Regarding the political outcomes with which it has been associated, ethnicity is undoubtedly an important political factor to be studied by political scientists. Issues such as ethnic group formation, boundary maintenance, mobilization, and violence have long been subjects of theorizing. In addition to these, in recent years, there has been an ever intensified effort to understand the political dynamics around ethnicity. On one hand, scholars study the construction of ethnicity as a political identity, and, on the other hand, they analyze the role of ethnicity in everyday economic and political outcomes such as public goods provision, development, voting, and coalition building to name a few. Jóhanna Kristín Birnir's Ethnicity and Electoral Politics exemplifies this latter strand of recent studies in ethnic politics.
One important focus of studies of ethnic politics is the relationship of ethnicity and ethnic diversity with attaining and sustaining democratic regimes. The conventional wisdom is that ethnic diversity is not good for democracy. It is assumed that establishing democracy and democratic institutions is more difficult in a divided society because it is more difficult to attain consensus among deeply divided groups and to prevent different groups from subverting the system and its institutions to their own advantage in a zero-sum fashion. The risk of ethnic violence looms over democracy like the sword of Damocles. This conventional wisdom has been challenged by empirical cross-national studies showing no positive association between democracy and ethnic diversity as well as by case studies. Birnir's study is another challenge to this conventional wisdom, arguing that ethnic diversity does not necessarily destabilize democracies; quite the contrary, ethnic parties may help new democracies stabilize. She uses an in-depth study of Romania and analysis of cross-national data from new democracies to provide evidence for her argument.
The book is about political expression of ethnicity “once democracy is established procedurally” (7), questioning the factors and mechanisms that cause a democracy to be peaceful or violent, or an ethnic group to prefer peaceful participation or violence. Birnir places the concept of “ethnic attractors,” which she defines as “stable but flexible ethnic information shortcut for political choices,” at the core of her explanation (9, italics in original). Using insights from social identity theory and the machine politics literature, she argues that people can be expected to differentiate into ethnic groups under either authoritarian or democratic regimes; and individuals develop a flexible (non-intransigent) identification with the ethnic group through socialization. Ethnic group membership, in turn, provides informational cues to individuals while they make political choices, such as choosing a political party.
Why would an individual who has an ethnic identification vote for an ethnic party? In answering this question, Birnir utilizes a rational choice approach to voting where a voter's choice of a political party is determined by “the policy proximity of the party to the voter's policy preferences and how closely the voter's beliefs about the party's policy position approximate its true position” (36). A newly democratizing political system wields many uncertainties, especially regarding political party platforms and success probabilities, which make the voter's decision-making difficult. In such an environment, ethnic group members have clear advantages, because the ethnic party would have on its agenda policies that are favorable to them, and it is highly likely that policies and true positions are similar. For continued electoral support as the democracy matures, ethnic parties need to support the informational advantage with “access.” They need to achieve control of positions of power, such as coalition partnerships, ministries, and so forth, so that the ethnic policy preferences are represented and ethnic policies are enacted. Birnir's critical argument is that if ethnic parties exist and achieve access in a new democracy, the political system will be more stable, volatility between elections will be less, and ethnic groups will not resort to violence because they have representation within the system.
The book presents the reader with a formal version of the theory, and a very carefully detailed, multi-level, empirical analysis, exemplifying perfectly what Laitin calls the “tripartite method” (David D. Laitin, “Comparative Politics: The State of the Discipline,” in Ira Katznelson and Helen V. Milner, eds., Political Science: The State of the Discipline, 2002). The empirical analyses—a case study of Romania; a comparative study of Hungarians in Romania, Turks in Bulgaria, and Catalans and the Basque in Spain; and cross-national statistical analyses of new democracies and ethnic groups living therein—support the argument that ethnic diversity is associated with stable electoral outcomes in the short run. Furthermore, long-term ethnic vote stability is contingent on the success of political parties in achieving representation of the ethnic group. Results also show that access to cabinet positions and increasing size of legislative representation decrease the likelihood of violent political activity by the ethnic group.
While I was very intrigued by the theory and impressed by the empirical evidence, I could not help but question two issues about the theoretical argument: first, the meaning and the role of “salience” and second, the centrality of policy in the theory.
Birnir defines ethnicity as “self identification around a characteristic that is difficult or impossible to change, such as language, race, or location” (66). She subscribes to the view that identities are constructed, multiple, and fluid. In studies that adopt this view, political cleavages form along the lines of the identity category (tribe, ethnicity, religion, and so forth.) that is salient. Birnir theorizes about the concept of salience extensively in chapter 3 as an exogenous determinant on the electoral choices of the ethnic voter, assuming that “when the ethnic issues are salient, the ethnic party policy package is on average closer to the preferences of the ethnic voter than is the policy package of any other party” (51). By this definition, salience of ethnicity is a framing effect. This is different from the literature, where an identity category is considered politically salient (which I distinguish from social salience in my research) if an individual engages in peaceful or violent political actions on the basis of that identity category. For example, ethnicity is more salient than religion for a voter if she votes for an ethnic party rather than a religious party. Conceived either as a framing effect or as an observed outcome, salience is endogenous to the political processes, especially electoral politics. Birnir theorizes about ethnic vote when salience is high or when ethnicity loses salience; however she does not explain how these changes in salience come about. Endogeneity of salience also has implications for the ethnic fractionalization measures employed in the data analyses (see David D. Laitin and Daniel N. Posner, “The Implications of Constructivism for Constructing Ethnic Fractionalization Indices” APSA-CP, Winter 2001).
The second issue is closely related to the endogeneity of salience, and is about the centrality of policy and the negligent role of ethnic elites. Birnir's theory rests on individuals' voting decision, and this is determined by the costs associated with the vote. Central to the calculation of the costs are the policy preferences and political parties' proposed and true policy positions. However, the role of political parties in this theory is limited to announcing policy positions and representation of group choices once in power. Ethnic political parties, in practice, do much more than making policies and providing access. Ethnic elites struggle for political power, but they are not as passive in this struggle as suggested in Birnir's theory. Ethnic elites use a variety of tools at their disposal, such as the fear discourse, in order to make the ethnic cleavages politically salient, and they often succeed (see, for example, James D. Fearon and David D. Laitin, “Violence and Social Construction of Ethnic Identity” International Organization, Autumn 2000). The book leaves the reader wanting a more detailed account of the role of political parties in mobilizing the ethnic group, aside from electoral successes, coalition formation, and policy making.
Ethnicity and Electoral Politics is a well-researched, well-written book with sound empirical analyses. Theoretically and empirically, it is a welcome contribution to the study of ethnic politics and a must read for students of identity politics, electoral politics, and democratization.
