Historian Robert Kramer's Holy City on the Nile narrates the emergence of the Mahdist capital Omdurman between 1885 and the Anglo-Egyptian conquest of 1898. Terming this period the “Omdurman experience,” Kramer characterizes it as one of rapid urbanization, centralization, and religious indoctrination (p. ix). His main goal in Holy City, however, is to illustrate the ways in which self-identified “Arabs” came to see Omdurman as a holy city (p. vii). Kramer's work builds on historian P. M. Holt's 1958 The Mahdist State in the Sudan (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958), shifting attention from Holt's emphasis on Mahdist political developments to the everyday experiences of Omdurman's inhabitants. Drawing on a substantial body of secondary literature, archival materials from Sudan and Great Britain, and oral interviews (undertaken in the 1980s) with men who lived in Mahdist Omdurman, Kramer presents the Mahdists and the city they established as products of both continuity and change. Kramer's main argument is that the Mahdists drew on the governing strategies of the Funj and Ottoman-Egyptian states that preceded them while at the same time creating new cultural idioms and governing strategies. He uses Omdurman as the context in which to discuss those symbols and tactics and to illustrate the processes through which they were forged and applied. Life in the Mahdists’ Holy City, he suggests, involved activities that were made holy or purged of their mundane qualities through Mahdist teachings and proclamations.
Kramer presents Holy City on the Nile in five topically organized chapters. The opening chapter is a genial portrayal of the history of the region that is now Sudan through a survey of its towns, showing how administrative and economic functions were managed by various short- and long-lived states from the 16th through the 19th centuries. Kramer's focus on Sudanese trading and administrative centers sets him up nicely for his later portrayals of life in Omdurman. In Chapter 2, Kramer narrates the creation and establishment of the Mahdist capital, highlighting its transformation from a military garrison in 1884 to a bustling administrative and economic center by the eve of the Anglo-Egyptian invasion. Kramer also provides attention in this chapter to Omdurman as a city of immigrants, showing how Khalifa ʿAbdullah (r. 1885–1991) forced settlement in the city after 1885. As Mahdist doctrine replaced hajj in the devotional experience of the region's Muslim inhabitants with hijra to Omdurman, the city emerged as both a holy place and a cosmopolitan city.
In his chapter on the Mahdist government (Chap. 3), Kramer takes up two topics in particular. The first is the circumstances under which Khalifa ʿAbdullah and his retinue adopted Ottoman-Egyptian governing practices as they transitioned their movement from a rebellion to a governing power. Kramer pays keen attention to the ways in which the Khalifa justified reliance on Ottoman-Egyptian practices and to the manner in which the governing methods of the “Turkiyya” were gradually made Mahdist. The second topic is the limitation of Khalifa ʿAbdullah's power. Here Kramer takes aim at British colonial accounts of the absolute nature of Mahdist rule, representing Khalifa ʿAbdullah as a pragmatic ruler who often gave in to familial pressures and cultural norms.
Chapters 4 and 5, the final chapters of the book, constitute the most masterful sections of Holy City. Kramer demonstrates how Mahdist teachings and proclamations were put into practice by the state and then negotiated, adopted, and resisted by the populace. In addition, Kramer takes great pains to demonstrate how the city was organized and to illustrate how inhabitants of Omdurman intermingled and intermarried, defying what Europeans had once described as a city of rigid ethnic and tribal divisions. Evoking his portrayal of Sudanese towns from Chapter 1, Kramer deftly represents Omdurman as city of many functions: political, economic, and religious.
The strengths of Holy City on the Nile lie in Kramer's solid research and in the detailed portrayal of life in the Mahdist city. The varied snapshots of the years between 1885 and 1898 that emerge from the book's pages will appeal to students of the Mahdiyya, the Mahdist government, and the various states and nationalist movements that came after them. The book is engaging and well written and will find an appreciative audience in students and specialists alike.
This work is strong on narrative detail, but it is lacking in historiography. While Kramer draws on a substantial body of secondary sources, for example, he offers no historiographical context within which the reader might place this study. In his acknowledgements, Kramer mentions his debt to P. M. Holt and several other luminaries in Sudanese history. He offers no links, however, between his book and greater trends or debates in the field. Given Kramer's claims about Mahdist reliance upon Ottoman-Egyptian administrative structures, how might we place Holy City in relation to works that present the Mahdiyya as a rebellion against foreign rule? The preface lacks a literature review, and the chapters are absent of any introductory or concluding suggestions about how the research should be situated.
Similarly, Kramer offers no theoretical framework within which the reader might engage his materials. Is this an urban history? Is it a book about what happens when reform movements become governments? Kramer indicates that the contents of his book should claim the attention of historians and other scholars, because “since the events of September 11, 2001, their importance seems to resonate more broadly and urgently” (p. vii). Why might this be so? Is Holy City on the Nile a cautionary tale about what happens when Islamic reformers take over? Kramer offers no explanations.
In addition, in his assertion that self-identified Arabs came to regard the city as holy, Kramer misses an opportunity to discuss race and the ways in which it has been constructed and remembered in Sudan (p. viii). He fails to tell us, for example, what Arab might have meant either at the time of Omdurman's establishment or at the end of thirteen years of ethnic and tribal intermingling. The reader is left to wonder about whom among the Mahdists identified as Arab and about what identifying as Arab meant in a late 19th-century Mahdist city (p. viii). His conclusion that Omdurman emerged as a city in which Arab had become the norm flies in the face of his rich portrayal of the city's substantial diversity (pp. 161–62). While offering suggestions about the widespread adoption of Mahdist Islam, intermarriage between Mahdists of differing ethnicities, and the intermingling of various linguistic dialects, Kramer does not present a convincing portrayal of cultural homogenization. Indeed, the book as a study in diversity has much more to recommend it than does the author's claim that Omdurman society was epitomized by the “Arabic culture of the Mahdiyya” (p. 162).
