This book takes its title from a well-known episode in the history of mathematics: the duel in 1832 that ultimately claimed the life of the twenty-year-old French mathematical prodigy Evariste Galois. Galois's short life – and the difficulties he experienced in trying to secure a fair hearing for his novel algebraic approach to the problem of solving algebraic equations by radicals – has long been the stuff of mathematical legend and storytelling. It is a tragic and dramatic tale that has served to humanize and dramatize a field that, to the layperson, seems neither human nor dramatic.
At its best, this book examines the genre of mathematical biography in the context of a handful of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century figures – Jean d'Alembert, Galois, Niels Henrik Abel, Augustin-Louis Cauchy and János Bolyai – and traces how their life stories have evolved in the telling over time. The reader gains insights, for example, into the making of the myth of Galois, the tragic genius who was rebuffed by the gatekeepers of mathematical Paris, as well as into the fashioning of the outer public and inner private personae of Cauchy. That said, it is sometimes difficult to determine when the interpretation of the life is that of a bygone biographer and when it is that of Alexander himself extrapolating a narrative for his own purposes from those of his predecessors. For example, after an analysis of a number of accounts of Galois's life, the culminating Galois is presented in rather purple-tinged prose as ‘the true genius who through his sufferings had become the patron saint of mathematics’ and ‘the embodiment of the true mathematical life – wholly immersed in a world of beauty and perfection, forever a stranger in the midst of mortals’ (p. 102). Similarly, the Bolyai that emerges ‘was a dramatic representative of the new mathematical persona. For if mathematics is a self-contained world of truth and beauty, then those who seek it out are brave and true souls, willing to risk all for a glimpse of this pure realm’ (p. 236).
These poetic, romanticized visions are, however, exactly what unite this particular cast of nineteenth-century characters. In Duel at Dawn, Alexander argues that the cultural shift that produced high Romanticism in the opening decades of the nineteenth century resulted not only in a new, widely shared image of the mathematician as a martyr, but also in a ‘modern’ approach to and understanding of mathematics. In the eighteenth century, personified here by d'Alembert, mathematicians were ‘natural’ men, who pursued mathematics in an effort to understand the mathematical order embedded in nature. Eighteenth-century mathematicians thus did ‘natural’ or, in more modern parlance, ‘applied’ mathematics, which Alexander illustrates with, among others, the seventeenth-century example of Johann Bernoulli's work on the catenary. In the nineteenth century, however, the Romantic world view recast the mathematician as the loner, the martyr, who pursued mathematics divorced from nature, as a field of inquiry sufficient unto itself, and in a new highly abstract and logically precise style exemplified by Galois's theory of equations and Bolyai's non-Euclidean geometry. Over the course of the nineteenth century, Alexander claims, ‘the vision of a self-contained mathematical universe freed from our material world was inseparable from a vision of the mathematician as a seeker of sublime truth, at home in the rarefied world of mathematics but unsuited for life in the crass world of men’ (pp. 14–15).
In Duel at Dawn, Alexander has turned the same sort of analysis on the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries that he applied to the sixteenth century in his earlier book, Geometrical Landscapes: The Voyages of Discovery and the Transformation of Mathematical Practice (2002). While this type of argumentation is highly suggestive and thought-provoking, it may ultimately leave the reader unconvinced of the tight connections and cause-and-effect relationships it seeks establish on the basis of what is ultimately a limited number of very special cases.
