I share Gary King and Maya Sen's view that applying the knowledge, approaches, and tools of the social and policy sciences might help us be more intelligent about shaping the future of the American system of higher education and its component parts. I have even been surprised, in turning from the scholarly field of my training and academic field to a professional preoccupation with higher education, to search in vain for sessions at APSA meetings in which my fellow political scientists might focus their analytical eyes on our own sector and institutions. Taking more systematic analytical approaches might certainly be a good alternative to riding the most recent serious source of anxiety—and there have been many in recent decades—or mining a particular strand of data in search of indicators that might serve as tea leaves or life rafts, also known in the trade as “benchmarks.”
But taking this call seriously requires more groundwork in some critical fundamentals about American higher education: a more informative historical framework that helps to identify the longer and repetitive forces that shape the system and its component parts; more clarity about the higher education system as a system; and more recognition of the efforts at change and transformation that have been taking place over the last generation. None of this reduces the urgency of King and Sen's call to action, but it might help frame what directions to take.
Before we go further, however, there is a definitional issue. King and Sen's essay is titled to speak of “colleges and universities” and “the American system of higher education.” I say more about this in the following text, in probing the idea of the higher education system. Suffice it to say that, indeed, we would do best to encompass the higher education system into our analysis, including attention to the very different types of institutions that it comprises, as well as the relationships among them. Much of “The Troubled Future,” however, seems mostly to consider research universities, especially the leading ones, and perhaps the private research universities. Some of the critical pressures on and preoccupations of other institutions in the system are not present enough. Here I attempt to write, instead, of the higher education system, understood more comprehensively.
HISTORICAL AND INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION
No doubt, as Gary King and Maya Sen wrote, “The American system of higher education appears poised for disruptive change of potentially historic proportions because of massive new political, economic, and educational forces.” But this assertion, to be more accurate, requires an additional word: again. The American system of higher education appears poised for disruptive change of potentially historic proportions again. Or maybe the added word should be still. The American system of higher education still appears poised for disruptive change of potentially historic proportions.
Studying the major changes that have transformed higher education on a recurring basis over its history, and certainly for the past 70 years, provides critical background for understanding the nature and likely impacts of the current disruptive forces, and perhaps assists us to construct timely, creative, effective responses to those forces. Universities have not remained the same for decades or centuries, let alone millennia. This should not make us sanguine about the challenges we face, but it should help us be smarter and rational about how to move forward.
There are many sources to consult for basic histories of American higher education, but two are especially relevant for a political- and policy-science understanding: Jonathan Cole's The Great American University (Cole Reference Cole2010), on the rise and challenges of the major research universities, and Christopher Loss's Between Citizens and the State (Loss Reference Loss2012), on American higher education in the twentieth century. These works make clear that it is not accurate to imply that the higher education system has been relatively stable and unchanging, only now rocked by the major forces delineated in “The Troubled Future of Colleges and Universities.” Ignoring the many forces that have been rocking and turning the boat for decades will leave us unprepared for effective analysis for the future. As with other major sectors of society, including political systems, understanding the situation that faces colleges and universities today requires a theoretical and empirical grasp of the forces that shape longer-term patterns of transformation and continuity. Identifying current threatening developments is not enough.
Among the dramatic changes that have taken place in higher education since the end of World War II are the dramatic rise in the higher education sector, including the number of institutions, the proportion of the “college-aged” population enrolled, and the proportion of adults enrolled. These changes do not just reflect scalar differences; they are linked to many kinds of transformations in expectations about education, its impact, the nature of what these institutions should be offering students, and even how they will contain and house the students, faculty, and staff.
It is difficult to overestimate the significance of another aspect of the growth of the higher education sector: its diversification with first-generation men due to the GI Bill (which included diversification of the ethnic base of the white male college population), then with women, members of American ethnic and racial minorities, more first-generation students and students without great financial means, students with physical and cognitive disabilities, and international students in successive waves from different parts of the world. Even more than the growth and change driven by the GI Bill (Mettler Reference Mettler2007), the successive struggles and debates about welcoming and accommodating each of these groups—and, after they entered, their perspectives and demands—made substantive changes in educational institutions and the larger system. Many of these changes were supported by federal legislation such as the Higher Education Act of 1965 (including the Pell Grants) and the Education Amendments of 1972 (including Title IX on equal opportunity across gender). Each wave of inclusion threatened the university as it was and, as advocates and opponents suspected, left colleges and universities changed places. They changed the expectations and perspectives on education found in the broader population. These waves of new students ultimately took their place as faculty, education leaders, educated parents of college-aspiring students, and public and private leaders.
Jonathan Cole (Reference Cole2010) has documented the forces that gave rise to government-sponsored research and the research university. The turns toward science and technology, toward language study and study-abroad programs, all provoked by the Cold War, also transformed the university. So did the increasing professionalization of many disciplines and the increasing view that if a profession is worthy, it should require a bachelor's degree … and later, a master's degree … and finally, a doctorate. What some academics have termed “degree inflation” changed the profile and mission of American higher education. It, arguably, fueled the demand for continuing education and degree programs among adults seeking to upgrade their earnings potential. It also created a ready market for online courses that did not require people with family obligations and jobs to be hampered by geographic or time limitations in their quest for improvement.
King and Sen rightly emphasize the impact of economic forces, but we need to go much further in understanding the changes in the political economy of higher education. They write that, “The business model of most universities relies primarily on revenue from teaching, with some additional funds from sponsored research and philanthropy.” Here, as elsewhere in their article, we need more attention to important variations in the sources and dynamics of financial support for different kinds of institutions, and the different pressures they face with respect to shifts in budget models and funding. The “status quo” business model for public institutions once relied substantially on state funding, of course, and the story of the reduction in that funding, in particular for the public doctoral institutions, is crucial to understand. But also, the political, structural, and market forces, as well as the issue of philanthropy, work very differently for different types of institutions. Other forces that shape the cost structure of universities include the changing demands of students (the dorms of old simply won't do any more; we are seeing a turning of the tide in the attractiveness of revenue-producing masters programs), and the options for covering major costs such as energy and health insurance.
Understanding the business model of colleges and universities and their history also requires paying careful attention to their business—what they are in business to do and how that is related both to their chief priorities for expenditure and resource deployment—and the sources of funding they attempt to access, and why those sources of funding may be made more or less available. That is not the same across different kinds of colleges and universities; systematic differences bear investigation. This raises another major point for which social scientists have useful tools and perspectives to bring to bear: the higher education sector as a system.
THINKING SYSTEMATICALLY ABOUT THE HIGHER EDUCATION SYSTEM
Gary King and Maya Sen open their essay by making a (well-justified) statement about “the American system of higher education.” Here, I would like to underscore that attacking this problem well requires that we seriously analyze American higher education as a system. The nature, challenges, and opportunities of the institutions of that system are far more diverse than our stimulus article implies, and they are linked together in interesting and important ways. Some of the generalizations about these institutions that appear in King and Sen's article mask some of these points, and even the some of the “economic attacks” enumerated in the article must be understood as changes—and certainly challenges—within that system rather than attacks wholly from the outside.
The United States has developed one of the most diversified and complicated systems of higher education in the world, and that system is part of the reason for both the evident comparative successes of American higher education and its challenges. Any few-sentence brief history must be too potted to be useful other than to serve as a reminder that our higher education system is too heterogeneous to be investigated other than as an internally diverse system. From the founding of the original American universities that served white men of a small socioeconomic range to the Jeffersonian Enlightenment idea embedded in the founding of the University of Virginia; through the profound effects of the Morrill Act; the opening of the first community colleges at the turn into the twentieth century, we already see the development of a differentiated set of institutions over a century ago.
The early post-World War II era arguably initiated the really systematic diversification of institutional paths when the Presidential Commission on Higher Education (“The Truman Commission”) pushed the ideas of supported systems of higher education that would ensure greater access through subsidy in light of the returning veterans (including specific reference to the necessary end to racial, ethnic, and gender discrimination), expansion of two-year community colleges, and of continuing and adult education (The President's Commission on Higher Education for Democracy 1947). Thus was the access agenda, still so challenging today, and the subject of intense political pressure and public outrage, truly born and given institutional forms.
At the same time, as Jonathan Cole has pointed out, Vannevar Bush (Reference Bush1945) was pushing for the partnership of government and universities to advance science, an effort that blossomed with the creation of the National Science Foundation (NSF). The creation of the research university, stimulated and mightily assisted by government-sponsored research, primarily in the basic and applied natural sciences but also parts of the social sciences as well as the arts and humanities, had some effects on the higher education system that are probably not much noted. It likely drove a clearer wedge between two groups of private institutions notable for educating the academically talented members of the elite sectors of society (plus “legacies” for whom elite qualifications were primary), the research institutions (such as the Ivy League, Stanford, Chicago), and the highly ranked liberal arts colleges (such as Williams, Swarthmore, Amherst, and Haverford). For public institutions, it drove a clearer wedge between the “flagship” research institutions, such as the Committee on Institutional Cooperation (CIC) institutions and Berkeley, and the “comprehensive” publics that came to be bound in the same public systems, which also created sibling rivalry and political tension.
The differences and relationships created by the matrix of public and private; research, liberal arts, and comprehensive; and two-year, four-year, and four-plus year institutions must be taken into account to understand the political economy of higher education, even of discrete sectors of this system, and the political and technological challenges. It cannot, for example, be said that, “The goal of most universities has been to educate only the most educationally advantaged students” (King and Sen Reference King and Sen2012. this issue). That goal is true only of certain subsectors of our higher education system, and they have long come under attack because of their contrast with those institutions whose mission is based more on access. This is certainly a major source of conflict in many states, where politicians, the public, and the faculty of the state comprehensives resent the apparent wealth of their flagships. The majority of the educated public did not receive their degrees at Association of American Universities (AAU) institutions, or even those in combination with the top-ranked liberal arts colleges.
The lines among these institutions are often blurred. This is certainly true at the flagship public land-grant universities that have significant outreach and continuing education missions. As in the broad field of comparative politics and political systems, however, the point is not just to inventory the variety of cases, but first to develop a useful comparative approach to understanding higher education and second, to understand the different cases as they are linked in systematic ways that affect them all.
Let us consider one of the major challenges to universities that King and Sen highlight—the variety of ways that new information and communication technologies provide fresh opportunities for shaping and institutionalizing teaching and learning. The authors are correct in saying that colleges and universities must make systemic efforts to understand the implications of these technologies for their own practices of teaching and learning and business operations. But it is most unlikely that all types of institutions share goals that will lead them to shape their technology use in the same way or to respond to the new institutional forms of technology-mediated teaching and learning similarly. It would not be appropriate. The top research and liberal arts institutions, public and private, do not compete with the University of Phoenix, and they will not be competing with massive open online courses (MOOCs) in the near future for their primary undergraduate population (from which they derive revenue) or their PhD programs (from which they derive prestige). For research and liberal arts institutions, the competition is seeking alternative sources of revenue from learners whom they have had little or no interest in serving on campus. They need to enter and be successful in a revenue-producing education business before the market becomes saturated, and alter their business models for executive and other extension education in a more contemporary, competitive manner. They must learn how to develop and use technology mediated teaching and learning systems that will surely be essential everyday features of the top residential colleges and universities some day. Worrying about whether Harvard or Michigan or Stanford or Pomona will lose significant numbers of undergraduates to the University of Phoenix or MOOCs is not a good use of time.
The real shake-up in basic business and education models is more likely to take place in among the public comprehensives (even more than in community colleges) because many of these offer relatively few advantages over online courses, including graduation rates that beat a flip of a coin. Today, about 90% of people aged 18–24 have completed high school, and of those who have, more than 70% of today's high school graduates enroll in an institution of higher education within a year (US Census Bureau, 2012a, US Census Bureau, 2012b). But a large portion of those students do not complete a degree. In the current, high-technology era, there are solutions that could be workable were politics not a problem: close smaller, less-successful campuses and offer more online education opportunities, perhaps even coordinated by refreshed extension colleges based at universities with the research and technical prowess to develop sophisticated and successful teaching and learning experiences, combined with clustered and mobile student services. But politics is an issue because some state legislator and member of Congress represents the district that is proud of the local college, even if it graduates less than half of its students.
Comparing the graduation rates of different “four-year” institutions to course and degree completion in the primarily online options (whether degrees at University of Phoenix or courses at the MOOCs) suggests that, contrary to King and Sen's observation, it is not necessarily that people are taking these courses and not finishing them because they are entertainment experiences one might drop at any time, but that they lack the characteristics of the best residential universities support completion. The array of advisors, high-touch academic experiences, support services, residential programs, efforts aimed at stimulating engagement and a sense of place and community, the face-to-face interaction with other students (even if they are all simultaneously texting) is an expensive and time-consuming infrastructure without which it is difficult to achieve the highest graduation rates, even with students of excellent academic background.
Community colleges play different roles in the higher education system and probably have a different relationship to the challenges of the new institutional structures of technology-mediated education. Whereas comprehensive public institutions aim to graduate students with a four-year degree—and relatively few do graduate even half their students in four years (Chronicle of Higher Education, “College Completion”), one central goal of many community colleges is to launch a significant proportion of their students on the path toward a four-year institution and a bachelor's degree. This type of goal requires an excellent advising system.
For-profit institutions are not external threats; they are finding their way as a part of the system. Online education is not a special sector; it is a mode that is used to varying degrees by different types of institutions for different reasons. MOOCs are in pilot- and market-testing stages. They will not disappear, but as King and Sen argue, we cannot just ignore them, even if we work in institutions whose targeted students population is not going to decide between our institution and a series of badges.
In the end, astute investigation of the current challenges King and Sen discuss—and others—depends on the development of a rigorous analysis of the higher education system as a system, understanding both the specifics of the different kinds of institutions in comparison with each other, and the empirical significance of the fact that they exist in a system. Of course, I have not even mentioned all the important lines and categories that determine the nature of this system and the categories within it. And, of course, the American higher education system is not an isolated, self-contained entity. As King and Sen's article suggests, we have to consider the nature of the global and international system. This means more than identifying the ways that many universities are filling their seats with international students, especially from China, or looking at the popular locations for attempting to establish international beachheads.
WHAT SHOULD WE DO?
The “we” of this question is a very complicated group of institutions. Political scientists may well have much to contribute in analyzing the American system of higher education and its current challenges.
It is certainly no longer possible for university faculty and administrators to be self-assured in assuming that it is obvious that what we do and how we do it is always worthwhile. It is not self-evidently so. Even after two decades in the growth of accreditation and assessment initiatives, it is not easy to get university communities to regard these as anything but annoying and invasive intrusions. But we must be able to explain why investment in our research is worthwhile, why education is expensive, and what is the value of the different degrees and educational experiences we offer, to whom, and why.
As King and Sen point out, we must keep improving our approaches to teaching and learning. But fortunately, there is significant progress in some of the areas they highlight. Certainly this is the case in the expansion of involving undergraduates in research and other discovery methods of learning, which are approaches that have been becoming increasingly important parts of undergraduate curricular at research universities since the publication of the Boyer Report (Boyer Commission 1998). Given the changing structures of knowledge, information, and communication, it is now even more important for students to have research and discovery experiences to prepare them for their professional futures, and here research universities have the advantage over other higher education institutions, residential and virtual.
The higher education sector expanded for decades. This expansion has included a certain amount of degree inflation. The public is less trusting in all sorts of institutions, including our own. Education is increasingly expensive during a sustained period of economic compression. It is not surprising that if people seeking education simply as a means for credentialing and specific types of job advancement take the option of earning certificates or badges if offered (Carey Reference Carey2012). But that means that institutions of higher education of all sorts whose mission is to offer more than certificates and badges for discrete accomplishments must go further to make it clear what we do, to demonstrate (not just explain) why that is important, and to show that we are able and willing to use our smarts to get better at it.
