In the early Victorian era the Great Experiment in the Caribbean was brought into question, headstrong settler colonies were given greater powers of self-government, protective tariffs and legislation were repealed and the contradictions of the East India Company's state gave way to direct, if still contradictory, imperial rule in South Asia. Against this background, free traders, humanitarians and entrepreneurs jostled to influence Britain's imperial affairs, forming a multitude of societies and leagues that adopted the tactics of their anti-slavery predecessors, often claiming to be their heirs. Some, like the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society, enjoyed mass support and campaigned throughout the nineteenth century. Others, such as the short-lived British India Society, drew substantial crowds, donations and attention before enthusiasm rapidly dissipated. Regardless of their ultimate influence, key lobbyists within each organisation inevitably struggled to define the terms of debate, vying for public support and the chance to influence government.
This article aims to elucidate the overlapping religious, social and commercial networks within which humanitarian lobbyists operated, with a view to accounting for their differing levels of success. By considering the Indian campaigns of the Aborigines Protection Society (founded 1837) and the British India Society (founded 1839), the article re-examines the relationships and ideas that shaped humanitarian and moral reform campaigns. It demonstrates that these were articulated across a wider transnational arena than previously assumed, one which stretched from Britain's settler and plantation colonies to India, as well as beyond the empire to the United States and Liberia.
Recent scholarship has traced how better-known and more successful organisations – particularly the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society and the Anti-Corn Law League – attempted to assume the mantle of abolition in the 1830s and 1840s.Footnote 2 In contrast, this study of the larger penumbra of less successful societies explores the influence of internecine rivalry. It also aims to assess the influence of the geographically capacious and interconnected worldview shared by moral reformers and humanitarians. Although ostensibly cosmopolitan intellectual frameworks were a feature of these campaigns, they often masked Eurocentric and superficial understandings of the world beyond Britain, and fell victim to the claims of the priority of metropolitan issues over imperial. Hence it is argued here that mid-nineteenth-century understandings of Britain's empire were more supple and interconnected than historians sometimes imagine.
The Aborigines Protection Society (APS) lobbied on behalf of indigenous peoples mainly within, but also beyond, Britain's Empire, advocating their rights to land, to the benefits of ‘civilisation’ and to protection from imperial violence. It was an organisation of humanitarian inclination, having intermittent and partial success, and limited support. Nonetheless, the APS endured until 1909 when it united with the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society (founded 1839). The British India Society (BIS) was inaugurated at a well-attended public meeting in London in July 1839. Although several of its founders were also APS committee members, they believed that the APS was neither sufficiently focused, nor sufficiently radical, to bring about Indian reform. The new society's prospectus emphasised that “justice for Indians” was connected to freer trade and the decline of US slavery. Despite initial publicity and high-profile supporters, by late 1842 the BIS was effectively defunct. A study of the scope and relationship of these two societies throws new light on the complex nature of mid-nineteenth-century lobbying on the empire, demonstrating how campaigners, whether motivated by humanitarian or economic interests, understood the empire and the peoples who populated it, and how they situated both in relation to more ostensibly metropolitan concerns. It is likely that the tensions revealed in this article were also experienced by other metropolitan societies, caught between the desire to promote particular aims and the knowledge that some causes were more popular than others, and led by driven and idiosyncratic personalities.
Historiography
The fracturing of the British abolition movement after the 1833 Emancipation Act has been extensively studied, most comprehensively by Howard Temperley.Footnote 3 The Act's compromises over compensation, apprenticeship and geographical scope exacerbated existing divisions within anti-slavery movements through the mid-1830s, while in the 1840s anti-slavery supporters debated whether the promotion of free trade or free labour should be their priority.Footnote 4 As Alex Tyrrell has argued, the movement's nature also changed in the mid-1830s as the “moral radical party” emerged, championing the moral authority of the provincial over the metropolitan, and the commoner over the aristocrat, in order to demand immediate reform. Joseph Sturge's success in forcing the issue of apprenticeship onto the national agenda in 1837–38 exemplified and boosted the strength of these radicals.Footnote 5 However, while many of the myriad societies that emerged in the next few years adopted the outlook and tactics of Sturge's Birmingham Anti-Slavery Society, others manifested a metropolitan bias and an enthusiasm for high-profile, high-status leaders.
The Aborigines Protection Society counted some provincial Quakers among its leading members but was nevertheless open to the moral radicals’ charge of being overly cautious and gradualist in its tactics. It has received less scholarly attention than its higher-profile, explicitly anti-slavery counterparts. Charles Swaisland, Roderick Mitcham and Rachel Whitehead have investigated the APS's better-known late nineteenth-century African campaigns, while older studies consider the Society's early advocacy on the Cape Colony and New Zealand.Footnote 6 James Heartfield's recent history surveys the whole period of its existence.Footnote 7 Amalie and Edward Kass's comprehensive biography of Dr Thomas Hodgkin, the APS's co-founder and central figure during its first twenty years, encompasses his significant medical and scientific career as well as his humanitarian activities.Footnote 8 Unsurprisingly, given the limited attention paid to the organisation, and its tendency to be seen as primarily engaged with settler colonies before the late Victorian period, this literature gives little coverage of the APS's mid-nineteenth century interests and activities outside the British Empire or its specific engagement with India.Footnote 9
The British India Society has received even more scant attention. S. R. Mehrotra briefly examined its membership and activities in 1967,Footnote 10 but the most comprehensive studies remain J. H. Bell's 1891 work on Joseph Pease's establishment of the society that rightly emphasised the importance of the connections between abolitionists and Indian reformers, and Anne Stoddart's 1899 biography of Pease's daughter, Elizabeth Pease Nichol.Footnote 11 Both are particularly useful for their incorporation of private correspondence which is now lost.Footnote 12 More recent considerations of the connections between advocates of free trade (and particularly the Anti-Corn Law League) and abolitionists only mention the BIS in passing.Footnote 13
Tony Ballantyne, Thomas Metcalf, researchers in the field of missionary studies and current attempts to link the colonial histories of Sri Lanka and India have underlined the rich possibilities of exploring connections between South Asia under East India rule and other, differently administered, parts of Britain's empire.Footnote 14 One of this article's aims therefore is to demonstrate that while governance of the subcontinent was clearly distinctive, nineteenth-century Britons certainly did not automatically regard India as entirely separate from those colonies governed through the Colonial Office.
While the activities, ideas and relationships of Britons who were centrally concerned with imperial reform are addressed, limited attention has been given to the objects of their campaigns or supporting or competing campaigns in the colonies themselves. Most of the action that is explored took place in Britain, much of it in London, although the actors roamed intellectually, and sometimes physically, to India, the United States, Southern Africa, the Caribbean, Liberia and China. The article focuses on these campaigns’ metropolitan dimensions, resonances and interconnections. In reasserting the importance of understanding the complexities of metropolitan Britain in relation to the empire, it builds on studies that emphasise the porous nature of colonial boundaries and the importance of metaphors of connection in understanding imperial mobility.Footnote 15 By considering how British-based activists acted as (and understood themselves to be) links between different parts of the world, it supports recent work that stresses the importance of reintroducing the post-revolutionary United States as a critical comparator and connection in the study of Britain's nineteenth-century colonies.Footnote 16 Further, it argues that charting links between different types of British space – metropole, settler society, plantation colony, and Company India – provides a clearer understanding of the empire as a whole.Footnote 17
The Aborigines Protection Society
From its foundation in 1837, the APS disseminated information to the British and colonial publics, encouraged colonial auxiliaries and lobbied imperial and colonial governments. It did so in an insistent but moderate fashion, mostly following the tactics (if not emulating the mass support) of earlier abolitionists. Indeed, well-educated, middle-and upper-middle-class non-conformists and evangelicals dominated the APS, although it aspired to be non-sectarian: Sir Thomas Fowell Buxton, the abolitionist hero, was its first president, while its membership had strong links to both anti-slavery and missionary societies as well as the Religious Society of Friends.Footnote 18
Historians seeking critics of empire have rightly found the APS rather ambivalent on this score.Footnote 19 Certainly, the Society accepted the fact, if not the virtue, of Britain's colonial possessions. Reflecting its solidly middle-class professional membership, APS zeal was almost always directed towards reforming the governance of empire rather than overthrowing British rule. On occasion it even advocated – if on defensive, humanitarian grounds – the extension of empire. Some of the Society's proposals were utopian, others would have revolutionised imperial encounters, but, invariably, they were presented in pragmatic, reformist tones. Nevertheless, in articulating the plight and rights of indigenous peoples across the empire, the APS attracted the attention, and sometimes the hostility, of metropolitan policymakers, indigenous leaders and colonial settlers.
Debates within the APS about the organisation's scope – including who, exactly, constituted the “Aborigines” – were indicative of more widespread uncertainty about to whom Britons, Christians and humanitarians owed responsibilities, and whether such commitments’ realisation could be confined to saving souls rather than improving bodily well-being. In a divergence from missionary strategies, particularly emphasised by the APS's co-founder Hodgkin, “civilisation” was promoted as leading to “Christianity”, rather than the more common reverse. The Society's stated interest was in the earthly, not the hereafter.Footnote 20 The APS was also unusually radical in the universalism of its outlook. Underlining its humanitarian credentials, all people were deemed of equal value and equal potential: its motto was ab uno sanguine (of one blood).Footnote 21 In an 1850 statement, the APS declared its determination to destroy “the prejudice which exists with respect to the capacity of native tribes”, and “not less stoutly and continually” to uphold “their claims to equal justice, equal rights, political and social, equal education, and equal humanity”.Footnote 22 To the APS, the plight of New Zealand's Maoris and Southern Africa's Xhosa deserved as much attention as that of slaves in the Caribbean, or, for that matter, Native Americans in the independent United States, opium addicts in China or chimney sweeps in Britain. A determination to alert Britons to the evils visited on indigenous peoples, and to demand a remedy from politicians and the public, was evident in every APS statement.
Like many nineteenth-century voluntary societies, the actions and objects of focus of the APS were determined by a small group of committed individuals who attempted to win donations and support from a much larger penumbra of less-engaged members of the middle classes.Footnote 23 Thomas Hodgkin was central to directing the Society's operations and focus until his death in 1866. His cornucopia of interests – medical, ethnological, reforming and religious – encouraged Hodgkin to foster connections with people across, and indeed beyond, the empire. This network was maintained by thousands of letters written to and from Hodgkin over several decades. It proved an important source of intelligence for the APS and allowed the distribution of its publications and message.Footnote 24 Other well-known members of the Society's committee in its early years included William Allen, Edward Baines, Saxe Bannister, Josiah Forster, Samuel Gurney, both Stephen and Charles Lushington, Charles Hindley, Robert Montgomery Martin, Daniel O'Connell and Joseph Pease. These men were typically non-conformists (often Quakers), with strong links to anti-slavery activism and reform more generally; several – like Bannister and Montgomery Martin – published extensively on imperial topics. As well as lobbying influential individuals, the APS held public meetings in London and experimented with travelling agents. Provincial and colonial auxiliaries were encouraged, although with limited success. In 1847, a journal, the Colonial Intelligencer (known also as the Aborigines’ Friend) supplemented the Society's sporadic, stand-alone publications.Footnote 25
While consistently protesting their equal potential and equal rights, APS engagement with indigenous peoples themselves in the mid-century was limited. This contact was also heavily imbued with assumptions about class and the superiority of ‘British civilisation’ over all other variants. Direct engagement between the APS and those it claimed to represent was limited to a few colonial correspondents and occasional, ad hoc encounters with indigenous peoples who visited or moved to Britain for work, or education or to make representations to the imperial government.
APS finances – derived from subscriptions and donations – did not allow much freedom of action; on several occasions only Hodgkin's financial largesse kept the Society afloat. Almost all the Society's supporters also subscribed to other domestic and imperial causes, often more generously. Retaining their attention and competing for their money was a constant challenge: the philanthropic pound was thinly spread. But the Society's advocacy of political intervention, its rejection of sectarianism and its attempts to divert some attention from slaves to indigenous peoples, also risked alienating its natural constituency of more denominationally conscious mission enthusiasts and more politically radical provincial abolitionists. While central to the Society, Hodgkin also contributed to its awkward external relations. He believed himself a diplomat but was in many respects a contrarian, prepared to take on the Quaker establishment. He was critical of missionaries who focused on religious salvation at the expense of human rights, and was frequently at odds over tactics and priorities with both the provincial ‘moral radicals’ and the metropolitan establishment of the anti-slavery movement.Footnote 26
Defining ‘Aborigines’: the APS and India
Although inspired by the 1835–37 Commons’ Select Committee on Aborigines, which assessed and condemned the situation of indigenous peoples in Britain's settler colonies,Footnote 27 the APS cast its net more widely when deciding who needed its protection. Thus, at one point or another, African Americans who had relocated to Liberia, indigenous peoples in the USA and Latin America, Pacific Islanders, Siberians, Egyptians and Syrians were all felt by the Society to fall within its remit, alongside the indigenous peoples of Britain's settler colonies. Perhaps because of this diversity, explicitly defining the ‘Aborigines’ proved difficult. The first issue of the Colonial Intelligencer recognised in 1847 that while the term ‘Aborigines’ had “a currency and acceptation”, it was “not so general as to render explanation unnecessary”. The journal resorted to contrasting Aborigines with European settlers, in a representative but contorted discussion. Emigrants from “civilized” societies who travelled to places “where a wider space is open before them”, it argued, would often “find the land imperfectly occupied by a race of men greatly differing from themselves. These are the so-called Aborigines of the country. . .” While the term ‘savage’ was deemed unhelpful, “more applicable to the visitor than to the visited”, the article acknowledged that separation from more civilised people had usually rendered Aborigines “very low in the scale of knowledge and art”.Footnote 28
Alongside the implication that Aborigines could only exist once outsiders had discovered them, levels of ‘civilisation’ also contributed to the definition. Buxton's Select Committee on Aborigines had not considered India, reflecting both the subcontinent's separate structures of governance and, as importantly, its position in European-generated hierarchies of human civilisation. In these schemes, Indians were placed far above Australian Aborigines, Amerindians or the South African Khoisan. In part, South Asians were seen as less ‘aboriginal’ than many of Britain's non-European subjects because they were deemed better able to protect themselves and thus more responsible for their circumstances. India's history, civilisation and religious traditions, while deeply disquieting to most British evangelicals, were regarded both as more complex and more resistant to change than those of societies deemed less civilised. As such, Indians carried some blame for any disadvantages attributable to their stubbornly unchristian lifestyles. Many of South Asia's inhabitants were also recognised as former colonisers – the Mughals, or their precursors – further confusing the already difficult question of aboriginality. Thus, only a few ‘tribal’ peoples of South Asia – Bhils, Kols and Santals, sometimes referred to collectively as ‘hill tribes’ or ‘hill coolies’ – were routinely categorised as ‘aborigines’ by nineteenth-century Britons.Footnote 29
These definitional conundrums, alongside competition from other organisations and ideas about how best to attract public support, influenced APS engagement with Indian issues in the 1830s. In 1838, several committee members, including the Quakers Joseph Pease and William Allen, and the imperial author and agitator Robert Montgomery Martin, urged the Society to take up the plight of the subcontinent under East India Company rule. Heavily involved in the struggle to end post-emancipation apprenticeship in the West Indies, Joseph Pease was first drawn into Indian affairs in early 1838, when examining the exploitation of Indians who had been indentured to planters in British Guiana and Mauritius. On 25 July 1838, he brought the East India Company proprietor Sir Charles Forbes to a committee meeting of the APS at which “the condition of India was laid before the members and their co-operation secured” in campaigning for reform.Footnote 30 Although, wrote Hodgkin, “the sufferings of the inhabitants of British India” differed from those considered by the 1835–37 Select Committee, they “were fully embraced by our design & . . . we had no hesitation in desiring to give to them our best attention”.Footnote 31
Once key APS committee members had come to regard India as a priority, the Society's loose remit made it straightforward for Indian affairs to be incorporated into its activities. The eclectic range of Indian issues considered by the APS reflected both the importance of members’ interests and correspondence networks, and continuing ambivalence about who could properly be considered ‘aboriginal’. In 1838 and 1839, India's tribal peoples received special attention on the basis that they were particularly exposed to practices akin to slavery. But the so-called Indian hill coolies, shipped to Mauritius, Guyana and elsewhere as indentured labourers, also became an object of APS concern. The tenor of these discussions implied that Indians, once removed from the subcontinent, became more appropriate subjects of humanitarian attention, and certainly in greater need of the Society's protection. This applied not only to Indians labouring in the plantation colonies: a coroner's report on an indentured Indian who had died in South Australia was also brought to the Society's attention.Footnote 32 Concern was not entirely limited to expatriate or tribal Indians, as the Society's efforts to publicise the devastating effects of the 1837–38 famine in north-west Bengal testify.Footnote 33
APS publications featured India too. Alongside early, specially commissioned, pamphlets on Upper Canada, New Zealand and Western Australia, Pease encouraged the Society to republish the concluding section of Robert Montgomery Martin's 1838 three-volume survey of India and relevant portions of William Howitt's works.Footnote 34 Martin, originally engaged by Sir Charles Forbes to explain Indian land taxes to Pease, had subsequently joined the APS committee. His work criticised East India Company rule for generating a “mass of wretchedness” under “the pretence of free trade”. “England” wrote Martin,
is considered the abode of a Christian people, enlightened far above their Continental neighbours, and blessed with all the advantages of advanced civilization. But how has England treated British India, which is as much a part of the Empire as Scotland or Ireland? . . . an insignificant island in the Caribbean seas excites more of our attention than an empire which would have quenched the ambition of Alexander, whose armies rival those of Rome . . . and whose commerce would have satiated Tyre or Carthage.
This oblique criticism of the undue attention paid by the British to anti-slavery resonated with other APS statements. So, too, did Martin's focus on the bodily rather than the spiritual. Prefiguring the commercial slant of later humanitarian campaigns, Martin denounced evangelism in the subcontinent, instead advocating fair commercial dealing and justice as the best remedy for India. “However gross in theory the religion of the Hindoos,” he argued, “it could not be more unjust in practice than has been the conduct of professing Christians towards Hindostan”. His pamphlet also warned that as “injustice acts like the scorpion's sting on its possessor”, England's “cruel and ungenerous treatment of India” would “recoil with tenfold effect”.Footnote 35 Thus, within a year of its foundation, the APS had expanded its definition of ‘aborigines’ to include the most numerous of Britain's subject peoples.
Competition and Collaboration in Humanitarian Networks
While its remit may have been wide, the influence of the APS was tiny in comparison with the potential reach of Britain's premier humanitarian movement, the anti-slavery campaign. As others have observed, divisions between abolitionists in the wake of the 1833 Emancipation Act created space for a range of empire-focused humanitarian societies to emerge. But the diversity of objects to which humanitarian organisations directed themselves was also revealing of the breadth and universality of their members’ aspirations. In debating their priorities, and competing for public support, in the 1830s and 1840s British abolitionists demonstrated the degree to which they understood imperial evils to be interconnected. While the APS may have adopted India as a cause in 1838, not everyone was convinced that the Society was the best vehicle with which to advance Indian reform. A consideration of how and why the APS fractured over India reveals not only the fluidity of imperial critics’ concepts of empire but also the complexity and interpenetration of humanitarian networks, and the degree to which personal friendships and rivalries influenced – and circumscribed – activity.
Despite having successfully engaged the APS with Indian affairs, Joseph Pease was not content to leave lobbying on the subcontinent to the society. Pease was both alert to the superior reach of the anti-slavery movement, and – as a northern, Darlington-based, Quaker, who fitted comfortably into Tyrell's “moral reform” group – anxious about the APS's moderate stance. While Thomas Hodgkin perceived the society as battling against Britain's established elites in government, parliament and the Church, to others it was full of middle-class, metropolitan types, too cosy with the nation's great and good to risk radical action. Such suspicion was characteristic of the abolitionists: famously, the movement had split in the early 1830s over priorities and tactics. Parliamentary insiders were intent on shaping workable, if partial, legislation; while some of their equally committed counterparts outside parliament rejected compromising on compensation and apprenticeship. The divide was understood to separate provinces and metropolis as much as political elites and “the people”. Thomas Fowell Buxton, the first APS president, was firmly identified with parliamentary abolition and – in the wake of emancipation – with the toothless Select Committee on Apprenticeship. The Birmingham Quaker Joseph Sturge, on the other hand, was not only central to the Anti-Slavery Agency Committee, which had revivified the campaign for immediate emancipation in 1831, but subsequently led the moral radical charge against apprenticeship in the mid-1830s. Despite being an APS committee member himself, Joseph Pease had reservations about the likelihood of the Society engaging in sufficiently radical action to achieve substantive Indian reform. His remedy for this was twofold: to energise the APS and its lobbying tactics, and to interest the broader abolition movement in agitating against Indian slavery.
When the end of apprenticeship was secured in 1838, most of Britain's abolitionists turned their attention to the United States or to West Africa, and gave little thought to the East India Company's state in South Asia.Footnote 36 The colonial author William Howitt recounted speaking to Joseph Sturge at this time:
on the comparative insignificance of the negro when taken into view with the whole greater question of our colonial barbarities . . . and he appeared astonished. He seemed hardly capable of comprehending that, in India alone, there could be one hundred millions of human creatures, under British rule, in a far worse condition than less than one million negroes had ever been in the West Indies.Footnote 37
Pease, with his excellent connections among Britain's abolitionists, hoped to redress this ignorance among anti-slavery activists and, through them, to mobilise public opinion against slavery in the subcontinent.
Only a week after the APS agreed to agitate on Indian affairs, Joseph Pease and his daughter Elizabeth took up an “excellent opportunity for propagandism” on India. Like the other leaders of radical abolition, the Peases were to mark the end of apprenticeship on 1 August 1838 with celebrations in Birmingham. Pease arranged to share a carriage on the partially completed railway from London with the Irish MP Daniel O'Connell, with the express intention of persuading O'Connell that anti-slavery attention should now focus on India. Part of the journey was by coach, giving Pease the opportunity to draw four MPs – Benjamin Hawes, Edward Baines and the brothers Stephen and Charles Lushington – into the conversation. In an account written much later, Elizabeth Pease described feeling herself “in a sort of Elysium while listening to the conversation of two men, who, to so large an extent, practically carried out the principle ‘that all men are created free and equal, and have an equal right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness’”.Footnote 38 Joseph Pease's strategy was effective: in their Birmingham speeches, both O'Connell and Stephen Lushington placed slavery in the subcontinent high on the agenda; O'Connell, in particular, would prove to be an enduring “Friend of India”.Footnote 39 And, in 1840, the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society (BFASS), which grew out of the Birmingham Anti-Slavery Society and the Agency Committee, would formally commit itself to bringing about the end of slavery in Company India.
The second element of Pease's strategy was to extend the reach and appeal of the APS. To this end, in late 1838 he persuaded the committee to hire the high profile anti-slavery lecturer, George Thompson, to embark on a lecture tour of Britain. Thompson had toured Britain as a stipendiary lecturer for the Agency Committee in the early 1830s.Footnote 40 After emancipation in the British colonies was secured, William Lloyd Garrison, founder of the American Anti-Slavery Society, invited Thompson to tour the United States.Footnote 41 There, he was instrumental in establishing several hundred American anti-slavery auxiliaries, although the climate was often violently hostile, and he was forced to flee the country in December 1835.Footnote 42 In November 1837, at the height of the radical anti-apprenticeship campaign, Thompson's criticism of Buxton and the compromises of the 1833 Emancipation Act had upset moderate abolitionist opinion.Footnote 43
Thompson was a passionate and compelling lecturer, with a maverick reputation. George Stephen, intending to be patronising, described him as a brilliant “platform speaker”.Footnote 44 With such qualifications, Thompson was a good choice to raise the APS's profile by drumming up support and establishing auxiliary societies in the provinces. His appointment should have been a coup. However, pre-existing tensions between Thompson and Hodgkin over American anti-slavery strategy intervened and threatened to undermine the APS. As such, Thompson's brief period of APS employment is characteristic of the interconnected, contested and transnational world of British humanitarian activism in this era.
Like Garrison and other American advocates of immediate emancipation, Thompson denounced an older movement, which argued that the solution to US slavery lay in the voluntary “repatriation” of American blacks to the West African settlement of Liberia. Immediatists considered this so-called colonisation to be a thinly veiled attempt to deport troublesome free blacks, thus actually upholding slavery and whitening the Union.Footnote 45 After returning from America in 1835, Thompson publicly debated – and reportedly bettered – the American Colonization Society's the Reverend Robert Breckenridge over five consecutive evenings in Glasgow.Footnote 46 Throughout the decade, he vociferously attacked every American colonisationist who visited Britain. Hodgkin, by contrast, thought gradual emancipation more likely to succeed than immediate, and was a supporter, although also a friendly critic, of the American Colonization Society.Footnote 47 Throughout his life he corresponded with senior members of the Society and with Liberian settlers, providing hospitality when they visited Britain, and lobbying on their behalf. In 1848, Hodgkin became the first British consul of the independent Liberian republic. With a typically expansive vision, he believed that Liberia would provide black Americans with the opportunity to flourish beyond the reach of entrenched white prejudice. Racism and slavery in the United States would both be undermined, while Liberia's black colonists and the “legitimate commerce” they introduced to West Africa would diffuse civilisation across the continent.Footnote 48
When Thomas Fowell Buxton established the British-based African Civilization Society in 1840, to promote legitimate commerce in West Africa through the Niger Expedition,Footnote 49 Hodgkin hoped that it would collaborate in his long-held plans to encourage black migration from Britain's Caribbean colonies to new West African settlements. However, influenced by the negative publicity generated by Garrison and Thompson, Britain's leading abolitionists, including Buxton, refused to recognise any connection or intellectual debt to the American colonisation movement. Despite lobbying hard, publicly and privately, Hodgkin was unable to convince Buxton, Thomas Clarkson or Joseph Sturge to acknowledge, let alone support, the American Colonization Society or his plans for Caribbean migration ‘back’ to Africa; the efforts of Garrison and Thompson had totally poisoned the British mood.Footnote 50
Most of the APS committee disagreed with Hodgkin on the virtues of American colonisation. Pease, for whom India had certainly overtaken ‘aborigines’ more generally as a priority by the summer of 1838, had approached Thompson independently in July, while his employment by the APS was ratified at a committee meeting on 6 August which Hodgkin missed. Aghast at Thompson's employment, Hodgkin protested that it was unwise to hire “so fierce & unfair” a figure, a man “so decidedly of a party character”.Footnote 51 But the majority agreed that “the fruits of [Thompson's] labours would more than cover the charge of his salary & travelling”.Footnote 52 As the APS deliberately left the subjects of slavery and the slave trade to the anti-slavery societies, it was hoped that Hodgkin and Thompson's past disagreements would not affect their new relationship.Footnote 53 The nascent APS was struggling both to spread its message and to bolster its finances in an atmosphere of fierce competition from other causes. Thompson, an electric speaker, with a high public profile and a record of establishing auxiliary societies, could prove an excellent investment. It was arranged that he would begin lecturing in Darlington and Newcastle in late August 1838, taking advantage of the crowd drawn to the inaugural meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science.Footnote 54
By the end of the year, Thompson had delivered twelve addresses across the north of Britain, speaking in Darlington, Newcastle, Edinburgh and Glasgow, sometimes alone and on occasion supported by Robert Montgomery Martin.Footnote 55 Although Thompson's first outings as a lecturer were notable for his ignorance of the subject, Elizabeth Pease collected, sifted and prepared evidence for his presentations, while the young W. E. Forster, future MP and sponsor of the 1870 Education Act, was pressed into organising meetings in the new year in Newcastle, North Shields, South Shields, Kendal, Carlisle, Darlington and Sheffield.Footnote 56 Aside from Elizabeth Pease's compilations, Thompson was armed with recent publications, including Martin's on India and William Howitt's 507-page Colonization and Christianity. Eleven of Howitt's twenty-nine chapters were devoted to the British Empire, and five of these to British India. Although not published by the APS, the book concluded with an explicit endorsement of the Society.Footnote 57
Thompson's links with the Peases, and his genuine absorption by the Indian material he had been given, meant that aboriginal affairs in the rest of the world were entirely excluded from his lectures. Initially the APS committee thought this unimportant, while “the cause remained entire”. However, according to Hodgkin, India's “extent & importance” and “its more intimate relation to home affairs” meant that it dominated not only Thompson's speeches but also his audiences’ interest and resultant press reports.Footnote 58 New societies were formed in Darlington and Newcastle, but they explicitly focused on Indian reform, not Aborigines’ protection.
In the last week of January 1839, Thompson stayed with Joseph and Elizabeth Pease in Darlington, meeting William Adam,Footnote 59 who had reported on education for the East India Company. The Darlington group decided that in addition to local provincial societies, a central London-based organisation, devoted to Indian issues, was needed. After completing his remaining scheduled lectures, Thompson returned to the capital in late February or early March to request his release from the APS. He intended to focus on forming a new society, campaigning only on British Indian affairs.Footnote 60
The British India Society: Profit and Morals Reconciled?
The platform of the British India Society (BIS) would explicitly link a series of geographically disparate interests: Indian reform, the abolition of American slavery and British prosperity. Since the 1790s, British abolitionists had called for the substitution of East Indian produce for slave-grown staples:Footnote 61 now the moral reformers would connect metropolitan and imperial free trade with the cause of free labour, in the process drawing in their abolitionist counterparts from the United States.
The new society's prospectus was issued on 27 March 1839, put together by a provisional committee which, in addition to Thompson, Pease, Howitt and Adam, included John Bowring, Lord Brougham, Sir Charles Forbes and Jonathan Backhouse.Footnote 62 On 1 June, a meeting of the new society was timed to coincide with the Quakers’ Yearly Meeting. A better-publicised inaugural meeting was arranged for the Freemason's Hall in London on 6 July. Chaired by Lord Brougham, it was attended by Indian and British notables, including East India Company officials, military officers and merchants; several Indians visiting London to appeal against Company decisions; a number of Parsi merchants and students from Bombay; British and US clergy; prominent Quakers and abolitionists; senior colonial officials, including the lieutenant-governor of the Eastern Cape Colony and the future governor of Hong Kong; and at least eight members of Parliament. Leading Anglo-Indians present included Forbes, John Crawfurd, William Henry Sykes and Colonel Charles Thompson.Footnote 63 Demonstrating the extent to which colonial lobbying organisations, and indeed reforming networks generally, overlapped, a significant proportion of those listed as attending the BIS's inaugural meeting, or among its first donors, were also or would become members of the APS, the Anti-Corn Law League, or the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society.Footnote 64
The prospectus and inaugural meeting of the BIS stand as a monument to moral reform. Thompson's arguments, honed by his months in the north, dominated the July gathering. His speech drew on pamphlets from the early 1820s,Footnote 65 when abolitionists and East India investors alike condemned the differential tariffs that favoured British Caribbean sugar production over East Indian.Footnote 66 However, while they had maintained that Indian labour was free, Thompson acknowledged and opposed forced labour in the subcontinent, as well as the United States. He connected slavery, commerce and colonial governance, drawing together arguments based on the principle of free trade with those founded in morality. Britain, he argued, had the opportunity not just to address Robert Montgomery Martin's concerns about Company rule in India but also to end American slavery. At the Freemason's Hall, Thompson declared:
by bettering the condition of our fellow subjects – the Natives of India, we shall be advancing the prosperity of our own country, and conferring incalculable benefits upon other parts of the world. Africa must be reached through India. – America must be reached through India. – Manacles still hang about the limbs of twenty-five hundred thousand of the coloured children of the United States. How are these manacles to be struck off? . . .When we do justice to India. When we prefer the Sugar of Bengal, and the Rice of Patna, and the Cotton of Bombay, to the produce of the despot-cursed regions of Carolina, and Louisiana, and the Texas! Then, my Lord, we shall have Cotton without Slavery, Sugar without Slavery. We have eighty millions of free fellow-subjects in India. With these we may successfully fight all the Slave-holders, Slave-breeders, and Slave-stealers in Christendom. Let the merchants and manufacturers of Liverpool, Glasgow, Manchester and London . . . help us to get justice for India . . . The produce of free labour shall drive out of the market the blood-sprinkled produce of the captive African. Political economy shall constrain the Slave-holder to do that which Reason and Religion now call upon him in vain to do.Footnote 67
In the wake of this and other rousing speeches, the meeting passed resolutions both condemning the status quo and pointing to the material benefits for Britain that would follow Indian reform.Footnote 68 Subscriptions and donations were generous, especially in comparison to the APS's efforts.Footnote 69 And, for a while, the British India Society briefly flourished. Thompson's Six Lectures on India delivered in Manchester late in 1839, were subsequently published in Britain and, via Thompson's transatlantic connections, in the United States. American delegates to the World Anti-Slavery Society Conference were also enthusiastic about attending the British India Society's anniversary meeting in July 1840.
More than a quarter of the initial BIS subscribers were also APS members, mostly very active members. In important respects the British India Society was closely aligned with the humanitarian message of the older society. In particular, the speech made at the inaugural meeting by the Irish “liberator” Daniel O'Connell had emphasised the human toll of famine and opium in the subcontinent, directly connecting both with the deficiencies of dual government. In contrast to the APS, however, the BIS was much more likely to allow Indians to state their grievances for themselves.Footnote 70 Most notably, the speech given at the inaugural meeting by Iqbal al-Daula, the pretender to the throne of Awadh, was translated for the audience from Persian. Al-Daula declared the people of India equal in terms of intelligence, industry and enterprise to those he had encountered across Europe, and spoke of how Indians, unable to gain justice in India from the Company government, were forced to come in person to Britain. He announced himself “astonished at the indifference manifested in regard to Indian subjects by the House of Commons”.Footnote 71
While the British India Society shared much with the APS, in terms of personnel and humanitarian ideals, it was more explicit in unashamedly reconciling commercial self-interest with philanthropy.Footnote 72 The Society's journal, the British Indian Advocate, which ran to fifteen editions in 1841 and 1842, used the telling slogan “Justice to India – Prosperity to England – Freedom to the Slave”. As Mehrotra's study of the society demonstrated, support came from far and wide, outstripping the humanitarian and missionary-dominated membership of the APS. Supporters of the BIS included the Anglo-Indian-dominated Landholders’ Society of Calcutta; a Bombay Committee which incorporated leading members of the presidency's Hindu, Parsi, Muslim and English communities; and, back in Britain, aristocrats as well as free traders like John Bright and Richard Cobden.Footnote 73 The disparity of these interests, and their conflict with humanitarian priorities, was underlined when, early in 1840, Thompson began to lecture against Britain's war with China.
Although it would enjoy a brief resurgence afterwards, the first Opium War marked the beginning of the end for the British India Society. Quaker committee members, especially those like William Allen who were involved with the Peace Society, were vociferous in their denunciations of the British government's engagement in the conflict, and of the East India Company interests it advanced. However, its wide reach meant that the BIS incorporated many others who were either directly involved in poppy production, like the Calcutta Landholders Association, or simply keen to open up trade with China. In their eyes, Britain's aggression promised new opportunities. For the BIS, more than principle was at stake. The Calcutta Landholders Association had authorised its London agent, BIS committee member John Crawfurd, to donate £500 to the British India Society. This, Crawfurd declared, he would withhold unless Thompson's public criticisms ended. Only one other committee member strongly supported Crawfurd – Major-General John Briggs, who had interests in the tea trade – but the withdrawal of the Landholders’ donation was sufficient to bring the Society's independent operation to a halt.Footnote 74
Less than eighteen months after they had abandoned the APS on the grounds of its diffuse humanitarianism, this crisis once again focused the minds of those central to the BIS – Thompson, the Peases and William Adam – on the best way to secure “justice to India”. As the Society teetered, the commercial priorities of their new partners apparently irreconcilable with humanitarian principles, the possibility of more explicitly harnessing abolitionist power arose again.
The Sturgite abolitionists, rebranded in 1839 as the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society (BFASS), had taken up the question of slavery in India early in 1840. Shortly afterwards, overtures were made to the BIS about union between the two societies. The abolitionists’ seriousness about India was underlined by the proceedings of the inaugural World Anti-Slavery Conference in June 1840. A number of delegates, including Daniel O'Connell, urged action against Indian slavery; William Adam delivered a long paper on the subject, subsequently published by the BFASS;Footnote 75 and the Convention passed eight resolutions condemning slavery.Footnote 76
However, while George Thompson responded positively to the idea of union with the BFASS, Joseph Pease urged caution. This change of heart, from the man who had worked so hard to engage high-profile abolitionists in the Indian cause requires careful explanation. It reflected the constantly evolving tensions between ‘provincial’ and ‘metropolitan’ abolitionists, and reveals that these ostensibly geographical markers were not straightforward. Although the BFASS was still dominated by Joseph Sturge – an even more vociferous critic of metropolitan moderation than Joseph or Elizabeth PeaseFootnote 77 – with the loss of “Birmingham” from its title, the society's centre of gravity had shifted to London. Scepticism about Londoners’ intimacy with power, about their reluctance to fully embrace women activists and about their lack of radicalism, infused the letters of particularly Elizabeth Pease at this time, and was directed at both the BFASS and the APS.Footnote 78 That Thomas Clarkson, who opened the World Anti-Slavery Convention's proceedings, was persuaded to drop India from his remarks,Footnote 79 while the Sturgites’ barred female delegates from the United States from taking their places at the meeting, confirmed the Peases against union. Both, evidently, saw their own provincial status (despite the BIS's metropolitan base, and their own extended visits to London) as purifying. Countering Thompson's enthusiasm for a merger, Joseph Pease argued that the “new and vigorous supporters” needed by the Indian cause were more likely to be found among Manchester's free traders, several of whom had already declared themselves “friends of India”. Father and daughter visited Manchester in the spring of 1840, ahead of the formation of “a Provincial British India Society” on 29 May.Footnote 80
By the time of the BIS's first annual meeting on 6 July (held in London and attended by the American anti-slavery delegates), a generous donation had ensured the Society's revival, the appointment of William Adam as secretary and endorsement of the provincial society's resolutions.Footnote 81 The Peases attended a public meeting in Manchester on 26 August at which the Northern Central British India Society was formed to work with the BIS.Footnote 82 With financial collapse averted, Thompson's services as lecturer could be retained. He spent much of the second half of 1840 lecturing (in Lancashire, Oldham, Rochdale and Salford), encouraging auxiliary Indian societies and preparing, with Elizabeth Pease's help, the first number of the British Indian Advocate, which appeared on 1 January 1841. From this time, the Peases became ever more intimately engaged with the Anti-Corn Law League (ACLL), deploying their considerable lobbying skills on its behalf.Footnote 83
Thompson had viewed union with the abolitionists favourably, but he too had firm links with Manchester. And, several other prominent BIS committee members, including John Bowring and John Briggs, were also ardent critics of the Corn Laws. However, before long, and despite their apparently complementary aims, the BIS's choice of Manchester free trade over anti-slavery would require its adherents to choose between India and the ACLL. A few days before the 1841 general election, Elizabeth Pease recorded that the BIS had:
consented, at the urgent request of the Anti-Corn Law League, to allow [Thompson] to devote his energies to their cause during their present struggle against the unjust monopoly of the staff of life – & they agree in return, afterwards to throw the weight of their influence into our cause – thus we hope, mutual advantage will result from a temporary union . . .Footnote 84
For its part, the ACLL passed a resolution noting that the objectives of the BIS were “kindred to its own” and “inseparably connected with the establishment of free trade and the protection of the best interests of the British Empire”.Footnote 85 William Howitt, some years later, would recall the League making “a direct proposition” to the Society, asking that agitation on free trade with India be suspended until after the Corn Laws had been overthrown, although conclusive evidence determining the precise order of advances has not been found.Footnote 86 Bringing Thompson into the campaign marked the League's determination to broaden its support base among those associated with abolition and other reform movements, as well as with women. Two of Thompson's earliest ACLL engagements, for example, were a ‘tea party’ to which prominent anti-slavery activists were invited in June 1841, and a speech at a conference of nearly 700 ministers of religion in August 1841.Footnote 87 Mehrota argues persuasively that by agreeing to share Thompson's services with the League, the British India Society dissipated both its landed support and its not inconsiderable momentum.Footnote 88
Free trade did absorb much of Thompson's energies through to mid-1842, but his involvement with the ACLL was not without frustrations. As Simon Morgan has demonstrated, the League's decision to prioritise its links with Southern sectional interests over those with American free trade abolitionists meant that from the spring of 1842, it dropped the argument that free trade in corn would undermine slavery in the southern United States.Footnote 89 Upset by this, Thompson left Britain to visit India in November.Footnote 90 By late 1842, the British India Society was in abeyance.
Interest in Indian slavery, however, promoted by the BFASS and taken up by American abolitionists, remained robust. In 1843, Joseph Pease's campaign to persuade the East India Company to outlaw slavery was finally successful, although the effect of the legislation was limited, and reflected the Company's response to public opinion as much as the efforts of the British India Society. Thompson also remained a focus for metropolitan calls for wider Indian reform. He took up a lucrative appointment as the representative of the former maharajah of Satara, making an eight-hour speech at India House on his behalf.Footnote 91 Thompson came to know the manufacturer and indigo planter Dwarkanath Tagore well, and continued to correspond with Anglo-Indian mercantile interests and Indian reformers in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras. It was Tagore who had invited Thompson to travel to India in 1842.Footnote 92 On his return, Thompson continued to advocate the Sataran cause and was briefly the representative of the Mughal Emperor, who he had met in India. Sataran money helped to secure Thompson the parliamentary seat of Tower Hamlets in 1847, and he continued to make speeches and publish pamphlets advocating free trade with the subcontinent and government reform.Footnote 93
The brief life of the British India Society illuminates the complex intersections, but also the cleavages, within British humanitarian and moral reform circles. The BIS's initial separation from the APS in 1839, its dalliances with the BFASS early in 1840 and its terminal agreement with the Anti-Corn Law League the following year, all indicate the interpenetration of reformist movements in early Victorian Britain. All emerged in the wake of the anti-apprenticeship campaign and this study also underlines that while the desire to harness the power and reach of abolition was strong, moral reformers were anxious about the polluting effect of metropolitan London society, and sometimes struggled to reconcile humanitarian ideals with free trading imperatives.
The APS without India: Demarcating Humanitarian Responsibilities
In 1839, the APS declared the split with the British India Society a judicious division for an already over-committed organisation. It wished the new society well, seeing “the labours of the two Societies as kindred exertions” and predicting “a reciprocity of sympathy and assistance”.Footnote 94 Privately, Thomas Hodgkin was pleased to be rid of Thompson's services, but he worried, rightly, about the yet greater competition the APS faced for public attention and financial support, especially given the emergence of the new anti-slavery society as well as the BIS. A trusted confidant was told that the separation “had been productive of weakness”.Footnote 95
In this way, India's inhabitants were as quickly excluded from the purview of the APS as they had been incorporated only a year earlier. However, this tightening of the Society's scope warrants closer attention. While the APS largely ignored India through the 1840s (both during and after the BIS's period of operation), in the years immediately preceding the revolts of 1857–58, India was subject to renewed APS attention. Confusion over the Society's remit reveals that it continued to be difficult to fit Indians into definitions of ‘aborigines’ more suited to ‘tribal’ societies, and that the APS was hampered both by the nature of their information networks in the subcontinent and by the unsettling impact of greater numbers of educated wealthy Indians in London. But flexibility about whom, exactly, the APS represented also illuminates humanitarian organisations’ strategies and the competition between them, as well as the ways in which Britons rationalised their moral and commercial priorities.
Only occasionally did APS attention turn formally to India in the 1840s. The 1846 Annual Report recorded that, given their “prodigious multitude” and intrinsic interest, Asia's “native tribes” had not received due attention from the Society. Some Asians, commented the Report, were “possessed of intelligence and resources to enable them to take care of themselves”. However, although the East India Company had attempted to rule those deemed less capable with “impartial justice”, abuses persisted. Judging from the sources cited, Francis Carnac Brown, the Indian-born owner of a Malabar estate, probably inspired these reflections. Critical of Company rule in the Madras Presidency, Brown moved to Britain in the late 1830s to publicise his claims, becoming a friend of George Thompson and joint secretary of the BIS. The same APS report recorded the work of a German missionary who had addressed the previous year's annual meeting before returning to the Nilgherry Hills to educate what was “supposed the oldest race in India”. Major-General John Briggs, a founding member of the BIS, who had left the society over the opium question, was likewise commended for his study of India's “primaeval people”.Footnote 96
The form of this minimalistic engagement with the subcontinent – the emphasis on the vulnerability of certain, more “primitive”, groups of Indians and the Company's failure to protect them – chimed with contemporary APS debates over ‘aboriginality’. Focusing on the uncivilised, even while protesting their potential, enabled the APS to set aside the questions of politics and international political economy raised by the British India Society. Apolitical Christian benevolence informed by scholarship, rather than radicalism, was encouraged.
In a decade when he became a founding member of the Ethnological Society of London, Thomas Hodgkin certainly seemed to see South Asia mainly as a field for scientific, and particularly ethnological, endeavours. His concern was to map (and connect) different peoples and, where they were threatened, to protect – or preserve – their cultures and languages. Like other APS members, however, Hodgkin also enjoyed increasing first-hand contact with Indians. Those who made the biggest splash were typically emissaries from India's courts, but students, scientists and intellectuals also circulated in London's professional circles. As a member of the senate of the new University of London, of the British Association for the Advancement of Science and of the Royal Geographical Society, Hodgkin was well placed to encounter them.Footnote 97 Some of these educated and urbane men – proof, if it were needed, of APS claims about human potential for civilisation – attended APS annual meetings. The indigo planter (and friend of Thompson's) Dwarkanath Tagore was lauded for his “enlarged mind and liberal hand” when he attended the 1846 annual meeting. The previous year three of Tagore's wards became some of the earliest Indians to study formally in Britain; the APS now recognised their success in carrying off several gold and silver medals during their London University medical studies.Footnote 98 These encounters with India's social and intellectual elites were a world away from the ‘tribal’, ‘primitive’ peoples that the APS saw itself as protecting and representing. Given that Hodgkin, the crucial node in the APS's extensive network of global informants, possessed few correspondents based in India and received much less immediate knowledge of particular injustices in the subcontinent, the neglect of Indian issues is more readily explained.
In this changing remit there was more at work than simply APS confusion over the scope of the term ‘aborigines’. Collaboration and competition between humanitarian organisations was also significant, and – by the early 1850s – could rival the importance of debates over definitions. The APS claim that there were more than enough injustices in the world beyond India on which a society with its limited means should focus was undeniably true. During the early Victorian period, as self-government loomed for the settler colonies, the inclination and power of the imperial government to prevent indigenous dispossession and to restrain colonial violence were tested and, in the Society's view, found wanting. Events in Southern Africa, New Zealand and North America absorbed and appalled the APS, which described itself repeatedly as concerned with those “Native Tribes who had claims upon our sympathy”.Footnote 99 Humanitarians also debated the effectiveness of methods to tackle the slave trade at its source in West Africa, and the continuation of slavery in Latin America and the United States.
Equally, different societies were explicitly recognised as ‘owning’ different issues or locations: slavery was the realm of the BFASS; India of the BIS; the APS, of course, had ‘aborigines’. This meant, for example, that if the condition of indentured Indians in Mauritius and the Caribbean really was akin to a “new system of slavery”, agitation on their behalf was properly carried out by the BFASS, although the APS would report and comment approvingly (or otherwise) on their campaigns.
In fact, such elements of collaboration and demarcation were more complicated than this suggests. The British India Society had only a brief existence; most of the reforms it advocated – reforms that the APS acknowledged would have positive humanitarian consequences – remained distant dreams. And, while a narrowly focused APS might have been both more popular and more effective, the society's activities remained diffuse and involved lobbying on behalf of a wide range of indigenous peoples beyond the settler colonies. Despite the ostensible division of the imperial philanthropic field between different societies, humanitarian organisations always competed for donors and subscribers.
By the early 1850s, the consequences of this competition for the APS had become acute. Not only was British colonialism becoming more violent, and the imperial government less likely to intervene, but the British public were more evidently indifferent to the plight of Aborigines than ever before. The APS's finances were dire, meaning that the Colonial Intelligencer appeared months behind schedule and the paid secretary had to be let go. Hodgkin's frustration with metropolitan disregard for indigenous peoples in the settler colonies became acute. He described the war against the Xhosa in the eastern Cape Colony as “disgraceful”, “unjust lamentable”, especially, as he wrote to David Livingstone, because the British public was “little informed on the subject” and simply wished “the Caffres destroyed with the least expense”.Footnote 100 His distress was heightened by what he saw as the “lively but useless compassion” for American slaves stirred up in Britain by Uncle Tom's Cabin. Slaves in the United States, asserted Hodgkin, were “beyond the reach of our assistance in a foreign land”.Footnote 101
This reference to “a foreign land” seems odd for a humanitarian genuinely committed to universalism, and the rights of all humans, whoever and wherever they were. In the same outburst, published as an “Address in Support of the Cause” in the Aborigine's Friend in 1853–54, Hodgkin argued that focusing on the “inhumanity of other countries” distracted Britons from “the efforts . . . we should make for the correction of our own national sins, which might enable us to enforce the injunctions of Christianity by the persuasive influence of example”.Footnote 102 For Hodgkin, the crisis within and on the borders of empire – in Southern Africa especially – led him to downplay the importance of the fight against American slavery; just as in the 1830s, he and Robert Montgomery Martin had tried to remind the public of their duty to all Britain's subjects, not simply to slaves in the Caribbean.
Hodgkin's public outburst worried his fellow committee members, who sensed that he would merely alienate the Society's dwindling supporter base. He was asked to clarify his stance in print, but when Hodgkin repeated his criticisms, the committee published its own renunciation in the Colonial Intelligencer. This reiterated the Society's monogenist, universal foundations:
We must not allow our labours to be contracted by any limitation of tribe or nation. The principle on which our Society is conducted – that God has made of one blood all nations of the earth, would effectually shut out the operation of any such limit . . . whilst oppression exists, we must labour for the oppressed, without regard to the question of to what nation the enslaved or the enslaver may belong.
In fact, this assertion of universalism was qualified. The committee recognised commonalities of ‘race’ between American settlers and Britons: these entailed “affinities of institution, of habit, and of language, which afford facilities for greater intercourse, and where public opinion is more readily influenced”. Thus, the APS felt “directly called upon to support, by . . . sympathy and encouragement, the courageous band of American abolitionists”. So, while Hodgkin demanded due attention be paid to Aborigines in the settler colonies, his fellow committee members were more pragmatic, sensitive to public interest and sympathies. Britons were “directly responsible” for wrongs committed against Aborigines in British colonies, but they were also, “without doubt . . . indirectly implicated in the crime of American slavery”, given British reliance on slave-grown US produce. This, of course, was George Thompson's argument from 1839. The rebuke to Hodgkin complete, the Committee reiterated that institutional advocacy on behalf of the enslaved would be left to the Anti-Slavery Society. Its own efforts would be confined to “those races of free Aborigines” who the abolitionists did not protect, “because they are free”.Footnote 103
This articulation of the Aborigines’ Protection Society's wide purview and the allusion to slave-grown produce were designed to reassure existing supporters and shore up the Society's appeal. It worked, as, by May 1854, new donations and reduced expenditure had entirely relieved the Society's previously crippling debt. Frederick Chesson was appointed as the new assistant secretary. Twenty years old, a radical abolitionist and Morning Star journalist, Chesson was already the firm friend of George Thompson and in 1855 would become his son-in-law. Hodgkin remained honorary secretary, but was recast as an ‘elder statesman’ and – in comparison with the earlier period – sidelined.
In this new era, the APS returned to advocacy on behalf of Indians. Although the defence of American slaves ‘belonged’ to the BFASS, others in the news lacked humanitarian champions. The requirement that the East India Company's Charter be renewed in 1853 had prompted a wave of pamphlets written by disaffected Indians, former Company officials and metropolitan free traders. All addressed the British public and politicians on the problems and benefits of Company rule.Footnote 104 Thompson had lost his parliamentary seat in 1852, but a few radical and liberal MPs coalesced to become the “friends of India” and then the Indian Reform Society.Footnote 105 These reformers were linked to the Aborigines Protection Society by multiple direct, if loose, religious and organisational connections. Chesson's connections to radical critics of the East India Company's rule of India, such as the disaffected former judge Malcolm Lewin, and old India hand General Thomas Perronet Thompson, particularly helped to steer the Society's attention back to the subcontinent.Footnote 106 By 1854, the government of India had become a subject of public discussion, and thus a means for the APS to raise its profile.
After almost no coverage of Indian affairs for fifteen years, more than 20 percent of the Colonial Intelligencer was devoted to South Asia over the next three. None of this coverage represented stories broken by the APS; much consisted simply of reprinted reports from government, newspapers, or well-known critics of the Company, including Lewin and Richard Cobden.Footnote 107 In contrast with the Society's earlier activism on India, no special emphasis was placed on ‘tribal Indians’.
Standing alone, the Society's interventions on India in the three years to 1857 are evocative of metropolitan attitudes but hardly worthy of sustained attention. The coverage in the Colonial Intelligencer fits neatly with contemporary metropolitan discussions of India before the mutiny, as outlined by Gautam Chakravarty and other work on ‘imperial journalism’.Footnote 108 Most attention was paid to the Santal rebellion, the Madras Torture Commission, the opium trade and the annexations of Burma, Awadh and Satara.Footnote 109 Like some other metropolitan critics, the APS predicted that violent resistance against colonial rule in India could not be far distant, given the lack of representation, the iniquitous tax system and the arrogance of India's British rulers.Footnote 110 Despite simultaneous concern about the impact of British colonialism in South Africa, Borneo and West Africa – all more typical subjects of APS activity – the strong Indian interest among the APS committee and India's topicality led to Indian misgovernment becoming the main theme of the Society's March 1857 Address to Britain's electors.Footnote 111 When news of the Mutiny broke in London in the summer, the APS collaborated with other organisations, including the Peace Society, to publicise the provocation faced by Britain's Indian subjects and to protest vigorously against the violent British response. As General Perronet Thompson put it, the British public should consider Indians as fighters against imperial oppression, rather than simply mutineers.Footnote 112
Conclusions
While the full story of the APS and the Indian Mutiny must wait for another occasion, this article has demonstrated both the extraordinary aspirations of the APS and the profound limitations on its activity. It has shown how the flexibility and mutability of the Society's remit was a double-edged sword, allowing room for manoeuvre but also serving to dissipate momentum and confuse even its own supporters. The story of the APS's engagement, disengagement and re-engagement with India and its colonised peoples demonstrates that the Society's definition of ‘Aborigines’, as well as humanitarian lobbying on imperial subjects in general, was affected by pragmatic, political and personal concerns and by changing religious, ethnological or imperial boundaries. Further, this analysis suggests that we must keep looking beyond the bounds of any particular colony or type of colony, and indeed beyond the empire, if we are to understand the universal aspirations of imperial critics in this period – and how those aspirations were curtailed. As demonstrated in the proceedings of the British India Society, the flexibility of the language deployed by humanitarians, moral radicals and liberals alike also deserves attention. At a superficial level, this language held out the promise of a peaceful, prosperous and honourable future, not only for Britain, but also for British subjects across the empire and people throughout the world. Free trade and free labour would come together for the benefit of all humanity, imbuing political economy with a strong moral force. But, as exemplified by the APS's dithering, and Thomas Hodgkin's lonely attempt to force the plight of indigenous peoples in Britain's settler societies onto the national agenda, it was easier to match metropolitan self-interest with the elevation of some groups – British or American slaves and South Asians, for example – than others. Moreover, and despite practical and philosophical collaborations, competition between societies reveals an underlying anxiety about the impact of finite resources – in terms of supporters’ attention as well as donations – on humanitarian efforts. Finally, while the APS represented a tiny minority of Britons, its reach and status was far greater than its modest financial power suggests, while its persistent (if sometimes confused) articulation of a language of “equal justice, equal rights, . . . equal education, and equal humanity” reminds us that such a position was possible in the dark days of the mid-nineteenth century empire.
