Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:26:17.716Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Granular flow on a rotating and gravitating elliptical body

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 April 2021

Kumar Gaurav*
Affiliation:
Mechanics & Applied Mathematics Group, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, IndiaDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
Deepayan Banik
Affiliation:
Mechanics & Applied Mathematics Group, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, IndiaDepartment of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
Ishan Sharma
Affiliation:
Mechanics & Applied Mathematics Group, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, IndiaDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
Pravir Dutt
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
*
†Email address for correspondence: kugaurav@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

We investigate two-dimensional shallow granular flows on a rotating and gravitating elliptical body. This is motivated by regolith flow on small planetary bodies – also called minor planets – which is influenced by the rotation of the body, as well as its irregular topography and complex gravity field. Governing equations are obtained in an elliptic coordinate system attached to the body by extending the framework employed for terrestrial avalanches to incorporate effects of rotation, varying gravity and a curvilinear surface. Additionally, we introduce criteria to monitor grain shedding and to track flow initiation and cessation. We delineate different types of regolith motion that are governed by the rotation rate and surface roughness of the body. We find that grains migrate towards the minor and major axis of the body at low and high rotation rates, respectively. Grains are shed when the basal pressure vanishes, and shedding is encouraged by Coriolis effects during prograde flow. We observe the coexistence of regions of static and mobile regolith and their reorganization owing to the merging or division of flows. We also probe the formation and destruction of dunes – bulges arising from local grain accumulation – and find several aspects of their motion to be different from terrestrial situations. We then perform discrete element simulations that display a good match with theoretical predictions. Finally, we consider the evolution of a bi-disperse regolith. We find that big and small grains occupy, respectively, the top and bottom of the dunes formed on the surface, which is reminiscent of observations on asteroids like Itokawa.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Image of asteroid 25143 Itokawa, obtained by the Japanese Space Exploration Agency (JAXA) spacecraft Hayabusa 1 in 2005. Distinct regions of small and large grains are observed in the image on either side of the white line. Source: JAXA Digital Archives.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic of our system consisting of an elliptical central body with a layer of regolith of depth $H$. Also shown are the elliptic coordinates $\mu$ and $\nu$, the rotation rate $\varOmega$ of the central body, the Cartesian coordinates $x$ and $y$, the linear eccentricity $a$, and the semi-major axes of length $a_1$ and $a_2$. We also indicate the flow directions normal $(u_1)$ and tangential $(u_2)$ to the surface. See § 2.3 for details.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Elliptic coordinate system where curves of constant $\mu$ (red) and $\nu$ (green) form confocal ellipses and confocal hyperbolae, respectively. The ellipse corresponding to $\mu = 0.4$ is highlighted for future reference.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Variation with the non-dimensional rotation rate $\omega$ of the scaled effective normal gravity $b_1$ at the ends of the major ($\nu =0 \ \mbox {and} \ {\rm \pi}$, blue curve) and minor ($\nu ={\rm \pi} /2 \ \mbox {and} \ 3{\rm \pi} /2$, orange curve) axes of an elliptical body with $\mu _E=0.4$$(e \approx 0.93, \gamma \approx 0.38)$. Here, $b_1$ vanishes first at $\omega _{sh}= 1.06$. (b) The shedding landscape for stationary regolith on an elliptical body in its shape ($\gamma$)–rotation ($\omega$) parameter space. The total area of the ellipse is kept constant as $\gamma$ is changed.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a) Variation with the non-dimensional rotation rate $\omega$ of the scaled effective tangential gravity $b_2$ for an elliptical central body with $\mu _E=0.4$$(e \approx 0.93, \gamma \approx 0.38)$. Several angular locations $\nu$ are considered and these are indicated next to their associated curves. (b) The migration landscape on a smooth ($\delta = 0^{\circ }$) elliptical body in its shape ($\gamma$)–rotation rate ($\omega$) parameter space. The total area of the ellipse is kept constant as $\gamma$ is changed.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Variation of the critical angle $\nu _c$ with axes ratio $\gamma$ for different choices of basal friction angle $\delta$ that are indicated next to their associated curves. The solid ($\nu _c^+$) and dashed ($\nu _c^-$) curves correspond, respectively, to the upper ($\omega ^+$) and lower ($\omega ^-$) bounds of the range of rotation rates within which stationary regolith can persist everywhere on the surface of the central body; see main text for details.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Continued from figure 5(b). (a) Different types of behaviour of surface regolith for an elliptical central body with $\mu _E=0.4$ and basal friction angle $\delta =20^{\circ }$. Zones $A$, $B$ and $C$, make up region ${\mathrm I}$ in figure 5(b). (b) Variation of the lower (dashed) and upper (solid) boundaries of zone $B$ in (a) for different basal friction angles $\delta$ that are indicated next to their associated curves.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Variation of lift-off velocities $u_l^+$ (positive) and $u_l^-$ (negative) along the surface of an elliptical body with $\mu _E = 0.4$ for different non-dimensional rotation rates $0 \leqslant \omega \leqslant \omega _{sh} = 1.06$, as indicated next to their associated curves. Positive and negative velocities correspond to, respectively, prograde and retrograde surface motions. Only the extent from $\nu =0$ to $\nu ={\rm \pi}$ is shown because of symmetry about the major axis. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity .

Figure 8

Figure 9.The different regimes of regolith behaviour as regulated by the rotation rate $\omega$ of the central body; see also figures 4, 5 and 7. The rate $\omega ^{{\scriptsize {minor}}}_{sh}$ is the rotation rate at which regolith sheds from the minor axis, and corresponds to the the orange line in figure 4(b).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Final deposits (solid lines) of an initially uniform layer of nearly frictionless grains are plotted alongside the corresponding equal area equipotential curves (dashed lines) for $\omega =0.34$ (pre-critical regime) and $\omega =0.76$ (post-critical regime). A body with $\mu _E = 0.4$ has $\omega _{th} \approx 0.7$. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.(a) Time evolution of the regolith in the pre-critical regime on an elliptical central body ($\mu _E = 0.4$) rotating at the non-dimensional rate $\omega =0.34$ for friction angle $\delta =4^{\circ }$. Snapshots at several non-dimensional time instants are shown, which are indicated next to their associated curves. (b) Final deposits in the same system as in (a), but for regoliths with different choices of $\delta$, which are noted along their corresponding curves. The equipotential curve encompassing the same area as the initial deposit is also shown. In both (a,b) the initial deposit is a uniform layer of grains. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.(a) Time evolution of the regolith in the post-critical regime on an elliptical central body ($\mu _E = 0.4$) rotating at the non-dimensional rate $\omega =0.99$ for friction angle $\delta =30^{\circ }$. Snapshots at several non-dimensional time instants are shown, which are indicated next to their associated curves. (b) Final deposits in the same system as in (a), but for different choices of rotation rates $\omega$ that are noted along their corresponding curves. In both (a,b) the initial deposit is a uniform layer of grains. Only the region close to the $\nu = {\rm \pi}$ end of the major axis is shown, as the regolith elsewhere remains immobilized. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Variation of (a) the percentage of mass shed and (b) the maximum non-dimensional height $H_{max}$ of the dune formed at the major axis with non-dimensional rotation rate $\omega$ for an elliptical central body ($\mu _E = 0.4$). Several different friction angles $\delta$ are considered and these are indicated next to their associated curves.

Figure 13

Figure 14.(a) Stages during the breaking of a dune with non-dimensional time that is indicated next to its associated curve. The dune is located initially at the major axis ($\nu = {\rm \pi}$) of an elliptical central body ($\mu _E = 0.4$) rotating at $\omega =0.34$, which lies in the pre-critical regime. The regolith has a basal friction angle $\delta = 8^{\circ }$. Acceleration and deceleration zones are also indicated. (b) Final deposits following the breaking of a dune composed of regoliths with different friction angles $\delta$ that are noted along their corresponding curves. The initial dune and other system parameters are as in (a). The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Stages during the evolution of a dune on an elliptical central body ($\mu _E = 0.4$) with non-dimensional time indicated next to its associated curve. (a) The dune was located initially at the major axis ($\nu = {\rm \pi}$) of the body rotating at $\omega =1.05$, close to the shedding rotation rate $\omega _{sh} = 1.06$. The regolith has a basal frictional angle $\delta =30^{\circ }$. (b) The dune was located initially at the minor axis ($\nu = {\rm \pi}/2$) of the body rotating at $\omega =0.87$. The regolith is described by the low friction angle $\delta = 2^{\circ }$. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Final deposits following the break up of dunes located initially at $\nu ={\rm \pi} /4$ (solid lines) and $\nu =3{\rm \pi} /4$ (dashed lines) on the elliptical central body rotating ($\mu _E = 0.4$) at $\omega =1.0$. Several friction angles are investigated as indicated next to their associated curves. The red arrow is in the direction of surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Evolution of a dune initially at $\nu =3{\rm \pi} /4$ and composed of regolith having $\delta = 6^{\circ }$ in the (a) pre-critical regime when $\omega =0.34$ and (b) post- critical regime when $\omega =0.8$. Both acceleration (A) and deceleration (D) zones are shown. Lighter shading indicates greater deceleration magnitude. The red arrow is in the direction of the surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 17

Figure 18.(a) Percentage of mass shed as a function of the scaled rotation rate $\omega$ for different initial locations of the dune that are indicated next to their associated curves. The basal friction angle $\delta = 20^{\circ }$ of the regolith. (b) Time evolution of the regolith following the break up of a dune located at $\nu ={\rm \pi} /4$ on a body rotating at $\omega =1.08>\omega _{sh}$. Several time steps are shown as noted along their corresponding curves. The regolith has a friction angle $\phi = 30^\circ$. For both (a,b), the elliptical central body is defined by $\mu _E = 0.4$. The red arrow is in the direction of surface velocity $\boldsymbol {\omega }\times \boldsymbol {r}$.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Time evolution of an inversely graded regolith consisting of small (black) and big (grey) grains with time $t$ in the pre-critical regime with $\delta =\phi =4^{\circ }$ and $\omega =0.34$.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Time evolution of an inversely graded regolith consisting of small (black) and big (grey) grains with time $t$ in the pre-critical regime with $\delta =\phi =30^{\circ }$ and $\omega =1.0$.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Snapshots in a co-rotating frame of DE simulations showing half of the elliptical central body (pink curve) and the regolith layer (yellow) composed of grains with a diameter of 1 m. Three different rotation rates $\omega$ are investigated whose directions are as indicated. (a) Uniform layer of grains at time $t = 0$ of depth 4 m. (b) Steady-state deposit in the pre-critical regime with $\omega = 0.32$. (c) Steady-state deposit in the post-critical regime with $\omega = 0.75$. (d) Mass shedding from the prograde side when $\omega = 1.0$. The prograde (P) and retrograde (R) regions, and the direction of the Coriolis acceleration (green arrows) are indicated. The white arrows indicate direction of grain motion. The simulation details are provided in table 1. The central body and the flow are scaled differently for better flow visualization.

Figure 21

Table 1.Details of our discrete element method (DEM) simulations.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Final deposit obtained from theory (solid curve) and DE simulations (dotted curve). (a) Pre-critical regime with friction angles $\delta =\phi =4^{\circ }$ and scaled rotation rate $\omega =0.32$. (b) Post-critical regime with $\delta =\phi =4^{\circ }$ and scaled rotation rate $\omega =0.75$. (c) Post-critical regime with $\delta =\phi =25^{\circ }$ and scaled rotation rate $\omega =1.0$ showing mass shedding. The prograde (P) and retrograde (R) regions are indicated.