This is a very ambitious book. Guy Standing codifies, in the form of a charter, the policy demands arising from his analysis of globalisation. Central to this is the idea that the rights of citizenship, established over two centuries through democracy and welfare states, are being lost (wholly or in part) by a growing minority of the populations of developed economies. The twenty-nine articles of the Precariat Charter aim to reverse the processes by which citizens have been relegated to the status of denizens in recent decades.
Standing shows how the neo-liberal project, launched by Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, fed directly into the financial crash of 2008 and the subsequent years of austerity. When international corporations created a global labour market, bringing two billion new workers from the developing countries into their productive sphere, this inevitably lowered the share of national incomes going to waged labour. Household incomes were sustained through low-interest mortgages, cheap credit and state subsidies (such as tax credits). The crash accelerated the transformation in economic relations brought about by these policies.
What emerged, he argues, is a new class system, consisting of a tiny plutocratic global elite; a salariat which retains the rights derived from welfare states, often supplemented by corporate or occupational membership benefits; mainly younger proficians, often prospering through self-employment and entrepreneurial projects; a shrinking proletariat of regular wage workers; and a growing precariat, with insecure jobs and uncertain access to housing and public resources, but no longer seeking the form of workplace security characteristic of proletarian lives.
So the central purpose of Standing's Charter is to define the very broad range of political demands arising from these new relations of production and distribution. He argues that the precariat is the new class carrying forward these demands, which arise from its experience of austerity, the political ideology and policy instruments deployed to discipline its members and the mass protests of 2011.
First, he identifies the differences between the principles informing the current policy consensus (‘moralistic paternalism’) and a ‘progressive instinct’ based on compassion and empathy. The former was consolidated under the Third Way when Clinton and Blair chose to promote labour-market flexibility, workfare and means-tested income support systems. The latter demands that new measures benefit the poorest and least secure, that state controls do not target specific groups, that rights are strengthened, that work is dignified and that ecological sustainability is not jeopardised.
The Charter demands a transformation, and its scope is comprehensive. All forms of work should be recognised and valued, not just paid labour, much of which violates progressive principles. Labour statistics should be reformed to count all forms of work, including care and ecologically minded activities (such as allotment gardening). Labour markets should be re-regulated, and recruiters made accountable to new community and occupational associations (the collective expression of precariat interests). Occupational communities should be reconstructed, and given influence over workplace issues. There should be collaborative bargaining between occupational organisations.
Migrants, the original denizens, should get the same rights as citizens. They should not be demonised, and should be treated as equals in labour markets, and in benefits systems. Housing policies should not create urban ghettos with concentrations of disadvantaged migrants.
All should have access to due process through courts and tribunals if rights are violated. Income support systems should be purged of poverty traps and systems that corral claimants in precarious employments. Disabled people should not be victimised. Workfare of all kinds, based on coercion, should be abolished. Payday loans should be regulated, and financial advice made accessible. The education system should be decommodified.
Underpinning all these reforms is the demand for an entirely new system of income maintenance. Tax credits, which depress wages, should be abolished, and there should be a move towards universal, unconditional basic incomes as a right of all citizens. National capital funds, such as those of Norway and Alaska, should be established. The commons should be protected and revived.
The fundamental problem of the Charter is how it relates to the consciousness of the precariat itself. Standing's twenty-nine articles draw on his extensive, worldwide experience of labour-market issues, on his progressive ethical principles, and on his research into various mobilisations in Europe. But the emerging class he identifies has yet to develop its new forms of association and collective action. There is no guarantee that it will adopt his Charter, or even his progressive principles, as he acknowledges.
Indeed, the evidence he presents from recent movements is mixed. For instance, Italy's Five Star Movement, which gained 163 senators and parliamentarians in the 2013 elections, marked the failure of social democratic opposition to austerity policies. But although most of those elected were young precarians, and the party demanded ecological sustainability and a generous unconditional basic income, its instincts on economic policy were neo-liberal. Its leader (a comedian) called for public-sector cuts and privatisation as well as cuts in state pensions. Standing's honest account of these contradictions recognises the problems facing new movements of the precariat, including the danger of neo-fascist mobilisations.
As someone actively involved in this struggle since the early 1970s, I recognise these dilemmas. In those days, the first expressions of the demands codified in Standing's book were set out by educated young radicals; they pioneered resistance to workfare and the basic income proposal, but they denounced our allotment scheme and co-operative initiatives. The precariat has always been diverse, dispersed and difficult to organise.
As Standing acknowledges, the mass protests of 2011, which seemed to come from nowhere, were ambiguous on this score. Clearly, insecurity and austerity policies underlay them, and they signalled a huge potential for transformation. But there has been little effective follow-up mobilisation of the precariat – as yet no organisation to march behind the banner of the Precariat Charter.
