This book brings together and reinforces ideas about the relationship between overseas trade and English economic development in the late seventeenth century that its author has been articulating in articles and essays for some years. It draws on an impressive range of printed contemporary writings as well as of manuscript sources to underpin its arguments. The focal point of the study is London, which, as Frederick J. Fisher and Ralph Davis noted half a century ago, dominated English overseas trade in the seventeenth century and, more particularly, was the driving force behind the growth of English colonial endeavours and related colonial and reexport trades between the 1640s and the early eighteenth century. Unlike Fisher and Davis, who largely focused on tracking trade patterns, Nuala Zahedieh, is more concerned to explore linkages between colonialism, trade, and economic change in England, and in this respect, her book falls more in the tradition of scholarship identified with Eric Williams and more recently underscored by Joseph Inikori. Zahedieh is more cautious than Williams and Inikori in attributing economic change in England from the late seventeenth century to slavery and colonialism. But she is in little doubt that, in reacting to the commercial opportunities created by colonial enterprise in the Americas, English merchants in general and London merchants in particular became important agents for change in English society after 1650. In her view, their endeavours reduced and even eliminated the productivity advantages in trade and shipping that the Dutch held in the mid-seventeenth century and in doing so offset many of the costs of the state-imposed mercantilist system and laid some of the foundations for the British Industrial Revolution.
The book is formally organized around chapters on merchants, shipping, exports, and imports, but at the heart of Zahedieh's discussion is a database of London merchants as well as their import and export activities for 1686. This is based on the London port books for that year. Those who know the port books will recognize the construction of such a database as being a remarkable and time-consuming achievement. When combined with other evidence, it allows her to trace the careers and patterns of activity of individual merchants while simultaneously locating them within the broader London community of colonial traders. In the period under discussion, London's colonial American trades were more open to entry than most other areas of English overseas trade, and while trade with the colonies was dominated by a core group of large merchants, as Zahedieh shows, it still remained competitive and risky, challenging the adaptive capacity of those who invested in it and encouraging innovation in commercial practice and marketing strategies that had long-term advantages for the English economy. In this respect, and in a challenge to so-called “small ratios” arguments, Zahedieh sees colonial trades as providing an impetus to economic change well beyond their specific share of English overseas trade or national income. Among other things, she sees the long-distance character of colonial trade as providing disproportionate gains to shipbuilding, insurance, and other service industries in England. She sees markets in the West Indies and mainland North America as providing exceptional opportunities for the diversification of home-produced exports away from woollens, anticipating changes more commonly identified with the eighteenth century. Above all, she sees the rate of growth of London's colonial trades and broad compliance with the navigation laws that surrounded it as prima facie evidence of improvements in productivity of London-inspired English commercial practice and shipping relative to the Dutch, thereby encouraging her to question Adam Smith's depiction of the navigation laws as a burden on the English economy. She does acknowledge, however, a slowing of the pace of growth of London colonial trade after the Glorious Revolution of 1689, attributing this largely to the effects of the revolutionary settlement on political rent-seeking and other forms of enterprise, but such developments do not detract in her mind from the positive and creative long-run impact of colonial trades before 1689 on the English economy.
This is both an impressively researched and contentious book. It deploys institutional approaches to studying productivity gains in English transatlantic trade, while also challenging the emphasis that some institutional economists (such as Douglass C. North and Barry R. Weingast, “Constitutions and Commitments: The Evolution of Institutions Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth-Century in England” in this JOURNAL 49, no. 4 [1989]: 803–32) have placed on the Glorious Revolution in spurring change and economic prosperity in Britain. It reasserts the importance of mercantilism and empire and, by implication, slavery to British development by linking them to domestic enterprise and seeking to trace the roots of such linkages to the seventeenth century. Some historians will doubtless remain sceptical of the weight Zahedieh places on such arguments, particularly given her reliance on qualitative rather than quantitative evidence on productivity growth in English colonial trade before 1700 relative to other nations, notably the Dutch. But all historians of English overseas trade should be fascinated by her analysis of the composition and structure of London's colonial trading community in the later seventeenth century. This rightly occupies center stage in her book and, regardless of the broader arguments about London enterprise and English economic change that she seeks to build on it, that analysis is likely to be a major and lasting contribution to the study of the English Atlantic world in the early modern period.
