Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T03:18:54.861Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Precursors of backflow events and their relationship with the near-wall self-sustaining process

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 December 2021

Byron Guerrero*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia 5005
Martin F. Lambert
Affiliation:
School of Civil, Environmental & Mining Engineering, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia 5005
Rey C. Chin
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia 5005
*
†Email address for correspondence: byron.guerrerohinojosa@adelaide.edu.au

Abstract

This study examines the precursors and consequences of rare backflow events at the wall using direct numerical simulation of turbulent pipe flow with a high spatiotemporal resolution. The results obtained from conditionally averaged fields reveal that the precursor of a backflow event is the asymmetric collision between a high- and a low-speed streak (LSS) associated with the sinuous mode of the streaks. As the collision occurs, a lifted shear layer with high local azimuthal enstrophy is formed at the trailing end of the LSS. Subsequently, a spanwise or an oblique vortex spontaneously arises. The dominant nonlinear mechanism by which this vortex is engendered is enstrophy intensification due to direct stretching of the lifted vorticity lines in the azimuthal direction. As time progresses, this vortex tilts and orientates towards the streamwise direction and, as its enstrophy increases, it induces the breakdown of the LSS located below it. Subsequently, this vortical structure advects as a quasi-streamwise vortex, as it tilts and stretches with time. As a result, it is shown that reverse flow events at the wall are the signature of the nonlinear mechanism of the self-sustaining process occurring at the near-wall region. Additionally, each backflow event has been tracked in space and time, showing that approximately 50 % of these events are followed by at least one additional vortex generation that gives rise to new backflow events. It is also found that up to a maximum of seven regenerations occur after a backflow event has appeared for the first time.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Computational parameters used to conduct the numerical simulations. Here $N_F$ stands for the number of consecutive volumetric flow fields used in this study; % BF is the contribution of the BF events to the total wall friction.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Instantaneous flow visualisations of low speed streaks (grey) and vortical structures computed using the $Q$ criterion plotted at a level $Q^+ = 5$. The $Q$ structures have been coloured by streamwise vorticity $\omega _x^+$ normalised in viscous units. The BF patches are depicted by blue contour lines at the wall. The reference time has been considered about the BF event occurring below vortex 1 in (c). The times at which the snapshots have been taken are (a) $\Delta t^+ = -20$, (b) $\Delta t^+ = -10$, (c) $\Delta t^+ = 0$, (d) $\Delta t^+ = 10$, (e) $\Delta t^+ = 20$, (f) $\Delta t^+ = 30$. The vortices that regenerate and produce BF events have been tagged and encircled in the order they appear as V1 (black dashed), V2 (red dashed), V3 (blue dashed) and V4(orange dashed). The arrows indicate the flow direction.

Figure 2

Figure 2.(a) The $x - y$ contour plane of streamwise velocity fluctuation $u_x^+$ computed from the field shown in figure 1(c) at $\Delta R\theta ^+ = 0$. The white contours are vortices V1 and V2 computed at a level $Q^+ = 9$, and the white arrows indicate rotation orientation. (b) Local velocity vectors ($U_x^+, U_y^+$), the blue contour lines highlight the position of the low speed streak at values $u_x^+ \leq 1$. The red curves highlight the regions where a local inflectional velocity profile $U_x^+(y)$ is attained. Flow direction is from right to left.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Top view of the high momentum isosurface at $\left \langle u_x\right \rangle ^+_{BF} = 0.8$ (red), low speed streak at $\left \langle u_x\right \rangle ^+_{BF} = -0.2$ (grey) and oblique vortex at a level $\left \langle Q\right \rangle ^+_{BF} = 0.5$ (green). The red and black centre lines ($-\cdot -$), corresponding to the orientation of the high- and low-momentum structures, respectively, depict the asymmetric interaction between these structures associated with a BF event. The three conditional fields have been computed at (a) $t^+ = -8.5$, (b) $t^+ = 0$ and (c) $t^+ = 8.5$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Time dependency of the streamwise velocity fluctuations conditioned by $Q_L$ negative WSS events. The negative values of time show the sequence of conditional events preceding the appearance of a BF event. Here $t^{+} = 0$ is the time at which the negative WSS appears. The positive time sequences show the evolution of the streamwise velocity structures that take place after a BF event happens. The $x - y$ contour plots show the conditional field $\left \langle u_x \right \rangle ^+_{BF}$ at $\Delta R \theta = 0$. The arrows indicate the flow direction. Here (a) $t^+ = -43$; (b) $t^+ = -26$; (c) $t^+ = -8.5$; (d) $t^+ =0$; (e) $t^+ = 15$; (f) $t^+ = 21$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Space–time correlation of the ($a$) high- and ($b$) low-momentum structures exhibited in figure 4. The $\times$ symbol depicts the peak of the correlation and the (dashed line) line shows the best fit of the peaks in $R_{u_z u_z}$. The best fit of the peaks in the correlation of the high- and low-momentum structures responds to ($a$) $\Delta x^+ = 15.2 \Delta t^+ + 0.26$ and ($b$) $\Delta x^+ = 12.0 \Delta t^+ + 22$. The line (blue dashed dotted line) in panel (b) exhibits the best fit of the peaks in the correlation at $0 \leq t^+ \leq 10$ and follows the linear expression $\Delta x^+ = 9.83 \Delta t^+$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.(a) Time dependence of the enstrophy intensification norm in the three orthogonal directions computed over a wall-parallel plane at $y^{+}\approx 12$. The colours represent the radial component (red), azimuthal component (black) and the streamwise component (blue). The norm has been computed on each of the time-dependent conditional fields as $\max \{\omega _i \omega _j \, \partial U_i/\partial U_j({\boldsymbol x},t) \}_{BF}$. (b) Time evolution of the minimum WSS in the streamwise direction $\left \langle \tau _{w,x} \right \rangle _{BF}^+$ within the conditional flow fields.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Time dependence of the conditional enstrophy amplification in the azimuthal direction $\left \langle \omega _\theta ^2/r \, \partial U_\theta / \partial \theta \right \rangle _{BF}^{+}$ due to vortex line stretching. The grey isosurface is the LSS. The enstrophy intensification has been normalised in wall units by $(u_\tau ^2/\nu )^3$. The red (positive) and blue (negative) isosurfaces have been computed at a level $\left \langle \omega _\theta ^2/r\, \partial U_\theta /\partial \theta \right \rangle ^+_{BF} = \pm 4.5\times 10^{-4}$, respectively. The colour contours exhibited in the $x - y$ plane correspond to the enstrophy intensification in the azimuthal direction. The vector plots exhibited in the $R \theta - y$ planes $b_1$ and $b_2$ have been computed at $t^+ = -8.5$ at locations $\Delta x^+ = -50$ and $\Delta x^+ = -250$, respectively. The red contours in planes $b_1$ and $b_2$ highlight the regions with high positive $\theta$ enstrophy intensification by direct stretching, and the blue line contours correspond to the LSS. The orange and blue transparent arrows exhibited on the transverse sections $b_1$ and $b_2$ aim to highlight the outer and the inner streamwise rolls that sustain the high- and the low-momentum structures associated with a BF event, respectively. Here (a) $t^+ = -26$; (b) $t^+ = -8.5$; (c) $t^+ = 0$; (d) $t^+ =15$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Time dependence of the conditional enstrophy amplification in the streamwise direction $\left \langle \omega _x^2 ~\partial U_x / \partial x \right \rangle _{BF}^{+}$ due to direct stretching. The grey isosurface is the LSS. The enstrophy intensification has been normalised in wall units by $(u_\tau ^2/\nu )^3$. The red (positive) and blue (negative) isosurfaces have been computed at a level $\left \langle \omega _x^2 ~\partial U_x / \partial x \right \rangle _{BF}^{+} = \pm 4.0\times 10^{-5}$, respectively. Here (a) $t^+ = -8.5$; (b) $t^+ = 0$; (c) $t^+ = 8.5$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a) Probability density function (p.d.f.) of the regeneration time of negative WSS events. (b) Probability distribution of the number of BF autogenerations.