Nowadays formalities of scholarship fully embrace the importance of writing in earnest. Although some may bemoan tendencies to privilege pre-established formats over creative poiesis, seminars and colloquia make for remarkable composing machines. Still—and despite their emphasis on “book projects”—these rites of passage seldom address the question of how to turn a whirl of articles or papers into a full-fledged book. For each book in the writing requires a far more demanding treatment, one that amounts to an architectural move. If articles can be compared to showrooms, a multistory house is what a book most closely resembles.
This very domestic metaphor is how Philliou chose to make her readers feel at home in Biography of an Empire. Yet it is hard to get a sense of the architectural move she opted for when writing it. Despite its suggestive title, this bio-graphy never quite develops into a form of life in writing. While the “phanariot house” survived its “demolitions” (p. 65) well into our times, the book leaves us readers disarrayed amid the rubble.
Biography's primary focus is on a captivating microcosm: the elites that were based in the Phanar neighborhood in Istanbul, with links to lay and clerical powers both in the Ottoman capital city and in certain provinces (Moldavia and Wallachia as well as the Aegean). Long famous (in particular since Andrei Pippidi's key studies in the 1970s), yet still little known, Phanariots can be approached as a showcase for the Ottoman topology of statecraft. This Philliou did with dash in several articles she published over the past few years. Here she embarks on a fuller survey of the “house” that the Phanar built—how it was shaken to its foundations by the 1821 Hellenic rebellion and how it managed to maintain its luster under a “neophanariot” guise (p. xxi).
Philliou resolves to look for a “sociopolitical portrait of the group [she is] calling phanariots” (p. 14). Those expecting a “sociology of empire” (p. xxviii) might be disappointed though: Biography's take on the “question of agency” (p. xxii) relates to individual trajectories rather than to social groupings. In this respect, Philliou's choice of terms (speaking of a Phanariot “house”) is judicious, since it conveys the uncertain balance between collective and individual career patterns that the study aims to unveil. It also makes for one of the book's most appealing suggestions: namely, that a complex play of analogies and homologies may be established between two “houses” that scholars have tended to keep tightly separated: Phanariots on the one hand and dynasties of provincial notables and the Janissary Corps on the other. “Examining phanariots alongside ayans/hanedans and janissaries in turn clearly shows that phanariots borrowed strategies from new elites while enmeshing themselves in domestic trade and politics long dominated by janissaries” (p. 24). This boils down to stressing, if need be, that Phanariots ought to be considered Ottomans among other—not to say “ordinary”—Ottomans.
Taking one's cue from the Phanariots also amounts, Philliou argues, to adopting a “view from the edge of the center,” that is, “from a perspective at the imperial center of Istanbul but not the perspective of the sultan and his vezirs” (p. xx). Implications sound far reaching: at stake is “a broadened definition of the political” breaking with “the statist master narrative that still haunts the modern field of Ottoman history” (p. xviii). Beyond the Ottoman locus, this move bears the imprint of a much broader ongoing shift, transverse to many fields in the humanities and social sciences, that tends to dis-locate the state's agency and the long presumed bipolarity of its relations to “society.”
Whereas from the “statist” perspective the history of the Ottomans’ “longest century” remains that of imperial disintegration, Philliou's “phanariot lens” (pp. 42, 59) reveals that “an intricate kind of integration” (p. 25) went on even during the chaotic decades covered by the book's time span (1774–1856). Here Biography's first chapters are particularly effective at highlighting the long-range interconnectedness of Phanariot networks. Yet in its focus on “the twin issues of predicament and agency” (p. 159), Biography gestures away from “the traditional focus on institutions” (p. xxi) only to promote a primarily cultural understanding of “governance.” Philliou thus stresses that “the disjuncture between political realities and political discourse” (p. xix) may help in figuring out how “possibilities of political integration” could come up “without a concomitant ideology or a fully elaborated imagination of integration” (p. 174). On this account, Biography is to be credited for quite elegantly taking stock of former reflections on “state-formation after the cultural turn” (George Steinmetz, ed., State/Culture: State-Formation after the Cultural Turn [Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1999]). But this leaves a lot to be desired regarding the forks and offshoots of the political economy involved. Philliou repeatedly hints at the importance of provincial administration in the maintenance of the Phanariot web of governance, yet she rarely dwells on how it played out in practice. Similarly, as a reminder of Peregrine Horden and Nicholas Purcell's “portfolio of the Gran Signor” (The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History [Oxford: Blackwell, 2000, p. 281]), a tentative assessment of Phanariot monies in flux may have been worth considering to support the book's main argument.
Yet what Biography most critically lacks is an overarching narrative coherence: for all its emphasis on the “epistemic framework” (p. 160) and “discursive arenas” (p. xxiii), it provides its readers with no viable sense of relatedness between its many constitutive parts. This concern with narrative economy clearly stood within Philliou's purview, and she chose to address it by equipping the book with all the trappings of the “biographical” genre. Hence her foregrounding of Stephanos Vogorides as a key narrative figure and her announcement that “the life, career, and writings of one man have not only served as a map for [her] research but have come to frame this book” (p. xx). To readers familiar with microstoria, the suggestion that Vogorides be considered “an aberration” that needs “writing back into history” (pp. xxi, xxv) instantly arouses compelling hopes: what if Vogorides took over the “immaterial inheritance” left behind by Chiesa the Piedmontese exorcist in Giovanni Levi's famous book (Inheriting Power: The Story of an Exorcist [Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988])? But soon enough these great expectations give way to the awkward realization that in proportion to the size of the whole, Philliou devoted an astonishingly limited number of pages to Vogorides' papers and a perplexingly large number (for a work supposed to rely on primary research) to recounting some of the long since known behind the scenes intrigues of the young and restless Ottoman top brass. Most of what Vogorides did or said ends up confined to five “biographical” interludes that never exceed (except for the dilated last one) a few pages in length and fail to divert or disconcert the master narrative underway in parallel chapters. To be sure, the aberrant Vogorides gets written back into history—but as a tiny falling Icarus inserted into a much larger (and unchanged) landscape painting.
Now which painting is this? Philliou's main working hypothesis is that “the arenas through which we can track changes in the calculus of power were those of diplomacy and the military” (pp. xxiii–xxiv). In her view, there occurred a “shift from the politics of military and court factions in the 1820s to the politics of international diplomacy in Istanbul [. . .] in the early 1830s” (pp. 108–109). Both the roughness of this periodization and Philliou's unsubtantiated claim to draw such clear-cut boundaries amid the enmeshed force fields of “the military” and “diplomacy” may arouse objections.
One may also wonder what alternate ideas of history Philliou's default narrative tends to expunge. How about unearthing some of the Phanariot house's provincial rhizome? What sense of “agency” could be at play in Vogorides' DIY karamanlidika-like transliteration system? Philliou's gestures toward these lines of inquiry only serve to reassert her bottom-line framework of analysis: military force vs. foreign politics (p. 171), politics of military and court factions vs. politics of international diplomacy (pp. 108–109). Have Ottoman studies been living so much apart from the sweeping ebbs and flows of scholarship? Philliou's answer amounts to a loud and clear affirmative: “the plotline of Westernization and modernization of the Ottoman military,” she argues, has kept Ottomanist scholars from overcoming its implied “polarities” (p. 41). Granted that the field of Ottoman history evolves in fits and starts, I doubt that all of its practitioners would subscribe to this bold statement. More seriously still, the trouble with Philliou's approach is that it itself endorses a wholesale reiteration of the Eastern Question framework. Suffice it to say how heavily Biography relies on a literature (Anderson 1966, Davison 1963, Mosely 1934) whose analytical trumps have long been thoroughly reshuffled (e.g., by Beshara Doumani, Rediscovering Palestine: Merchants and Peasants in Jabal Nablus, 1700–1900 [Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1995], not quoted once). All in all, Philliou's acknowledgement that “the framework of the Eastern Question does not allow for complexity and implications of changes in Ottoman politics” (p. 224) may sound as a mere way of begging the question, if not an act of self-inflicted cruelty.
Another instance of this historiographical posturing manifests itself in Philliou's emphasis on the Phanariots serving the Ottoman sultanate “as Christians” (p. 168), which points at the “possibility of asserting political agency as Christians within the realm of Ottoman governance” (p. 172). Her whole line of reasoning here derives from the assumption that “phanariots were engaged in a paradoxical imperial enterprise,” on account of being at odds with “religious dogma and political ideology underpinning Ottoman governance, which forbade Christians a formal share in Ottoman sovereignty” (p. 5). Yet Philliou's contribution to this debate consists precisely in showing that dogma and ideology, for all their relevance, were not the alpha and omega of the Ottoman polity (pp. 13–18). Hence her statement of “agency as Christians,” as well as her somewhat overstretched reference to “the binary opposition between secular and religious” (p. 174), contradicts her earlier assertion that “phanariots were able to attach themselves to Ottoman political culture through confessionally neutral terms” (p. 27). The paradox, if there is one, only stems from having leveled down “the twin issues of predicament and agency” to mere “constituent parts of what we now refer to as ‘identity’” (p. 159). As for the argument that certain elite members (namely, Christians), while “invisible” as compared to others, could still take the floor and “articulate a justification for their service” (p. 169), it bluntly sounds as if Philliou failed to notice that “subalterns” can speak.
In sum, Biography does not deliver on its commitment to historiographical revisionism. Repeatedly Philliou hints at the urge to “shift the terms of the debate” (p. xvii)—only to fall back on shopworn frameworks that turn out to glaringly mismatch these contentions. The book thus falls short of its ambition to bring the “question of agency” to bear on the notions of modernity (e.g., bureaucratization, politicization, or confessionalization) that have punctuated 19th-century Middle Eastern history. Here resides Biography's strangest paradox of perceptions: it introduces us to new actors and networks who end up unable to change our sense of their historical capacity. Not only do their patterns of agency remain “invisible” but also they more crucially prove ineffective at changing the course of our history writing. For all her pledge to vest history with the powers of “indeterminacy” (p. xxiii), Philliou failed to retrieve the idiosyncrasy of historicity.
