Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T13:11:34.495Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Experiments on Marangoni spreading – evidence of a new type of interfacial instability

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 March 2023

Xue Ma
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, 5th ZhongGuanCunNan Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China
Yao Huang
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, 5th ZhongGuanCunNan Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China
Yanru Huang
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, 5th ZhongGuanCunNan Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China
Zhanwei Liu*
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, 5th ZhongGuanCunNan Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China
Zhenzhen Li*
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, 5th ZhongGuanCunNan Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China
Jerzy M. Floryan
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Western University, London, Ontario N6A 5B9, Canada
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: liuzw@bit.edu.cn, zhenzhenli@bit.edu.cn
†Email addresses for correspondence: liuzw@bit.edu.cn, zhenzhenli@bit.edu.cn

Abstract

Marangoni spreading on thin films is widely observed in nature and applied in industry. It has serious implications for airway drug delivery, especially in surfactant displacement therapy. This paper reports the results of experimental investigations of a surfactant-laden droplet spreading on films made of more viscous Newtonian fluids as well as on films made of viscoelastic fluids. The experiments used particle seeding, the transmission-speckle method and particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) to determine the deformation of the film–droplet interface and to measure velocity fields. Radially aligned patterns were observed on Newtonian films. Similar patterns, but with much smaller wavenumber, were observed on viscoelastic films in combination with rapid azimuthal variations of the film thickness. The Saffman–Taylor instability at the film–droplet interface explains the formation of patterns on a more viscous Newtonian film, and their onset requires exceeding the critical capillary number. The pattern formation on viscoelastic films is correlated with an instability at the film–droplet–air contact line when the liquid is expelled radially by the spreading droplet. PTV revealed azimuthal variations of the velocity field in the vicinity of the contact line. The observed contact line instability is different from previously reported fingering instabilities of Newtonian thin films. A simple scaling law accounting for the Marangoni-stress-induced elastic shear deformation is proposed to describe the flow field in the patterns formed in the viscoelastic films.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Variations of viscosity $(\eta )$ and the first normal stress difference $({N_1})$ of the substrate fluid as functions of the shear rate $\dot{\gamma }$. Symbols represent experimental points and continuous lines represent correlations determined using the least squares method and constrained to represent a parabola. Blue and red colours represent different Boger fluids and black colour represents PEG solution (Newtonian fluid).

Figure 1

Table 1.Viscosity $\eta $ and viscoelastic relaxation times $(\tau )$ of solutions used in this study. Here, ${\tau _\phi }$ was obtained from the Oldroyd-B model (Lindner et al.2002) (see text for details) and ${\tau _\eta }$ was determined from measured viscosity $\; \eta $ (see text for details). Symbol ‘Suc’ indicates sucrose solution with the number next to it denoting concentration. All measurements were carried out at 25 °C.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Experimental setup used for observation of droplet spreading. (a) Schematic diagram of the light transmission method. (b) Schematic diagram of the transmission-speckle method; a plastic sheet with a regular pattern (i.e. lattice) is placed under the liquid container with the red layer indicating the LED illumination. (c) Sketch of the LED light path for the transmission-speckle method; light is refracted at the glass–liquid boundary, and then refracted again at the liquid-air interface. (d) Speckles’ virtual deformation pattern observed during spreading; the red line identifies the quarter-circular zone used in the analysis.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Images of spreading of surfactant-laden droplet with $\eta = 1\;\textrm{mPa}\ \textrm{s}^{-1}$. (a) Droplet position during spreading on the Boger 2 (see table 1 for its properties) liquid film with thickness ${h_0} = 85\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$ at time t = 0.16 s; orange arrow points to the rib-like patterns; blue arrow points to the interface corrugation patterns; green arrow points to the position of the spreading front (Marangoni ridge), the position of the outer edge of the wide fingers very close to the Marangoni ridge is identified using the spreading radius R. (b) Copy of panel (a) with a blue line marking the contact line and showing the formation of wide fingers, and a red dashed line identifying the rib-like patterns with the same wavenumber as the fingers. (c) and (d) Droplet's positions at times t = 0.94 s and t = 6 s, respectively; the rib-like patterns can be observed; blue arrow points to the highly stratified fingers in the thinned zones upstream of the Marangoni ridge. (e) Spreading of an identical droplet on a Newtonian PEG fluid (see table 1) with viscosity similar to the viscosity of the ‘Boger 2’ fluid and with the film thickness ${h_0} = 89\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$ – position of the droplet at time t = 20 ms; red arrow points to the radial patterns. ( f) Copy of panel (e) with a blue line marking the position of the wavy contact line without any fingers. See text for other details.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Phase diagrams identifying conditions leading to the formation of stable and unstable interfaces during Marangoni spreading of a less viscous droplet on a more viscous Newtonian thin film. (a) Phase diagram in the $(\mathrm{\Delta }\eta = {\eta _f} - {\eta _d},{h_0})$-plane; green colour identifies conditions leading to an unstable interface with radially aligned patterns; purple colour identifies conditions leading to a stable interface; orange colour identifies conditions corresponding to the partially unstable cases. Data for the Boger 1 and Boger 2 fluids are included; the rib-like patterns were observed for both fluids. Black arrows identify conditions corresponding to experiments displayed in figure 4(c) (unstable region), figure 4(d) (partially unstable region) and figure 4(e) (stable region). Data used in panels (a) and (b) were collected at 10 ms, whereas data used in panels (c–e) were collected at 320 ms to have instability features more pronounced for better identification of stability regimes. (b) Phase diagram in the $(Ca,{h_0}/{R_{in}})$-plane; colours have the same meaning as in panel (a). (c) A typical image of an unstable interface. (d) A typical image of a partially unstable interface. (e) A typical image of a stable interface. ${R_{in}}$ stands for the diameter of the inner region.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Temporal variations of the spreading radius R for thin films of Boger 2 fluid. Experiments were repeated five times to demonstrate their reproducibility. Each experimental dataset is identified using different symbols and colours.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Droplet spreading on liquid films visualized using the light transmission method. Films were seeded with 10 μm particles. (a) Very initial (t = 32 ms) spreading on Boger 2 film with the initial thickness ${h_0} = 60\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$; gradations of grey correspond to regions of thicker (darker) and thinner (lighter) film; the white arrow identifies the position of the Marangoni ridge. (b) Same experiment as in panel (a) at the final stage of spreading (t = 808 ms) showing severely thinned regions with particles pinned to the surface identified using a black arrow. (c) Spreading on Newtonian PEG liquid film with a comparable viscosity and with the initial thickness ${h_0} = 60\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$ showing uniform particle distribution in the azimuthal direction at a position indicated by the white arrow; the black arrow identifies the severely thinned region. (d) Spreading of a surfactant-laden droplet seeded with 10 μm particles on the Boger 2 film without particles. The particles’ distribution identifies spreading paths of the droplet.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) measurements for the Marangoni spreading on the Newtonian PEG fluid (see table 1) with the initial film thickness ${h_0} = 59\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$. (a) Picture taken at $t = 8.14\;\textrm{ms}$ from the beginning of spreading. (b) Particles identified from data in panel (a) with the colour and vector length indicating velocities of individual particles. (c) Azimuthal distributions of the normalized surface particle density ${\rho _t}(\theta )/{\rho _0}$ in the region bounded by the two dashed orange lines in panel (b) at times $t = 0$ and $t = 8.14\;\textrm{ms}$. (d) Radial distributions of the depth- and azimuthally averaged velocity in the region bounded by the two solid green lines in panel (b). (e) Azimuthal variations of the depth- and radially averaged particle velocities at the Marangoni ridge; colours of the dots indicate the velocities of individual particles and the red line indicates the depth- and radially averaged value.

Figure 8

Figure 8.PTV measurements for the Marangoni spreading on the Boger 2 fluid with the initial film thickness ${h_0} = 59.2\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$. (a) Image recorded at $t = 14.3\;\textrm{ms}$ from the beginning of spreading. (b) Particles identified in the image displayed in panel (a) with their colours and vector lengths indicating the velocities of individual particles. (c) Azimuthal distributions of the normalized surface particle density ${\rho _t}(\theta )/{\rho _0}$ in the region bounded by the two dashed orange lines in panel (b) at times $t = 0$ and $t = 14.3\;\textrm{ms}$. (d) Radial distributions of the depth- and azimuthally averaged velocity in the region bounded by the two solid green lines in panel (b). (e) Azimuthal variations of the particle velocities at the Marangoni ridge; colours of the dots indicate velocities of individual particles and the red line indicates the depth- and radially averaged value.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Determination of the elastic shear moduli for the Boger fluids by the PTV method. (a) Variations of the surface tension gradient as a function of the strain in the zone characterized by the formation of the rib-like patterns. The blue colour corresponds to the Boger 1 fluid with the initial thickness ${h_0} = 39.5\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$ and the red colour to the Boger 2 fluid with the initial thickness ${h_0} = 59.2\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$. The shear moduli are determined by the slopes (1.23 and 0.45) through linear curve fitting. Borders of the coloured areas are determined by the shear modulus $G = [\eta /{\tau _\phi };\;\eta /{\tau _\eta }]$ calculated from a rheological measurement (see table 1). (b) Particles in the rib-like structures in the Boger 2 fluid. (c) Image similar to panel (b) but for the Boger 1 fluid. The red dots in panels (b) and (c) identify particles used in panel (a). Their movement follows the extension and retraction of the ribs which demonstrates that they are located at the film–droplet interface and their motion reflects the shear-driven interface deformation.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Deformation of interfaces during droplet spreading on the Boger 2 film with the initial thickness ${h_0} = 93\;\mathrm{\mu }\textrm{m}$ measured using the transmission-speckle method. (a) Shape of the droplet–air interface determined under the assumption that the deformation occurs only at this interface. The area used in the analysis is shown in figure 2(d). The white line (a circular line with radius of 9.2 mm and centred about the droplet deposition point) identifies locations of measurement points at the droplet–air interface in the outer region used in panel (b). The white arrow points to the apparent azimuthal height variations of the order of 2–4 μm at the droplet–air interface in the inner region which are due to the azimuthal deformations at the film–droplet interface. (b) Azimuthal height variations $\delta h$ along the white line in panel (a). Here, $\delta h = h - \bar{h}$, with $\bar{h}$ being the mean value of h. (c) Sketch of the interfacial deformation at the droplet-air interface (upper sketch) and at the Boger film–droplet interface with a flat droplet–air interface (lower sketch). Both cases lead to the same speckles’ virtual displacement S. The angles ${\alpha _1}$ and ${\alpha _2}$ are the refractive angles at the droplet–air interface and at the film–droplet interface, respectively, $\; {\beta _1}$ and ${\beta _2}$ are the incident angles, and ${\varphi _1}$ and ${\varphi _2}$ stand for the inclination angles of the deformed interfaces. (d) Side view of the droplet and the film at t = 1.7 s. The blue arrow points to the inner region where the droplet–air interface appears to be smooth and the red arrow points to the corrugation patterns at the droplet–air interface in the outer region.

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 1

Spreading of a surfactant-laden aqueous droplet on a more viscous viscoelastic (left) and Newtonian (right) thin liquid film. Both films have similar viscosities (22.7 mPa.s for the viscoelastic Boger 2 fluid, 21.5 mPa.s for the Newtonian PEG solution, fluid properties are given in Table 1). Rib-like structures characterized by low wavenumbers are formed at the Boger film - droplet interface (left), whereas radially aligned structures characterized by large wavenumbers are formed at the Newtonian film-droplet interface (right). Many very small fingers form at the end of spreading on Boger film (left) after deposition of a second surfactant-laden droplet.

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 1(Video)
Video 13.6 MB

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 2

See "Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions"

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 2(Video)
Video 10.2 MB

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 3

See "Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions"

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 3(Video)
Video 6.2 MB

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 4

See "Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions"

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 4(Video)
Video 3.2 MB

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 5

See "Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions"

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie 5(Video)
Video 13.9 MB
Supplementary material: File

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions

Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions

Download Ma et al. Supplementary Movie Captions(File)
File 13.7 KB