In his new book What Money Can't Buy Harvard philosopher Michael Sandel sets out the case for a rethink of the role of markets in contemporary societies. Sandel accepts that ‘No other mechanism for organizing the production and distribution of goods [has] proved as successful at generating affluence and prosperity’ as markets (p. 5). But he argues it is nevertheless necessary to keep markets in their place and this has increasingly ceased to be the case, particularly in the United States and Britain where recent decades have seen an unprecedented expansion in the role of markets. Sandel's book is full of examples of what he considers to be the encroachment of markets, or market values, into areas of life previously untouched by markets, such as ticket touts selling seats for Papal Mass, school children receiving cash incentives for achieving good grades and the naming of sports stadia after commercial sponsors.
Sandel believes that the spread of markets should be resisted for two principal reasons. First, because markets respond to purchasing power, rather than any deliberate assessment of need and those with less ability to pay will not have their needs met as effectively as those with greater financial resources. If healthcare is provided via the market, for example, the rich will be able to pay for superior treatment compared to that received by the poor. Second, it is argued that unchecked markets are corrosive of the cultural and moral fabric: ‘markets reflect and promote certain norms, certain ways of valuing the goods they exchange’ (p. 78), and these norms should be limited to the properly commercial sphere. Monetary incentives for good grades may help school children improve their test results, for example, but such rewards will ultimately undermine the appropriate ways of valuing learning and education.
These concerns about the social and cultural impact of markets are not new, but have been discussed and debated since at least the advent of modern commercial societies in the eighteenth century. Sandel's contribution principally lies in setting these arguments in a contemporary context, rather than in providing new theoretical or philosophical insights.
There a number of problems, however, with Sandel's empirical analysis. He describes contemporary Britain and America as societies in which markets have been allowed to run rampant, even referring at one point to ‘the market mania of the age’ (p. 164). But it is hard to square this account with a reality in which governments routinely spend between a third and a half of GDP, a large proportion of the population receive their income from the state either as public employees or welfare recipients and the state actively prohibits many activities, such as the sale of recreational drugs, smoking in enclosed public places and even the ownership of a television without a licence. There is a danger that Sandel's account obscures the fact that for all the pro-market rhetoric of recent decades the state remains the most significant single player in economic and social life.
A deeper empirical problem concerns the distinction between markets and politics. Sandel assumes that there is a clear choice between market and non-market or political provision of a good or service. In reality, as figures as diverse as F. A. Hayek and Karl Polanyi have pointed out, all markets exist in a social, political and legal context which determines the rules, conventions and norms within which markets operate. In order for a good or service to be bought and sold there must be a prior process in which a property right in that good or service and a medium of exchange acceptable to both parties are established. Both parties must also either trust one another to honour their contact and/or be satisfied that an adequate legal process exists to settle any dispute. This is all some distance from the portrayal of disencumbered and disembodied markets found in Sandel's book.
Sandel's failure to properly situate markets in their social, political and legal context probably accounts for the fact that many of his empirical examples seem to rely on false dichotomies between markets and politics. A whole chapter is devoted to the growth of markets that enable people to pay to queue jump, for example at theme parks, sporting events and in accessing private healthcare. But a dichotomy between markets and queues is surely false given that queues are ubiquitous to markets and to politics, being found in supermarkets, cafes, restaurants and department stores, as well as in polling stations and government offices. It is not clear that there has been a decline of queuing indicative of the spread of markets, rather than increasing differentiation within markets leading to more but, on the whole, shorter queues.
The alleged dichotomy between commercial practice and education and learning could similarly be challenged. Most academic monographs, textbooks and journals are published by commercial enterprises intent on generating profits, for example. Indeed, Sandel's book is itself published by a subsidiary of Pearson, the world's largest book publisher. If paying students to pass exams is corrosive of the values of learning and education, why is it not similarly corrosive to pay teachers, or, for that matter, to pay Harvard professors salaries that dwarf the wages of most workers?
The most interesting part of Sandel's book is the account of the use of economic incentives in the political realm set out in chapter 3. Here Sandel's provides an interesting discussion of experimental evidence that suggests that paying people to be good citizens reduces their willingness to act altruistically. The use of economic mechanisms to achieve deliberately chosen, political ends does seem to raise a series of interesting and difficult questions about politics and markets that take the analysis beyond the sometimes crude distinctions found in other parts of the book.
Sandel's book is clearly intended to appeal to both scholars and a more popular readership and this attempt to reach out beyond the academy is surely to be applauded. The book provides a reliable rehearsal of some long-standing debates set in a contemporary context, but ultimately it provides few answers while raising many questions about the complex relationship between politics and markets in contemporary liberal democracies.
