There is quite a bit more than cervical cancer analytics going on in Rebecca Martínez's Marked Women. The book is based on research begun in the mid-1990s, partly seen through the lens of a shorter sojourn in the late 2000s, and thus covers a greater chronological distance than is common for anthropologists on a first book. In addition, Martínez challenges readers to attend to some personal dimensions of her work, including her advocating for patients as a chicana (woman of Mexican descent) in Venezuela, and her experiences of sexual harassment in the field. While I am not convinced that reflecting on these aspects enriches the book as a cervical cancer study, it certainly makes the ethnography more poignant and delivers important lessons for the ethical practice of feminist anthropology.
Martínez set out to understand how knowledge of cervical cancer is explained, appropriated and transformed among Venezuelan physicians, patients and public health administrators in the context of a neoliberal regime. The clinical perspective, the author argues, is enduringly shaped by the conviction that individual female behaviours (such as promiscuity and lack of hygiene) lead to illness. Health workers, in turn, associate these behaviours with the culture of the urban poor. Conservative media outlets reinforce these biases by portraying the urban poor as violence-prone, corrupt and diseased, and by focusing on the negative consequences of internal migration and that from neighbouring countries. The public health establishment also contributes to the status quo by casting cervical cancer prevention as a matter of individual behaviours. Governmental campaigns emphasise the salutary effects of limiting female sexual activity to single-partner, heterosexual, procreative, married relations, with scarce mention of the structural constraints (including transportation shortages, lack of trained personnel, and sexual violence) faced by women who seek or need medical attention.
Elite disdain and fear of the urban poor have translated into calls for the study of their allegedly distinct illnesses and the policing of their behaviour since the republics were established in the nineteenth century, in order to produce a healthier citizenry and buttress the power and prestige of fledgling medical authorities. Despite its smaller contribution to national morbidities and mortalities (relative to malaria or tuberculosis, for example), cancer has been a medico-social concern for decades. Moreover, as in other countries, female cancers provided the model for the first cancer control campaigns Latin American nations embarked on in the 1910s. Of all cancers, cervical cancer has been the most extended, lethal and preventable. By the 1960s, its burden had become so visible that Latin American health ministries, including the Venezuelan one, frequently coupled its prevention to the prevention of rapid population growth, taking advantage of the resources the United States was willing to throw at the latter issue. To this day, as Martínez notes, cervical cancer remains a substantial contributor to female mortality in Latin America. At the same time, its link to the human papilloma virus (HPV) has disseminated the threat to new populations (men who have sex with men, for example) and new organs (the throat, anus and penis), while stubbornly keeping sexuality central to its aetiology and epidemiology. Readers will need this context to understand why cervical cancer deserves broader attention.
Although Martínez undersells the distinctiveness and timeliness of her subject, this study can deepen conversations regarding why cervical cancer prevention efforts have yielded such slow results. Martínez's fieldwork, for example, takes place in two modern hospitals in Caracas. It would have been interesting to delve into the rationale for choosing these sites. More importantly, her choice should lead us to consider what would happen if cervical cancer prevention privileged investments in detection and expedient clinical intervention in small urban and rural settings, rather than in large urban tertiary care institutions. Likewise, Martínez makes it clear that missing work days and arranging for childcare are financially taxing for female patients. Including cancer care in state insurance schemes would relieve some of this burden, while preserving the health of people in their prime economic productivity years. Yet the adoption of these policies in Latin America has been uneven. Martínez is arguably at her best when she details her interactions with patients seeking medical help. Although many of these women were satisfied and grateful for the care received, Martínez also documented how clinicians’ failure to invite questions, their rough manners and their lack of acknowledgement that some interventions are painful and iatrogenic work against the establishment of trusting relations with patients and dissuade the latter from seeking follow-up services. Faced with these too-common situations, Martínez behaved admirably, setting aside the notebook to ask questions on behalf of individual patients and to console some. Making room in the clinical encounter for lay people to act as cancer patients’ advocates (by developing special non-adversarial training sessions for existing volunteers, for example) might help address common blind spots in medical interactions.
Considering the radical political transition Venezuela has undergone from the mid-1990s to the present, it bears asking about cervical cancer before and during the Bolivarian Revolution. Yet, because of time constraints during Martínez's visit in 2008, her insights in this regard are limited to noting a novel official position associating public health with social justice, alongside obdurate medical attitudes linking illness and behaviour. Cancer care as part of the signature Misión Barrio Adentro programme for impoverished urban areas, and its fate amidst the worsening crisis of the Maduro regime, fall outside the scope of this interesting study, hopefully not for long.
