Alexander Wilde's edited volume, Religious Responses to Violence: Human Rights in Latin America Past and Present, examines the impact of religious action in Latin America, by exploring the relationship between faith and constructive agency in response to situations of violence. The volume as a whole seeks to raise analytical issues concerning the factors that motivate religious responses to violence, continuities and changes in violence and such responses, and the impacts of religious social action. In particular, the volume seeks to consider these questions in terms of the themes of human rights and the concept of ‘contemporary ministries’.
The volume opens with the framing introduction and two background chapters, one each by Daniel Levine and Robert Albro. The chapter by Levine provides a useful historical overview of the vocabulary of rights in Latin American Catholicism starting in the second half of the twentieth century, in response to the surge in both increased struggles for social justice and authoritarian violence. Albro offers a powerful look at contemporary forms of violence and solidarity in twenty-first century Latin America. While this chapter is not focused on religion, its concept of negative solidarity, or solidarities built around memories and experiences of violence, provides a potential point for deeper exploration of the role and attraction of religion in violent contexts.
The remainder of the volume is divided in two parts. Part I unites six chapters under the theme of religious contributions to human rights. Each of these chapters takes up a specific historical moment and explores an aspect of the relationship between state-directed violence and the Catholic Church. Individually, the chapters make valuable contributions to the study of their specific locations. Several explore the impact of liberation theology on social and Christian activism; others take on the degree of collusion between the Catholic Church and repressive regimes. The chapters by Gustavo Morello and María Soledad Catoggio on Argentina are notable for their nuanced treatment, demonstrating how the Church, and Catholics themselves, adopted contradictory positions around the issue of state terrorism. As a unit, these chapters provide an in-depth look at liberation theology and its role in incorporating a form of social activism into religious discourse in Latin America. Yet, overall, the section does not engage deeply with the issue of human rights. The goal of these chapters does not lie in unpacking the impact in Latin America of what Kamari Maxine Clarke and Mark Goodale have called the ‘transnational normative discourse’ (Clarke and Goodale, eds., Mirrors of Justice, Cambridge University Press, 2010, pp. 9, 17, 18) of human rights that was taking shape at this time, or in the role of human rights as an emerging legal discourse (though some of the chapters touch on these issues). Nor do they engage with religion(s) and human rights in a broader sense, as converging/conflicting philosophical principles as does, for example, Boaventura de Sousa Santos in Si Dios fuese un activista de los derechos humanos (Editorial Trotta, 2014), where he considers the relationship of human rights, political theologies and social activism. In this sense, the section does not deliver on its promise to serve as a rethinking of religious contributions to human rights, though the chapters themselves are strong.
Part II groups seven chapters under the idea of pastoral ministries and accompaniment, or ‘an active pastoral policy in the churches to be present among the poor’ (p. 12), as responses to violence. This section includes chapters that expand the focus beyond the Catholic Church to include Evangelical Christianity, and places the ideas of the defence of dignity, compassionate witnessing (Tate), and the politics of presence (Johnson) at the centre. This section contains two excellent chapters, by Winifred Tate and Kimberly Theidon, both of which consider the many complexities of violence and pastoral care, each taking a nuanced and sophisticated view of the role of (Evangelical and Catholic) churches and their adherents in different regions of Colombia.
The main weakness of this volume lies not in its content, which is in general thoughtful, grounded and informative. Rather, it is in its framing that the volume left me somewhat uncomfortable. In the Afterword, it is made explicit that the rationale for the book is to show the ‘unique qualities of religion as a social force against violence’ (p. 478). Yet the book is not an assessment of religious responses to violence or of the relationship of human rights to religion (as suggested in its title), nor even of the relationship of Christianity to Latin American violence. Throughout the introductory chapter, the words ‘religion’ and ‘Christianity’ are seemingly used as synonyms, which of course they are not, not even in Latin America, and, for a book focused on pastoral accompaniment and the preferential option for the poor, the lack of any mention of Rabbi Marshall Meyer's work in Latin America is striking. The majority of chapters do focus in one way or another on pastoral accompaniment, and the concept is productively explored throughout. And yet this is not the same as looking more broadly at the relationship of religion and collective action against violence in Latin America, which is how it is proposed to the reader and which would necessarily include other Latin American religions (Judaism, Islam, Candomblé, indigenous cosmologies, etc.), whose absences are thus notable.
Overall, the volume will be useful to anyone interested in historically grounded and detailed discussions of Christian activism against and in the face of violence in Latin America in recent decades. Though defence of dignity might have been more productive than human rights as a framing concept for the research collected here, the majority of the chapters are well worth a read.
