did not consist solely, as the author emphasizes, of “things Western,” but rather things “hybridized” and reflective of the complexity and creativity inherent in Chinese modernity.
Studies of modern Shanghai have disproportionately focused on the city in the early twentieth century, particularly in the Republican era. Liang's work is a welcome remedy to this obvious imbalance in the field. For its glimpse of life in late nineteenth-century Shanghai and for its rethinking of issues related to city, gender, and modernity, it will be a useful handbook for historians and students of cultural studies.
