“The first book-length critical study devoted to Springsteen's multi-faceted work” is an enticing claim even if the book turns out, instead, to be fourteen essays. The editors have gathered these into broad themes that can be paraphrased as class, gender, religion, and social justice. The contributions come from a wide range of expertise, which helps balance the parochial feel given by the apparent fact that all the contributors are American, and overwhelmingly from eastern US universities. More important than this, though, is whether the commentators do justice to the subject. Introducing the collection, Kenneth Womack and Jerry Zolten cite Rolling Stone magazine's Parke Puterbaugh's observation that Bruce Springsteen “is a peerless songwriter and consummate artist” who has produced album after “painstakingly crafted album.” This being so, the challenge is not merely to write about Springsteen the performer but also to match his standards of writing, editing, compilation and production. It is not easy to translate the experience of seeing, hearing and contemplating Springsteen into a serious critical response but most of the contributors rise to the challenge. Unfortunately, one element of this anthology falls woefully short. On almost all levels, it is poorly edited. There are three editors, and perhaps a copyeditor, yet it seems that no one has proofread the book. The first sign of this is on the contents page. In the title of Part One, Springsteen is spelt “Springsten,” a typo repeated in the section itself. We all make errors so should perhaps overlook one or two, however catastrophic, but the problem is endemic. The two-and-a-half-page introduction (an opportunity for concise eloquence) repeats three lines of a sentence word for word. In both the case of “Springsten” and the introduction, someone has cut and pasted and not carefully reviewed the result.
In the essays themselves the errors are too frequent to be ignored. Some of the contributions seem to have had no editorial input. One essay uses “never fully” or “never really” four times in twelve lines, another uses the adjective “unforgettable” three times in two pages, while yet another talks of “interaction” between “one another,” or variations thereon, three times in six lines. There are also numerous typos, including “Used Car” for “Used Cars”; Too Kill a Mockingbird rather than To Kill …; and a rewrite of the song title, “Jesus Was an Only Son” as “Jesus Was an Only Song.” The scholarship is uneven between essays and too often the quality of the argument and the writing needed sharpening. One contributor offers the tautology that “Springsteen's sense of freedom is a form of liberation” and refers to the E Street band as “a multiracial and multigendered outfit.”
This is a shame. It does not help the cause of those who think Springsteen is worthy of intellectual attention, and it does not do justice either to Springsteen or to the knowledge and skill most of the contributors have put into their essays. Still, all the contributors provide something new on a musician who has been a soundtrack to many lives. David Gellman is informative about Springsteen's influence on Richard Ford and Bobbie Ann Mason. Jefferson Cowie and Lauren Boehm provide an excellent reading of “Born in the USA.” Donna Dolphin offers a useful discussion of Springsteen and Woody Guthrie. Elizabeth Seymour examines the difference between “restorative” and “reflective” nostalgia in Springsteen's songs as well as his constructions of male and female identity. Liza Zitelli discusses mothers and sons in the songs. Samuele Pardini emphasizes Springsteen's Italian side (his mother's maiden name being Zirilli). A number of essays, notably Heather Stur's, refer to his relationship with the Vietnam era. The section on Springsteen and religion includes not just his latent Catholicism but, through Spencer Allen, the Puritan ideal. Matthew Orel explores Springsteen's use of Scripture in his lyrics and Scott Wagar discusses Springsteen's nonreligious spirituality, ingeniously linking the Boss's worldview with Buddhism. Edward Murphy, Jason Stonerook, Steven Fein, and John Massaro each illustrate different approaches to Springsteen and social justice. Elements of the volume will therefore send readers back to Springsteen's music and lyrics with new information and insights. Had the editors and publisher taken care to ensure the whole matched the standard of professionalism of its best contributions and of the work of Springsteen himself, I would find it easier to describe this as a volume worthy of its subject matter.
