Despite the outpouring of Propertian scholarship since 1975/6, there has been nothing to supplant the books of Hubbard and Sullivan as a general introduction to the poet in English. One reason for this may be the particularly contentious and polemical nature of ongoing debates. It would be a tall order to satisfy all readers of Propertius at this moment, and in her new overview Keith rightly does not try. The thorniest problems are relegated to circumspect endnotes or are elided entirely. It is appropriate that a volume in a series devoted to ‘genre and theme’ should largely steer clear of technical issues, but it may be going too far in that direction that the main body of the text does not even alert the novice reader of Propertius to the existence of current controversies.
The book is divided into six chapters, each of which treats a different theme. The first is an extremely useful and up-to-date discussion of what we know about Propertius himself and his family. The second is a discussion of legal and forensic rhetoric in Propertius. This is the most sustained original argument in the book, but it is not fully convincing. Unlike Ovid, there is no evidence that Propertius spent considerable time as a young man in rhetorical training (K. invokes Prop. 4.1.131–4, but this need not be any more than a gesture at the sort of life that Propertius would have been expected to lead if he had not become a poet). That is not to deny the presence of legal metaphors in his work, but it is not clear why we should relate Propertius’ skill at creating vivid characters to the courtroom and classroom rather than to, say, the theatre or to his reading of Greek poetry. Reducing Propertius’ mythology to schoolboy exercises takes no account of its ironic dimension: for example, compare K.'s treatment of myth in 1.15 (pp. 23–5) with the discussions of Gaisser (AJP 98 (1977), 381–91) and Perutelli (MD 32 (1994), 169–71).
The third chapter is an excellent discussion of the nature of elegy and its relationship to other genres. K. has particularly incisive and interesting things to say about Propertius’ relationship with Catullus, Horace, Tibullus and Philetas; this chapter is the highlight of the book. The crucial relationship with epic is oddly postponed, however, until we come to ch. 5. The fourth chapter is about Cynthia, and provides a good overview of the recent work that has emphasized her protean, fictive and metapoetic qualities. It is curious, therefore, that the chapter begins with a discussion of Apuleius’ identification of Cynthia with Hostia and concludes by lamenting the poverty of evidence for women's lives in antiquity. One would have thought that this chapter had established that a picture of a real Roman woman is one thing Cynthia could never yield.
The fifth chapter is about Propertius’ relationship with other men. The theme is homosocial solidarity, which works very well for Gallus, presumed here to be the fellow elegist, but not so well for Ponticus, Bassus, Lynceus, Tullus and the rest, since Propertius uses them as contrasting foils against whom he highlights his own very different choice of lifestyle and above all, genre. Solidarity is therefore a problematic and confusing perspective to take on these addressees. The final chapter is on ideology, elegiac and imperial. K. makes the now-ritualistic disclaimer of a reductively pro- or anti-Augustan interpretation (141), but not everyone will agree with that self-assessment; her Propertius never undermines Augustan or traditional Roman ideals except insofar as a conflict is predetermined by the values of elegy.
The final three chapters are inspired by feminist, queer and post-colonial theory respectively, but unlike some other scholars who have taken these approaches, K. does not find Propertius a kindred spirit, wittily interrogating the power relationships in his society; rather he is an artifact produced by and reproducing the dominant ideology. The greatest loss here is Propertius’ self-reflexive sense of irony: to give one small example, compare K.'s discussion of the role of Apelles the artist at 1.2.22 (pp. 94–5, 147) with Sharrock in JRS 81 (1991), 39–40. An intrinsic weakness of the thematic organization of the book is the need to revisit key passages again and again for different purposes. The cross-referencing is excellent, but when one revisits a programmatic couplet for the fourth or fifth time, one begins to wonder if Hubbard's decision to focus on a different book in each of her four main chapters was not a wise one. The argument is clear, cogent and supported by extremely copious quotation, but a student who uses this book as a point of entry may be surprised and disoriented to find other scholars differing on fundamental questions of the constitution of the text, poem and book division and political allegiance. Not everyone will agree with K.'s Propertius: an apologist for Roman imperialism in general and for Augustan ideology in particular, who objectifies women more than he pokes fun at his own objectifying persona, and whose text has suffered nothing more than localized and minor corruption. But even those who do not will nevertheless want to engage with the many original and valuable observations in this scholarly and intelligent survey.
