In 2002, when the Iraqi-French filmmaker Abbas Fahdel received news about the looming American invasion, he flew to Baghdad to document and film his family. Fahdel has said he was certain that the American army would bomb Iraq to the ground, and that his family home, his homeland, would perish. It is with this exilic nostalgia and anxiety that he recorded more than 120 hours on his lightweight camera in 2002 and 2003, but for a decade he could not touch the footage because of his nephew Haidar's tragic death during the invasion. Ultimately, in 2013, he went back to the project, editing the footage first to an epic twelve-hour, then nine, and eventually a five-hour-thirty-four-minute tour de force, released as Homeland: Iraq Year Zero. By his own account, he wanted to show audiences the portraits of ordinary, middle-class Iraqis, whom, he notes, are nowhere to be found in American films on Iraq. It was during the editing phase that Fahdel also realized the two-part structure in the documentary.
Part 1, entitled “Before the Fall,” takes place during the months leading up to the American invasion, and features Fahdel's family, who, while they intuit the disintegration of the social contract in Iraq, show prodigious dignity in keeping whatever normalcy they can in their everyday life. As they wait for the American army to arrive, Fahdel's family prepares for war: they dig a well in their garden, bake extra bread, tape up the glass windows, and stock up on antibiotics while still keeping their tea rituals, doing homework, playing hide-and-seek, shopping for books on al-Mutanabbi Street, attending weddings, discussing Socrates, and engaging in charitable practices. While the agility in war preparations reveals the war-torn psyche of the Iraqis, Abbas’ lens shows that these middle-class Iraqis weren't getting ready to fight, they were only trying to protect what little life they had in their homeland. Fahdel's eleven-year-old nephew, Haidar, who is one of the few people in the film with no memory of the previous wars in Iraq, dominates part 1 with his joie de vivre and his intelligent curiosity and desire to converse about everything. Fahdel ends this part with a family trip to the Amiriya shelter where Haidar guides his uncle through tunnels of destruction, and photos of the burnt bodies of children, unaware of his own fate in war.
If part 1 is about the fleeting joys of family life under sanctions and the nearing war, then part 2, “After the Fall,” is about loss. Filmed right after the American invasion in 2003, Iraq is now replete with bombed buildings, checkpoints, and Humvees; the germinal phase of what will turn out to be a decade-long destruction of urban life is evident. The artistic allusions to Roberto Rossellini's Germany, Year Zero (1948) are noticeable here. Like the young Edmund in Rossellini's film, Haidar has to grow up unnaturally fast during wartime. He engages in public quarrels about how Saddam executed his uncle and learns to use a pistol because bandits have already proliferated in Baghdad. Fahdel calls Haidar's premature adulthood “pas normal,” in other words, not normal, and emphasizes the absurdity of an eleven-year-old wanting to talk politics and war all the time.
As part 2 breaks away from the idyllic scenes of the city of Hit and joyful gardens that we see in the first part, we understand that this is the beginning of the end: culture, education, and social life in Baghdad fade away, and the brutal invasion of violence and terror take over. Unlike part 1, which juxtaposes domestic scenes with family trips to museums, schools, and abandoned theater houses, part 2 shows the fear of leaving home. Even attending school becomes risky, and in that regard, part 2 portends the fate of Iraqi children whose formal education is now interrupted by incessant wars.
Homeland is both a meditation on the domestic life of middle-class Iraqis and an elegy for Iraqi children like Haidar. Instead of blurry footage of explosions, radio transmissions, and the totality of neuroses derived from a war zone, Homeland offers long and insistent camera shots with gentle and patient portraits of Iraqis, reminiscent of the photos of twentieth-century German portrait photographer August Sander. The camera lends a particularly realistic perspective of Iraqi women and children. Fahdel shows a panorama of Iraqi women of all ages. They are dancing, carrying water from the river, studying for their exams, stuffing grape leaves, feeding goats on the rooftop to feed their young children, practicing medicine. They are more varied than their veiled and exoticized counterpart in the western imagination. The same is true for the representation of children. Fahdel gives children a voice in this film. They are expressive, cognizant of what war means and how it affects their lives; they are mature and curious.
Homeland will most certainly contribute to a realistic understanding of war's long-lasting effects on the lives of ordinary Iraqis and cultivate a sincere understanding of what that ordinary life was like for middle-class citizens before the invasion. Both as an educational tool and as a superb chronicle of war, Homeland distinguishes itself more with its patient and affectionate tone than its aesthetic and cinematic quality. In mainstream American narratives of the Iraq war, Iraqi mothers cry hysterically, the sounds of Baghdad are excessive, perhaps even off-key, and children wander purposeless or lost. To Fahdel, this is his homeland, and his camera insists on that fact.
