The first 76 pages of this volume deal with Marxist theory and practice and argue for the centrality of popular participation in ensuring the viability of socialist revolutions. The rest of the book presents a comparative analyses of the revolutionary governments of Cuba (Chapter 4), Venezuela under Hugo Chávez (Chapter 5), and Chile under Salvador Allende, Nicaragua under the Sandinistas and the ‘Carnation Revolution’ in Portugal in 1974 (Chapter 6). Much of the author's analysis is original and based on a thorough grasp of the events in all five countries.
Raby's starting point is the observation that Latin American Communist Parties have never come to power either by peaceful or non-peaceful means. She attributes this failure not to ‘conjunctural mistakes’ such as political alliances, but rather to ‘lack of confidence in popular instincts and in the autonomous dynamics of popular movements’ (p. 228). Furthermore, dogmatic formulas have not only been conducive to an unattractive, stodgy style, but have impeded the party's ability to grasp and assimilate popular culture. This observation leads to Raby's second major thesis, namely that successful revolutionary movements in Latin America identified themselves with national popular culture and only subsequently have moved on to embrace Marxism with its ‘universal revolutionary ideology’ (p. 261).
Raby's cardinal examples of this sequence is what she terms the ‘revolutionary or progressive populism’ (p. 253) that assumed power in Cuba in 1959 and Venezuela in 1998, two regimes representing ‘the real revolutionary alternative for our times’ (p. 8). The Sandinistas who governed after 1979 and the non-dogmatic left in Portugal after 1974 were also examples of revolutionary populism. The fifth case analysed, namely the Popular Unity government under Allende, is characterised as a ‘counter-example’ (p. 8), in that the Chilean Communist and Socialist Parties adhered to various brands of Marxist orthodoxy and lacked the ‘eclectic ideologies,’ ‘ideological flexibility’ (p. 19) and ‘fluidity’ (p. 113) characteristic of the other four.
In her chapter on Cuba, Raby underlines the populist origins of the movement against Batista and popular participation continuing up to the present. She argues that far from winning the struggle single-handedly, the small guerrilla force led by Castro relied on the participation of tens of thousands of Cubans in the nation's major cities, thus rejecting the thesis promoted by the ideologues of foquismo, Che Guevara and Régis Debray, that the urban support effort was essentially ‘reformist and ineffective’ (p. 85) and at odds with the revolutionary direction of the guerrilla movement. Raby also labels the early Castro a populist. As is typical of populist leaders, for instance, Castro during his early months in power denied that his movement was located either on the left or right of the political spectrum, recalling Juan Domingo Perón's ‘third position.’ Raby's view of the assertiveness and vibrancy of the rank and file of Castro's movement is contrary to the stereotype of populist followers as an ignorant mass, dating back to the writing of Gino Germani among others. Raby goes on to point to the close link between the revolutionary leadership and the Cuban people since the seizure of power. In doing so, she draws heavily on recent empirical studies such as Peter Roman's People's Power to demonstrate the popular input in decision making particularly at the local level and the partial opening up of the Communist Party as shown by its acceptance of Catholics and Protestants as members. This fluidity and the originality of the Cuban experience differentiate the nation's leadership from its Soviet counterparts and explain why it was able to survive the collapse of the USSR in 1991.
Raby is even more glowing in her praise of Venezuela under Chávez, claiming that the nation has ‘probably the most genuine democratic system existing anywhere in the world’ (p. 194). In doing so, she emphasizes the importance of popular participation. While recognising that Chávez has usually set in motion the activities of Chavista social movements, Raby credits the rank and file for responding with determinism and creativity and for exerting constant pressure upward within the movement. Furthermore, the massive mobilisations that were essential for Chávez's political survival have not only been independent of vertically structured political parties, but have sometimes been spontaneous, such as those on 13 April 2002 which restored Chávez's government following the two-day coup. Raby ends the chapter on Venezuela by pointing to the ongoing evolution of the Chavista phenomenon, characterising it as ‘surely the most promising and inspiring political process in the world today’ (p. 196).
Another thesis that Raby weaves into her analysis of the five revolutionary experiences under examination is the importance of charisma. Raby describes a ‘dialectical relationship’ (p. 246) in Cuba and Venezuela between the charismatic leader and his followers in which the latter convey their demands and aspirations which in turn are articulated by Castro and Chávez. This process represents a ‘genuine dialogue’ which ‘contributes to the forging of a collective identity among the participants and also to the ideological evolution and maturity of the leader’ (p. 244). In her largely uncritical analysis of Cuba and Venezuela, Raby passes over the downside of the all-encompassing authority of charismatic leaders, particularly when they become irreplaceable. Charismatic leadership may play a critical role in the early stages of a revolutionary process. Certainly relentless hostility from the United States has provided limited options for both Cuba and Venezuela and has placed restraints on popular input in decision making, thus encouraging centralised rule. Nevertheless, the Chavistas failed to take advantage of their upper hand following Chávez's triumph in the August 2004 presidential recall election by implementing internal democratic procedures. Party primaries, for instance, may have facilitated the emergence of a leader to replace Chávez when his current presidential term expires in 2013. In short, readers of all ideological persuasion will agree on the originality of this book, even though some will undoubtedly consider Raby's views on the prospects of radical democracy overly optimistic. This ambitious study is well timed given the new leftist-inspired democratic models that are emerging and being put to the test throughout Latin America.
