In early 1994, the World Bank (hereafter the Bank) leapt onto the uncrowded stage of debate on pension reform. Recognizing both the looming threat of aging populations in many middle income and transition economies and the bankruptcy of many national pension systems, the Bank's publication, Averting the Old Age Crisis, compellingly argued the merits of a Chilean-style pension reform. The book preached the salvation that a multi-pillar approach—centered on a mandatory, privately run, funded defined contribution (DC) pillar–could provide for fiscally-strapped governments and insolvent pension schemes, not to mention its potential for enhancing economic growth. Over the following decade, the Bank aggressively promoted this vision with loans to member governments, policy research and advisory services, and technical assistance. Consistent with its practice of carrying out ex post evaluations of its work, the present volume, which I shall refer to as the Report, provides an evaluation of the Bank's efforts at pension reform.
The Report was written as an internal assessment for the Bank's Executive Board, so it covers such topics as: (i) the Bank's strategy for pension reform; (ii) the different ways in which the Bank promoted such reforms; (iii) the quality of the initiatives adopted under Bank tutelage; (iv) the impact of such reform efforts in the concerned countries; (v) the effectiveness of the Bank in building an institutional capacity for pension policy development and implementation; and (vi) the cohesiveness of the Bank's efforts both internally and with other external agencies also engaged in pension reform work. Some of these issues will be of limited relevance to those outside the Bank. Also, curiously, the evaluation exercise chose as its criteria for assessing the success of the Bank's efforts not the policy recommendations from Averting, but rather the official Strategy for Social Protection, which was only adopted by the Bank's Executive Board in 2001, long after much of the evaluated work had occurred. Moreover, and not surprisingly, the Report focuses principally on countries that sought the Bank's guidance on pension reform and where the Bank was heavily engaged (largely in Latin America, the Caribbean, and the Eastern European and Central Asian transition countries). Thus, many issues germane to pension policies in countries with less developed pension systems were neither addressed by the Bank nor considered in this Report.
As a result, the reader interested in pension reform may come away from the Report wishing for more. Should a country institute a model that differs from the Bank's official Strategy? What are the pros and cons of alternative strategies for developing social protection schemes that encompass not only a formal pension system but also a social safety net for the vulnerable elderly? How should one approach the reform of a financially weak pension system? Fortunately, these issues are the subject of many books, articles, and conference proceedings published by the Bank over the last decade, many on the web. As noted in the Report, that research has contributed importantly to clarifying our understanding of the policy and implementation issues involved in pension reform.
Notwithstanding these caveats, this Report is nevertheless a fascinating read for pension specialists, illuminating clearly the many challenges and difficulties involved, not only in designing a pension reform, but in developing effective institutions for implementing and administering a new pension system. For example, in reviewing the Bank's experience with countries that sought Bank guidance or loans, the Report illustrates how the Bank, despite its missionary zeal in promoting a DC-focused multi-pillar system, often found itself working instead with governments to implement parametric reforms to existing PAYG systems. In practice, the Bank's staff recognized that a one-size-fits-all approach would be impractical, in part because often countries wanted help with policies quite different from those recommended in Averting.
The Report also underscores the multiple dimensions of a successful reform program, particularly one that presupposes the development of new institutions in both the public and private sectors. It illuminates how the Bank, in providing policy guidance, often did not examine whether the institutional preconditions or economic and financial structure of a country were appropriate for a multi-pillar approach, particularly one reliant on a funded DC system. Surprisingly, the Bank did not make projections of the fiscal expenditure requirements of the minimum pension guarantees often provided in connection with mandatory DC schemes. The Report also contains occasional jewels of information illustrating how the arguments for a mandatory private pillar proved more fragile than logic would have suggested. For example, in many countries that adopted a private funded DC system, the private pension money tended to be heavily invested in government securities, rendering their financial prospects not dissimilar from those of a PAYG system (viz., reliant on the fiscal sustainability of the government's finances). This resulted from limited development of the financial sector in the countries concerned, the need for financial instruments of a relatively long-term nature mirroring the maturity of potential liabilities, and the effect of government regulations limiting the riskiness of the portfolio investments of these funds.
Confirming the concerns expressed by early critics of the Chilean reform, the Report also notes that in other countries, the net return on many funded pension systems proved to be not much larger than the growth rate of wages (i.e., the return associated with a PAYG system), reflecting the high burden of administrative costs and risk premia. Moreover, the Report underscores that most of the key secondary objectives posited for a DC funded pension pillar—an increase in the savings rate, improved labor market incentives, an increased coverage rate, and financial market development—were unmet. Finally, and perhaps less surprising, the Report underscores the bottlenecks observed both in internal and external coordination among the different bureaucratic players and agencies dealing with pension reform issues. Externally, in its discussions with many countries, the Bank worked fairly independently from other aid agencies. And internally, there was little coordination between those in the Bank dealing with policy development and those engaged in actual discussions with country officials on specific policy reforms and Bank lending programs.
One final observation emerges from the Report. There remains an enormous gap in actuarial expertise in many reforming countries, throwing doubt on their nations' capacity to analyze the financial viability of alternative proposed reforms. Despite the growing importance of pension institutions, actuarial education, particularly outside the United States, remains underfunded and underprioritized, leaving many countries with inadequate capacity to program and design pension policies.
