Those looking for a fresh approach to eco-theology will find much food for thought in this important contribution to the field. The author deliberately sets out to ground his theological discussion by reviewing three representative models of practice, namely, eco-justice, stewardship and ecological spirituality, placed alongside what he argues are representatives of those traditions as found in Thomas Aquinas, Karl Barth and Maximus the Confessor/Sergii Bulgakov. He intends, by structuring the book in this way, to tease out a basis for dialogue between three ecclesial orientations towards Roman Catholic, Reformed Protestant and Eastern Orthodox approaches to grace. In as much as he deliberately refrains from a constructive approach to eco-theology, this book is open textured, allowing room for different audiences to engage with those parts of the book that tune in more precisely with their specific traditions. He also seeks to represent those traditions by a careful reading of the sources concerned and, while some critical commentary is included, the overall impression is that the author is trying to create a map which can capture something of the importance of these traditions for eco-theology, rather than attempting a more systematic analysis. In as much as theologies of grace have received rather less attention than they deserve, this book offers an important corrective.
The book begins with a discussion of global environmental issues in relation to ecological practices of revival communities in Africa. The question that Jenkins asks here is an important one, namely, why is such attention to the environment a vital ingredient in the grammar of grace? But, rather than dwelling on what might be termed the local contextual theological vision of African theology, Jenkins turns instead to traditional modes of expressing theology through representatives central to different ecclesial traditions. While this has the advantage of fostering a greater interest in ecological concerns among those (incorrectly) bent on interpreting such authors in narrowly anthropocentric terms, its disadvantage is that the theological aspects of the voices emerging from such practices are pushed into the background. Hence, there is very little reference to liberation theology, feminist theology and other contextual theologies in this book and the passing reference to more radical authors like Matthew Fox sits in a rather ungainly manner alongside the likes of the Russian Orthodox writer, Sergii Bulgakov.
Nonetheless, Jenkins helpfully moves away from the somewhat tired debate between anthropocentrism and biocentrism which tends to dominate Christian interpretations of environmental ethics, or the equally (at times) shallow descriptions of worldviews, and seeks, instead, to give theology more attention by making it far more relevant to discussions of practice. His review of the status of the field is helpful in as much as it seeks to set out what has been and has yet to be achieved in bringing together secular and theological accounts of environmental ethics. While he is not alone in wishing to include a strong doctrine of redemption alongside that of creation in the development of eco-theology, he also acknowledges the importance of sanctification, as expressed in eco-justice and deification, as expressed in ecological spirituality of the Eastern church. The plurality is deliberate on his part, in that he believes that the problem is too complex to be answered through the insights of one tradition. At times I found myself wanting rather more clarity on where the author situated himself in relation to these debates, and even though his close attention to different traditions was commendable, my impression was that, in a subliminal sense at least, the Reformed tradition was his preferred starting point. Hence, even though he took great trouble to try and understand the alternative positions with which he engaged, his treatment of other authors such as Thomas Aquinas was, by his own admission, somewhat idiosyncratic (he uses the term ‘novel’, p. 150), at least according to scholars occupied with the work of this theologian. While I share many of his insights, especially in his push towards eco-justice, the reader is at times left wondering where his particular interpretation parts company from standard Thomist texts.
Although the notion of stewardship has come under a particularly severe critique among some academic theologians, his treatment of this topic is carefully thought through, and will be useful for those who rely on such a notion in arriving at a model for ecological activism. Sergii Bulgakov would not have anticipated how his ecology of wisdom might have been translated into a theologically informed basis for practice, but it seems to me that Jenkins is correct to point to his significance, not only for Eastern traditions more generally, but as a dialogue partner for those in the Western world.
Overall there is much to ponder in this text, and students interested in reflecting more carefully on the relevance of ecology for different traditions will find this book particularly valuable. If it succeeds in persuading those in a particular tradition that ecological concerns can no longer be ignored, then it will have served a vital purpose in the debate.
