My finishing reading Sean T. Mitchell's Constellations of Inequality coincided with the publication of an interview in the German Spiegel with the former Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who was incarcerated at the time. It was impossible not to notice how the topics discussed and the issues evoked by Lula, such as the ‘rise of the poor’ in recent decades, US threats on Brazilian sovereignty, and the need to ‘catch up’ with the world's ‘developed’ countries, resonated strongly with some of the book's main themes. Mitchell's overarching concern with the relationship between inequality and political consciousness, skilfully dovetailed with an engrossing ethnography of Alcântara villagers’ struggles over land throughout the past few decades, not only makes the book highly relevant but also renders it indispensable to anyone wanting to understand some of the main social and political issues at stake in contemporary Brazil.
A major focus of Constellations of Inequality is the transformations in local conceptions of race, ethnicity and inequality that have accompanied a change in political strategy and representation. In a meticulous and stimulating ethnographic account of the rural quilombola (Maroon descendants) population of Alcântara, a municipality in the northwest of Maranhão state, Mitchell examines their forms and rhetoric of political mobilisation. He shows how political organisation shifted, especially in the last two decades, from revolving principally around a class identity to emphasising ethno-racial history and identity. Affirming the importance of ethnographic and historical analysis as complementary to economic analysis in understanding how inequalities are rendered political, Mitchell adeptly navigates the different scales of his analysis, moving with great ease and coherence from ‘the local’ to ‘the national’ and ‘the international’.
The ethnography revolves around the conflicts that arose from the implementation of Brazil's space programme in Alcântara, a project hatched and partly carried out during the years of the military dictatorship (1964–85). While the plan to create a satellite launch base in the municipal area was met with local resistance from its inception, its construction in the early 1980s and the relocation of 23 village communities between 1986 and 1987 to seven agrovilas (government-built settlements) instigated a strong rural mobilisation around land, which eventually took full shape as a conflict between a national ethno-racial social movement (Quilombola) and the Brazilian state.
Two key concepts, proposed by the author, run throughout the book: ‘complementary hierarchy’ and ‘mimetic convergence’. The first, a concept similar to clientelism but with broader encompassment, takes inspiration from Roberto da Matta's ideal-type form of Brazilian racism, historically premised on the idea that ‘whites, blacks, and Indians are unequal, but complementary’ (‘Notas sobre o racismo à brasileira’, in J. Souza (ed.), Multiculturalismo e racismo: Uma comparação Brasil–Estados Unidos, Paralelo 15, 1997, pp. 69–76). The second captures the notion that ‘the poor people and countries will “catch up” to the rich in a kind of progressive teleological emulation of them’ (p. 53). According to Mitchell, while both concepts have been weakened due to the period of struggle around the spaceport and challenges posed by new relations and conceptualisations of inequality, they remain relevant to local and national political realities and hence to the book's discussion, especially in light of ongoing transformations. Mitchell argues that deep-seated inequality, obscured during the economic boom of the first decade of the twenty-first century, continues to permeate Brazilian society.
Criticising the scholarly thesis that suggests changes in Brazilian racial politics have drawn or accentuated racial divisions where there were none, resulting in the ‘racialisation’ of the population, Mitchell produces a shrewd and important analysis of the ongoing transformation of the meanings of ‘racialised (and racist) orders’ (p. 120) and the forms of ethno-racial identification in Brazil, pointing to a bicolour (black and white) discourse that has replaced the long-established colloquial racial palette.
From looking at local forms of collective land occupation where, in line with existing (mostly Brazilian) scholarship, the author conveys to an English-speaking audience the nature of land occupation by quilombolas – essentially the notion that uso comum (‘common use’) is ‘reducible neither to instrumental and self-interested economism nor to its communitarian negation’ (p. 74) – to a critical comparative discussion of political organisation around race and class in Brazil and the United States (Chapter 6); and from discussing the ‘social role of various forms of knowledge and expertise’ (p. 96) to investigating how different interpretations of the explosion of the Brazilian satellite launch vehicle (VLS-1) in August 2003 reveal the inequalities and the different imaginaries of the future and of the nation-state of the parties involved, the book examines Alcântara's spaceport conflict from a wide range of theoretical and empirical perspectives and engages with issues that animate quilombola-related discussions inside and outside academia.
As with every great ethnography, Mitchell's Constellations of Inequality is not immune to critical reading. One question I would like to raise is whether ‘economic boom’ (p. 45), while certainly relevant at the national level, is the appropriate term to describe the emergency relief-like series of actions (such as cash transfer programmes) that took place in Alcântara under the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores, PT) governments. A second thought concerns the usefulness of thinking about Alcântara's land conflicts through an ‘equilibrium of antagonisms’ lens. Drawing on Gilberto Freyre's idea of ‘antagonisms that are balanced and therefore at an impasse’ creating an ‘equilibrium of antagonisms’ which informs Brazilian society (Casa-grande e senzala, 1933), Mitchell contends that, similarly, ‘Alcântara is the site of many such antagonisms, seemingly suspended in equilibrium among villagers and their allies, on the one hand, and the military and civilian proponents of the space program, on the other’ (p. 9). In a book dedicated to understanding ‘the decades of conflict’ around land in Alcântara, the idea of an ‘equilibrium’ between two parties in open and direct confrontation appears somewhat paradoxical.
A final remark regards the overall scope of the discussion, which focuses almost exclusively on those villagers directly affected by and in the vicinities of the base, leaving out a significant number of Alcântara's quilombos and issues other than the space programme that also impact villagers’ land struggles. While Mitchell sometimes refers to ‘the conflict in Alcântara’ in the singular (p. 103), alluding to the major role the launch centre has occupied in local quilombola political organisation, local land conflicts are not reduced to the one around the space base. Alcântara, the municipality with the largest concentration of quilombola communities in Brazil, comprises a widely diverse landscape where multiple land issues are at stake. For example, the growing presence of Pentecostal Christianity in a traditionally Catholic quilombola territory and the related – still latent – tensions around land occupation that have emerged in recent years are completely absent from Mitchell's narrative of the ‘equilibrium of antagonisms’ in Alcântara, as is religious consciousness from his analysis of ‘politicised forms of mobilisation’.
Despite these minor critical points, which make the book all the more stimulating to read, this is an outstanding political ethnography and a great book for anyone who wants to have a deeper, ethnographically grounded understanding of the persistent yet changing faces of inequality in contemporary Brazil.
