Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:53:36.809Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Flow-excited membrane instability at moderate Reynolds numbers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 November 2021

Guojun Li*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, National University of Singapore, 119077 Singapore, Republic of Singapore
Rajeev Kumar Jaiman
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4 Canada
Boo Cheong Khoo
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, National University of Singapore, 119077 Singapore, Republic of Singapore
*
†Email address for correspondence: li.guojun@u.nus.edu

Abstract

In this paper, we study the fluid–structure interaction of a three-dimensional (3-D) flexible membrane immersed in an unsteady separated flow at moderate Reynolds numbers. We employ a body-conforming variational fluid–structure interaction solver based on the recently developed partitioned iterative scheme for the coupling of turbulent fluid flow with nonlinear structural dynamics. Of particular interest is to understand the flow-excited instability of a 3-D flexible membrane as a function of the non-dimensional mass ratio ($m^{*}$), Reynolds number ($Re$) and aeroelastic number ($Ae$). For a wide range of parameters, we examine two distinct stability regimes of the fluid–membrane interaction: deformed steady state (DSS) and dynamic balance state (DBS). We propose stability phase diagrams to demarcate the DSS and DBS regimes for the parameter space of mass ratio versus Reynolds number ($m^{*}$-$Re$) and mass ratio versus aeroelastic number ($m^{*}$-$Ae$). With the aid of the global Fourier mode decomposition technique, the distinct dominant vibrational modes are identified from the intertwined membrane responses in the parameter space of $m^{*}$-$Re$ and $m^{*}$-$Ae$. Compared to the deformed steady membrane, the flow-excited vibration produces relatively longer attached leading-edge vortices which improve the aerodynamic performance when the coupled system is near the flow-excited instability boundary. The optimal aerodynamic performance is achieved for lighter membranes with higher $Re$ and larger flexibility. Based on the global aeroelastic mode analysis, we observe a frequency lock-in phenomenon between the vortex-shedding frequency and the membrane vibration frequency causing self-sustained vibrations in the dynamic balance state. To characterize the origin of the frequency lock-in, we propose an approximate analytical formula for the nonlinear natural frequency by considering the added mass effect and employing a large deflection theory for a simply supported rectangular membrane. Through our systematic high-fidelity numerical investigation, we find that the onset of the membrane vibration and the mode transition has a direct dependence on the frequency lock-in between the natural frequency of the tensioned membrane and the vortex-shedding frequency or its harmonics. These findings on the fluid-elastic instability of membranes have implications for the design and development of control strategies for membrane wing-based unmanned systems and drones.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Flow past a flexible membrane wing: (a) schematic of fluid-membrane interaction; (b) illustration of three-dimensional membrane wing with free-stream velocity $U_{\infty }$ and a given angle of attack $\alpha$. In panel (a), the red dashed line indicates the time-averaged membrane shape, and the black solid line represents the instantaneous membrane shape. In panel (b), the red and blue contours are the positive and negative membrane displacements, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Three-dimensional computational set-up for a fluid–membrane interaction: (a) membrane wing geometry and support frame section; (b) schematic diagram of computational domain and boundary conditions.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Stability phase diagram: non-dimensional Reynolds number $Re$ (R1$\to$9) versus mass ratio $m^{*}$ (M1$\to$6) for the 3-D flexible membrane at $Ae=423.14$ for $\alpha =15^{\circ }$. Here, the dashed line is plotted to distinguish the flow-excited instability boundary, $\square$ denotes the simulation results corresponding to the deformed steady state and $\triangle$, $\triangleright$, $\Diamond$ and $\circ$ respectively represent the chord-wise first and span-wise second mode (C1S2), the chord-wise second and span-wise first mode (C2S1), the chord-wise second and span-wise fifth mode (C2S5) and the chord-wise second and span-wise ninth mode (C2S9) in the dynamic balance state. The label with or without filled colour is the flexible membrane with attached vortices or vortex shedding, respectively.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Dominant aeroelastic modes of 3-D flexible membrane in DBS regime: (a–d) the chord-wise first and span-wise second mode at (M6,R5) and (e–h) the chord-wise second and span-wise first mode at (M4,R5). Contours are coloured by the real part of the Fourier transform coefficients of membrane displacement on the whole surface (a,e), membrane surface pressure difference (b,f), pressure coefficient fluctuation on the mid-span plane (c,g) and $y$-vorticity fluctuation on the mid-span plane (d,h).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Coupled fluid–membrane dynamic characteristics of the 3-D flexible membrane at $Ae=423.14$ for $\alpha =15^{\circ }$ over the full $m^{*}$-$Re$ parameter space: (a) time-averaged lift coefficient; (b) time-averaged lift-to-drag ratio; (c) maximum time-averaged non-dimensional membrane deflection; (d) maximum r.m.s. membrane deflection fluctuation; (e) non-dimensional dominant frequency in fluid domain; and (f) non-dimensional dominant frequency in structural domain via the FMD approach. The dashed line is the flow-excited instability boundary given by the empirical solution equation (4.2), $\square$ represents the membrane with a deformed steady state and $\triangle$, $\triangleright$, $\Diamond$ and $\circ$ denote the dominant modes with the C1S2, C2S1, C2S5 and C2S9 mode shapes, respectively. The blank region in panel (f) represents the deformed steady membrane without vibration.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Comparison of flow features of the flexible membrane with attached vortices (M3,R6) (a,c) and vortex shedding (M5,R4) (b,d) for instantaneous streamlines coloured by pressure coefficient (a,b) and time-averaged pressure coefficient difference $\overline {C}_p^{d}$ between upper and lower surfaces (c,d).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Evolution of 3-D membrane dynamics as a function of $m^{*}$: (a) time-averaged lift coefficient and r.m.s. lift coefficient fluctuation; (b) time-averaged drag coefficient and r.m.s. drag coefficient fluctuation; (c) time-averaged lift-to-drag ratio; and (d) maximum time-averaged normalized membrane deflection and r.m.s. membrane deflection fluctuation.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Time histories of instantaneous lift coefficients (a) and normalized displacements (b) at the membrane centre along the $z$-direction for four selected cases with $m^{*}=1.2$, 2.4, 3.6 and 14.4 at a fixed $Re=24\,300$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Instantaneous streamlines of 3-D flexible membrane wing on the mid-span plane coloured by pressure coefficient for $(Re,m^{*})=(24\,300,1.2)$ (a), $(24\,300,2.4)$ (b), $(24\,300,3.6)$(c) and $(24\,300,14.4)$ (d).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Flow past a 3-D rectangular membrane wing: (a–d) full-body profile responses of 3-D flexible membrane wing at mid-span location; (e–h) time-averaged pressure coefficient difference between upper and lower surfaces; (i–l) turbulent intensity; and (m–p) time-averaged normalized velocity magnitude on five slices along the span-wise direction at $(Re,m^{*})=(24\,300,1.2)$ (a,e,i,m), $(24\,300,2.4)$ (b,f,j,n), $(24\,300,3.6)$ (c,g,k,o), $(24\,300,14.4)$ (d,h,l,p). The red dashed line denotes the time-averaged membrane shape in panels (a–d).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Mode frequency and energy map of coupled fluid–membrane system based on FMD analysis as a function of $m^{*}$: (a) comparison of aeroelastic mode frequencies between decomposed Fourier modes of the $Y$-vorticity field in the fluid domain and the structural modes with obvious mode energy; and (b) mode energies of the structural first and second modes.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Time histories of instantaneous lift coefficients (a) and normalized displacements (b) at the membrane centre along the $z$-direction for four selected cases with $Re=2430$, 12 150, 24 300 and 72 900 at a fixed $m^{*}=4.2$.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Instantaneous streamlines of 3-D flexible membrane wing on the mid-span plane coloured by pressure coefficient for $(Re,m^{*})=(2430,4.2)$ (a), $(12\,150,4.2)$ (b), $(24\,300,4.2)$ (c) and $(72\,900,4.2)$ (d).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Flow past a 3-D rectangular membrane wing: (a–d) full-body responses of 3-D flexible membrane wing at mid-span location; (e–h) time-averaged pressure coefficient difference between upper and lower surfaces; (i–l) turbulent intensity; and (m–p) time-averaged normalized velocity magnitude on five slices along the span-wide direction at $(Re,m^{*})=(2430,4.2)$ (a,e,i,m), $(12\,150,4.2)$ (b,f,j,n), $(24\,300,4.2)$ (c,g,k,o), $(72\,900,4.2)$ (d,h,l,p). The red dashed line denotes the time-averaged membrane shape in panels (a–d).

Figure 14

Figure 15.Mode frequency and energy map of fluid–membrane coupled system based on FMD analysis as a function of $Re$: (a) comparison of aeroelastic mode frequencies between decomposed Fourier modes of the $Y$-vorticity field in the fluid domain and the structural modes with obvious mode energy; (b) mode energies of the structural first and second modes.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Stability phase diagram: non-dimensional aeroelastic number $Ae$ versus mass ratio $m^{*}$ for the 3-D flexible membrane at $Re=24\,300$ for $\alpha =15^{\circ }$. Here, the dashed line is plotted to distinguish the flow-excited instability boundary, $\square$ denotes the simulation results corresponding to the deformed-steady state and $\triangle$, $\Diamond$ and $\triangleright$ represent the C1S2 mode, the C2S1 mode and the C2S2 mode in the dynamic balance state, respectively.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Coupled fluid–membrane dynamic characteristics of the 3-D flexible membrane at $Re=24\,300$ for $\alpha =15^{\circ }$ over the $m^{*}$-$Ae$ full parameter space: (a) time-averaged lift coefficient; (b) time-averaged lift-to-drag ratio; (c) maximum time-averaged non-dimensional membrane deflection; (d) maximum r.m.s. membrane deflection fluctuation; (e) non-dimensional dominant frequency in fluid domain; and (f) non-dimensional dominant frequency in structural domain through the FMD approach. The blank region in panel (f) represents the deformed-steady membrane without vibration.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Time histories of instantaneous lift coefficients (a) and normalized displacements (b) at the membrane centre along the $z$-direction for four selected cases with $Ae=84.63$, 423.14, 1269.42 and 2115.7 at a fixed $m^{*}=9.6$.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Flow past a 3-D rectangular membrane wing: (a–d) full-body responses of 3-D flexible membrane wing at mid-span location; (e–h) time-averaged pressure coefficient difference between the upper and lower surfaces; (i–l) time-averaged streamlines and normalized velocity magnitude on the mid-span plane at $(Ae,m^{*})=(84.63,9.6)$ (a,e,i), $(423.14,9.6)$ (b,f,j), $(1269.42,9.6)$ (c,g,k), $(2115.7,9.6)$ (d,h,l). The red dashed line denotes the time-averaged membrane shape in panels (a–d).

Figure 19

Figure 20.Schematic of the positions of the monitoring lines and points. The red dashed line indicates the time-averaged membrane shape. The black solid line represents the instantaneous membrane shape.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Schematic of a rectangular membrane with all fixed edges undergoing large amplitude vibration in a uniform flow. A deformed shape and the Gaussian quadrature procedure are illustrated.

Figure 21

Figure 22.Areal strain of mean membrane shape and r.m.s. of areal strain (a,c,e) and comparison of natural frequencies of tensioned membrane and vortex-shedding frequencies measured along Line2 (b,d,f) as a function of $m^{*}$ at fixed $(Re,Ae)=(24\,300,423.14)$ (a,b), $Re$ at fixed $(m^{*},Ae)=(4.2,423.14)$ (c,d) and $Ae$ at fixed $(m^{*},Re)=(1.2,24\,300)$ (e,f). The areal strain is calculated by integrating the finite element area from the structural responses. The nonlinear natural frequency is predicted by (4.6) with the aid of numerical simulations.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Cross-correlation between the membrane deflection fluctuation $\delta _n^{\prime }$ collected at three equispaced points along the membrane surface and the local flow velocity fluctuation $u^{\prime }$ measured at the point in the middle of monitoring Line1 near the leading edge (a,c,e) and monitoring Line2 (b,d,f) in the proximity of the trailing edge as a function of $m^{*}$ at fixed $(Re,Ae)=(24\,300,423.14)$ (a,b), $Re$ at fixed $(m^{*},Ae)=(4.2,423.14)$ (c,d) and $Ae$ at fixed $(m^{*},Re)=(9.6,24\,300)$ (e,f).

Figure 23

Table 1.Mesh convergence of a 3-D rectangular flexible membrane wing at $Re=24\,300$, $Ae=423.14$, $m^{*}=2.4$ and $\alpha =15^{\circ }$. The percentage discrepancies in the brackets are calculated with respect to the finest mesh M3.

Figure 24

Table 2.Time-step size convergence of a 3-D rectangular flexible membrane wing at $Re=24\,300$ and $\alpha =15^{\circ }$ based on mesh M2. The percentage discrepancies are calculated by using the results of ${\rm \Delta} t U_{\infty }/c = 0.0182$ as the reference.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Comparison of membrane response characteristics between the present simulations and experiments (Rojratsirikul et al.2010b,  2011) at $U_{\infty }=5$ m s$^{-1}$ for maximum magnitude of the normalized time-averaged membrane deformation ($\overline {\|{\boldsymbol d} \|}^{{max}}/c$) (a), time-averaged normal force coefficient difference ($\overline {C}_N^{{Fle}}-\overline {C}_N^{{Rig}}$) between the flexible membrane wing and rigid wing (b), normalized circulation ($\varGamma /U_{\infty } c$) of tip vortices on a plane perpendicular to the freestream near the trailing edge (c) and membrane vibration frequency at the point with maximum standard deviation (d). Contours in panel (d) are coloured by the frequency spectra of the experimental results (Rojratsirikul et al.2011). The red $\triangle$ in panel (d) denotes the dominant frequency contents measured from our numerical simulations.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Magnitude of turbulent intensity on the mid-span plane obtained from present simulation at $\alpha =16^{\circ }$ (a), experiment (Rojratsirikul et al.2011) at $\alpha =16^{\circ }$ (b).