This article will reflect upon a clinical incident involving the issue of consent, utilising Gibbs’ structured model of reflection [Gibbs, Reference Gibbs1988]. The incident will be briefly described followed by a discussion on my feelings and thoughts, and an evaluation of the positive and negative aspects of this incident. Subsequently, a critical analysis of the incident focusing on the three key themes of consent, advocacy and beneficence will explore legal and ethical issues. To conclude, an overall summary of learning achieved and the main points of the essay will be given followed by an action plan that will highlight future developments and changes to my professional practice. Confidentiality will be maintained throughout in accordance with the Nursing and Midwifery Council [NMC; 2008] code.
Description
It was a busy orthopaedic list in a day case surgery environment. Upon performing the ‘Time Out’ section of the World Health Organisation [WHO; 2008] Surgical safety checklist and prior to skin incision, it became apparent that the consent form had not been signed by the patient. However, the patient had already been anaesthetised under general anaesthesia, so I consulted the theatre team leader, who was the scrub practitioner for this case. The entire theatre team, including myself as the circulating practitioner, the scrub practitioner, the surgeon, the registrar, the anaesthetist and the anaesthetic nurse, discussed the appropriate course of action. I voiced my concern that the patient should be woken up and returned to the ward. However, it was decided among the senior members of the team to proceed with the surgery, with the justification of implied consent in light of the patient attending for elective day surgery and receiving a regional nerve block while conscious. The registrar would return post-operatively to the ward for the patient to sign the consent form. An incident form was also completed.
Feelings
I felt a sense of great responsibility when undertaking the WHO Surgical safety checklist. So when I discovered that the patient had not signed the consent form, I panicked about what would happen next. Being the only junior member within the team, I felt uncertain of the correct course of action and whether I possessed enough knowledge and experience having only qualified six months prior to the incident. This uncertainty made me feel apprehensive to question the decision of my colleagues to proceed with the surgery. Even in light of the patient's implied consent, the decision to continue did not inspire me with confidence that I was providing the best duty of care towards the patient. I felt that it was not correct practice ethically for the patient to sign the consent post-operatively while under the effects of general anaesthesia, although I felt it was outside my scope of practice to question this.
Evaluation
The positive aspects of the incident was that the WHO Surgical safety checklist was performed prior to skin incision and all members of the theatre team were involved in the ensuing discussion regarding the best course of action and justification of proceeding with surgery. It was good that an incident form had been completed, as this could be investigated to prevent similar events from occurring in future. The negative aspects of the incident were that the consent form had not been checked correctly on the ward and that my personal lack of confidence prevented me from asserting my opinion, in spite of my junior level to deliver the best duty of care towards the patient.
Analysis
In line with local and national policy, the WHO Surgical safety checklist was performed prior to skin incision. This is not an isolated check; indeed, it is a cluster of several checks to be commenced during different stages of the patient's peri-operative journey. Launched in 2008 by WHO as part of its safe surgery saves lives challenge [National Patient Safety Agency, 2009] and comprising 19 fundamental factors [Walker and Wilson, Reference Walker and Wilson2009], it not only facilitates a safer patient journey [Clarke and Reid, Reference Clarke and Reid2009] but is endorsed by the National Patient Safety Agency [2009]. The checklist is not exhaustive; however, it relies on health-care practitioners to execute it appropriately. Brown and Feather [Reference Brown and Feather2005] state that even with the best of intentions, health-care staff are not utterly infallible. Although the NMC [2008] state in their professional code that nurses must be competent in their knowledge and skills, in addition to being responsible for maintaining their own learning and practice, a vision that is echoed within the sphere of clinical governance, the onus of staff development and competency is cast upon both employer and employee [Royal College of Nursing, 2010a, 2010b].
This became apparent upon discovery of the unsigned consent form. The individual responsible for checking the patient pre-operatively had failed to adequately check the consent form. The essence of a legally valid consent to treatment is that it is an informed and voluntary agreement between the practitioner and a competent patient [Corfield and Pomeroy, Reference Corfield and Pomeroy2008]. The question arises of whether it is legally appropriate to proceed with the surgery. The Department of Health [2009] state in their reference guide that although a completed consent form is not a legal requisite it is considered good practice pertaining to surgery. Although it is often thought that written consent is superior with regard to lawful practice, written, verbal and implied consent are all of equal standing when validity is present [Reid, Reference Reid2003]. Dimond [Reference Dimond2008] reiterates this statement, while stating that written consent is superior as evidence of agreement involving the treatment and possible risks that could later result in litigation for battery. As the patient had voluntarily arrived for the elective surgery, had been verbally consented on the ward by the operating surgeon and received a regional nerve block while conscious, it could be deemed that implied consent would make it justified to proceed. Dimond [Reference Dimond2008] gives little value to implied consent, stating that its weakness lies within the ambiguous nature of whether a clear agreement of treatment and proposed outcomes have been achieved by both parties, with the risk of subsequent litigation for failure to deliver the expected duty of care resulting in negligence.
As the patient was unconscious at this point and unable to execute their autonomy, it fell upon us as nurses to act as an advocate for the patient in the delivery of the best duty of care. The NMC [2008] code expects all nurses to act as an advocate when necessary for patients in their care. Farrell [Reference Farrell2003] contests this historic viewpoint stating that for peri-operative nurses to be true patient advocates, they should ideally be autonomous practitioners with up-to-date evidence and knowledge base. This argument is indeed most likely true for junior members of the team such as myself, and hence my uncertainty as to what I should do and the subsequent escalation to my team leader. Being aware of my responsibilities in the duty of care towards the patient in accordance with the NMC [2008] code, it became a conflict with my junior status and lack of clinical knowledge and experience. I voiced my opinion that the patient should be woken up and returned to the ward, although I lacked the confidence to substantiate this with knowledgeable evidence due to my lack of experience. Fullbrook [Reference Fullbrook2007] states that to prevent negative outcomes it is imperative to take ownership of personal practice by reflection, learning and maintaining that knowledge and skills are up to date. A fundamental aspect of clinical governance is delivering the best duty of care, utilising the correct knowledge, skills and attitude [Royal College of Nursing, 2010a, 2010b]. It could be argued that all of these attributes to become an effective patient advocate develop with experience and when faced with circumstances outside of an individual's sphere of competence it is best practice to seek advice and support from appropriate senior staff. This is the action I took, believing it to be outside my scope of competency and that seeking senior guidance would enable the best duty of care to be executed for the patient.
It was decided among all members of the theatre team to proceed in terms of acting in the best interests of the patient to deliver the best duty of care. Kennedy [Reference Kennedy2004] states that the concept of beneficence involves weighing up the positives and negatives to deliver care of benefit and worthwhile outcome, a fundamental attribute all nurses identify with. Farrell [Reference Farrell2003] argues the viewpoint that peri-operative nurses easily confuse the act of beneficence with that of advocacy. Beneficence originates medically from the teachings of Hippocrates and has evolved through nursing in the form of a patient-involved process of decision making [Rumbold, Reference Rumbold2004]. This raises the issue of whether nurses are ideally placed with the adequate skills and knowledge to ultimately dictate the patient's best interests, and if so it is in fact a decision to be undertaken by medical staff. As the patient was unconscious, it became the responsibility of the theatre team to ascertain the patient's best interests and wishes. There are indeed no absolute guidelines when faced with ethical dilemmas, so it could be argued that the involvement of all theatre individuals, both medical and nursing, facilitated effective communication of individual viewpoints to deliver the best duty of care to the patient. This allowed the moral points to be analysed and dissected to ensure absolute beneficence in this case. The completion of an incident form furthermore ensured adequate documentation and advertisement to the appropriate risk management personnel of the decision-making process in addition to an objective record of events. This is in line with correct protocol in context to quality improvement within the sphere of clinical governance in the minimisation and management of risk and incident reporting to deliver the best duty of care [Royal College of Nursing, 2010a, 2010b].
Conclusion
It is evident that the incident discussed raises multiple questions pertaining to ethics, best practice and the complex factors to take into account surrounding decision making. As the circulating practitioner, I could have checked the consent form once the patient had arrived in theatre prior to anaesthetic induction, which would have avoided the incident from happening. Once the incident had taken place, I could have escalated the issue to my team manager in light of my uncertainty of following correct procedure. This may have enabled a more thorough risk assessment of the incident and a different course of action. The theme of consent has identified the myths and ambiguities surrounding correct procedure and the nursing role. The themes of advocacy and beneficence have identified various viewpoints pertaining to a nurse's role in the peri-operative environment, and that of the context in which this role should be undertaken when encountering complex ethical events. It has also highlighted my personal requirement to expand my knowledge and skills base to be a competent theatre practitioner. I have learnt a vast amount from this incident and the research involved in writing this essay for which I can transfer this knowledge into my professional practice.
Action plan
Since the incident, I am now in the practice of checking the consent form and documentation prior to anaesthetic induction. I have escalated my concerns surrounding the execution of the WHO Surgical safety checklist and suggested to the clinical lead that audit and further training may benefit its use in the future to avoid future occurrences of similar incidents. I also plan to expand my knowledge and skills pertaining to the key themes discussed in addition to the wider scope of ethical and lawful practice. This will enable me to deliver the best duty of care towards patients in my care.
