Scholars have long explored how Native peoples creatively responded to European colonization. Faced with land pressures, depopulation, debt, cultural impositions, and a myriad of other challenges, Native Americans searched for ways to safeguard their families and communities. Two new books about the American South and New England continue these discussions by highlighting the traumatic effects of colonialism and the different ways that Native peoples reorganized their lives.
Robin Beck's excellent study of the Native South from the year 1400 to 1725 builds on recent scholarship to provide a convincing explanation of Catawba coalescence. In Chiefdoms, Collapse, and Coalescence in the Early American South, Beck addresses a major historical development in the region that has captured the attention of archaeologists, anthropologists, and historians: the shift from a precolonial Mississippian world of chiefdoms to powerful Indian nations and confederacies by the eighteenth century. Scholars increasingly favor the term “coalescence” to describe this remarkable shift, as does Beck, but he modifies the concept to center less on changes in societies and more on changes in polities. By looking at political economies and polities, Beck stresses how coalescence is fundamentally “a nation-making process” (7).
Although the book is about the Native South, it centers on the Catawba and their neighbors in the Carolina Piedmont. Readers of this review will naturally think of James Merrell's Bancroft-winning The Indians' New World (1989), which also addresses how Siouan-speaking Piedmont peoples became “Catawba,” but Beck adds more depth to these transformations by tracing their pre-eighteenth-century history and by explaining how the Catawba created a distinct political structure, or “nation.” Beck also differs from Merrell by providing a theoretical framework to explain the process of coalescence. The introduction in particular reveals the heavy influence of social theory, especially the subsection on “Structures, ruptures, and rearticulations,” which is based largely on William H. Sewell Jr.'s The Logics of History: Social Theory and Social Transformation (2005). Sewell's work, Beck writes, “supplies the theoretical vocabulary” for his analysis of coalescence, for it allows him to link the precolonial Mississippian world to eighteenth-century Indian nations (8).
The book is thereafter divided into three parts that follow Sewell's theoretical model of structure, rupture, and rearticulation. Part I examines the structure of Piedmont chiefdoms. This section especially benefits from Beck's background in archaeology and anthropology as he uses extensive archaeological data to complement the written accounts of early explorers. Part II focusses on the rupturing of Piedmont Mississippian society in the second half of the seventeenth century, owing largely to slave raiders such as the Westo, followed by recurring epidemics near the turn of the century. The influence of Robbie Ethridge's concept of the “shatter zone” is apparent as Beck describes in this and the subsequent section how the intensification of the Indian slave trade reshaped the region. Most notably, chieftancy emerged as “a new form of regional polity” whereby Native communities were embedded in a political economy based not on maize surplus, as was the case with Mississippian chiefdoms, but on deerskins and captive slaves. This “nontributary basis of its political economies,” Beck argues, “spurred coalescence” through the “joining of chieftancies at a multiregional scale,” which in turn forged the southern Indian nations of the eighteenth century (17–18).
Beck writes that the aim of his book is twofold: to explain Catawba coalescence and to offer “a conceptual framework for understanding coalescence more broadly” (2). He succeeds on both counts, although some scholars may find his focus on political economies and polity formation too narrow and will continue to emphasize changes in indigenous cultures and societies. Others may be hesitant to identify Yamasee, Creek, and Cherokee regions as “chieftancies.” The writing is also a bit technical at times as Beck explains how theory undergirds his framework, but his priority of offering a broad regional synthesis means that this is a very readable book, one that could be assigned to advanced undergraduates and one that should be assigned to graduate students. It is a must-read for teachers and scholars of the Native South.
While Beck is more concerned with Native political economies and polity formation in the American South, Julius H. Rubin explores the role that Reformed religion (Puritanism) played for various groups of Native Americans confronting settler colonialism in New England from roughly 1630 to 1820. A professor of sociology at the University of Saint Joseph in Connecticut, and the author of several books on religious melancholy, Rubin brings a firm grasp of sociological and religious theory to the field of Native American history in Tears of Repentance: Christian Indian Identity and Community in Colonial Southern New England. Retelling the well-trodden stories of Eliot and Mayhew's proselytizing in the environs of Natick and Martha's Vineyard, as well as the stories of Samson Occom and Moravian missionaries, Rubin seeks to explain why Reformed Protestantism appealed to various groups and how they selectively appropriated, embraced, and institutionalized aspects of the faith within their respective communities.
The introduction and first three chapters of Rubin's work are laden with theory and are understandably dense. In essence Rubin argues that his earlier work on religious melancholy is applicable to Native groups wracked by disease, demographic decline, the disruption of traditional lifeways, hostility with neighboring communities, and internal factionalism. Reformed Protestantism provided for Natives an explanation for a world rent asunder and a way to ritualistically restructure their lives around consciousness of sin, actions which brought pardon from the European deity and a rationale for explaining misfortune, loss, and disaster. In this new religion, Native groups forged a “practical divinity by developing new ritual forms that sought to restore balance and reciprocity with the powerful other-than-human persons, Jesus and God, consistent with traditional spirituality and lifeways” (41). With the schematic framework laid in these chapters, the theory fades in favor of a narrative chronicling the trials of Samson Occom in mediating between Native communities and colonial and missionary leaders, the decline of the Stockbridge and New Jersey Brotherton tribes, and their retreat into the Iroquoian “borderlands” to found separatist communities of Brothertown and New Stockbridge. A chapter devoted to Moravian missions at Shekomeko and Pachgatgoch stresses the darker side of religious paternalism in the Brüdergemeine and the divisive influence that missionary discipline had on Native kinship and communities.
Each community explored by Rubin suffered from the same general issues: circumscribed legal rights, a dwindling land base, alcoholism, and complications arising from ethnic diversity (Brothertown itself was composed of members from seven distinct groups). Though leaders tried to promote ascetic rituals that would bring favor from the Christian deity, prevent alcoholism, and maintain control over land, they all failed due to the religious paternalism that precluded their full participation and acceptance in colonial society. Problematic are the unanswered questions in Rubin's monograph: did these communities fail as a result of colonialism or because visions diverged between the laity of particular communities and leaders like Waban, Ashpo, or Occom? Similarly, did bouts of Native despondency result purely from a life animated by religious melancholy, or were Natives responding to the visceral loss and communal erosion that stemmed from colonialism in general? While it could be argued that Occom best exemplified one Native American struggling with religious melancholy in the wake of colonialism, his literacy and role as an ordained minister set him apart from other examples in Rubin's expansive study.
Rubin's book is part of a growing body of scholarship reevaluating the religious experiences of Native groups in colonial New England. Though Rubin's use of sociological theory to explain Native engagement with religion is innovative, Edward E. Andrews's Native Apostles: Black and Indian Missionaries in the British Atlantic World (2013) and Linford D. Fisher's The Indian Great Awakening: Religion and the Shaping of Native Cultures in Early America (2012) provide greater depth in understanding the role of indigenous missionaries as cultural brokers and the selective engagement that Native communities had with Christianity in general.
The use of theory by both Rubin and Beck is an innovative methodological approach and an underused tool compared to ethnographic studies that rely primarily on archaeological and anthropological research to supplement the paucity of written Native sources. Though not without their own limitations, these conceptual models nevertheless allow the authors to provide additional insight into the various approaches that Native peoples used to cope with colonialism. The ethnically diverse Indians in Rubin's study formed distinct communities while turning to Christianity as a basis for reorganizing their lives. In a very different context of power relations, Native peoples in villages and towns throughout the colonial South forged coalescent polities on a scale unknown in eighteenth-century New England. As traditional worlds collapsed in both regions with the expansion of Anglo-American settlements and market economies, Native Americans proved remarkably creative and resilient as they adapted to rapidly changing circumstances.
