Dramaturgy in Motion: At Work on Dance and Movement Performance is a comprehensive survey into the role of the dramaturg in physical and devised work. The book is a notated, analytical journey built out of Katherine Profeta's twenty-two years as a dramaturg, with a particular focus on her eighteen years of collaboration with choreographer Ralph Lemon, which began during Lemon's guest residency at the Yale Repertory Theatre in 1997. Lemon's work, which Profeta illustrates with poignancy and detail throughout, walks the fine line between dance and theatre in its investigation into language and situation. Part anecdotal narrative, part intercultural and philosophical theory, and written with the embodied intelligence of the expert dance dramaturg, Dramaturgy in Motion is an essential read.
Profeta describes Lemon's work as a brilliant evocation of love, mourning, and racially bound identity through an American framework and the search for a spiritual locus. She specifically focuses on Lemon's Geography Trilogy (1997–2004), an exploration of race, history, and memory, as well as his major work, How Can You Stay in the House All Day and Not Go Anywhere? (2010). Geography was initially inspired by the search for a new performance language that defied geographical bounds, and began during Lemon's Yale residency, where he collaborated closely with both African American and West African performers. The trilogy grew into Tree (2000), another intercultural collaboration involving Eastern dance and performers, and Patton, which emerged from site-specific and sacred works that explored and decoded myths of the American South, even as How Can You … ? was a moving exploration of Buddhist themes and personal loss.
Profeta structures her book into five chapters, as well as an introduction and “Postface.” The chapters, on “Text and Language,” “Research,” “Audience,” “Movement,” and “Interculturalism,” respectively, explore their subjects in detail, and Profeta weaves theory, performance anecdote, and the role of the dramaturg into each theme. She understands the movement dramaturg herself as kinetic, fluid, contemplative, and communicative, a figure whose axes of research branch out into both the academic and corporeal realms. Profeta describes the dramaturg as insatiably curious, investigative, and curatorial, a person whose primary role is to inspire and who inhabits both the exterior world of academic research and the interior realm of the rehearsal hall itself. The movement dramaturg, as she describes, thus physically oscillates between theory and practice.
The sticky relationship of dance dramaturgy to language is a critical point of investigation. In Chapter 1, Profeta observes the cynicism dramaturgy may evoke among devised movement collaborators due to the reductive quality of language and the hazard of prematurely naming an impulse before it is fully generated or realized. She also acknowledges the power of the word in identifying patterns and movement codes in improvisational work, and the ability to capture new performance knowledge through the process of verbalization. Profeta supplies clear and colorful examples in which language is deconstructed and highlighted time and again, from folding a multilingual rehearsal process into a structured production improvisation, to the contrast of an extended soliloquy juxtaposed with muted movement, to the use of props, such as a loosened microphone, during a contact-driven dance/monologue performance.
Additional methodologies for which Profeta offers examples include the use of the literary-based “unreliable narrator” (43), whose greater truth is found in the underground meaning of what is circumvented purposefully or left unsaid, as well as the post-Holocaust concept of the “countermemorial” (48), a sculpture meant to evoke a lost or hidden history by pointing to its absence. Profeta also offers the intriguing notion of the “soft narrative” (52) for the twenty-first-century postdramatic performance lexicon. She describes it as a helpful lens for understanding dance and argues that it characterizes performance events unfolding over time in a panoramic arc, typically absent overt character, psychology, and mimetic representation. In such performances, the subjectivity of audience response and the meta quality of spectatorship are underlined.
In Chapter 2, Profeta suggests tools for the dance dramaturg, which she calls the “first register” and the “second register” (62). The former can be understood as a traditional academic style of compiling research; the latter directs awareness to “new ways of looking” (63), thereby evoking new knowledge. Ideally, the first register of research inspires the second register, so that a continuous spark of material can be generated. Profeta also offers the concept of the “active archive” (80) as a critical source of dramaturgy within this democratized collaborative process. The “active archive,” a term coined during a 2014 public conversation by Profeta and dramaturg Talvin Wilks, can be considered an assemblage of material generated during the production process from all the collaborators. But it does not function simply as gathered information; rather, it serves to inspire further the project and collective.
In Chapters 3 and 4, Profeta considers audience and the dramaturg's attentiveness to movement. For Profeta, movement dramaturgy thrives in the democratized and process-oriented system of Marianne Van Kerkhoven's “new dramaturgies” (92), where the dramaturg is as an integrated agent in the field of rehearsal and discovery, even at times physically embedded in the work. Another keystone of Profeta's book is her point that the dramaturg must advocate for both the audience and the subject matter, specifically in the cultivation of abstract but gravity-laden work. Profeta points to this task as the ethical obligation of the dramaturg and as part of the nuanced challenge of drawing a decipherable path for the audience through the work. The ethics of dramaturgy are discussed especially thoroughly in her final chapter, “Interculturalism,” in which she highlights the importance of dramaturgical obligations to international collaborators and to performance itself, and advocates for a particular sensitivity during intercultural dialogue.
A fundamental investigation within the book appears to be how to map the ineffable, give form to the formless, and translate the unspeakable in and through performance. Profeta explores these questions through what amounts to an epistemological discourse on dance—its construction, process, and reception. Dramaturgy in Motion is written gorgeously, flush with demanding, precise, and elegant language, all pointing toward the eruptive potential of dance dramaturgy, and it is a true contribution to the field.
