A welcome voice has been added to recent conversations regarding the nature of American democracy across the nineteenth century's transition from a rural world smothered in smug notions of demographic homogeneity to a morass of roiling urban cauldrons confounded by ethnic heterogeneity. James Connolly, author of a 1998 study of early twentieth-century political culture in Boston, asks some of the same questions, covers much of the same chronology, and investigates some of the same cities as other authors (Laura Westhoff, for example), but along the way he broadens this discussion to include a purposeful re-analysis of New York City politics with reoccurring references to Boston, Philadelphia, and Chicago, as well as, on occasion, a handful of other eastern cities. His quick dismissal of relevant urbanizing processes on the West Coast, however, is disappointing because, as John C. Putnam has demonstrated, late nineteenth-century labor and women's politics could be just as energetic and consequential along the left coast as Connolly's East Coast and Midwest.
A unique contribution in this nicely written volume derives from the author's refusal to settle for yet another rerun of reformers' ubiquitous attacks on emerging political machines. Instead, he moves beyond this old story to persuasively evaluate the bosses' unembarrassed pushback against mugwumps and others of their ilk. Through publications such as North American Review, the Tammany Times, and semi-authorized biographies, these new-era politicians forcefully—and at times insightfully—offered alternative interpretations of the pluralistic realities facing American democracy in an age of industrialization and urbanization. No longer, the bosses argued, should public officials pursue that elusive phantom of the “common good,” a quest that preoccupied political leadership during the country's first half-century.
In Connolly's account, the path toward a broader, inclusive definition of democracy begins with the antipartyism and antifactionalism of the Federalist Letter Number 10, extending through the confident governance styles of Richard Vaux and Josiah Quincy, to the rise of Fernando Wood. As the early national period slid into the Jacksonian era, political leaders continued to herald the “elusive unity” that bound “authentic” Americans to the nation's holy experiment. The general welfare, that imperfectly defined set of communal interests, was central to each political movement during the early nineteenth century. Leaders of those movements espoused complete confidence in their depiction of the American people (not peoples). Then came the Irish and ultimately a host of other foreigners. Streetwise politicians appeared from the cities' grittiest districts, demanding a place at the national political table.
Connolly works from a premise that conceptualizations of a national commonweal presented by early-century reformers and political movements offered authentic representations of the American mind and not just the self-serving justifications of ambitious individuals. Whether the everyday American ever tussled over these theoretical considerations is never addressed. Only when class and ethnic divisions hardened following nationwide strikes and other threats of social upheaval during the Gilded Age was the notion of a single public ultimately replaced by an admission that diversity now prevailed. As the author sagely points out, democracy in the end had to include participation, respect, and deliberation, admirable virtues that even today are too infrequently honored.
After opening with a discussion of the pervasive single community motif of the early nineteenth century, Connolly proceeds to measure the new realities facing post-Civil War New York. Here the story is familiar, with anti-boss stalwarts such as E. L. Godkin voicing their rage against the Tweed Ring even as political machines offered reasonable, if perhaps not preferred, responses to the nation's thickening urban centers. This is followed by chapters on Gilded Age labor politics (the Knights of Labor in particular) and the appearance of female voices through agencies such as the Chicago Women' s Club. After the aforementioned and very persuasive chapter on the bosses' defense of their new politics, the author turns his attention to three individuals who represent various streams of turn-of-the-century social commentary and urban policy: settlement house pioneer Jane Addams, social center innovator Edward Ward, and theorist Mary Parker Follett. Preceding a very brief epilogue is a unit in which theory is finally applied, however briefly and ineffectively, to reality through the career of Lincoln Steffens.
One of the admirable strengths of this study is the author's comfortable incorporation of the relevant secondary literature, including the writings of Mary Ryan, Philip Ethington, David Roediger, and Richard Schneirov. Mayoral biographies, of contemporary and more recent vintage, have been thoughtfully employed as have the pertinent observations of Poe, Whitman, Henry Adams, and William Graham Sumner. Journalistic sources such as the Brooklyn Eagle, Harpers' Weekly, and Nation have been culled for pertinent material. Additionally, the author has examined the papers of individuals such as Henry George, Samuel Tilden, Jane Addams, and James Michael Curley. In total, Connolly has demonstrated admirable resolve in his research and analysis, creating a thoughtful set of insights into the elusive concept of pluralistic democracy.
