Should we celebrate or regret the drive to efficiency that has motivated so many human endeavours? That is the question that animates Jennifer Karns Alexander's ambitious book. Juxtaposing cases drawn from across two hundred years, two continents and four countries, Alexander does not provide a definite answer to this bedevilling question at the heart of technological modernity. Instead, she explores how efficiency has always been double-faced, both a boon and a threat to freedom. Similarly, she shows how the concept is curiously doubled internally, with theories of efficiency variously emphasizing the importance of balance and stasis as well as the potential for growth and dynamism. Armed with this pair of contradictory notions, Alexander compiles an album of alternative ‘greatest hits’ drawn from the industrial and postindustrial history of efficiency in Europe and the United States, which augments, rather than repeats, the arguments made in substantial previous studies of work, machines and modernity such as Anson Rabinbach's The Human Motor (New York, 1990) and Sigfried Giedion's Mechanization Takes Command (New York, 1948).
The six historical case studies range across disciplines and national boundaries, with two taken from the UK, two from the US, and one each from France and Germany. Alexander starts with a detailed examination of a set of waterwheel experiments carried out by John Smeaton in England in the 1750s and at the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia in 1830, arguing that these different approaches to measuring the waterwheels' action demonstrate the way in which efficiency could be an abstract, philosophical topic or a highly practical one. The second chapter examines the thought of Gérard-Joseph Christian, director of the Conservatoire des arts et métiers in Paris in the early nineteenth century. Christian believed that efficient machines could effect social as well as technological transformations, freeing people from servitude to machines and enabling them to do other, more interesting work. The third chapter compares the contrasting views of Charles Darwin and the economist Alfred Marshall. While Darwin stated that natural selection was an efficient process, but not one that could be deliberately managed or achieved, Marshall argued that business managers could deliberately organize their enterprises to maximize efficiency. In a fourth chapter, Alexander turns to how efficiency was measured and defined in the United States during the Progressive Era, tracing the ever-widening application of the concept to industrial management and personal discipline. She then moves to late Weimar Germany, where managers tried to control human movements in order to eliminate waste in industrial production, designing seating configurations to keep workers as fixed in their motions as the machines they serviced. Finally, Alexander turns to the scholarly controversy over Robert Fogel and Stanley Engerman's 1974 Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery, in which they argued that slaves were more efficient farm workers than free agricultural labourers in the north. She uses the dispute to untangle the links between efficiency, moral probity and violent social control in the academic discourse of late twentieth-century America.
Alexander's cases collectively demonstrate how the concept of efficiency emerged from the relative obscurity of philosophical discourse in the early modern period (alluded to but not described fully in this book) into energetic application during the Industrial Revolution and finally into bland ubiquity by the early twentieth century, when ‘efficiency’ became a marketing catchphrase used to advertise domestic appliances and cosmetics. The variety of cases, and their often quite detailed technical content, can make for demanding reading, as the narrative shifts quite abruptly from chapter to chapter, with relatively little attention given to drawing material together across cases. Nevertheless, this very range supports Alexander's central claim that the concept of efficiency, in its many guises, came increasingly to be the ground upon which debates over the social meaning of both technological and managerial innovations took place. The variety of meanings attached to it, and its own internal contradictions, are evidence of its increasing centrality in a world where men and machines labour ever more intimately together.
