Katherine Steele Brokaw's rich and erudite Staging Harmony analyzes medieval and early modern theatrical music in England in the context of debates about the proper role of music in religious observance. Moving incrementally through a series of nuanced readings of individual plays from the fifteenth century to the early seventeenth century, the book builds the powerful argument that staged music, partly due to its interpretive flexibility, emotional intensity, and ability to trigger both individual and cultural memory, “provided a creative space in which it was at times possible for understanding and even tolerance to take tentative, fragile form” (3), even in the contentious context of the English Reformation.
The book's first chapter uses the fifteenth-century plays Wisdom and Mary Magdalene to “set up issues regarding the interpretive flexibility of staged music and the confessional complexity of audiences, issues that resonate throughout the plays and periods discussed in this book” (13). Expertly synthesizing a large body of material, Brokaw outlines defenses of music (drawn from ancient and patristic writers) that stressed the divinity of the classical concept of the “music of the spheres” (18) and the reflection of those universal harmonies in the human soul. Attacks on music centered on “anxieties about the sensual nature of music” (13) and the related claim that music was “tainted by virtue of being made and consumed with the flesh” (19). As she does in the later chapters of her book, Brokaw roots these larger philosophical debates in a particular historical moment, here fifteenth-century East Anglia, where a culture of liturgical polyphony flourished in tandem with Wycliffite critiques of music as “indulgent, vain, expensive, and distracting” (24). These plays, Brokaw argues, articulate the potential dangers of music's association with the flesh, as for example in the dancing of Mary Magdalene, but they ultimately express “doctrinal hybridity” (42) and create harmony through such moments as the singing of the “Te Deum” at the end of Wisdom.
The next three chapters trace the vicissitudes of both religious and theatrical music through the crucial first decades of the English Reformation. Chapter 2, which analyzes music in the plays of John Bale in the context of positions on religious music held by major Protestant reformers, develops the surprising but convincing argument that Bale's work often belies the former friar's vehement antimusical stance in his prose writings. The third chapter argues that at the start of the Marian reign, Nicholas Udall's plays “found a way to use the resources of music and theater to urge compromise in a time of religious uncertainty” (120). Moving to the next reign, Chapter 4 shows how plays such as Cambises and Patient and Meek Grissill “present the non-ecclesiastic, private singing of religious music promoted by the Elizabethan church as an effective way to petition God in musical prayer,” even as they “train audiences to be wary of worldly music that may be used to mask political and moral corruption” (126). Other compelling points in this chapter include the claim that the morality plays Like Will to Like and The Trial of Treasure complicate the “dogmatic binaries between the saved and the damned” (141) central to the Calvinist doctrine of double predestination, in the process revealing how “music, with its interpretive flexibility, can exceed the received wisdom of the morality plot's simplicity” (141).
Advancing to the professional London theatre and the 1590s, Chapter 5 builds on previous chapters by tracing the multiple ways in which Marlowe's Doctor Faustus comments metatheatrically on staged music traditions, conventions, and debates. The play “pushes the morality play tradition of equating music with vice to its logical extreme” (157). For example, the words ravishing, sweet, delight, and pleasure, so crucial to defining the nature of Faustus's temptation, simultaneously gesture to attacks on music that associated it with sensual pleasure; and the Maledicate Dominus dirge of the Friars might have invoked both nostalgia and disgust in auditors in the 1590s. The strength of Brokaw's approach is especially on display in the wonderful final chapter on The Tempest and The Winter's Tale. The reading of The Tempest is particularly original in linking the raucous balladry of the subplot with the more heavenly, harmonizing music of Ariel and Prospero, so that, for example, Stephano's “‘I shall no more to sea’ … offers a profane and land-locked perversion of the funeral tune ‘Full Fathom Five’” (202), and “‘Where The Bee Sucks’ … is … a high art version of Caliban's mockery of a freedom song” (208). In her discussion of The Winter's Tale, Brokaw illuminates Leontes's antimusical stance as an important dimension of his early iconoclastic frenzy, and she brilliantly connects Autolycus's ballad singing with the play's larger embrace of religious music, dramatized in the statue scene. Brokaw ultimately shows that “[a]gainst calls for natural purity, for unadorned churches and unaccompanied psalms, The Winter's Tale iterates a trope of polyphony, of hybridized art forms, of messy disguises and morally ambiguous tricks” (223).
Staging Harmony makes a significant scholarly contribution not only to the study of what Bruce R. Smith has called the “acoustic world” of early modern England but also to other veins of contemporary scholarship: recent work tracing the lingering imprint of medieval plays in early modern drama, studies of popular religious culture, and—most broadly—revisionist accounts of the English Reformation as long, contested, and religiously pluralistic. Brokaw's work will be of particular interest to theatre historians, both for its careful attention throughout to dramaturgy and because it so fully develops the ambitious claim that “the formation of the Anglican liturgy, the rises of polyphony, psalmody, and balladry, and the growth of the professional theater are related developments” (4). With a powerful central argument and rich, complex readings of individual theatrical moments, Staging Harmony shines new light on both the English Reformation and the music of the late medieval and early modern English theatre.
