Documentary forms, including visual and aural devices, have been acting as an important catalyst for new representational conventions in the performing arts over the past two decades. Both anthologies explore this proliferation in Western and non-Western stage practices. The diversity of theoretical approaches manifests the complexity of documentary theatre, avoiding homogenizing concepts such as ‘truth’, ‘originality’, or ‘authenticity’. Get Real explores reality-based theatre in two main directions. The first presents a historic overview of the hybrid nature of Western documentary theatre since the 1930s. Ben Harker examines the fusion of naturalistic and anti-naturalistic strategies in the ‘carefully rendered realism’ (p. 28) of Theatre Union's Last Edition, a neglected intervention into the living newspaper genre in 1940. Colin Chambers explores the impure nature of London's communist-oriented Unity Theatre and its use of documentary and non-documentary forms in order to embrace, politically and aesthetically, the ‘real’ by ‘truthfully interpreting life’ (p. 39). Derek Paget underlines the gap between the ‘didactic purpose’ (p. 228) of the committed documentary theatre back in the 1960s and the increasing distrust in politics in the postmodern era which interrogates means of persuasion and oppositional tactics.
The second direction points to insightful analysis of a range of current practices, with a specific interest in British verbatim theatre, highlighting the North London Tricycle Theatre as the ‘epicentre of the revival in documentary performance in the UK’ (Megson, p. 195). This mapping is enriched by the inclusion of non-Western contexts in the contributions of two authors who also feature in Dramaturgy of the Real: Yvette Hutchison points out the (culturally necessary) blurring of ‘real’ and ‘fictional’ testimonies in the post-apartheid South African verbatim narratives, and Carol Martin explores the possibility or the impossibility of documentary theatre to recreate history by incorporating the media version of an event ‘to the degree that today media is a key arbiter of truth’ (p. 74). In her own collection, Martin claims a ‘global cosmopolitanism’ which could be generated from a ‘constellation of the local in the global’ (p. 4). This expansion of the documentary field raises the prejudice that the reality-based theatre needs its specific sociopolitical context in order to be comprehensible. Her collection favours the analysis of contemporary theatre practices as engaged ‘in the larger cultural obsession with capturing the “real”’ (p. 1). Juxtaposing theoretical texts and plays, Martin's book appropriates the structure of the 2006 TDR special issue on the topic from which it reprints some material. What seems more interesting here is its highlighting of the inner relation of postmodernism with documentary stage traditions regarding the dramaturgical, the directorial as well as the spectatorial devices. Based on the assertion that truth is unverifiable, Martin proposes in her introduction the concept of ‘constructivist postmodernism’, which ‘permits the recognition that although postmodern techniques are largely shared by many cosmopolitan places in the world, these techniques can be and are used for different ends’ (p. 3).
The aesthetic legacies of ‘theatre of the real’ are expanded through Agnieszka Sowinska's exploration of the ‘paradocumentary theatre’ in the stimulating Polish landscape. These enlarge the concept of stage reportage and the fact-montage theatre of Leon Schiller in 1930 by using ‘interviews, facts, and newspaper reports as its point of departure, with the factual sources serving to inform and inspire the creation of the text’ (p. 72). The variety of contemporary documentary productions is enriched by a text on Rimini Protokoll's ‘experts of the everyday’ as analysed by Florian Malzacher, which is adapted from Malzacher's co-edited study on the company. Consciously opposing the idea of amateur theatre (p. 81), Rimini's experts redefine the presence of the actor in documentary theatre perceived as a ‘mediator’ between representation and actuality. This links to Alan Filewod's argument on the collapsing of reality into the presence of the actor in Get Real (p. 62). Such interconnections between the two dense volumes manifest a necessity for further theoretical discussion about the multiplicity of documentary theatrical forms, in order to stress more clearly the need for wider intercultural as well as interdisciplinary approaches.
