Women's Romantic Theatre and Drama is an expansive and satisfying collection of fourteen essays by Italian, British, and North American scholars that both revisits established scholarly territory and forges new, productive inroads into Romantic drama and theatre. In this volume, those female theatre artists who occupy central positions in the current discourse (Joanna Baillie, Elizabeth Inchbald, Sarah Siddons) share the page with lesser-known or underresearched women working in the theatre; time-honored approaches and topics for historians and literary scholars of Romantic drama are relaunched in service of innovative inquiries. Though the essays in this collection lean more heavily toward text-based analyses than the book's balanced title indicates, editors Crisafulli and Elam have assembled a diverse group of scholars and scholarly projects that confirms just how fertile the field of Romantic drama and theatre remains.
The book's first part, “Historical Drama and Romantic Historiography,” highlights female Romantic playwrights’ penchant for interrogating contemporary sociopolitical structures and gender roles through the use of the recently “rediscovered genre” of historical drama (13). In Chapter 1, Greg Kucich asserts that the feminized, affective histories of the period (employing pathos, tableaux vivants, and centralized female figures) represented women and their struggles as essential threads running through “the social fabric of the past,” and through them “explored the dramaturgical possibilities for enacting this precise linkage” (28, 31). In Chapter 2, Crisafulli locates within women's historical dramas moments of female agency, despite marginalization and constant monitoring by a vigilant patriarchy; moreover, Crisafulli sees the act of historical playwriting itself as a crucial exercise in intellectual autonomy by which dramatists “disputed and renegotiated their place and their role within society through the world of drama” (52). Reconstructions of Anglo-Saxon history written by Hannah More and Ann Yearsley are the subject of Cecilia Pietropoli's essay in Chapter 3, in which she argues that the playwrights’ foregrounding of female characters regenders historical moments by bridging the often disconnected worlds of the political and the sentimental. Serena Baiesi, in Chapter 4, examines the frequent use of the historical siege in women's Romantic drama. As Baiesi argues, female dramatists complicated the standard dichotomy of aggressor and besieged (often differentiated by race or cultural practice) by including females on both sides who heroically prioritize the safety of their families over militaristic games. In Chapter 5, Gary Kelly traces Felicia Heman's writing career as an “exemplary European liberal voice” (85), a creator of feminized and politicized histories, and a skillful adaptor of Schillerian dramaturgy, concluding his chapter with a profitable comparison of Schiller's and Heman's dramatic forms. On occasion the essays of Part I dovetail too much, becoming repetitive in their assertions about the shared goals of female Romantic playwrights in ways that slow this part's momentum. Nevertheless, Part I is rich in substance and ably demonstrates the forging of new historiographies by women in the Romantic period.
And if the book's first part is remarkably unified in its themes, voices, and projects, its Part II, “Dramaturgical and Cultural Processes,” offers an enjoyable and diverse assortment of essays. In Chapter 6, Catherine Burroughs identifies examples of “domesticated eroticism” (106) in Joanna Baillie's The Bride and Frances Anne Kemble's An English Tragedy, in which “dramatic representations of incest can serve to express a longing to have one's sexual initiation—one's defloration—managed by the family compound” (106–7). Diego Saglia explores, in Chapter 7, the social and professional networks available to female Romantic writers as well as the relationship of those networks to wider male-dominated literary circles, attesting to “the existence of an intellectual, literary and dramatic community of women writers who provided each other with vigorous support, encouragement and sponsoring” (144). Elizabeth Inchbald is the focus of back-to-back chapters by Franca Dellarosa and Vita M. Mastrosilvestri: in Chapter 8, Dellarosa analyzes Inchbald's efforts as dramatic critic—noting that she measures the worthiness of a play not just on its literary merit, but on its theatrical efficacy—and compares her to Baillie, whose own discussion of the drama focuses on the “modality of reception” and implies that the act of reading permits a more intense engagement with the play than can the act of viewing (156). Mastrosilvestri attends, in Chapter 9, to the playwright's translations of foreign plays, arguing that Inchbald's intimate knowledge of the London theatregoing public prompted her Anglicization of Continental characters, situations, and themes. In Chapter 10, Gioia Angeletti asserts that Scottish women playwrights were doubly marginalized—by both their gender and their nationality—and consequently developed strategies to reduce their otherness without compromising their artistic goals, including cultivating submissive professional voices, employing performative mechanisms to obscure strong social critiques, and adopting masculinized pen names and attitudes. Part II thus boasts a persuasive set of studies in Romantic dramaturgy, with Burroughs's and Saglia's fascinating and immensely readable essays emerging as standouts.
Jane Moody's Chapter 11 essay on the multiple (and often collaborative) means of censoring Jacobin theatre begins Part III, “Women Staging, Women Staged,” a succinct but meaty compilation of studies. By comparing different printings of politically radical plays by Inchbald and her contemporary Thomas Holcroft, Moody identifies revisions and omissions that were prompted not just by official censors, but by performers, audiences, critics, and the playwrights themselves, offering “a new appreciation of Inchbald's watchfulness and her subtle art of political calculation” (211). Joanna Baillie's dramatic meditations on science and religion are the focus of Isabella Imperioli's contribution in Chapter 12; in particular, the author examines Baillie's attempts to dramatize the psyche's emotional and spiritual turmoil and morally to instruct and enlighten audiences. Using portraits of famed actress Sarah Siddons as a focal point, Claudia Corti discusses in Chapter 13 the theatrical portrait's popularity in the Romantic period, its unique place at the aesthetic intersection of British theatre, poetry, and painting, and its performative potential as an idealized representation of the actor's pictorial art. Finally, Stefania Magnoni's lively Chapter 14 essay sketches the early-nineteenth-century antitheatrical bias against Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, and presents Elizabeth Vestris's successful 1840 staging of the play as the first to prove the fantastical comedy was not meant just for the closet.
While the book's first two parts make attempts (some successful, some less so) to consider feminist historiographies, playwriting, and other cultural practices as crucially performative, it is in “Women Staging, Women Staged” that the notion of performativity truly comes to life, via the expressive instability of Baillie's characters, the iconographic, pictorial representations of Siddons's art, and Vestris's recognition of the fundamental performability of A Midsummer Night's Dream. Impressive in its variety and readability, Women's Romantic Theatre and Drama is a welcome contribution to the growing body of scholarship on female cultural expression in the Romantic period.
