Some rare works of fiction have had a profound social and political impact. For instance, Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Julie (1761) and Émile (1762) were major catalysts of Romanticism, Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852) helped supercharge the abolitionist movement, and the Victorian-era novels of Charles Dickens stirred widespread empathy for the poor and downtrodden. The wildly popular Harry Potter novels of J. K. Rowling may well fall in this category. Rowling has described her series of novels as “a prolonged argument for tolerance, a prolonged plea for an end of bigotry.” For tens of millions of young readers, the Potter books have been a powerful moral voice for the values of equality, diversity, antihierarchicalism, inclusion, and multiculturalism.
The Potter books and films have, of course, generated reams of scholarly and popular commentary. Books have appeared exploring connections between the Potterverse and philosophy, religion, psychology, science, history, and international relations. Not surprisingly, several works have delved into the politics of Harry Potter, including Bethany Barratt's The Politics of Harry Potter (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012) and Rubén Jarazo-Álvarez and Pilar Alderete-Diez's Cultural Politics in Harry Potter (Routledge, 2019). John S. Nelson's Defenses against the Dark Arts offers a new and interesting take on the political dimensions of the Potter books and films.
Rowling has described the novels as “a political metaphor,” and the political themes in the books are indeed obvious and pervasive. At its most basic level, the Potter stories are about a failed coup attempt by a group of twisted Nazi-like racial supremacists bent on world domination. These plotters are successfully opposed by a rainbow coalition of improbable heroes and misfits united in their Dumbledorian dignitarian faith that “it matters not what someone is born, but what they grow to be.” Throughout the books, Rowling preaches the values of tolerance, acceptance, and equal inherent dignity, and opposes the those of hierarchicalism, authoritarianism, bigotry, and exclusion.
Nelson, a professor of political theory and communication at the University of Iowa, has written widely on the intersections of politics with movies, Westerns, and other forms of popular culture. In Defenses against the Dark Arts he displays an impressive grasp of the Potter books and literature, and offers a good deal of insightful commentary on their political resonances as seen through the lenses of liberalism, socialism, totalitarianism, conservatism, anarchism, populism, perfectionist politics, and other ideologies.
The book is divided into two general parts. In part 1 (“Pottery”), Nelson argues that the Potter tales offer strategies for combating dark arts in dark times and that there are striking parallels between Harry's world and ours. In part 2 (“Polity”), Nelson analyzes each of the seven books in turn through the prism of a wide array of political ideologies, movements, and styles. Throughout his analysis, he draws on an impressive range of sources, though oddly he rarely quotes from Rowling's own wide-ranging comments on the political aspects of her work.
The Potter books can be a kind of Rorschach test that often reveals more about the preconceptions of the reader than it does about the text. Agenda-driven readings abound in the secondary literature. Nelson's hobby horse is that everything is ultimately about politics. This is an interpretive grid that sometimes leads him to strained readings. In truth, the Potter stories are about many things (friendship, loyalty, death, faith, courage, love, respect, personal growth, to name a few) that are at most only tangentially related to politics.
Nelson's discussion of environmental themes in the Potter novels is a case in point. Nelson claims that Hagrid's care for nonhuman creatures reflects a “deep ecology” (179) view of nature. This is supposedly because deep ecologists believe that all living things have intrinsic value and deserve moral consideration and respect. Deep ecologists certainly do believe that, as do most contemporary environmentalists. But Hagrid is no deep ecologist. He is a gamekeeper who shoots wild animals with a crossbow, carries sausages in his pockets, hangs gamebirds from the rafters of his shack, serves up “beef” dishes with talons in them, and owns a huge hunting dog named Fang. Deep ecologists, in fact, are thoroughgoing nonanthropocentrists who hold far more radical environmental views than Hagrid or any other character in the Potter stories.
Despite such lapses, Nelson's book is timely and shines a useful light on the challenges of contemporary politics. The early Potter volumes were published in the 1990s, when many prophesied an “end of history” and the permanent triumph of Western liberal democracy. Now, both in the United States and in many places around the world, we witness a troubling upsurge of right-wing populism, nationalism, and authoritarianism. Once again we may need defenses against the dark arts in dark times.
