Introduction: Śiva worship under the Guptas and Vākāṭakas
In a recent important study Alexis Sanderson shows, through detailed analysis, how Śaivism became the dominant Brahmanical religion in the early medieval period (Sanderson Reference Sanderson and Einoo2009). While Sanderson's study is concerned with the post-Gupta period, it is clear that this development did not come out of nowhere. In this paper I will present, by way of a few examples, some of the evidence attesting to the growing influence of Śaivism in the courts of the royal houses of the Gupta-Vākāṭaka age. One of the main questions which this brings up is why and how was the ideology of Viṣṇu as the model of kingship abandoned in favour of the complex character of Śiva?Footnote 1 In the second part I will consider the identity of the kind of Śaivism which flourished in this period.
As is well-known, the Gupta epigraphical records refer to the kings of the Gupta dynasty as paramabhāgavatas, which we can safely assume refers to their personal devotion to Viṣṇu.Footnote 2 However, it is also clear that theirs was not an exclusivist religion, for within the Gupta empire there is abundant evidence for the support of other religions as well, most notably Buddhism, Jainism, and Śaivism. Two Gupta inscriptions in particular are important, because they show the support of Śaivism by prominent members of the Gupta court:
• Karamdanda Inscription of the Reign of Kumāragupta.Footnote 3
On octagonal base of liṅga at Karamdanda (12 miles from Faizabad), dated [Gupta] Saṃvat 117 (= CE 436). Records a gift, on 10th day of Kārttika, by Pṛthivīṣeṇa, Kumāragupta's minister (mantrin), for the worship of Mahādeva Pṛthivīśvara (i.e. his chosen deity); also mentions Mahādeva Śaileśvara.
• Udayagiri Cave Inscription of Candragupta II.Footnote 4
Records excavation of a cave, out of devotion (bhaktyā), for Bhagavat Śambhu by Vīrasena, who came from Pāṭaliputra and was a minister of Candragupta II. The latter is reported to have come to the site with him (rājñaiveha cāgataḥ).
These two records attest to the adoption of Śiva worship by primary members of the Gupta court, while the Udayagiri inscription makes it clear that they were supported in their religious activities by the Gupta kings. On the other hand, no evidence exists to show that any of the Gupta kings themselves favoured Śiva as their iṣṭadevatā. On the contrary, the Bhāgavata faith remained a central characteristic of this royal house.
The situation is significantly different for the Vākāṭakas, their neighbours ruling to the south of the Vindhyas. Members of the dominant, eastern branch of this dynasty were predominantly Maheśvara worshippers, with the noteworthy exception of Rudrasena II and his remarkable Gupta wife Prabhāvatī Guptā, both of whom followed the Bhāgavata faith of her family. Rudrasena I, for example, is standardly referred to in the Vākāṭaka pedigrees as “foremost among the devotees of Lord Mahābhairava” (atyantasvāmimahābhairavabhakta). This is in itself an important piece of evidence for the history of early Śaivism, because it is among the first attestations for the terrifying form of Śiva as Mahābhairava, quite probably referring to a deity housed in a specific temple, as Hans Bakker has argued.Footnote 5 Subsequently the Vākāṭaka rulers used more general royal titles, such as atyantamāheśvara or paramamāheśvara, to express their faith.Footnote 6
The name Śiva itself occurs in connection with the ancestral claim of Rudrasena that he descended from the Bhāraśivas, a “House that was installed by Śiva, who was pleased that its members wore His emblem, the liṅga, placed as a load on their shoulders”.Footnote 7 In inscriptions of Pravarasena II, son of Rudrasena and Prabhāvatī Guptā, we encounter the repeated claim that he “established the Kṛta yuga [on earth] by the grace (prasāda) of Śambhu”.Footnote 8 In the Patna Museum Plate he also claims that he “carried as his weapon the lance by the grace (prasāda) of Śambhu”.Footnote 9 It is interesting to note that the name Śambhu also turns up in one of the new inscriptions uncovered from Mansar, at the site of Pravarasena's royal sanctuary.Footnote 10 Another such fragmentary wall inscription contains the word prasāda (‘grace’),Footnote 11 which once again brings to mind Pravarasena's royal inscriptions. Although these new wall inscriptions are very fragmentary they do give us some insight in the kind of Śaivism followed by Pravarasena, in that they seem to highlight once again the concept of ‘grace of Śambhu’ (śambhuprasāda), a benevolent god who granted Pravarasena the authority to rule.Footnote 12 The fragmentary inscriptions also contain an intriguing reference to the Vedānta, i.e. the doctrine of the Upaniṣads.Footnote 13 In this connection it is noteworthy that it is in the teachings of the Śiva-oriented Śvetāśvatara-Upaniṣad that the concept of grace (prasāda) plays a key role.Footnote 14 In this Vedic text the former outsider Rudra is presented for the first time in a Vedic context as the One God (eko devaḥ) upon whose grace final liberation depends. If we also take into account the fact that the Śvetāśvatara-Upaniṣad is a text associated with the Taittirīya school of the Black Yajurveda and that the copper plate charters of Pravarasena show the king's support of Taittirīya brahmins we can surmise that it was this Vedic school that provided the religious basis for Pravarasena's Śaivism.Footnote 15
Another potential source for tracing the Śiva devotion of Pravarasena and the Vākāṭakas, in addition to the epigraphical and art-historical material, is the Setubandha or Rāvaṇavāha, a Prakrit kāvya attributed to Pravarasena himself. The evidence for this attribution may be inconclusive but it is quite likely that it is a product of the Vākāṭaka period.Footnote 16 Although the subject of the poem – the building of the bridge to Laṅkā – is by definition Vaiṣṇava, it is striking that after first invoking Viṣṇu in four verses, the author continues with four verses dedicated to Śiva. As Handiqui observes, this may well reflect the author's Śaiva leanings: “the emotional fervour of the verses (1.5,7,8) in which he invokes Naṭarāja Śiva might be an indication that, even though he venerated Viṣṇu as Rāma, his iṣṭadevatā was probably Maheśvara in his dancing form”.Footnote 17 More research on this question is needed, but it is not altogether impossible to see in these eight opening verses an allusion to the concept of Harihara,Footnote 18 which would have been particularly apposite in a Vākāṭaka context, because of the support of both Bhāgavatism and Śaivism by this royal house during this transitional period.
To express his devotion to his Lord, Pravarasena built the Pravareśvara temple at the new capital Pravarapura, which has yielded some of the most intriguing and beautiful Śaiva sculptures in existence, including the justly famous ‘Mansar Śiva’.Footnote 19 Given the references to Śambhu in Pravarasena's inscriptions it is tempting to see in this unique image an expression of the concept of Śambhu ‘the Benevolent’.Footnote 20 The name of the temple (devakulasthāna), Pravareśvara, is among the first examples of royal sanctuaries dedicated to a chosen deity (iṣṭadevatā) incorporating the ruler's name. These temples became a characteristic feature of most early medieval kingdoms, in which Śaivism was the norm.
Two Inscriptions from Mandasor
While these records all attest to the royal support of Śiva worship during the Gupta-Vākāṭaka age, they do not show one particular feature of later Śaivism, which, arguably, made it so successful, namely its hierarchical, all-encompassing stance, integrating Brahmanism and Śaivism. Sanderson has supplied much evidence for this attitude in Tantric Śaivism in the early medieval period, but it is also central to early Śaiva Purāṇic literature. We can observe a trend moving in this direction in an inscription from the early sixth century: the ‘Mandasor Stone Inscription of Yaśodharman and Viṣṇuvardhana’, dated Mālava (= Vikrama) Year 589 (= CE 532).Footnote 21 The second benedictory verse reads as follows:
svayambhūr bhūtānāṃ sthitilaya[samu]tpattividhiṣu prayukto
yenājñāṃ vahati bhuvanānāṃ vidhṛtaye |
pitṛtvaṃ cānīto jagati garimāṇaṃ gamayatā sa śambhur
bhūyānsi pratidiśatu bhadrāṇi bhava[tām] ‖
This is translated by Fleet, the editor of the inscription, as follows:
May he, (the god) Śaṁbhu, confer many auspicious gifts upon you, – employed by whom in the rites of (effecting the) continuance and the destruction and the production of (all) things that exist, (the god) Svayaṁbhû, is obedient to (his) commands, for the sake of the maintenance of (all) the worlds; and by whom, leading (him) to dignity in the world, he has been brought to the condition of being the father (of the universe)!Footnote 22
This verse makes, it appears, two central statements:
1. Śaṁbhu employed Svayambhū (= Brahmā) for the tasks of creation, maintenance and reabsorption of the universe;
2. He bestowed ‘fatherhood’ (pitṛtva) upon him, causing him to be respected in the world.
Both statements indicate a hierarchical relationship between the two deities: Śiva is the ultimate master and Brahmā owes his position to him. The second statement requires some comment: while Fleet supplies “of the universe” it is in my opinion more likely that the poet refers here to the Brāhmaṇa myth according to which Prajāpati (here Svayambhū) is the father of Rudra.Footnote 23 While the inscription apparently accepts this father-son relation, it makes Śiva the active agent and thus reinterprets their relation.
The author(s) of the strongly Śaiva Skandapurāṇa, a text datable to the end of the sixth or early seventh centuryFootnote 24 and as such after the period under discussion, went a lot further. In its opening chapters the Skandapurāṇa turns the Brāhmaṇa mythology on its head, for here Brahmā, initially regarding himself as the first being out of ignorance, is made to realise that he is in fact the son of Śiva (SP 3.1–9). It also makes up for the Brāhmaṇa presentation of their relationship, for it tells that Śiva granted Brahmā a boon to be born as his son after he had been propitiated by him (SP 4.1–7). This ‘son’ is not really Śiva himself but a Gaṇa named Nīlalohita Rudra, who chops off Brahmā's fifth arrogant head (SP 4.11–20, 5.22–66). This story shows a significant development in the religious imagination, in which the notion of Śiva's birth from the creator god was not acceptable.Footnote 25
A second example of this process of religious hierarchisation is provided by another inscription from the Mandasor area: the Rīsthal inscription, dated CE 512. This rich inscription contains a wealth of important information on the history of the Aulikaras of Mandasor, but is also relevant for the history of the later Guptas, as Richard Salomon has demonstrated (Salomon Reference Salomon1989). It records, among other things, that Bhagavaddoṣa, the viceroy of Prakāśadharman, “constructed in Daśapura the Prakāśeśvara Temple, the symbol of Bhāratavarṣa” (22). It continues to note that he built, “within that same city, a beautiful shrine of Brahman” (23) but also that he “built a shrine to Kṛṣṇa and one to Bujjuka as a refuge for ascetics who devoted themselves to (the practice of) Sāṃkhya and Yoga” (24).Footnote 26 Although this might be viewed as attesting to Prakāśadharman's tolerant attitudes towards religion in general, it is also clear that a hierarchical order is expressed, for, while the Śaiva temple established for Prakāśeśvara, Prakāśadharman's iṣṭadevatā, is the main object of description and receives extensive praise, to the extent that it is even called ‘the symbol of Bhāratavarṣa’, the shrines to Brahman, Kṛṣṇa and the (probably local deity) Bujjuka, are simply listed as other examples of the numerous religious works performed by him. The incorporation of the royal founder's name as the first element of the name of the temple (X-īśvara) became increasingly characteristic for the building activities of kings in the medieval period and played an important role in the expression of royal ideology.Footnote 27 Prakāśeśvara may stand as an early example of the later royal temples which came to dominate the medieval landscape of India and beyond.
In the aforementioned study ‘The Śaiva Age’ Sanderson identifies five “key elements of the social, political and economic process that characterises the early medieval period”, arguing that Śaivism was so successful in that period because it “legitimated, empowered, or promoted” these elements.Footnote 28 One of these elements is the “multiplication of land-owning temples”, which involves among other things the phenomenon of royal temple building which I have just discussed. Another element is, in his words, “the expansion of the agrarian base through the creation of villages, land reclamation, and the construction of water-reservoirs, wells, and other means of irrigation, with the steady growth in population that these developments imply”.Footnote 29 Now this element also plays a key role in the Rīsthal inscription, for one of the other main activities recorded in this inscription is the construction by Prakāśadharman of “this broad Vibhīṣaṇa Lake, which is a mirror-image of the Bindu Lake, dedicating to his grandfather, King Vibhīṣaṇavardhana, its great meritorious fruit of excellent dignity” (19).Footnote 30 Indeed the two main objects of the inscription are the temple and the lake, as becomes clear in the final verse:
As long as the wind blows, twirling the leaves of the vines and wafting the sweet perfume of the flowers, so long may this beautiful lake and this temple of Śambhu remain, spreading their glories and blocking the path of misfortune. (28)Footnote 31
Thus in this early sixth-century inscription from Mandasor we find some of the quintessential activities of early medieval Śaiva kings referred to. As such it is important to note that the Śaiva kings of medieval India were not introducing a new practice, but were simply following a model that had already been established earlier, as is indicated by this inscription, recording the religious deeds of former feudatories of the Guptas. In fact, as Willis shows at length in his recent book The Archaeology of Ritual, the whole system of land grants and agrarian expansion under land-owning temples effectively starts with the early Guptas.Footnote 32 One crucial element is still missing though: the king's initiation (dīkṣā) into the Śaiva fold by a tantric rājaguru (cf. Sanderson Reference Sanderson and Einoo2009: 254 ff.).Footnote 33 But for that most important element we find in the Rīsthal inscription early medieval Śaiva kingship in a nutshell.
The Pāśupata Movement
As for the question of the kind of Śaivism in existence in the Gupta-Vākāṭaka age, as mentioned there is no evidence as yet of the existence of the tantric form of Śaivism, which involved, among other things, initiation of the king into the tantric fold. The Śaiva Siddhānta tradition was still in its initial stage of development, although the most ancient core of the earliest surviving Śaiva Siddhānta Tantra, the Niśvāsatattvasaṃhitā (still unpublished), has been recently dated to ca. CE 450–550 (Goodall & Isaacson Reference Goodall and Isaacson2007). Instead, for the main agents involved in this period we have to look at the Pāśupatas, an ascetic movement of Śiva worshippers, whose basic text was the Pāśupatasūtra. Its commentary, the Pañcārthabhāṣya by Kauṇḍinya, may well stem from the Gupta period.
On the other hand, the precise identity of the Pāśupatas remains a complex topic. First of all there is the issue of Lakulīśa. In scholarly literature it is generally held that Lakulīśa, an incarnation of Śiva, was the historical founder of the Pāśupata movement and that he lived sometime in the second century CE. This view mainly rests on the famous Mathurā Pillar Inscription of Candragupta II, dated [Gupta] Saṃvat 61 = CE 380.Footnote 34 However, in fact there is no mention of the name Lakulīśa in that inscription nor of the term Pāśupata. What we do get is a lineage of teachers (ācāryas), the tenth of which is a certain Uditācārya, the donee mentioned in the inscription, who trace their origins back to Bhagavat Kuśika. This Kuśika is usually identified with the first of the four pupils of Lakulīśa. However, we have no evidence that the notion of Lakulīśa as an incarnation of Śiva existed at the time. The name Lakulīśa, or a variant of it, is attested for the first time only around the sixth century,Footnote 35 while the earliest images seem to stem from about the same period. Moreover, the inscription makes no direct reference to Pāśupatas but only to Māheśvaras, who are asked to do worship (pūjā) in the ‘teacher's shrine’ (gurvāyatane). One of the intriguing aspects of the inscription is that it refers to some of the ācāryas mentioned as the ‘spotless students’ (vimalaśiṣya) of their own preceptor. This indicates first of all a fascination with an unbroken lineage of teachers, which remains characteristic for all forms of later Śaivism, but also, in stressing the word ‘spotless’ (vimala), a possible connection with the mysterious Vaimalas (‘followers of the Spotless one’), who are sometimes mentioned as a group of Pāśupatas in Śaiva tantric sources.Footnote 36
It is evident that much remains to be done on the Mathurā Pillar Inscription.Footnote 37 In a recent article, Diwakar Acharya has suggested a new reading of the crucial last line, proposing to read caṇḍa instead of Bhandarkar's daṇḍa:
jayati ca bhagavā[ñ caṇḍaḥ] rudradaṇḍo [']gra[nā]yako nitya[ṃ] Footnote 38
And always victorious is Lord Caṇḍa, [he who is] the rod of Rudra,Footnote 39 the foremost leader [of the Gaṇas].
As Acharya argues, this is relevant for the interpretation of the figure depicted on the pillar in front of the triśūla. Rather than it being a representation of an unknown deity Daṇḍa, as earlier scholars have taken it, he argues that it may in fact represent an early pre-Lakulīśa Pāśupata deity Caṇḍa, also known as Caṇḍeśa.Footnote 40 The figure of Caṇḍeśa itself has been put into a new light more recently by Dominic Goodall, in an article called ‘Who is Caṇḍeśa?’ (Goodall Reference Goodall and Einoo2009), where he shows that, contrary to what has long been supposed, Caṇḍeśa is not exclusively a Śaiva Siddhānta deity from the Tamil-speaking South of India, but has a more complex historical origin, independent from Śaiva Siddhānta and not confined to Tamil Nadu. This again has a bearing on the interpretation of images of Lakulīśa, for given the potential for confusion between the two, as is convincingly shown by the studies of Acharya and Goodall, some of the images so far identified as Lakulīśa may in fact represent Caṇḍeśa instead. A possible Gupta example of this is a loose image from Nāchnā in Madhya Pradesh, which Joanna Williams in her The Art of Gupta India identifies as Lakulīśa, but for which, given that the main attribute is clearly an axe and not a club, an identification of Caṇḍeśa may be more appropriate.Footnote 41
In a way the issue concerning the identity of the deity Caṇḍeśa is illustrative of a larger and complex subject, namely the still little-understood variety of Pāśupata and Māheśvara worship in this period. While there has been a tendency in scholarly literature to narrowly identify the Pāśupata cult with the religious system of the sādhaka outlined in Kauṇḍinya's commentary on the Pāśupatasūtra, this in fact represents only one element of the tradition. The Pāśupata system as outlined by Kauṇḍinya involves a lifelong career of extreme asceticism, which is hard to reconcile with other early references to Pāśupatas, in particular epigraphical records. Thus, for example, the earliest explicit epigraphical references to Pāśupatas that we possess are at the same time among the earliest examples of copper-plate grants recording endowments for temple worship. These are the copper plates from Bāgh, which record the land grants given by the mahārājas of the Valkhās, who were very probably subordinates of the Guptas. The inscriptions themselves stem from the second half of the fourth century. Seven copper plates in total in this collection refer to Pāśupatas as recipients of grants for the performance of worship in temples (Nos. III, V, VI, IX, X, XII, XIV).Footnote 42 Other religious communities are mentioned as recipients of these grants as well.Footnote 43 The deities under worship are not limited to the figure of Śiva alone, however, for among the names of gods to whom the grants were dedicated we encounter Nārāyaṇadeva (no. III), Mahāsenadeva (i.e. Skanda; no. IX) and Bappapiśācadeva (nos. V, VI, XII and XIV). The last one, perhaps a local form of Śiva, seems to be connected with the Pāśupatas in particular, as in two of the grants (nos. V and VI) only the Pāśupatas are mentioned as recipients. One of the grants (no. X) also records that a shrine to the Mothers (mātṛsthānadevakula) had been established by the Pāśupatācārya Lokodadhi in the village of Piñcchikānaka.
What these grants show is that not all Pāśupatas followed the rigorous ascetic system of Kauṇḍinya, but that there were others who served the needs of a larger, lay Śaiva community. The mention of Nārāyaṇadeva among the gods worshipped moreover suggests that they could also fulfill priestly services in temples dedicated to non-Śaiva deities. The Pāśupata career outlined in the scholastic work of Kauṇḍinya, with its emphasis on lifelong asceticism, as such only represents one strand in a larger, complex religious field. In fact Kauṇḍinya's system itself clearly requires the existence of such ācāryas, who by definition can not themselves be engaged in the kinds of activities that the sādhaka has to perform on the stages of the Pāśupata path to liberation. Likewise there would have been a community also of those who have faith in such Pāśupata ācāryas and in the Pāśupata teaching, but who are tied to their own lives and can not take the large step of renunciation and consequent adherence to the Pāśupata sādhaka's rules.Footnote 44 As such one may conceive of a Pāśupata community consisting of three segments: 1) ācāryas (such as Kauṇḍinya himself), 2) sādhakas (practicing the system outlined in the Pāśupatasūtra and Kauṇḍinya's commentary thereon), and 3) a community of the faithful (consisting of uninitiated, non-ascetic supporters/devotees).Footnote 45 For information on the third segment one has to look at more popular texts, such as the Skandapurāṇa, but in particular at the various texts which together make up the Śivadharma corpus. These texts, such as the Śivadharmaśāstra, the Śivadharmottara and the Śiva-Upaniṣad, are still much neglected, with the larger part of this corpus not having been properly edited.Footnote 46 In addition, Diwakar Acharya has recently discovered a number of Pāśupata manuals (vidhis), which likewise hint at a more diverse Pāśupata religious milieu, involving both an ascetic and a lay community.Footnote 47
Interaction with non-Śaiva traditions
The division into ascetic and lay community calls to mind the religious traditions of Buddhism and Jainism, where such a division was already in place for a longer time. It may well be that the Śaivas modelled themselves on these traditions, although we have no direct evidence for this. It is striking, however, that the iconography and life-story of Lakulīśa and the Buddha have shared characteristics. Both icons depict a human being in a seated posture, possessed of various divine or auspicious attributes. But for the distinctive features of the erect penis, the club and the matted hair, there is a strong resemblance between early depictions of Lakulīśa and the Buddha, which suggests that Buddhist (but possibly also Jain iconography) had a big impact in this formative period on the iconography of Lakulīśa. When we look at the life-story of Lakulīśa, the most striking feature is its emphasis on the humanity of God's descent. This is not a cosmic type of avatāra, as tends to be the case with the avatāras of Viṣṇu, but it is the story of a God taking on human form, who wanders from place to place, initiates his four pupils at different places in the north of India and instructs them in His (Paśupati's) teachings. This conjures up the image of the Buddha wandering through Magadha. The similarity may not have escaped the Pāśupatas themselves, for in a late passage of the Skandapurāṇa mention is made of Lakulīśa's (laguḍīśvara) wanderings, surrounded by his pupils, in Magadha. Eight sites (aṣṭau sthānāni) in Magadha are said to be connected with these wanderings, which once again brings to mind a Buddhist tradition, namely the eight great sites (aṣṭamahāsthāna) of the Buddha's life story.Footnote 48
That there should be such an interaction between these traditions in this period should not come as a surpise. It is noteworthy, for example, that some of the major Pāśupata sites are also places with a strong Buddhist connection. As examples may be mentioned the two cases just discussed, Mathurā and Bāgh,Footnote 49 but also Vārāṇasī, arguably one of the most important Śaiva places of all time, which is not too far from the Buddhist site of Sārnāth. Anyone reading Hsiuen-Tsang's travelogue cannot fail to note the constant references to Pāśupatas whom the Buddhist pilgrim encounters on his travels through seventh-century India.Footnote 50 The evidence is not limited to iconography and topography, but there is textual evidence as well, for one of the earliest quotations of the Pāśupatasūtra itself occurs in a Buddhist work, Bhā(va)viveka's Mādhyamakahṛdayakārikā.Footnote 51 The name of the author itself, it may be noted, could hint at a possible earlier Pāśupata background, for names with Bhā-x or Bhāva-x are very common among Pāśupatas.Footnote 52 In any case, it is intriguing that this sixth-century Buddhist author had access to the Pāśupatasūtra, an esoteric text in principle meant only for an initiated community of sādhakas. It certainly indicates the extensive exchange that took place between these different religious traditions during the period under discussion.
