There is a classic way to tell the story of Mormons’ relationship to American society during the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era: following the Civil War, Protestant reformers launched an aggressive legal campaign to end Mormon polygamy, which the inaugural Republican Party platform had identified, along with slavery, as one of the “twin relics of barbarism.” Mormons resisted, claiming free exercise of religion; but by 1890, hundreds of Mormon polygamists were in prison, church leaders had fled underground, state and federal governments had curtailed Mormon suffrage, Congress had taken the unprecedented step of disincorporating the church and moving to confiscate its property, and the Supreme Court had upheld these measures. At that point, Mormons capitulated, abandoning polygamy in the name of a divine mandate to obey the law of the land. A rapid, dramatic transition followed: within six years Utah was granted statehood, and in the following decades Mormons developed a sterling reputation as clean-living, industrious patriots.
In a landmark 2004 study, American religious historian Kathleen Flake complicated this classic narrative. Flake moved the story's decisive turning point from 1890, when Mormon leadership announced the cessation of polygamy, to 1904–1906, when the appointment of a Mormon apostle, Reed Smoot, to the U.S. Senate prompted Protestant outrage and Senate hearings to investigate charges that Mormon leaders were still solemnizing covert polygamous marriages and directing Mormons’ political participation. Flake's story about Mormon accommodation shifted self-consciously from the realm of law to that of politics. Instead of a tale of Mormon capitulation, Flake told of a negotiation, in which Mormons agreed to really abandon polygamy and to behave like a denomination rather than a theocracy, while the federal government began a long, slow shift away from Protestant nationalism toward a “broader political understanding of religious liberty and narrower reading of permissible establishment.”Footnote 1 Smoot kept his Senate seat, Protestant outrage notwithstanding. In Flake's telling, Mormon accommodation was a two-way process: Mormons changed to accommodate majority norms and majority norms changed to accommodate them.
Now another American religious historian, Thomas Simpson, has expanded the story of Mormon accommodation in yet other directions. Where Flake pushed the decisive moment of accommodation forward, from 1890 into the first decade of the twentieth century, Simpson pushes the beginnings of accommodation backward, into the 1860s. Where Flake turned from law to politics as a realm in which to track Mormonism's transformation, Simpson looks to the realm of higher education.” Modern Mormonism,” he argues, “was born in the American university, and the Mormon path to citizenship—to a genuine, passionate sense of belonging in America—ran directly through it.” Simpson follows late nineteenth-century Mormons who migrated, as students, from Utah to prominent universities like Harvard, Columbia, and Michigan, where they “f[e]ll in love with America again”—then back to Utah, where they helped guide their coreligionists from cultural separatism to rapprochement. Like the politicians, prosecutors, and judges who implemented the anti-polygamy crusade, hospitable university presidents like Harvard's Charles Eliot pursued an assimilative “nation-building project,” but one that wooed Mormons rather than coerced them (1–2). Like Flake, Simpson rejects a narrative of simple capitulation, emphasizing Mormons’ agency in working out their place in American society: “Neither rejecting American culture nor assimilating to it, Mormons made strategic choices, and engaged in fierce debates, about how to use education to build the kingdom. … [T]he Mormon path to modernization was neither narrow nor fixed, and external pressure alone could not have produced modern Mormonism” (5).
Simpson's archival research and data gathering are impressive. He has tracked down basic biographical data for over two hundred Mormons who attended universities outside Utah between the 1860s and 1920s. Drawing from unpublished diaries, letters, and other personal papers, he narrates the vexed relationship between Mormon university students and church leaders in four acts. Act One, 1867–1877: Brigham Young sends selected Mormons—including women—back east to earn degrees in medicine and law, his plan being that they will return to Utah and train others, thereby eliminating the need for further traffic with outside educational institutions. Act Two, 1877–1896: Young's plan backfires because university-educated Mormons develop “extra-ecclesial loyalties” to non-Mormon cultural authorities that “dismantle the ideological framework of Mormon separatism and pave the way for Mormons’ voluntary reimmersion into the mainstream of American life” (28). Act Three, 1896–1920: Mormonism undergoes its own version of the modernist-fundamentalist controversy as theologically conservative leaders in the church and its education system restrict the teaching of evolution and higher criticism. Act Four, 1920–1940: Despite the setback in Act Three, academic out-migration continues, and Mormons with PhDs enjoy “unprecedented” influence in the church (92)—sparking another, more effective, fundamentalist backlash, led by Columbia law school graduate and former U.S. ambassador J. Reuben Clark. By the end of the 1930s, Simpson concludes, Mormons had settled into an “ambivalence … about the American university” (124) that persists to the present: Mormons value the expertise afforded by university education, but the church's fundamentalists periodically reassert and enforce boundaries.
In terms of making original contributions to the history of Mormonism in the United States, the first half of Simpson's study is more significant than the second. The early twentieth-century intellectual conflicts to which Simpson devotes Chapters Three and Four have already been told. Simpson's retelling may be useful for readers who are not specialists in Mormonism, but it is Chapters One and Two that break historical ground. Those chapters are especially significant because Simpson highlights the experiences of women—some of them polygamous wives—who left Utah to earn pioneering degrees in medicine and contributed to a late nineteenth-century flowering of Mormon feminist discourse. It is disappointing that Simpson did not carry his focus on women's experiences through Chapters Three and Four. Simpson points to an early twentieth-century “domestication of Mormon feminism,” when Mormon women shifted from medical studies to the fields of education and “domestic science”—and once they've made that shift, Simpson loses interest in them. “In the twentieth century, the public struggle to define Mormon identity would be a man's game, with women on the sidelines” (54–55). Granted; but even on the sidelines, Mormon women in universities did cultural work that positioned themselves within Mormonism and Mormonism within American society. Since no one is likely, for some time to come, to delve as deeply into these archival materials as Simpson has, it is regrettable that he didn't pay more attention to early twentieth-century Mormon women's experiences while he was in there.
