As a former member of the Potomac Appalachian Trail Club, I was very happy to read this very informative history of its inception in 1921 and subsequent implementation and development through the twentieth century. Because of the unique features of the Appalachian Trail (AT), its story eludes neat categorization and therefore allows the author to explore and describe the complex and entangled lineages of modern American environmental politics.
The AT was from its beginning a comparatively domesticated form of environmental engagement. It was proposed by Benton MacKaye as a form of communal rural development to combat the problems of living in modernity without leaving human civilization behind. Mittlefehldt tells a fascinating story of a vision of community-oriented environmental justice; the trail would provide opportunities for a more holistic life, in which agrarian pursuits, cooperative ownership and democratic management would alleviate the malaise caused by the fractures of industrialization.
The trail's implementation required intensive cooperation between landowners and volunteers. The growing interest in hiking as recreation enlisted northeastern hiking clubs in the project, but the goal to extend the trail to the south ran into regional divisions. Unhappy experiences of federal interventions like the Tennessee Valley Authority and the national-park clearances that forced mountain communities out of their homes, combined with resentment of northern “condescension” (49), complicated the extension of the trail. Mittlefehldt demonstrates how the trail's implementation has always involved the complicated personal politics of working with private property owners, bureaucratic conservationists, illegal moonshiners, and hiking enthusiasts, a set of players that led to interesting and sometimes unpredictable alliances.
By the late 1930s, however, the federal government had become more involved in the implementation of the trail. The Civilian Conservation Corps increasingly replaced the grassroots volunteers who had provided the majority of the labor. The National Park Service's involvement also signaled a higher investment in creating a controlled environment for the trail, including increased public holdings along the path, relocations to maximize the scenic potential of the trail, and the construction of a shelter system. This reflected a shift away from MacKaye's original mixed-use vision toward the emergence of a pleasure trail for elites.
Because of its location in the most heavily populated area of the United States, the AT was by necessity involved in land-use conflicts. In the middle of the twentieth century, the trail was caught between the preservationist environmental vision of escaping into a pristine wilderness untouched by human activity, and the reality of logging, farming, and towns through which it led. Despite the 1964 Wilderness Act, which advocated protecting a “pristine” wilderness, the location of the trail made it clear that such a vision was unrealistic. Instead, the trail fell into an emergent mixed-use framework that nonetheless failed to capture the economic and environmental communalism of MacKaye's vision. For many trail users and advocates, the cultural and historical resources along the trail were not distractions from a pure wilderness, but rather an enjoyable enrichment of the trail experience.
By the late twentieth century, changes in landownership, governance, and usage of the trail brought a new set of difficulties. Because of its particular history as a loosely organized public–private partnership, the bureaucratic structure of the trail was unclear. In addition, residential development brought many new landowners into involvement with the trail, some of them less than enthusiastic about having increasingly countercultural hikers cross their land. By the 1970s, a growing resistance to “big government” saw efforts to acquire land adjacent to the trail as a violation of private property rights (109). The appointment of James A. Watt as Secretary of the Interior signaled the ascendancy of the New Right, and federal disinvestment in the trail.
Mittlefehldt's metaphor of tangled roots aptly captures how the Appalachian Trail reveals the messiness and complications of environmental politics in the United States. The original vision of the trail, as a multiuse communal project involving both environmental protection and economic justice, largely fell through the cracks of the complex alliances that made the trail possible. However, the complexity of the trail's implementation offers an alternative vision of US environmental history that contextualizes many current debates.
This book would be useful in upper-level courses on environmental policy, as well as for scholars of environmental justice or environmental history.
