It is rare to find an academic such as Richard Frye, who is so enthralled by the people and cultures of a world region. He needs no introduction to scholars and students of Iranian, Afghan, and Tajik studies. After sixty-two years of travel, research, and publications, Frye decided to set down his memories and remembrances of a lifetime of dedicated scholarly work and long-term residency in and out of his beloved “Greater Iran.” He defines this area as Iran and “much of the Caucasus, Afghanistan and Central Asia,” where “my life came to be dedicated to portraying and explaining the role of Greater Iran in the history of civilizations” (p. ix).
A peripatetic Harvard historian, archaeologist, and linguist, Frye, who started his memoir at the age of twenty-two, began his work thusly: “The train was agonizingly slow as it stopped at every village or even just a gathering of people by the tracks. But what an exotic landscape of brown, beige and sunset shaded desert or dusty green oases the likes of which I had never seen before” (p. 1). From the memoir it is clear that Frye focused his travels and research on both the societies and the lands of Greater Iran, no matter how painstakingly difficult it was to reach a village or distant mosque or how miserable were the means of transportation or living quarters. For him, it was important to take “trips to the field” as part of the learning process. As he admits to have said to his students, “In the area of study of Central Asia and Iran not just book learning, but first hand acquaintance with land and people was necessary” (p. 148). In a sense, Frye spent his years of academic work fulfilling that dictum. He was clearly no “ivory tower” scholar like so many of his Orientalist contemporaries but an avid field researcher of the ancient west and central Asian worlds.
He divides his memoir into four parts. The first nine chapters (1942–45) focus on his intriguing and unscholarly life as a member of the World War II Office of Strategic Services. Due to his wide range of language skills and research interests in the region, Frye was assigned in the midst of his graduate studies to teach English at Kabul's Habibiya School while secretly listening to German broadcasts to Japan and reporting on Axis activities among the Pushtun tribes on the Indian border. Shortages of food and equipment in Kabul, work on his dissertation, and intelligence-gathering activities took him back and forth several times from India to Egypt via Iran before hostilities ended. Those experiences profoundly shaped his scholarly directions.
His next nine chapters (1946–65) are devoted to his life at Harvard University, including the creation of the Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations and the Center for the Study of World Religions. When Frye did get away from Harvard, he usually roamed the hilly and mostly barren rusta, or countrysides, of Iran and Afghanistan in search of archaeological sites or of antiques on behalf of Hagop Kevorkian. His brief descriptions of meeting Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadeq on 9 August 1953, ten days before the overthrow of Iran's popular leader, and those turbulent days of the British- and CIA-assisted coup d'état are unfortunately very brief.
The remainder of the work is devoted almost entirely to his three life-changing residencies in Hamburg, Germany (1968–69), Shiraz, Iran (1969–74), and Dushanbe, Tajikistan (1990–91) in the midst of his countless travels to conferences and seminars in Japan, China, Russia, and Afghanistan.
Frye's scholarly contributions to Iranian studies evolved in two directions unusual among his contemporaries. First, his odysseys to the region of Greater Iran and his linguistic abilities in at least six regional languages allowed him to be au courant in Iranian, Afghan, and Tajik studies and to emerge as the leading American regional scholar in the eyes of Persian, Afghan, Tajik, Russian, Chinese, Japanese, and European academics. Indeed, Frye was more than proficient in European Orientalist methodologies. He actively sought out other methods to understand the politics, societies, and cultures of Greater Iran via multidisciplinary and holistic approaches characteristic of the academic communities in the era after World War II. Second, his conviction that the region of the “Middle” or “Near” East was best seen through its languages, buildings, statuary, pottery, and manuscripts rather than through the popular lens of imposed post World War I borders or Cold War ideologies led him to call the region Greater Iran. Although rejecting a narrow national historiography, he turned instead to a broad civilizational approach not unlike the latter works of Samuel Huntington and Bernard Lewis.
The concept made sense to him not only in the traditional Orientalist paradigm of dominant languages, arts, history, and humanities of local elites but also in the folklore, traditions, and social systems of villagers, pastoralists, and traders of the region's other classes. For him, Greater Iran embraced the region of both the imperial elite and the local husbandman and artisan of the pre- and post-Islamic era. In the end, Frye reveals one of his deepest “irandoost” aspirations of being buried on the banks of Isfahan's Zayandeh Rud River alongside his predecessor and colleague, Arthur Upham Pope. In 2004, in the year of his retirement from Harvard, the former Iranian President, Mohammad Khatami, approved that long hoped-for future resting place.
Greater Iran is a romance between a scholar and a world region. Appropriate for graduate students and the well-traveled public, the work will be difficult for many people unfamiliar with the blizzard of historical names and sites, as well as the long litany of scholars from Boston to Beijing who crossed his many paths. Unfortunately, the sparse index and equally sparse two maps do not support the very readable and fast-paced narrative and will send many readers running to their atlases and encyclopedias in order to fully comprehend his observations. A detailed chronology and full bibliography of Frye's life and publications would have greatly enhanced his historical data and experiences. Lastly, any personal conflicts between his patriotism and his World War II Afghan work or his intense affection and devotion for all things Iranian is never examined or explained, nor is much of his personal and family life or his intense lifelong friendships. Like so many scholars who cross back and forth between the world of the academy and the world of geopolitics, whether nationalist or Islamist, his preferences are to study objects, archives, and conferences rather than the daily grind of peoples' lives in Greater Iran. Frye's “romance” with the region in terms of “collectibles” is a loss for readers who want to know more about this man's emotions about the “street” during his odyssey in such an important world region.
For better or for worse, the work is a benchmark of contemporary American scholarship on the ancient and medieval worlds of western and central Asia. Frye's life began in Birmingham, Alabama, ran through Danville, Illinois, to Cambridge, Massachusetts, and eventually will end on the banks of the Zayandeh Rud in Isfahan, Iran. A life could not be more global or more fulfilling.
