Eric Engel Tuten's Between Capital and Land is one of the few academic works to focus on the operations of the Jewish National Fund (JNF) in pre-1948 Palestine. The JNF was established in 1901 by the World Zionist Organization to purchase land for Jewish settlement in Eretz Israel in the name of the Jewish people, and during the British Mandate, it became the dominant force in Jewish land acquisition in the country. Because of the inalienability clause in the Fund's by-laws (which prohibited it from selling any of the land it purchased), Zionist officials regarded land purchased by the JNF from Palestinian Arabs as “redeemed.” From the mid-1930s onward, JNF land purchases were aimed specifically at shaping the territory and borders of the future Jewish state. For this reason, JNF operations during the Mandate period are a crucial piece in the puzzle of understanding the success of Jewish nation building during this period.
As Tuten points out, despite the profound impact of the historical events of the late 1930s and 1940s on the country in general and on JNF operations in particular, most scholarship on Jewish land acquisition in Palestine has steered clear of this period. Between Capital and Land looks at JNF operations between 1939 and 1945, and for this reason, it is an important book. The stage is set with the publication of the 1937 Peel Commission partition plan, which sparked Zionist officials to expand their land-purchasing goals to include certain parts of the country with little or no Jewish land ownership to ensure the inclusion of these areas in the future Jewish state. However, this new approach was almost immediately challenged by two other factors. One was the loss of traditional JNF income from European Jewish communities at the outbreak of World War II. The other was the British-imposed restrictions on Jewish land purchases in most of the country that were proclaimed by the White Paper of 1939 and institutionalized by the Land Transfer Regulations of 1940. How did the JNF overcome these financial and legal obstacles to continue and actually expand its land purchasing operations, not just in the small zone of the country where Jewish purchases remained unrestricted but in the rest of the country as well? This is the major question addressed in Between Capital and Land.
The thrust of Tuten's argument is that the JNF flexibly and effectively modified its financial and land acquisition policies to overcome these challenges. On the financial front, JNF officials developed new programs to raise capital by cooperating with private investors while simultaneously identifying new sources of more traditional types of Jewish “national” income (such as donations, wills, and “living legacies”) in non-European English-speaking countries, most notably the United States. On the legal front, they developed sophisticated methods of circumventing the Land Transfer Regulations by taking full advantage of its loopholes.
Tuten classifies the book as an “institutional history” and limits himself from the outset to a discussion of JNF policies and internal developments. For this purpose, his sources, which include archival documents from the Central Zionist Archives and an extensive bibliography of Hebrew and English secondary sources and reports, appear to be sufficient. Limiting himself to a close analysis of internal JNF developments also allows him to steer clear of controversial issues that often make it difficult to write a balanced account of land issues in pre-1948 Palestine, and his treatment of the material is fair and well substantiated.
The book's primary weakness is its structure. Aside from an introduction, a conclusion, and a chapter presenting the challenges facing the JNF at the outbreak of World War II, there are three chapters that make up the book's body. Each focuses on a short chronological period of two years (1940–41, 1942–43, and 1944–45). Each chronological chapter, in turn, consists of two sections, the first of which examines JNF income, expenditures, and land purchases. Breaking down this information into two-year periods makes sense, and, although the text is burdened with details and figures, the first part of each chapter effectively illustrates the gradual yet dramatic improvement of the JNF's financial situation during the war and its resulting ability to expand land purchases according to the new geographical priorities of the time.
The problem comes in the second part of each of the three main chapters, where Tuten presents chronological installments of four “case studies”: the joint land purchase scheme, the farm city scheme, the Huleh region, and the Negev. The first two case studies examine the evolution of two unique land purchasing projects aimed at mobilizing capital from private investors. The last two document JNF land acquisition in specific geographical regions. Simply put, it is difficult to follow the detailed descriptions provided in the four case studies when each is broken up into two-year segments spread throughout the book. The case studies might have worked better had they been presented as whole units, perhaps grouped together into two separate chapters (one containing the case studies on private capital mobilization and the other containing the case studies on regional land acquisition) and placed after the chronological chapters on finances and land acquisition.
This problem may be largely an editing mishap. Between Capital and Land is for the most part a reproduction of Tuten's 2000 Ph.D. dissertation, which bears the same title and the same structural flaw. Although the dissertation clearly underwent copy editing and some other minor changes before being published as a book, the editors should also have paid attention to flow, organization, and structure.
Finally, although this book is currently the only English language source on JNF operations in Palestine during World War II, it soon will be joined by Yossi Katz's The Battle for the Land: the Jewish National Fund before the Establishment of the State of Israel, which was published in Hebrew in 2001 and which will soon appear in English. The Hebrew version of Katz's book is better structured and more comprehensive than Tuten's book, and we can expect that the English version will be too. Nonetheless, as one of the few archive-based studies of the JNF, Between Capital and Land should be carried by libraries and consulted by interested specialists and students.
