I. INTRODUCTION
Despite recent victories for the LGBTQ+Footnote 1 community,Footnote 2 problems remain concerning access to justice for, discrimination against, violence towards, and access to adequate medical care for LGBTQ+ individuals.Footnote 3 Medical-legal partnerships (“MLPs”) provide an avenue for increased access to health care and justice, allowing individuals to address the discrimination and violence they face as members of the LGBTQ+ community. This Note argues that MLPs should be integrated into queer resource organizations to serve the community’s unmet needs and address discriminatory practices against LGBTQ+ people in the medical and legal fields.
Part II describes MLPs and elaborates on the need for legal access amongst LGBTQ+ people. Then Part III addresses how the LGBTQ+ community will benefit from the establishment of MLPs in existing LGBTQ+ resource organizations and how MLPs are well-suited to the needs of the community. Part IV considers some potential challenges and benefits of integrating MLPs into LGBTQ+ organizations. Part V discusses what the integration of MLPs would ideally look like, taking into account financial, structural, and systemic factors. This Note concludes by summarizing the need for the integration of MLPs into LGBTQ+ resource organizations.
II. MEDICAL-LEGAL PARTNERSHIPS AND THE LGBTQ+ COMMUNITY
This Part describes what an MLP is by detailing their origins, the forms they take today, and how they are financed. The Part goes on to explain the need for MLPs in the LGBTQ+ community, which is evidenced by homophobia in both the legal and medical fields.
A. What is a Medical-Legal Partnership?
An MLP is an interdisciplinary practice that seeks to address both physical health and the social determinants of health through legal methods, usually by incorporating attorneys into health care settings.Footnote 4 The historical basis for MLPs align with current MLP goals of addressing the social determinants of health, particularly for vulnerable and underserved populations.
1. The Origin of MLPs
The most famous MLP origin story was in the early 1990s, when physicians teamed up with Greater Boston Legal Services (“GBLS”) because of an influx of repeat emergency visits from pediatric asthma patients.Footnote 5 After observing children coming in repeatedly and with alarming frequency, the doctors treating these patients decided to investigate.Footnote 6 They discovered that the children having the recurring asthma attacks were living in mold-infested conditions that their landlords refused to remedy, so the doctors reached out to GBLS, a provider of free civil legal services to low-income communities in the metro Boston area.Footnote 7 Once GBLS attorneys dealt with the noncompliant landlords, the substandard living conditions were remedied, and the patients’ emergency room visits decreased.Footnote 8
Despite the popularity of this narrative, the collaboration of medical and legal services providers actually dates back to at least 1967 when a doctor in Mississippi hired a lawyer “to address patients’ food and housing problems.”Footnote 9 The idea developed further in the 1980s when health care institutions worked closely with attorneys to provide for the end-of-life-needs of HIV/AIDS patients, a majority of whom were gay men.Footnote 10 Regardless of when and how MLPs truly began, today they can be found in a variety of settings, including Veterans Affairs’ medical centers, children’s hospitals, and institutions serving elderly populations.Footnote 11
MLPs’ prevalence within different kinds of institutions reflects the diverse array of services MLPs can provide and focuses they can have. Some MLPs specialize in issues surrounding poverty;Footnote 12 others focus on substance use, family/domestic issues, and disability law; and many more are general in practice.Footnote 13 Since the legal professionals in MLPs often work on a pro bono basis,Footnote 14 MLPs are well-suited to the law school clinic setting, and in fact, over fifty law schools are partners in MLPs in the United States.Footnote 15
2. MLPs Today
MLPs often take the form of a legal services organization or law school clinic partnering with a medical clinic.Footnote 16 MLPs are typically hosted within the health organization, in some cases with the health organization hiring attorneys directly to serve as the “legal” portion of the MLP rather than partnering with an external legal services provider.Footnote 17 As in the GBLS example,Footnote 18 typically, patients will see their doctors, and through asking patients about their lives and living situations, medical providers can uncover underlying problems that are causing their patients’ poor health outcomes.Footnote 19 When a health organization is part of an MLP, they can then refer the patient to their legal partner, who is able to see if there are any legal processes or remedies that would ameliorate the underlying situation contributing to the patient’s diminished health.
The main focus of MLPs—particularly for their legal side—is on social determinants of health (“SDoH”). SDoH are environmental conditions that are present in the places people work, study, live, or otherwise inhabit and impact health, wellness, and other quality-of-life indicators.Footnote 20 They are the conditions independent of health care that can have a significant impact on a person’s wellness.Footnote 21 For example, across races and ethnicities, highest level of educational attainment can uniformly be used to approximate whether an adult is in poor health, and low income correlates with higher incidence of chronic disease in adults.Footnote 22 Such determinants include income, housing and utilities, education and employment, legal status, and personal and family stability.
Addressing income issues through legal methods includes helping people with food stamps denials, health insurance complications, cash benefits, and disability benefits.Footnote 23 Legal assistance in the area of housing and utilities often means helping with housing subsidies, improving substandard conditions (which is particularly salient for people who do not own their homes, but instead deal with a landlord), preventing evictions, and protecting people against utility shut-off. The latter two of these have been especially important to address during the COVID-19 pandemic.Footnote 24
MLPs can also help with education and employment by assisting individuals in obtaining specialized education services, addressing instances of employment discrimination, and enforcing workplace rights.Footnote 25 Legal status problems that MLPs commonly help with include veteran discharge, criminal and credit histories, asylum applications, and immigration and citizenship.Footnote 26 MLPs are not uncommon in Veterans Affairs medical centers and are regarded as efficient, useful, and particularly well-suited to tackling the complex issues veterans face.Footnote 27 Finally, personal and family stability issues may encompass helping individuals get restraining orders in cases of stalking and domestic violence among other things; completing the adoption process; and obtaining custody and/or guardianship of children.Footnote 28
Any and all of these SDoH may intersect, especially among populations that are themselves intersectional, such as the LGBTQ+ community.Footnote 29 Because of the nature of SDoH, the examples given above can easily implicate physical wellbeing and health issues. Someone without secure housing could find themselves homeless and in poor health due to continuous exposure to the elements, someone with low income could have dietary health issues due to the cost barrier to buying healthy foods; those are just a couple of situations where health is complicated by external factors. Addressing legal issues alone is insufficient because the individuals in these situations are experiencing declining health, and medical treatment alone is not enough because the other issues will persist without legal help. An MLP combines these services to create a team that is treating both the symptoms and causes of complicated matters arising from SDoH. Further, all of these areas speak to the broader needs for stable housing, secure income, and healthy interpersonal relationships; when these kinds of needs are addressed and satisfied, people experience reduced stress and increased capacity for self-care, which is important for individual wellness.Footnote 30 Therefore, when SDoH and the related impacts on physical health are addressed by MLPs for the LGBTQ+ community, they will be better equipped to address their personal wellbeing. This is important because LGBTQ+ individuals are more likely to experience mental illness than their non-LGBTQ+ counterparts.Footnote 31
3. MLP Financing
About half of MLPs are funded at least partially through their health center’s operating budget, which can include funding from the Health Resources and Services Administration (“HRSA”).Footnote 32 The median budget of an MLP is $100,000 per year, and the median staffing is one full-time equivalent attorney and 0.2 full-time equivalent health care organization support staff.Footnote 33 Altogether, this does not sound like much, but between pro bono legal work and in-kind support from other organizations, the median budget and staffing is likely underrepresenting the value and manpower that goes into operating the average MLP.Footnote 34 MLPs, especially when they are in the early stages, tend to be heavily reliant on philanthropic funding to fill gaps between what the health organization is able to put towards the MLP and what is needed to actually make it operational.Footnote 35 In fact, a majority of MLPs rely on at least two sources of funding,Footnote 36 with 64% of them relying at least in part on philanthropic contributions to their operational budgets.Footnote 37
While philanthropic means of funding and support are beneficial, relying on a patchwork of funding that can fluctuate from year to year is a barrier that MLPs generally have to overcome.Footnote 38 The organizations or entities providing funding may also undervalue the services being provided by the MLP and choose to prioritize other projects. At this point, MLP budgets are mostly for legal services,Footnote 39 which makes sense because legal services are typically less accessible than medical services and tend to have a higher cost barrier for commonplace services.Footnote 40 However, having a more equal distribution of full-time equivalent employees on both the legal and medical sides of an MLP could only aid in the goals of getting MLP patients/clients effective, holistic legal and medical care.
The National Center for Medical Legal-Partnerships has long pushed for sustainable MLP funding that goes beyond reliance on philanthropic contributions and prioritizes not just the initial set-up but the long-term vision for the MLP.Footnote 41 At each level—federal, state, local, and private—health services and legal services can obtain funding to help support the overall MLP. As mentioned, at the federal level, HRSA enabling services and Medicaid funding can help fund the health care side of the MLP. Accordingly, Legal Services Corporation funding has been used to fund the legal side.Footnote 42 Also at the federal level (though state administered), Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants and Americorps legal assistance programs have helped support MLPs.Footnote 43 At the state level, public health funding and appropriations, state legal service funders, and interest on Lawyers Trust Accounts can provide funding; while at the private level, operational revenue, insurers, law school collaborations, and legal fellowship programs have all been used before to contribute to the functioning of MLPs.Footnote 44
Each of these avenues is more sustainable than relying on charitable gifts that lack consideration or promise of continuance, and, therefore, are more stable ways to support a new or growing MLP. This is particularly relevant if MLPs are expanded in LGBTQ+ communities, as the next Section recommends.
B. The Need for Legal Access in LGBTQ+ Communities
Broad legal support for the LGBTQ+ community in the United States is relatively new—consider that we are merely seven years removed from the Obergefell v. Hodges decision which legalized gay marriage.Footnote 45 Additionally, it has been mere months since the Supreme Court found workplace discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity to be a legal wrong in Bostock v. Clayton Cty. Footnote 46 After a long history of discrimination both in the United States and globally, the victories from cases like Obergefell and Bostock, as well as older decisions such as Lawrence v. Texas Footnote 47 and Romer v. Evans,Footnote 48 are monumental, but legal intervention in certain arenas (sexual and legal relationships, employment, housing, etc.) does not stop instances of discrimination, hatred, or violence.Footnote 49 In the wake of increasing acceptance both socially and in light of the aforementioned decisions, anti-LGBTQ+ campaigns have been launched that are trying to carve religious exemptions out of antidiscrimination laws and rulings.Footnote 50 Opponents of equality have also sought to push anti-transgender legislation, clearly demonstrating their bias against LGBTQ+ individuals.Footnote 51
1. Homophobia in the Legal Profession
The legal profession itself has a long tradition of homophobiaFootnote 52 and anti-LGBTQ+ bias, both within the profession and towards LGBTQ+ individuals seeking legal assistance.Footnote 53 In this highly conservative profession,Footnote 54 there has been a long-standing “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy as well as overtly toxic office culture that allowed and maybe even encouraged homophobic jokes and stereotyping.Footnote 55 This is perhaps unsurprising in a profession that historically struggled to be inclusive—explicitly excluding women, people of color, and non-Christians from bar membership for decades.Footnote 56 Bar associations and the legal profession as a whole still struggle to lessen discrimination, promote diversity and inclusion, and alter the composition of the profession to be something other than cisgender, heterosexual, white males.Footnote 57
With LGBTQ+ individuals facing the realities of discrimination, it becomes all too important to provide them with better access to justice, and particularly to do so in ways and spaces that they can be comfortable. Nothing would truly change if some improved access to justice schemes were implemented without assuring the target population feels comfortable or safe taking advantage of such systems. Thus, the method of implementation is of the utmost importance for those historically unsupported by the profession. Resources need to be held out in ways that are likely to be taken advantage of to both address the issue of access to justice and make the implemented solution meaningful and effective. Combatting fear and the trauma of past experiences like bullying, harassment, assault, and ostracization will never be an easy task, but the LGBTQ+ community both needs and deserves improved access to health care and justice.
There are especially vulnerable subsets of the community that are more likely to encounter the kinds of problems that legal assistance could address. Many LGBTQ+ seniors face issues with housing security, health care benefits, and spousal benefits, while still being confronted with the effects of having previously experienced discrimination in these areas.Footnote 58 HIV-positive individuals (queer and otherwise) experience continued stigma that only compounds as they battle with their declining wellbeing—and potentially income and housing insecurity because of poor health.Footnote 59 Homeless LGBTQ+ people have to wrestle with almost every issue that MLPs seek to address, and they do not have the finances to obtain traditional legal assistance.Footnote 60 These are the kinds of issues that fall squarely into SDoH and could be effectively remedied by professionals looking at their problems from a multidisciplinary point of view.
2. Homophobia in the Medical Profession
The medical profession has similarly been problematic in their treatment of LGBTQ+ people. The most relevant issue for the purposes of this discussion is refusal to treat LGBTQ+ patientsFootnote 61 and general hostility, ridicule, or both, towards queer patients.Footnote 62 Like the legal profession, the medical field has also engaged in gatekeepingFootnote 63 to prevent queer individuals from practicing and encouraging the now (mostly) infamous policy of “don’t ask, don’t tell.”Footnote 64 Historically, doctors have ignored advanced directives of LGBTQ+ patients and outright refused to provide services for procedures like gender-confirmation surgery.Footnote 65 Refusing to follow advanced directives of LGBTQ+ patients has meant doctors have prevented their patients’ partners from being involved with health care decisions and information.Footnote 66 Often doctors do this under the erroneous belief that provisions which allow doctors to be non-compliant for reasons of conscience (e.g., religious views) permit them to ignore patient autonomy.Footnote 67 And even when doctors are willing to perform services like gender confirmation surgery, pervasive societal and legislative transphobia build hurdles to treatment.Footnote 68 Though strides have been made in the treatment of queer people—like removing homosexuality from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—institutional discrimination remains.Footnote 69 For example, though homosexuality was removed from the diagnostic manual, “gender identity disorder” was added, which targets manifestations of non-heteronormative behaviors in children; this diagnosis mainly impacts LGBTQ+ youths, who have few if any protections against forced treatment at the hands of their parents or doctors.Footnote 70
Where medical professionals or entities do not refuse to treat LGBTQ+ people, the attitudes, biases, and ignorance of health professionals can resoundingly discourage queer people from seeking out and accessing medical services, let alone feeling comfortable in a health care setting.Footnote 71 Cultural competence, both in terms of unique or specific issues affecting LGBTQ+ individuals and of the structure and dynamics of queer communities, is critical to effectively treating LGBTQ+ people.Footnote 72 Lack of such knowledge may lead medical professionals to make erroneous assumptions about their queer patients and to fail to consider their patients’ opinions on their health care options, which could very well differ from what the heteronormative viewpoint would default to.Footnote 73 For example, LGBTQ+-identifying individuals recount inappropriate questions, a lack of understanding of their sexuality and the resultant implications on health, and completely erroneous presumptions about individuals based on their sexuality.Footnote 74
***
Though attitudes toward queer people have been evolving in recent decades, there is still a lot of work to be done to improve access to health care and to help LGBTQ+ people feel comfortable with medical care, corresponding legal assistance, and their health care providers. Ensuring that LGBTQ+ individuals can access health care and insurance is extremely important, as is making sure that they feel accepted, safe, and validated during their visits with health care professionals.Footnote 75 The MLP model—especially as recommended in this Note—would help bridge the gap between purportedly providing a welcoming, safe, and inclusive medical practice and creating an actually safe, non-discriminatory medical practice.
III. MLPS IN EXISTING LGBTQ+ RESOURCE ORGANIZATIONS ARE A GOOD FIT FOR SERVING THE NEEDS OF LGBTQ+ POPULATIONS
This Part explains why MLPs being integrated into existing LGBTQ+ resource organizations would benefit and cater to the needs of the LGBTQ+ community. For one, MLPs established in these organizations can leverage the existing trust between the LGBTQ+ organization and the population the MLP would be trying to serve. Further, the organizations can provide multi-purpose care through the MLP, allowing them to address social and physical needs for their community members. Finally, this Part concludes with a formal recommendation for what an MLP integrated into an LGBTQ+ resource organization should look like.
A. MLPS can Benefit From Existing Trust Between the Providing Organization and the Communities They Serve
If MLPs were placed in existing LGBTQ+ resource organizations (or at the very least formed explicit partnerships with these organizations), the LGBTQ+ populations would feel more assured and educated about their rights when receiving medical and legal care. LGBTQ+ resource organizations are designed for the LGBTQ+ community, and they have built trust with that community, demonstrating that they are working towards and in the community’s best interests. Conversely, visiting a health care provider can be daunting for those in the LGBTQ+ community, given the historical discrimination and stigma previously described. Further, the professional gatekeeping that occurs in the legal field, makes attorneys and the law seem extremely unapproachable for a layperson, never mind those in vulnerable populations.Footnote 76 Thus, housing the MLP within an LGBTQ+ organization (“the parent organization”) that the target communities are already familiar with, or at least trusting of, would make these services more accessible. This would in turn increase their likelihood to access the additional resources that the MLP would offer, remain in compliance with treatment plans, and be forthcoming about the problems they need addressed.Footnote 77
Integrating legal and medical services into existing organizations would also make it easier for the MLPs to move past the pilot phase of their existence. The parent organization would have already performed outreach, gained a reliable community following and consistent participation in programming, and become a resource that the community is aware of. A steady, pre-existing patron-client base would enhance the early-stage stability of the MLP and bring it to a fully operational capacity sooner.Footnote 78 Essentially, the pains of starting the MLP would be eased by the reputation and existing patron-client base that the organization would have.
This trust would especially aid MLPs seeking to serve LGBTQ+ populations because low-income LGBTQ+ people are disadvantaged by their intersecting class, sexual, gender, and romantic identities as well as racial, ethnic, and other minoritized identities.Footnote 79 As such, there would be increased distrust in the medical and legal professions stemming from other minoritized aspects of queer individuals’ identities that could be circumvented by bringing in the LGBTQ+ organization, which has built a relationship with the MLP’s prospective clients.
B. Parent Organizations can Provide Multi-purpose Care Through MLPs
As stated, MLPs are designed to address complex issues that stem from SDoH—issues that can compound when someone finds themselves at the crossroads of being queer and facing a socioeconomic hardship whether that be poor living conditions, discriminatory workplace environments, insecure food or housing, or any of the many other issues people face every day.Footnote 80 Integrating MLPs would allow the parent organization to improve their medical and legal resources. Integration would create direct resources and services where once the parent organization may have needed to refer people out to medical centers or legal service organizations. Having an MLP as a resource would eliminate the burden of queer people who are suffering also having to untangle the complicated web of problems they are dealing with to figure out how to remedy their situations. Reducing off-site referrals would also likely reduce potential strain on the entities that were previously aiding the parent organization—especially if they were assisting in a pro bono capacity.Footnote 81 This would likely give those entities greater capacity to aid in more meaningful ways, instead of stretching themselves thin to cater to as many issues as possible—essentially giving greater depth of services instead of breadth.
That said, a parent organization could choose to formally create a partnership with a legal or medical center without pursuing in-house services. This might be a particularly appealing model where a strong relationship with a law firm, legal services organization, or health care entity already exists. It would allow the organization to continue relying on and strengthening that tie with an outside organization while providing the benefits of the MLP model to their patrons. However, the parent organization could thus miss out on some of the benefits discussed in the next Section by not having a fully integrated MLP.
Integrating formal MLPs would allow parent organizations to have attorneys and medical providers (or only one of the two, depending on the resources and structure that the particular MLP takes) available full-time, rather than depending on pro-bono work. Establishing an MLP would also make accessibility easier for the patron-client population. Instead of having to bounce between the parent organization and a medical clinic and an attorney’s office, all of these services would be present in one place.
Admittedly, depending on the depth of medical treatment necessary, the MLP’s health care provider may not be able to handle all aspects of a patient’s case, but check-ups and preventative care would likely be entirely feasible and reasonable. Additionally, federal funding for the MLP could add to the parent organization’s funding, which would make sustaining the MLP easier.Footnote 82 Discretionary budgets vary from organization to organization, but larger ones like PFLAG could provide a few million towards funding MLPs.Footnote 83 Being able to draw from the parent organization’s budget would be a huge asset to MLPs and would lend some much needed stability that relying on discretionary philanthropic contributions would not provide. Ultimately, so long as proper funding sources and key medical needs are addressed, MLPs can thrive and offer access to much needed care and legal services.
C. Proposed MLP Format
Ideally, an MLP formed in the manner and for the purposes proposed would be fully integrated within the LGBTQ+ organization—meaning the medical and legal services can be accessed within the same four walls.Footnote 84 The MLP would have a patron-client of the MLP/LGBTQ+ organization fill out both a medical and a legal check-up form when doing their intake appointment.Footnote 85 Within the engagement and authorization to treat forms would be a HIPAA-compliant waiver allowing the medical provider to share relevant information with the legal services provider,Footnote 86 and initial consultations on either side of the MLP should begin with an explanation of what the consent forms mean, what information could potentially be shared (and with whom), and the parameters of the services being provided.
Incorporating MLPs into existing organizational structure is also more efficient than trying to start a new MLP trying to serve the same demographic. As stated earlier, MLPs benefit from integrating into a known entity that already has a good reputation with the communities the MLP would be trying to reach. Integration would also be less cost-intensive, which allows the parent organization to provide more services. Currently, many LGBTQ+ organizations already have health education services if not full clinics.Footnote 87 Consequently, only the legal part of the equation would need to be addressed to form an MLP. Thus, parent organizations only need to put money and logistical resources toward either finding a legal services provider or hiring in-house attorneys to become an MLP.
Further, if the MLP is established in an organization that already has a clinic on site, then funding would only be crucial for the legal services, and the LGBTQ+ organization could seek funding from the Legal Services Corporation or from a state Interest on Lawyers Trust Account.Footnote 88 They could also partner up with a law school or pro bono legal services provider,Footnote 89 but these options would likely place some limits on the time and effort that would go into the legal services that employing dedicated full-time attorneys would prevent. If the parent organization does not already have a clinic, then it can look to HRSA enabling services funds and potentially nonprofit community benefit funds (depending on the requirements for accessing that kind of funding) to finance the medical services.Footnote 90 Philanthropic contributions to the MLP would be a great help, but MLPs should not plan to rely on that, even if such charitable funding is available from the MLP’s inception and from a seemingly reliable source, because such funding is less stable.
IV. INTEGRATION INTO LGBTQ+ ORGANIZATIONS
This Part discusses the actual logistics of integrating an MLP into an LGBTQ+ organization. Primary among those logistics is the potential challenges, including the formation of the attorney-client relationship, doctor-patient confidentiality, establishment of relationship between the MLP or LGBTQ+ organization and the patron-client, and where to establish the proposed MLPs. The Part then goes on to explain the benefits of the proposed MLP model. Such benefits include access to justice and care, health benefits, monetary savings, reduction in impact of SDoH on health, and increased efficiency over establishing an independent MLP.
A. Potential challenges
There are a number of potential challenges to establishing the MLP structure proposed by this Note. First among them is the establishment of the attorney-client relationship, which could be fraught with issues of confidentiality, conflicts of interest, and client identification. Second, doctor-patient confidentiality raises potential issues since cross-talk is needed between the legal and medical aspects of the MLP. There is also a potential for complications in deciding who among the parent organization’s community is allowed to access the MLP, for example whether there should be temporal requirements before services can be rendered. Finally, where to place the MLPs provides a problem since there would be a choice between serving large, evident populations or trying to reach more obscure LGBTQ+ communities.
1. Attorney-Client Relationship
Key to any legal representation or attorney-client relationship is confidentiality. For lawyers, the obligation of confidentiality is governed by their respective states’ analogues to the Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.6 (“MR 1.6”). MR 1.6 essentially dictates that “all information related to a lawyer’s representation of a client must be kept confidential; unless the client provides informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized by the representation …, or unless one of the exceptions to [MR 1.6] applies.”Footnote 91 MR 1.6 makes exceptions where disclosure would prevent death or bodily harm, would prevent or rectify fraud by the client, would prevent or rectify perjury, or would protect a person with “diminished capacity.”Footnote 92
In the MLP setting, confidentiality would be implicated whenever a lawyer communicates with a medical professional about the patron-client-patient. To communicate about the representation, the lawyer would need to obtain the informed consent of the patron-client-patient. Such informed consent would require explaining to the client the scope of the information that would be communicated to the doctor, the potential costs and benefits of disclosing the information, and the client’s right to revoke their consent at any time.Footnote 93 However, MLPs could accomplish this by creating a memorandum of understanding (“MOU”) among the MLP partners, which establishes roles and responsibilities of each participant in the MLP (including the patron-client-patient); by obtaining effective waiver and consent forms which are carefully tailored to the needs of the MLP as a collective as well as the respective halves of the MLP; and by prioritizing transparency, communication, and informed consent with the patron-client-patient and between the medical and legal sides of the MLP.Footnote 94
Another area of concern is conflicts of interest. In the course of representing a person, a lawyer may adversely impact the interests of another person, which means that the lawyer cannot then represent that second person in the future. This ethical imperative is supported by a number of the Model Rules of Professional Conduct, which emphasize that a lawyer cannot undertake a representation which is opposed to a current client or which is opposed to a former client in a similar matter to the original representation of the former client.Footnote 95 This duty to avoid conflicts would impact the MLP practice setting; MLP attorneys would have to be careful not to receive any sensitive information about clients whom they cannot represent and would therefore need to have screening protocols in place to avoid learning information about prospective clients who are in conflicts with current clients.Footnote 96 The MLP attorneys would also need to be careful to avoid institutional conflicts where the MLP patron-client-patient seeks to sue institutions that the attorney has a relationship with or that the MLP has a relationship with—particularly the LGBGTQ+ resource organization.Footnote 97
Finally, in the MLP setting, attorneys may have issues identifying the client in the first place and differentiating between an attorney-client and doctor-patient relationship. In medical settings, patients may bring third parties like relatives, and that does not impact doctor-patient confidentiality—but bringing a third party to a legal consultation can destroy attorney-client privilege.Footnote 98 This makes it important for the MLP patron-client-patients to clearly know who is part of the legal team and who is part of the medical team. It is also important then for the attorney to know who the patron-client-patient is so that they do not make unauthorized disclosures to people outside the representation.
Ultimately, attorneys and the MLP as a whole will want to obtain a signed MOU and to document all understandings, agreements, waivers, consents, and the general set-up of the MLP.Footnote 99 They will also want to have the client-patient acknowledge such writings. Among such agreements should be one specifying that the MLP attorneys do not represent the parent organization, because doing so could lead to conflicts between the representation of clients and the needs of the organization. The goals of the MLP would be better served if the parent organization is represented by outside or separate in-house counsel. MLP attorneys should not serve a dual function as in-house and patron-client-patient attorneys.
2. Doctor-patient Confidentiality
Doctor-patient confidentiality poses similar problems. HIPAA guidelines require that medical professionals not disclose identified, protected health information (“PHI”) to any non-authorized persons or entities, with a few exceptions for safety.Footnote 100 Unlike the legal field, there are not typically equally dire consequences for a blip in confidentiality.Footnote 101 When confidentiality is breached in a legal setting, it can mean that all the leaked information can no longer be protected (especially where the attorney-client privilege is implicated) whereas a patient retains their right to privacy in a medical setting unless there is a relevant exception (e.g., state and federal reporting, evaluating the care doctors and facilities provide).Footnote 102 Even where there are exceptions, a patient’s medical information is not made public,Footnote 103 and even if it were, the results from such a breach would be of a more reputational or societal nature. This is as opposed to breaches in legal confidentiality where the leaked information can be used against a client in a proceeding, which can lead to criminal and civil consequences depending on the legal issue.
Regardless, doctors still have an obligation to keep their patients’ information private, which could be problematic depending again on the way information is stored and who in the organization has access to it. In many types of MLPs, the medical and legal providers are entirely independent entities, with a spectrum of involvement in each other’s practices and records.Footnote 104 The MLP can exist as a simple referral network in which the doctors refer patients to a participating legal entity, or the legal and medical sides of the MLP can go so far as to share access to electronic health record systems.Footnote 105 Any model along the continuum of completely independent to completely integrated is going to have its own benefits and drawbacks, especially when considering autonomy of providers versus ease of access and communication in a more integrated MLP practice.Footnote 106
Where the entire MLP is contained in one larger organization or provider, a referral system would still be logical to formally document and differentiate between medical services’ patients and legal services’ clients, but in such circumstances, consent to information sharing would need to be addressed.Footnote 107 That said, addressing consent would mostly solve the problem of cross-talk between the halves of the MLP without violating attorney-client or doctor-patient confidentiality. Fully integrated MLPs can receive patient consent to share PHI with legal services providers with the patient’s intake and consent to treatment forms, so long as the consent forms are HIPAA-compliant.Footnote 108 This would solve some of the confidentiality problems as it pertains to the providers themselves, since there would be authorized information sharing, and the lawyers and medical professionals could still maintain their separate recordkeeping systems, which would limit who in the organization could access patron-client information.Footnote 109
Patients of a fully integrated MLP—where both the medical and legal halves of the partnership are hosted within the same four walls—benefit from a tight connection between legal needs and patient health, as well as regular screening for health-impacting legal needs and provision of legal services.Footnote 110 This makes a fully integrated model ideal for any population that needs greater access to justice, like LGBTQ+ communities. Thus, with the benefits in access to care and justice, the lack of complications in matters of consent, and the circumvention of other issues pertaining to doctor-patient confidentiality, a fully integrated MLP would be the best type to install in LGBTQ+ resource organizations.
3. Becoming a Patron-client of the MLP
There is also a question of what depth of relationship needs to exist between the parent organization and a potential patron-client before they can utilize the MLP’s services. This hinges in part on what kind of demand could be placed on the MLP and if it varies with how open the MLP is for walk-in appointments, so to speak. If in fact the MLP is overburdened by being open to anyone off the street—and indeed this could inadvertently impede the goal of aiding the LGBTQ+ community, specifically—what standard should be used to judge depth of relationship and what threshold is needed before accessing the MLP? Several options for the threshold include: (i) a certain number of visits, (ii) a specified duration of (an at least periodic) relationship with the parent organization, (iii) the potential severity of the problem the patron-client is seeking MLP services for, and (iv) a demonstrated need for MLP access (i.e., an eviction notice, proof of substandard living conditions, etc.).Footnote 111
The first two options require that the parent organization keep some kind of record or roster of people who access the organization’s resources and/or attend events. Yet, it is possible that some organizations do not keep such formal records and instead rely on social media and word of mouth. However, it is likely these organizations at least have some record (e.g., an e-mail list) that could be cross-referenced to determine if an individual meets whatever threshold the organization deems appropriate for the provision of MLP services. The latter two options run more of a risk of including non-target individuals in the pool of people who can access the MLP. While this is not intrinsically bad, it strays from the goal of implementing the MLP in the first place—namely, to provide services to patrons of the parent organization. It would also require people to share personal, potentially embarrassing, or private information with a third party who would then judge the validity of their problem, threatening the trust in the parent organization and potentially harming the patient-client.
The clearest standards to use would be a temporal threshold, whether that be the duration of the relationship or number of visits to the parent organization. However, it is also unlikely that non-target individuals would be seeking out MLP resources at the parent organizations, so allowing people to make appointments with the MLP—particularly the clinic/medical side, as is the case for traditional MLPsFootnote 112—as their first visit to the organization is just as reasonable.Footnote 113
4. Where to Establish MLPs
Finally, a possible hurdle to instituting this MLP-in-LGBTQ+-organizations paradigm is the question of where they should go. On an individual level, each organization would be making the decision of where to establish a physical presence for itself, but if there were a more organized push for more MLPs to be established from a national LGBTQ+ advocacy organization like PFLAGFootnote 114 or GLAAD,Footnote 115 the question remains as to where these organizations should be located.
A knee-jerk response may lead someone to answer, “urban areas” or “large cities,” but that raises a subsequent concern. Metropolitan areas have larger populations and tend to have higher concentrations of socially liberalFootnote 116 and queerFootnote 117 individuals, but would putting MLPs in such areas mean not providing resources where they may be needed most? LGBTQ+-identifying individuals also live in areas where there are not huge,Footnote 118 known communities who would need or want to utilize LGBTQ+ organizations. Many live where these organizations, and the MLP services they could provide under this proposed model, are still sorely needed. This in turn raises a more systemic question concerning continued homophobia and transphobia: are there meaningful differences in need between areas that are more accepting, with seemingly larger queer populations and areas where continued lack of acceptance abounds, though with potentially an equal amount of queer people living, just much more quietly?
To determine where to locate services, a balance is likely needed. While less-accepting areas may have just as dire a need, there is no guarantee that LGBTQ+ populations would feel safe coming into contact with the organizations themselves, let alone accessing the resources they provide. A large demonstrated demand for resources (and therefore expectation of utilization) is just as important as trying to serve as many areas as possible, given the relative ubiquity of queer individuals, out or not, across the nation.Footnote 119 Essentially, without enough supply, equality and justice hang in the balance of these competing interests, and MLP LGBTQ+ resource organizations should first be placed where they are most likely to be used, especially when the model still needs to gain traction and prove itself before being more widely implemented.
Ideally, MLPs would be established at some of the more prominent, highly-trafficked LGBTQ+ organizations in cities like New York, San Francisco, Portland (OR), and Austin.Footnote 120 Queer populations are more common in urban areas, particularly port cities since, historically, discharged LGBTQ+ soldiers have remained in the port cities they were dropped off in and built communities there.Footnote 121 That activity created a resultant pull of other LGBTQ+ people to the communities being built up in cities.Footnote 122 Though placing these MLPs in urban areas risks avoiding providing assistance to queer people who live in some of the more homophobic regions and states, LGBTQ+ individuals with unmet needs exist everywhere, and it would be critical for the MLPs to justify their existences (particularly with regards to cost) in the initial, start-up-like phase. Putting the MLPs first where they are likely to be utilized would be the wisest move to build regard and a body of proof for the model’s efficacy, which would encourage its adoption in places with smaller LGBTQ+ communities than some of the hotspots mentioned above.
There also remains a question of whether these MLPs should be placed in LGBTQ+ organizations in a capacity that is entirely separate from the organization’s existing medical clinics or if they should be integrated with existing clinics. Integration would allow the MLP to reduce needed initial capital input by utilizing existing resources, but maintaining the two separately may more easily allow the MLP to expand what medical services are provided. Most queer organizations focus their health initiatives and clinics on sexually transmitted diseases/infections and other aspects of reproductive health,Footnote 123 which makes sense given the historical and present importance and impact of STDs and STIs on the LGBTQ+ community. However, if the medical side of the MLP were merely relying on the services already provided by the organization’s clinic, it may take more training to ensure the health care providers ask the right questions, are capable of administering more services, and properly interface with the legal side of the MLP. Essentially, there may be more growing pains to ensure that the MLP functions are fulfilled. Conversely, maintaining the MLP separately from any existing clinic may unnecessarily drain funding, result in duplicative services, and cause clinic patients to miss the opportunity to benefit from MLP services.
This best option would likely be a combination of integrating the MLP with existing clinical services (where they exist) but also adding general practitioners and medical personnel trained to work with legal services providers. This would ensure that the legal side of the MLP gets the referrals it should, that all patron-clients of the organization have their needs screened by the MLP, and that the MLP runs efficiently, without duplicating services or taking funding unnecessarily. There may still need to be extra training of the clinic employees, but the addition of practitioners who provide more holistic care, are trained to work with MLPs, or both would mitigate the resources that would need to be expended to train them. Additionally, this would serve to better integrate the MLP into the organization itself by attaching itself to an entity and services that already existed in the parent organization.
B. Potential benefits
Establishing these MLPs comes with ample benefits to outweigh the potential complications discussed above. The MLPs would enhance access to justice and care, which is needed due to the homophobia and prejudice that LGBTQ+ individuals have faced from the medical and legal professions. The MLPs would also provide health benefits and monetary savings to those who utilize the services available and would reduce issues connected to SDoH by addressing both causes and results of poorly indicated SDoH. Finally, establishing the integrated MLPs as proposed would be more efficient than the traditional means of establishing an independent MLP.
1. Access to Justice
The ultimate desired outcome of the proposed MLPs is to increase access to justice and medical services for the LGBTQ+ community.Footnote 124 Integrating MLPs into LGBTQ+ resource organizations will put resources in place where this community—especially low-income populations and those facing the kind of intersectional issues that MLPs are designed to addressFootnote 125—is already likely to turn to for assistance. As explained previously, parent organizations already have trust and relationships with the community, so integrated MLPs are a good fit for serving LGBTQ+ populations. This integration eliminates some of the structural barriers that are particularly exacerbated for members of the LGBTQ+ community who have multiple minoritized aspects of their identities and are therefore reluctant to go to doctors or lawyers; experiences with discrimination are intersectional and stem not just from sexual or gender identity.Footnote 126 With increased access to justice, MLPs can begin to remedy the continued discrimination happening in our country.Footnote 127
Additionally, with access to justice and clear opposition to discrimination, there will hopefully be a further and stronger push for societal acceptance overall, which would in turn lessen some of the more egregious instances necessitating legal intervention. Increased access to medical services, too, will improve health outcomes and ideally push back against the homophobic and heteronormative biases that still exist in the medical field.Footnote 128 With more health professionals treating LGBTQ+ people in a setting where it is evident and expected that people are not heterosexual, cisgender, or both, and treating LGBTQ+ patients as normal people—just with slightly different concerns than straight, cis patients,—such care would become standard practice within the medical field. This rationale applies to the legal field as well—the more professionals you have who begin to normalize interacting with patients and clients who are part of the LGBTQ+ community, the more it becomes an unquestioned norm in the profession as a whole.
2. Access to Care
Increased access to MLPs generally will also produce better health outcomes. Increased prevalence and use of MLPs will lead to enhanced wellbeing of the people using them, both via basic access to care and by addressing the SDoH that may be creating more complicated medical problems that need to be treated.
Adequate health care is critical to health outcomes, and integrated MLPs provide such care directly. However, such care must also be accessed. Many circumstances prevent access to care, like lack of health insurance, but insured status alone is not sufficient to determine whether someone will be in good health or can effectively utilize the health care system.Footnote 129 What is more important is actually guaranteeing people will use health services and have the ability to both see a practitioner and comply with their instructions.Footnote 130 In most cases, non-financial barriers are what limit access to care.Footnote 131 Often, SDoH are these factors limiting access—factors that are also addressed through the MLPs. Therefore, MLPs both provide basic care and help eliminate barriers to access to care by more holistically addressing the sources of illness via SDoH.
As with legal services, access to care amongst the queer communities that these MLPs are available to is likely to increase, both because the MLP would provide an opportunity for health services outside of the stigma present in the medical fieldFootnote 132 and because ideally these MLPs would be more accessible—in terms of timing, location, affordability, etc.—than traditional medical care providers.
3. Health Benefits and Monetary Savings
MLPs have proven improved health outcomes for over half of the patients who utilize them.Footnote 133 In a self-reported survey, sixty-six percent of clinicians relayed improved health outcomes for MLP patients, seventy-three percent reported improved access to personal and family stability needs, seventy-nine percent said that their MLP patients had improved access to income and insurance needs, and eighty-two percent indicated that patients have improved access to housing and utilities needs.Footnote 134 MLPs can also save their patients/clientsFootnote 135 as well as the MLP health care partnerFootnote 136 a significant amount of money. Through the MLP, individuals may save money by having their debts reduced,Footnote 137 by having more stable living situations, by resolving personal issues that would have economic consequences (receiving unemployment benefits; assistance with resolving discrimination claims; enrolling children in school; fighting an insurance denial),Footnote 138 or by reducing visits to medical professionals.Footnote 139 MLPs have a good return on investment for the hosting organization, particularly in cases where they work to resolve previously denied benefit claims,Footnote 140 allowing the medical provider to be properly compensated for services rendered.
In the cases of LGBTQ+ individuals who are struggling financially (especially if they have left their childhood residences at a young age and do not have a reliable or extensive support systemFootnote 141), these savings can be a significant help. Integration into LGBTQ+ spaces also intrinsically makes accessing the MLP resources—particularly the legal portion—less daunting and more economically feasible.Footnote 142 An important, notable barrier to people accessing legal services generally is the sheer cost of representation,Footnote 143 so reducing these costs is another point in the MLP model’s favor, and something that will facilitate access to justice.
4. Reduction in Problems Associated with Social Determinants of Health
Using MLPs more broadly would also likely lead to a reduction in issues stemming from SDoH, including compliance with medical treatment.Footnote 144 Homelessness is also an especially important issue to address since it is not uncommon for LGBTQ+ youths who come out—or worse, are outed—in unaccepting environments to either leave or be kicked out of their former residences.Footnote 145 From a health care point of view, HIV/AIDS treatment is also particularly relevant because HIV/AIDS disproportionately affects LGBTQ+ populations and still has a good deal of stigma around it.Footnote 146 Therefore, having a clinic that is not only used to handling HIV/AIDS cases but is trained to be sensitive, act with compassion, and treat the patient like any other person would likely increase compliance with medical treatment—which is very important in managing HIV/AIDSFootnote 147—and ensure that queer people are more likely to seek testing and treatment in the first place.
SDoH affect everyone, though some people see more negative impacts than others. As such, they are important factors to consider and address within the LGBTQ+ community.Footnote 148 MLPs are inherently designed to focus on and ameliorate the complications that arise from SDoH. Thus, MLPs are perfectly situated to fill the need to address root causes of illness and prevent recurring, situational illnesses for everyone, including LGBTQ+ communities.
***
Overall, it is clear these benefits outweigh the potential problems associated with MLPs. All of the anticipated issues can be solved through careful research and planning, while the benefits convey an overall increase in quality of life that cannot be overlooked by what are more or less logistics.
V. CONCLUSION
Ultimately, MLPs should be integrated into LGBTQ+ resource organizations because of the huge potential benefits to queer individuals. As SDoH are being increasingly recognized as critical to treating people for their physical ailments, so too is the fact that more people are not cisgender, alloromantic, and heterosexual, and instead identify as members of the LBGTQ+ community. Basic human rights and standards of living should be afforded to all people, regardless of any defining facet of their identity, and increasing access to health care and legal services is a step in the right direction to making that a reality.
To build that reality, MLPs should be established in LGBTQ+ resource organizations. These MLPs should have attorneys that solely attend to the needs of the patron-clients of the MLP, and memoranda of understanding should be effectuated that explain confidentiality and allow the halves of the MLP to speak to each other and coordinate care. The MLPs should be established first in areas where there are larger LGBTQ+ communities who can take advantage of the services rendered and justify the existence of the MLPs in the early days of this model’s life. The MLPs should also attempt to be fully integrated into the organization—that is, wholly housed within the walls of the LGBTQ+ parent organization—and would ideally attach themselves to a parent organization that already has clinical services that the MLP can supplement. In our increasingly complex world, these MLPs could start bridging the gap between providing health care and treating the root causes—SdoH—and the inequities they spring from.
