This book is a powerful examination of the politics that emerge around missing persons in the aftermath of political violence. Jenny Edkins drops hints about her theoretical interlocutors—including Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Ranciere, Elaine Scarry, Judith Butler, and Michel Foucault—but the theoretical influences take a back seat to the stories she tells about the search for the missing across a range of cases. Her central argument critiques the ways that “personhood is regularly produced under current forms of political order in the West, a politics that misses the person, a politics that objectifies and instrumentalizes,” a “politics that misses the person” (p. 2). In turn, she seeks to give life to the stories of those who highlight the singularity of our ethical and political responsibilities, a “politics of the person as missing” (p. 2). The result is an engaging text that illuminates its central argument by showing rather than telling, demonstrating with great force the dangers of the depersonalization, and depoliticization, of human life.
Edkins begins with a personal narrative about stories of displaced persons in United Nations archives. The anecdote sets the tone for the rest of Missing, bringing back to life the lost stories of missing persons and those who search for them. She describes her motivation as anger about how “prevalent forms of political or biopolitical governance both objectify and instrumentalize the person…. [T]hey treat people as objects to be governed” (p. viii). The argument draws from Agamben's critique of the politics of bare life (See Agamben, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life, 1998), in which the person is stripped of significance and becomes a mere object, a life “with no political voice” (p. 132). While this idea has been explored extensively in spectacular displays of state power, such as the torture of enemy combatants or in concentration camps, Edkins looks to the more quotidian ways that missing persons are objectified and transformed into objects through ordinary state practices of categorizing, prioritizing, and rationalizing the search for the missing. The text ranges from an examination of post-9/11 recovery efforts, the search for missing and displaced persons in the aftermath of World War II, the “disappeared” in Argentina, and the case of the deliberately missing.
In each narrative, Edkins moves back and forth between the efforts of the government to impose an order on the missing (and the living) and the attempts by those searching for the missing to make sense of their absence. The first example on which the author draws to highlight this tension is Manhattan in the aftermath of the 9/11 disaster. She explores the images of those who were searching for their loved ones, describing in careful detail everything from individual flyers produced by families to public memories. Central to the production of memory was contestation about the meaning of the tragedy, the treatment of the debris, and the co-optation of the memory of the missing. For example, the Not in My Name campaign protested the utilization of the memory of 9/11 and its victims to justify military actions (pp. 32–33).
In another powerful example, Edkins explores the aftermath of the London bombings in 2005 in which the government prioritized the identification of the bombers and other suspected terrorists “to establish order and control rather than to communicate with those missing their relatives” (p. 86). As a consequence, the missing became secondary to the security goals of the state. She contrasts this with the process of the eventual inquests in which witnesses gave detailed accounts of the day, narrating the final moments of the individuals lost. Against the depersonalization that enabled the terrorists to murder anonymous unknown individuals and that enabled the state to deprioritize the importance of the loss of individuals, these stories bring to the fore the importance of what Edkins calls “persons-as-such” as a means of challenging the ability to engage in acts of violence against those individuals.
In the midst of these moving stories, the author focuses on details that are both fascinating on their face and devastating in light of her overall argument, moving between the governance concerns of the state and the sense of loss of the survivors. However, she finds some hope in these stories, often examining how those who engaged in acts of resistance politicized the process and challenged the reduction of persons to things. She identifies women as often being key agents of repersonalization because of their roles in relation to the missing. In the case of postwar repatriation, Edkins notes that women who were working on the ground with refugees were often the ones who helped to establish a tracing bureau that could help locate missing family members. Even as the state was centrally concerned with questions of identifying enemy nationals, for instance, women were seeking to reunite missing families, establish the fate of missing family members, and bear witness to the crimes of the war. In the case of Argentina, she focuses on the Madres of the Plaza de Mayo, who organized a political movement around publicizing the disappearance of political dissidents by appealing to their roles as grieving family members.
The book's conclusions echo a range of literatures through a concrete examination of specific events, although Edkins focuses on examples rather than allowing the stories to vanish behind abstract theory. Her work will resonate with feminist scholars who have emphasized the importance of the concrete other, and it also contributes to the growing literature on the politics of memory and mourning. Her work also echoes the concerns of authors interested in the relationship between an ethics of singularity and politics, such as Emmanuel Levinas and Jacques Derrida. Though contributing to a rich theoretical literature, Missing is accessible and readable even for those less versed in political theory.
While the narrative is compelling, the ultimate conclusion about the politics of the person as missing should draw greater engagement from theorists as Edkins clearly articulates a broader vision for political engagement. As she argues about the Madres, “The demand for the reappearance of the disappeared is not just a demand for the tracing of the missing or for a determination of their fate. Rather it is a protest against the injustice of the disappearances and demand that the disappeared be restored to their existence as fully political beings—beings who lived lives, fought political battles, had children and families” (p. 174). She suggests that these political struggles are on behalf of a “new politics,” though her narrative, which demonstrates the repetition of processes of depersonalization and resistance, indicates how intractable the “politics that misses the person” seems to be (p. 2).
Edkins's title suggests that it is not only persons but politics that have gone missing, although she finds politics not in transformative political struggles that might end these processes but, instead, in the small acts of resistance in particular moments generated by incredible loss. This vision of politics may be as dark as the narrative itself, calling for a constant vigilance in the face of what seems to be inescapable tragedy. Thus, while the text strongly conveys the dangers of missing the person, its political vision can seem small and limited in the shadow of the violence it seeks to confront.
