Justin Williams's Rhymin’ And Stealin’: Musical Borrowing in Hip-Hop begins with a simple premise: musical borrowing is the fundamental element of hip hop culture and aesthetics. Although all musical traditions engage with the past in some form or another, Williams explains that hip hop is distinctive for its “overt borrowing of preexisting materials to new ends” (1). However, as acknowledged by the book's title, taken from a 1986 song by the Beastie Boys, this basic idea is not new to hip hop, nor is it new to hip hop studies.Footnote 1 Like previous scholars, Williams understands hip hop creativity as a technologically mediated extension of black cultural traditions in which practitioners demonstrate their wit and offer pointed commentary by revising ready-made tropes.Footnote 2 By taking an expanded view of this remix culture, Rhymin’ And Stealin’ deepens our understanding of the music's intertextual nature.
As the hip hop group Stetsasonic once reminded critics, sampling is just a “tactic,” not the reason for the genre.Footnote 3 Although he does not ignore sample-based production, Williams explores numerous musical practices that have not yet garnered significant attention. Introducing musicologist Serge Lecasse's term “allosonic” to describe the use of preexisting material not directly sampled from recordings, Williams explores the plethora of verbal quotations and musical interpolations that populate the genre. Expanding his account of musical phenomena to include visual imagery, music videos, album art, and advertisements, he demonstrates the importance of borrowing in hip hop aesthetics and argues that it serves as a kind of cultural glue for the hip hop nation.
Each of the book's five chapters presents a case study of particular borrowing practices. Chapter 1 focuses on “intrageneric” references and the ways gestures to hip hop's own history have become meaningful in rap music. Others have commented on hip hop's self-reflexive nature, but Williams takes an original approach by focusing on how rap artists bolster their own credentials—what he calls “historical authenticity”—through imagery, sampling, quotation, and other stylistic allusions that historicize hip hop itself. For example, by reworking and incorporating rapped verses from the classic 1982 film Wild Style, or by sampling the soundtrack from the movie itself, more recent rap artists affirm their place in the tradition.
Williams's attention to historical thinking in rap music should encourage others to probe further. A deeper reading of Wild Style, for example, could reveal more about precisely how and why certain artists have continued to mine the film.Footnote 4 What differences or similarities might one note about the cultural work historicism does for artists as diverse as Mos Def, Nas, the Beastie Boys, and MF DOOM, who have all borrowed from Wild Style? What is more, if the notion that hip hop's essence can be traced to a fixed origin is “romantic illusion” (45), as Williams argues, then what would a fuller, more accurate picture of hip hop's earliest days look like?
Chapter 2 shifts focus smoothly to “intergeneric” borrowing, that is, the way that hip hop artists refer to other musical genres. Specifically, Williams turns to two groups, A Tribe Called Quest and Digable Planets, who in the early 1990s made a variety of stylistic allusions to jazz. At a moment when the classicization of jazz was in full swing (think of Wynton Marsalis's tenure with the Lincoln Center, which began in 1987), Williams argues that certain rappers drew upon the growing symbolic cachet of jazz as “highbrow sophistication” (50) to mark their work as unique.
Williams's method, which focuses on the musical codes that signal jazz, is innovative. Rather than discuss the intentions of performers or the actual identity of the recordings being sampled, he attends to the way that instances of musical borrowing are interpreted and contextualized by lyrics and imagery. The use of a walking bass line or trumpet with a Harmon mute might come to symbolize jazz, even if the recording being sampled is not commonly understood as such. Given this approach, I was surprised not to see more discussion of rap songs that sample jazz recordings but are not commonly associated with “jazz rap.” It would have strengthened Williams's argument to acknowledge, for example, the way that jazz samples have been used to support more street-oriented rappers, such as Jay-Z, Nas, or Mobb Deep.
Chapter 3 takes a spatial turn and explores musical borrowing tailored to suit the automotive experience. By immersing himself in the audiophilia of customized car culture, Williams rolls down a hermeneutic window into Dr. Dre's G-Funk. He explains that just as customizers “individualize” automobiles from “previous forms and materials” (74), rap producer Dr. Dre works creatively with music from the past to fashion a distinctive sound reflecting Southern California's car culture. Rather than sampling directly from preexisting recordings, Dre employs studio musicians to replay classic grooves. This approach to borrowing allows him to maintain greater control over timbre and ensure an ideal separation of frequencies well suited for automotive sound systems. Williams offers a wonderfully lucid analysis of Dre's customized beat for Snoop Doggy Dogg's debut single, “Who Am I (What's My Name)?,” detailing the way Dre pieced the beat together from studio replays of fragments of different songs.
Chapter 4 turns toward another kind of borrowing altogether, one that has only recently begun to receive attention in writing about popular music.Footnote 5 Williams provides a thorough account of how rappers Biggie Smalls and Tupac Shakur have become not only deceased artists, but also important commodities and symbols. Beginning with an overview of the “martyr industry,” which shamelessly profits from the dead, Williams explores the cultural work of living rappers who participate in “postmortem sampling.” Looking closely at two different recordings, one by Jay-Z and another by Nas, he shows how each uses the voice of a deceased great to legitimize his own place in the rap canon. In Williams's words, “Both Nas and Jay-Z use the voices of Tupac and Biggie, respectively, as tribute but also as an appeal to authority to reinforce their own status as dominant rappers” (138).
The fifth chapter serves as an extension of the preceding chapter, exploring how more recent rappers Eminem and 50 Cent also draw upon the “symbolic immortality” of past greats. As musicologist Robert P. Morgan has observed, musical lineage is not a natural phenomenon. Relationships to the past are actively constructed, and hip hop culture is no exception. Connecting his focus on musical borrowing to previous musicological studies of artistic lineage, Williams explains how Eminem and 50 Cent participate in a centuries-old practice now updated in the digital era. He cites, for example, Tia DeNora's work showing how Beethoven's references to Mozart helped him articulate his own claim to musical genius.
Rhymin’ And Stealin’ concludes with a brief consideration of Paul D. Miller's (aka DJ Spooky) reflections on the electronically accelerated culture of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Aspects of hip hop's “open source” approach, which once seemed novel, now permeate daily life in many parts of the world. Every day, a new video parody on YouTube, a new meme circulating through social media sites, or some other cultural mash-up foregrounds how cultural borrowing has become an accepted feature of twenty-first-century life. Although Williams does not credit hip hop directly for such phenomena, the implication that hip hop music somehow prefigured or perhaps even helped precipitate such developments should give scholars of “new media” reason to pause.
Given the wide reaching and ambitious nature of this project, it is surprising that Williams did not analyze the work of any female artists. One can imagine how Missy Elliot's various sonic and sartorial nods to the old school might be incorporated into chapter one, or how Nicki Minaj's gender bending covers of various Notorious B.I.G. tracks might have been worked in to chapters four and five.Footnote 6 In fact, it is Williams's openness to such possibilities that make Rhymin’ And Stealin’ an important contribution. His meticulously researched work draws from a wealth of primary sources and insightful references to previous scholarship, both hip hop and non–hip hop related. His refusal to overstate the uniqueness of hip hop music opens a critical space to explore its workings alongside other forms and genres. Although Williams does not position his approach as a self-conscious theoretical intervention, Rhymin’ and Stealin’ itself borrows and samples freely from the musicologist's crate of ideas and methods. Possibly one of the book's most useful contributions is the way it demonstrates how new ways of looking and hearing become available when supposedly disparate intellectual and artistic traditions are brought into dialogue with one another. Rhymin’ and Stealin’ quotes Gary Tomlinson on authenticity, Michel Foucault on the romantic idealization of historical origins, Richard Dyer's work on pastiche, and many others. Yet these sources are not introduced “from above” to elevate hip hop or to legitimate it. Like Afrika Bambaataa spinning the Monkees or Kraftwerk for South Bronx audiences in the 1970s, Williams lays down a compelling mix to get popular music scholars dancing to new and unexpected beats.
