This volume is the sixth instalment of the Skandapurāṇa: Supplement to Groningen Oriental Studies series, and the first since Brill has taken over the series from the Groningen-based Egbert Forsten. There is, happily, no noticeable difference in the high quality and careful editing to distinguish it from the earlier volumes in this series, one which comprises some two decades of research on the Skandapurāṇa in the ongoing preparation of its critical edition. This volume features more colour illustrations than the earlier volumes, along with maps that are now courtesy of Google Earth.
The present volume is presented in two parts. In the first, “The World of Power”, the author paints a picture of the political landscape of northern India from roughly 500–700 ce. Though hesitant about making claims that exceed available hard evidence, the author nonetheless makes a compelling case throughout the book for linking the composition of the Skandapurāṇa to the reign of king Harṣa, who had by the start of the seventh century reclaimed the prized city of Varanasi and restored the empire at Kanauj to glory, ruling for nearly half a century. Indeed, Harṣa's prominence may in part explain why this staunchly Śaiva text is named after the god Skanda and not Śiva: a young Harṣa – before he was crowned king – being anointed commander of the coalition that defeated the Gauḍa king Śaśāṅka (“Moon”) was seen in the literary imagination of the day to parallel Skanda commanding the army of the gods against the demon Tāraka (“Star”) (pp. 17–18; pp. 161–165).
Part I moves chronologically, from the disintegration of the Gupta empire, to the rise of the Maukharis in Kanauj and their defeat, to the reclamation of the Kanauj-based empire by Harṣa and, followed by his steady extension and strengthening of it. This is a thoroughly researched and updated dynastic history, incorporating evidence from inscriptions, archaeological finds, and literary references in reconstructing an impressively detailed and lively historical narrative. During the course of this, a number of welcome new observations and hypotheses are offered; this research will interest historians of a wide range of regional specializations, covering as it does the considerable geographical scope of the Skandapurāṇa, encompassing much of the northern part of the subcontinent.
In Part II, “The World of Culture,” the mytho-geographical focus of the Skandapurāṇa comes to the fore. A chapter comparing the Skandapurāṇa with Bāṇa's Harṣacarita shows how both the poet Bāṇa and his subject, king Harṣa, are tied to the local lineage mythologies of the Thanesar/Kurukṣetra region, which is the subject of the first of the many place-encomiums (māhātmyas) that comprise the Skandapurāṇa text (155-172). The other chapters of Part II are for the most part close historical studies of sites whose mythologies are mapped in the Skandapurāṇa. The text locates the mythical sacrifice of Dakṣa, for example, at a location near Hardwar which we learn was home to several ancient sacred sites that had been appropriated by Śaivas by the sixth century. The methodological approach in Part II combining epigraphic and architectural observations with close readings of the relevant Skandapurāṇa narratives, is executed meticulously. Rather than relying solely on old reports, the author has personally re-examined and revisited most of the inscriptions and sites detailed.
Unifying the volume is the developing conviction that the Skandapurāṇa was a project of the Pāśupatas, composed for the purpose of weaving the sacred geography of northern India into a grand Śaiva narrative (p. 137). With the Purāṇa, the Pāśupatas effectively aggregated a diverse range of religious sites in northern India and beyond into a transregional Śaiva network, with Varanasi – the likely site of the text's composition – as the central hub. In this the author acknowledges a crucial change in his earlier thinking about the Pāśupatas, now allowing, in keeping with recent research, that the sect was not a marginal group of ascetics whose only known text is the philosophical tract, the Pāśupatasūtra, but was rather a “composite movement” representing a “broad religious community of Śaivas”. (pp. 139–140)
If anything, this volume understates its central but only tentatively articulated argument: that the Skandapurāṇa was the signature literary project of a Pāśupata movement which had become the most influential religious group of the time. By the sixth century, Pāśupatas had effectively usurped the sacred landscape of much of the subcontinent and had become intimately tied to royal power. Indeed, the Skandapurāṇa emerges just on the cusp of what Alexis Sanderson has rightfully dubbed the “Śaiva Age”; though this has been discussed with only passing acknowledgement of the Śaiva Purāṇas, likely the most popular and widespread of Śaiva texts, and of which the Skanda was almost certainly the first.
While this landmark study provides the deepest insights into the Skandapurāṇa to date, it raises a great deal more questions, as our deepening knowledge of this text continues to challenge our notions of early Śaivism. How does the Pāśupata-constructed Śaivism of the Skandapurāṇa relate to the early Tantric Śaivism of the Niśvāsatattva corpus, the genesis of which might be roughly contemporaneous with the Skandapurāṇa (9 n. 36)? Were the Pāśupatas linked to the “Śaivism-for-householders” corpus of texts known as the Śivadharma, another incredibly important set of early Śaiva texts which are only just beginning to receive the attention of scholars (p.10)? What again became of the Pāśupata terrestrial and textual networks when the later exoteric Śaivism of the Siddhānta, and the corresponding (and often competing) esoteric traditions of the Kaula, Krama emerged? These and similar questions linger over the present volume, and as research on the Skandapurāṇa and other Śaiva sites and texts continues to develop, more answers will be no doubt be forthcoming.
The tremendous value of this volume – and of the entire Skandapurāṇa project – cannot be understated: it is a model of thorough and sober scholarship on this fascinating and tremendously important text. A project of this magnitude and quality is sure to enrich Indological scholarship for generations to come.
