In her book on tears and crying in imperial historiography, Judith Hagen sets out to analyse tears as a form of expressing emotions. Her focus is on the depiction of tears that are shed in the context of power, either by powerful people themselves or by others in the presence of those in power. Her main theoretical premise is that shedding tears in public has both an emotional and a ritualistic aspect. Crying in public can therefore involve a tension between emotion and ritual. H. wants to combine historical and philological approaches to analyse relevant text passages from the viewpoint of the history of emotions. Although the study does not always completely fulfil its own criteria, it results in a stimulating book which offers new insights into a large variety of texts about tears (Träne, δάκρυ, ‘lacrima’) and crying (weinen, κλαίω, ‘fleo’).
An introductory chapter (14–66) summarises relevant scholarship and details the methodological approach, which is that of the history of emotions in the broadest sense (62–3). On the one hand, tears are to be interpreted as part of ritualistic behaviour. H. thus detects structural similarities between certain forms of behaviour that involve crying. On the other hand, tears are interpreted as expressions of individuals’ feelings in a specific situation. The text corpus exceeds imperial historiography in the strict sense, since H. includes works such as Lucan's Pharsalia and covers texts from Julius Caesar down through the imperial and late antique periods as far as Paulus Diaconus and Einhard. She wants to interpret these texts not only as sources but also as literature.
The main chapter (67–319) is in five parts, each of which deals with one aspect of shedding tears: places, groups of people, women, regulations and emotions. In the chapter as a whole, the ambivalence or tension between ritual and emotion is not as decisive for the analyses of tears and crying as the introduction would suggest — and the opposition between ritual and emotion is in fact abandoned explicitly in the summary later (324). Emotions such as grief, fear, anger, pity, sympathy and joy, which are expressed by tears and that are at the heart of the methodological approach described in the introduction, fully come to the fore only in the last part of the main chapter.
Part one of the main chapter (67–109) presents places where people regularly shed tears: in court, in the curia, in the forum, in the circus and theatre, in church, in camp and on the march, and in private. Part two (109–64) deals with crying emperors, military leaders, soldiers and senators. It interprets crying as part of the communication processes between these groups, in which tears express emotions that are specific for each group and addressed to someone whose behaviour is to be influenced by pointing out the close relationship with him. Part three (164–94) turns to gender-specific aspects of women in power and the evaluation of their tears or of their withholding tears. Part four (194–273) focuses on the contexts in which the interactions analysed in the previous sections take place. H. discusses tears that express grief for the dead, prohibitions and punishments for tears, shedding tears when saying goodbye, and religious contexts (repentance, prayer, conversion). Part five (273–319) finally zooms in on the emotions expressed through crying. The focus is on the question of how leaders deal with their emotions in public, and so the relationship of tears, emotions, virtues and character depiction is at the heart of this section. Whether someone is considered as capable of being a leader also depends on the positive or negative evaluation of his display of pity, sympathy and grief (including the simulation of these emotions), which can involve tears and crying. A brief summary (320–7) is followed by the bibliography and two indices (index personarum and locorum).
The revealing observations H. has to make could be presented in a more appealing and convincing way. Her chapters sometimes read more like a collection of summaries of single text passages than like a coherent interpretation. For example, her discussion of tears in court as depicted in historiography (75–81) does not draw on Cicero and Quintilian until the very end of the section (82), with their evidence summarised separately (67–74). Texts from very different authors and eras are combined without providing much context and without really taking into account their literary agendas. H. points out that imperial historiography is to be characterised by its uniformity (but the corpus clearly exceeds historiography in the strict sense) (324), and argues that the public shedding of tears did not change much in the 800 years covered in this study, from the late Roman Republic to the early Middle Ages (325). But even then, the individual text examples could be presented in a more contextualised form that takes into account e.g. their generic qualities and the author's political attitude.
Most illuminating are H.'s interpretations of tears as rather complex and ambivalent signs. The section on crying women, for example, nicely brings out that the evaluation of female tears depends on the women's relationship with their own individual or a man's interests (175–91). The analyses of tears that are only simulated (304–5), and of the absence of tears (188–90, 301–3), add important results by focusing on not (really) crying. H.'s book will thus be both helpful for everyone who deals with texts about tears and an inspiration for further studies.
