Abdeslam Maghraoui reveals that this work began as a doctoral dissertation completed fifteen years earlier and identifies two developments that revived his interest in the subject matter. The first involves the Bush administration's use of “freedom” and “democracy” as slogans for the invasion and occupation of Iraq. For Maghraoui, the administration's claims were reminiscent of earlier imperial ventures and offered another example of the historical complicity between liberalism and colonial conquest—or what the author terms “colonial liberalism.” The focus of Maghraoui's work is the role of colonial liberalism in the failed efforts of reformists during Egypt's so-called “liberal era” of the 1920s and 1930s. His aim is not only to question liberalism's claim to cultural neutrality but also to demonstrate how, in embracing the language of colonial liberalism, reformist thinkers of this period took on a project of cultural assimilation, which ultimately proved both undemocratic and nonemancipatory for the majority of Egyptians.
Maghraoui identifies his second impetus for returning to this project as the perestroika movement that developed within the American Political Science Association and brought a greater openness to nontraditional approaches to the study of politics. Of particular relevance to Maghraoui's work was the interest perestroika garnered in bringing questions from political theory and methods from cultural studies to bear on debates relevant to comparative politics. In this regard, Maghraoui's work attempts to challenge social-science research that focuses on structural or institutional factors that impede democratization but pays insufficient attention to “the culture and language which give meaning to citizenship and political community” (p. 11). What he finds in his study of various legal documents, literary texts, newspaper articles, and political cartoons is that the liberal discourse in Egypt during this period “was more exclusive and non-democratic than institutions allow us to see” (p. 124). Liberal democracy does not fail in Egypt because of Egyptian reformists' inadequate appreciation or comprehension of European liberalism—a view Maghraoui associates with works by Nadav Safran, Afaf Lutfi al-Sayyid, and p. F. Vatikiotis. Rather, it fails because Egyptian liberals mimic European liberalism too well.
Central to Maghraoui's analysis is the work of various critics of colonialism and postcolonial theorists, such as Aimé Césaire, Albert Memmi, Franz Fanon, Edward Said, Jacques Lacan, Gayatri Spivak, and Homi Bhabha. Using Lacanian psychoanalytic theory, Maghraoui offers a linguistic rendering of emancipation as he draws parallels between “an incomplete or derailed Oedipal experience and the Egyptian liberals' drive to identify Egypt as a European entity” (p. 35). Maghraoui's analysis highlights Egyptian intellectuals who, inspired by liberal European thought, came to define themselves and their political community “from the point of view of the European looking at the non-European other” (p. 86), thus adopting biased and contradictory cultural assumptions that necessitated the formulation of Egyptian national identity in opposition to an Arab and Islamic other and the formulation of notions of citizenship based on categories of racial, cultural, and social exclusions. Maghraoui's most fully developed example of this phenomenon lies in his analysis of Egypt's 1923 constitution, which both outlines “formal civil and political rights that were compatible with the most liberal constitutions in Europe at the time” and “assumes a political community whose members are not only disconnected from their history and traditions but also believe in the superiority of European culture and social manners and enthusiastically embrace them as their own” (pp. 63, 145).
As application of postcolonial political theory and as analysis of the discourse of Egyptian nationalists, Maghraoui's book is engaging. Although perhaps not adequate in itself as an explanation of liberalism's presumed “failure” in Egypt, it does offer an explanation and critique of Westernized intellectuals' intolerance toward and degradation of local identities and popular beliefs and practices. However, Maghraoui fails to discuss recent scholarship that offers new perspectives on modern Egyptian society. For example, the work might have considered Roel Meijer's study of what he terms “authoritarian modernism,” which Meijer traces to secular liberalism and argues found its highest form in the radical politics that emerged in the decade following that covered by Maghraoui. Like the “rule of experts” for the presumed sake of development and modernization so poignantly analyzed in Timothy Mitchell's recent work, Meijer reveals the undemocratic and illiberal dimensions of intellectuals' enthusiasm for remaking society “in accordance with the spirit of the age.”
So too, the author did not take advantage of recent studies that have contributed to our knowledge of the historical experiences of Egypt's peasantry and popular classes and of early expressions of Arabism and Islamism. As such, the work pays insufficient attention to those who were contesting and resisting various aspects of “colonial liberalism” rather than simply reproducing the language of the other in a self-deceiving way. Yet, inspiring such work seems to be part of the purpose of Maghraoui's study. The book's conclusion offers praise of Roxanne Euben's careful study of Sayyid Qutb for rendering intelligible the Islamist thinker's apprehensions about liberalism and the vision of the ethical community he sought to establish. Thus, Maghraoui ends his work with a call for social science to take more seriously the political thought of nonliberal thinkers.
Despite the lack of a full account of recent scholarship on this period that provides more context and contours to the general argument, Maghraoui's work offers a cautionary tale well worth reiterating for the remaining few who tout the “war on terrorism” as a “war of liberation” as well as for those who will undoubtedly embark on a mission to remake some part of the world in their own image.
